I’m Sunni and I went to the 10th Muharram procession in Melbourne!

Australia is known for its racism. I expected at least a few condescending glances but it was nothing like Pakistan.

Sabeer Lodhi November 07, 2014
Pakistan, home to 180 million people, saw another deadly Muharram this year when 57 people were killed in a suicide bombing in Lahore. Each time, short term administrative solutions are followed to bandage the plague of ideological intolerance that has infected us for years.

Cities are put under curfew, statements of condemnation floated, promises of fool-proof security made and cellular services blocked for as long the government deems fit. Nothing much has changed since last year, when Raja Bazar in Rawalpindi was gripped by sectarian violence.

This religious intolerance and administrative failure is in stark contrast to what I recently experienced in a foreign land. I come from a Sunni background, but this year, I took part in a 10th Muharram procession organised in Melbourne. This was to show solidarity with my brothers in faith back home.

Australia is known for its racism. Hence, I expected at least a few condescending glances as thousands of people from the world over wore black and walked the city’s street as a unified force.

Mourners walk on LaTrobe Street. Photo: Sabeer Lodhi

Participants pass through LaTrobe Street towards Carlton Gardens. Photo: Sabeer Lodhi

Nohas were played on loudspeakers and participants thumped their chests in grief. Information leaflets were also distributed which explained the reasons behind this procession and who Imam Hussain (RA) is.

Participants perform 'matam' at Carlton Garden. Photo: Sabeer Lodhi

Participants perform 'matam' at Carlton Garden. Photo: Sabeer Lodhi

People from all nationalities and races transcended their nationalistic differences and came together for a single cause – the cause of Imam Hussain’s martyrdom.

Family is distributed information leaflet to explain who Hussain was. Photo: Sabeer Lodhi

The procession was taken out right before the Melbourne Cup was to take place a few blocks away. It is a popular horse race that allows people to bet on their favourite horse and drink in celebration. Just that fact was enough proof of the plurality and tolerance of divergent views. We walked further on towards Carlton Gardens where a wedding was taking places only a few minutes earlier.

Tram with Melbourne Cup Carnival poster running parallel to the Muharram procession. Photo: Sabeer Lodhi

Bridesmaids getting their picture taken seconds before the procession reached. Photo: Sabeer Lodhi

Following that, Zuhr prayers were offered and the participants dispersed to peacefully go home.

Zuhr prayers being offered in Carlton Garden. Photo: Sabeer Lodhi

Man carrying flag with religious scripture printed on it. Photo: Sabeer Lodhi

How unfortunate that this proof of coexistence was blatant in a ‘gora land’ and not in my own country that boasts of 98% Muslim population and was founded on secular, pluralistic principles. There was no threat of violence or fear of being attacked. There was no hint of racism in a country known for it. The government didn’t have to put security on high alert neither did it jam cell phone services.

Security personnel leading the rally to stop traffic. Photo: Sabeer Lodhi

Participants pass through LaTrobe Street. Photo: Sabeer Lodhi

Women congregate as the procession reaches its end at Carlton Gardens. Photo: Sabeer Lodhi

Will we ever be able to fight the ideological extremism prevalent in Pakistan and allow space for such peaceful coexistence of different beliefs and values?

Will we ever see a day when the government doesn’t have to enforce shallow administrative actions to fight the larger battle against extremist mindsets and a lack of plural values?

Let’s hope so.
Sabeer Lodhi

The writer is a graduate of Monash University, Melbourne. He is a perpetual student and supporter of human rights with a focus on gender equality, minority rights and post-colonialism. He tweets as https://twitter.com/sabeerlodhi">@sabeerlodhi.

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Mohsin Khan | 9 years ago | Reply what i fail to understand so far is that why do we mourn on ashura when we clearly know and believe that those who are martyred are not dead, and that Allah feeds them well. That in turn means that Imam Hussain, and everyone who has ever been martyred, is not even dead... then why mourn over someone who is not dead in the first place? yes, i have heard the explanation that we mourn because of the brutalities that they were subjected to... agreed, but give me the name of one martyr who is martyred without any pain or suffering? so then why dont we mourn every day, many times a day, for the many hundreds and thousands of martyrs who were persecuted at one point in time or the other... why dont we dedicate ourselves, our lives to mourning, in an attempt to show solidarity and respect to all the martyrs so far in the recorded human history... and more importantly, why do we stop mourning after muharram? why can't the event of karbala stay with us 365 days a year in the same manner as it does on 9-10th muharram? no one stops us from beating our chests everyday, just as no one does on 9-10th muharram... and a clarification: i am not a sunni. just a plain, regular muslim - no sect - no fiqah - just muslim. in search of a rational answer, not an emotional answer wrapped in religious sentiments.
Fatima | 9 years ago | Reply You can go to a Muharram procession in Pakistan too. Whats the big deal????
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ