And that’s really weird. It’s weird because Noon has been around since the dinosaurs roamed the earth. It’s rooted in the soil, so to speak. The squirming tentacles it sports wiggle down to the lowest of levels, yes galli mohalla type level. The party has workers spread over every inch of Punjab, drinking lustily from the patronage wells being dug up in a neighbourhood near them. They are supposed to have their ear to the ground; finger on the pulse, etc. They are supposed to feel the slightest shift in mood, the ever-so-delicate fluidity of emotion and the slightest of change in morale.
And yet Noon ain’t just gettin’ it. It’s really weird.
Except it’s not.
Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif visits flood affectees in Jhang on Saturday. He’s wearing his traditional light-coloured shalwar kameez and waistcoat. Cufflinks glitter on his wrists as he addresses a gathering through a megaphone. And what does he say? That his government is not corrupt; that he’s not doing anybody any favour by coming here; that he will use funds to help the poor. Blah, blah and blah.
This is officialspeak. Serious, unadulterated, toxically-rich officialspeak. The thing about officialspeak is that it is derived from a strange language called officialese, which comes from a number of places — except the heart. And that is the problem with our third-time prime minister: he’s not feeling it. Which is perhaps why he is not getting it. Yes, there is a soft rumble on the ground; a faint echo of a distant thunder; dark tidings of a storm building across the horizon. Yes, the wind has picked up; the leaves are flailing about, trees leaning to one side and the air quietly belching moisture.
But Chief Noon is not getting it. It’s a train wreck in slow motion. A classic case of a hardened politician missing the change even as it opens up like a giant yawn in his face. Noon derives its strength from its traditional way of politicking — the way of clans, biradris, electable candidates and their captive vote banks, and of course, working the system to their advantage. That’s how politics has been waged in this country forever. That’s how it spins around a system lubricated with taxpayer money and state patronage. Here, Noon excels like no other. And so Noon keeps muscling its way back into power.
But now Noon is not adapting to the change. Noon is not being flexible and innovative. Noon is lumbering like it is weighed down by heavy body armour. Yes, this constitutional armour may provide Noon some protection, but the opponent is nimble, agile, energised and fuelled by hi-octane motivation. As steel blades collide, and passions drips down like heavy sweat, a new discourse is being born amongst us. This birth spawns tales of a glorious future where moth-eaten tradition will sleep with the fishes while glorious idealism will roam our land like a tiger uncaged. Such tales are now echoing across the airwaves, mobilising men, women and children to transform themselves into mammoth crowds gyrating to a music that weaves dreams and promises a better tomorrow.
But wait.
Winds of change can also sweep away a sense of reality. And the reality is that fiery rhetoric can fuel passions and drive movements, but it cannot construct change brick by agonising brick. Imran Khan’s juggernaut is gathering momentum by the day. His every jalsa is hammer-blow to Noon; his every accusation an arrow piercing deep into the government’s soft, blubbery flesh. The hunger for a new dawn is revitalising a dejected electorate, and Noon is fast finding itself on the wrong side of the future. But if David does indeed fell Goliath; if our political Godzilla is indeed brought crashing down by a thousand fatal blows; if Gulliver is in fact tied down, and kept down by the political Lilliputians; if all this were actually to happen, what then?
What after Noon?
Here’s where the fairy tale begins. Or ends, depending on how you look at it. This system that we have, this system abhors change. It is a system evolved over centuries, held together by tradition, by family and clan linkages, by a steel web of kinship and patronage, all housed within an archaic state that is hard, brittle and resistant to any kind of change. It is Noon that is dependent on this system, not the other way round. Yes, Noon feeds of this system and extracts the most out of it, but it is the system that ultimately nourishes Noon. Noon may go. The system will most certainly not.
And this reality will knock the dreamers awake. The reality that we are awash in tradition and inertia; the reality that deconstructing a status quo regime will not usher in utopia; the reality that Imran Khan ascending the Pakistani throne will not lead to a dramatic transformation of this nation. Slaying Noon may bring satisfaction, it will not bring an end to status quo.
After Noon, we will continue to suffer the high noon of an unrepenting system built to last external shocks. Change in this modern world is a generational phenomenon, driven by patience and perseverance. Change in our context will mean living with a humbled but persistent Noon, a chastened but determined PPP and the all-pervasive establishment that likes to keep change on a tight leash.
The Khan juggernaut’s success lies in the fact that it has triggered an avalanche of emotion; and set the wheels of change in motion. This juggernaut is now leading the charge against Noon and all that it represents. It would soon discover that taking down Noon was the easy part. The real battle will begin when it comes face to face with the system that feeds all — including many in the PTI juggernaut itself.
After Noon, the story actually begins.
Published in The Express Tribune, October 12th, 2014.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (37)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Good After Noon All.
For the intellectual satisfaction of minds submerged in inertia, fears, uncertainty, conspiracy theories, rhetoric, apprehensions, reservations and most importantly those over-flowing with emotions, those who think an End to Noon will bring a Dawn or those who think that nothing will CHANGE!
"Imran Khan will not bring any change. He will simply set the direction correctly. Change is not brought by individuals but by nations collectively after the direction is set straight"
ET does not allow agenda driven comments, as per its policy. How come an agenda driven write up finds space here?
@Xman: Your comment was above par of the average knowledge/intelligence of most commentators on this piece. But Fahd would get it, I am sure. Dreaming something to be actual where it might be just be plausible does not really get anyone to the truth. Selection of some facts while leaving others equally important facts distorts the whole picture. Cognition of comprehensive truth is very elusive.
I was not particularly surprised that my recent comment pointing out how the Express Tribune has thrown away all pretense of objectivity and become a PTI mouth piece was not allowed. But I am trying again. Maybe it will slip the ET censors this time.
PTI supporters make a lot of noise, and dominate the social media, but they are still a minority of Pakistani electorate. The silent majority of Pakistani voters are smart enough to ignore the noise, empty rhetoric, wild promises, and emotional appeals of PTI sympathizers in the media. Come next elections, this silent majority will judge Imran Khan and the PTI by results in the KP province rather than by noisy jalsas, fancy English language rhetoric in newspaper columns, and circus like antics of certain talk show hosts on TV.
No wonder PTI sympathizers never say one word about PTI's record as the governing party in KP. They want people to forget that PTI is governing KP at all. They know if the electorate decides to judge them by their record in KP, PTI might not win 3 seats in the next parliament.
Nice try, but it will not work. PTI can run by cannot hide from their dismal failure in managing KP.
"officialese, which comes from a number of places — except the heart. And that is the problem with our third-time prime minister: he’s not feeling it." How could the prime minister go to Saudi Arabia for 10 whole days to look after his business abroad while his country men were drowning by the thousands and losing homes, no doubt he is not feeling it. It is nothing new in Pakistan, I recall Zardari was vacationing in France while his country men from end of the country to another end were drowning by the thousands too, yes he stayed there and went on to London for more fun. I do see awakening of the nation and specially the young generation to bring the change and the change will come eventually. I enjoyed reading your article, it is food for thought as usual.
What a brilliant columnist for an IK fan. Love his style, the Game of Thrones jargon and sometimes 1984 style. His perspective and surity of argument since August 14, 2014 events has provided much guidance to say the least. Hope to read more from you in the coming days/times.
A very precise depiction of our current situation and the future it can lead to.Attending jalsas with starry eyed adulation and sky high expectations is one thing,coming to grips with the reality is another.The blinding effect of our wishful thinking is so grave that the enthusiasts seem totally oblivious to the presence in their ranks of a considerable number of thugs of the older order.How can these people be the harbingers of any change.Fahd Hussain has put it across beautifully --the situation after noon goes is going to be the real challenge and may take us to where we find ourselves a year after the imposition of every Martial Law.God bless you Fahd and more strength to your pen!
"But now Noon is not adapting to the change. Noon is not being flexible and innovative." You have underestimated NS and Noon League. Noon did adapt by not using tools of violence to disperse the dharnas. Noon must have shown flexibility with the top brass of the Army to reach an understanding. Noon is more resilient than you think or wish. Noon is smart enough to wait out for a more favorable time to counter its opponents. A few more rallies and the whole movement against the Noon is likely to fizzle out. Or an overwhelming rallies and response from Noon will drown out the opposition. Just wait and see.
@Hasnain Abidi:
An apt description for your comment is:
Whom the Gods wish to destroy, at first they make mad!
Waste of space, in my opinion.
Given our densely-populated urban slums, it's not a big feat to gather a mob. People's party and PML(N) can easily gather a mob and stake their claim on "change'.
As for the 'system that abhors change': that's like every system in the world.
Broaden your horizons Mr. Fahd, you're experiencing confirmation bias. And you just don't know it yet.
This particular author usually attempts to corroborate his thesis with prolific choice of esoteric metaphor, that mostly lacks substance. Just for the record, the story will not begin "after noon" in fact their is no story to begin with. And the "story" will never end, no matter how much pareidolia is infused through numerous cognitive biases that have been peppered thorough out the article. Now in layman's language, may I summarise : leave the system alone and stop finding faces in clouds at noon!
"Rome wasn't built in a day".The adage means that time is needed to create great things.Atleast the requirement of time to bring Change is known to the participants of the two dharnas,this was evident from the answers which were given in response to the questions put to the participants by reporters of various TV channels.Nawaz Sharif now represent the united political status quo forces as he has obtained their unanimous support in the joint session of the Parliament. So as a first step towards The Change,it is imperative that he leaves.The more he delays the more fatal would be the fall.As indicated by the author the real story would then begin.The Change or revolution which IK and TUQ wants to bring is to be structured within the framework of the Constitution as per their own assertion.If people are ready for the fundamental changes in the way the system functions,it would be visible in the elections to form the next government.The Change means that the same people has to Change themselves to bring a change in functioning of the system.Is this possible?.Study of history indicates that the answer is affirmative.History is replete with examples where the same set of people has changed for the better.To have / elect the Right Leadership is the key.
@S.R.H. Hashmi: Well said, and I fully agree.
impressive one
Very eloquent as always. Agreed the task for change harbingers is monumental. But begin you must because the alternative is so horrendous. Successful societies have always improved incrementally. They never let the prospect of getting less than a perfect outcome deter them from following the path forward in things big and small. However limited the gain, you would still be better off than not trying. And hopefully, the process will continue long after Imran is gone from the stage.
The way forward is to go out there and attract the best adminstrators from all over the world like water power health enviroment the civil service left by the british was the reason why pakistan became the fastest growing economy in the world during the 60s then came the political jobs and drains on all our institutions example is dubai today there 100000 british working there and countless other nationalities almost all 5 star hotels have expat managers including emirates airlines and all other important institutions if you bring in these foreigners to head all your institutions bar defence and within a few years you will see the speed of the transformation
The answer to Fahad's questions lies in Pakistan's demographics, which are heavily skewed towards young people and increasing urbanization.
Fahad is correct to point out that change will not come the second after the hated non league disappears, but COME IT WILL in giant, chunky lumps as cohorts of these young, biradriless individuals, trained in better educational institutions and fed a fresh dose of nationalism, will move into the bureaucratic, political and private spheres of power in droves.
It is imperative that most resources after the proverbial change are spent on cleaning up our educational system, which is akin to the computer operating system in its importance for a society--it essentially governs how the rest of the system will run--producing civic minded, patriotic individuals, not half literate, confused, skillless wanderers.
This is where salvation lies and it is worth a try. Otherwise, all waderas will have "qabza" on their respective provinces and the rest of us will have to toil in hardship and shame to feed these monsters forever. The nation, thanks to Imran, has gotten this message loud and clear and knows what plans our rulers have hatched for us and our children.
Full speed ahead Imran--you are worth the gamble and that is why we are all with you!
The writer says "This system that we have, this system abhors change. It is a system evolved over centuries, held together by tradition, by family and clan linkages, by a steel web of kinship and patronage, all housed within an archaic state that is hard, brittle and resistant to any kind of change. It is Noon that is dependent on this system, not the other way round. Yes, Noon feeds of this system and extracts the most out of it, but it is the system that ultimately nourishes Noon. Noon may go. The system will most certainly not."
Yet, if we go back not centuries but just about five decades, things were a lot better in Pakistan. The area comprising present -day Pakistan was used by the British to supply agricultural produce and soldiers for their army and lacked industry. However, better leadership and civil service established institutions of repute and industries in Pakistan. While working within the same system, PIA was a pride for the nation, justifying every word of its slogan 'Great People to Fly With' and it even helped establish aviation industry in the Gulf. Taking note of the fact that private sector will not establish units requiring huge investments and having long pay-back period, Pakistan Industrial Development Corporation (PIDC) set up and ran such units and when they became commercially viable, sold them to private sector and used the proceeds to establish yet other units in sectors where private sector would not have taken initiative.
So the quality of leadership does matter and even operating within the same system, an honest and capable leadership can make substantial difference, more so when it concentrates on improving the systems and strengthening the institutions instead of messing the two in order to facilitate its corruption, like PML-N and Peoples Party have been doing. Given full five years, through extreme corruption and greed, the PML-N will take the country beyond redemption, leaving it with huge debts because of massively over-priced projects, with the excess stashed away in their accounts abroad. Moreover, all the profitable units in the country would have been sold at rock-bottom prices to their nominees, causing big drain on foreign exchange resources of the country through repatriation of profit and dividends.
All considered, Dr. Tahirul Qadri and Imran Khan are the only hope for the country.
Karachi
@fahdhusain to understand your article need MPhil English Literacy! Here 24 confused words weird squirming tentacles roamed wiggle down lustily delicate fluidity glitter soft rumble belching moisture flailing leaning lumbering nimble agile spawns tales mammoth gyrating agonising blubbery flesh Goliath political Lilliputians Slaying
Fantastic piece. One Battle at a time. It is the awakening of the people that matters most. I believe this pressure will persist even with PTI government (if it is to be so) after Noon is gone. It's not an easy road. But sometimes a sense of better direction is all it takes to bring peace and contentment. Happiness and contentment after all are relative phenomenas.
A soft but very firm and incisive argumentation. In fact the mola jutt style of hurling fuming volition is not the correct way of analysis and fact presentation. This is what impacts.impacts. Fahad sahab maintain it.
We need maturity not emotions.
A very well written piece. The writer has missed one thing, the people supporting the change are the SYSTEM itself. I have been to almost every jalsa, dharna etc of PTI. I dont dance and jump about but talk to people. There are bureaucrat, industrialists, shop keepers, clerks etc who I talked to and all were of the same opinion, "We are ready for change and we will ensure it" The status quo that we talk about is there because the environment encouraged it. People are not inherently bad, the environment suppresses the good. When a critical mass is reached for any event, the majority follows. Look at Fatah Macca. Only 10 thousand muslims. Others were sitting on the fence waiting to see which way to jump. In three years after that, the last Khutba had 125,000 muslims. In Pakistan there are a lot of fence sitters, paying bribes, evading taxes, waiting for VIPs to pass. But then they will jump to the side that wins. And Insha Allah we are hopeful that the side will be of good people.
"After Noon, the story actually begins."
And it can only hope to begin after noon.
An excellent example of thought, observation and sarcasm mixed, and shaken so well as to produce a delicious and heady cocktail. Well-done Fahd!
But there is one important ingredient the absence of which I could not help noticing. I refer to that all-powerful one with strong menacing tentacles that is ever present before Noon, during Noon and after Noon. That is wisdom!
An excellent mixture of wisdom, thought and sarcasm shaken well to produce a delicious and heady cocktail. Well done Fahd!
I however could not help noticing the absence of an all powerful and essential ingredient. I refer to the one which for over 67 years has been menacingly howcvering
The system can and will change by adopting the "Two Year Rule" which I propose as follows:
No person may hold a senior, elected or selected position for more than two years. Immediate members of family of such persons are not eligible to ever hold elected office. Persons having held an office in the past cannot repeat a term.Such persons are required to stay within the country for a further period of two years so that any questions as to corruption or misappropriation of public funds are fully resolved.
-- Aussie: Shahid Saleem Arshad, MSIE, PhD, (USA) Sydney
Simply quite a partisan pro-PTI article.
The system can and will change by adopting the "Two Year Rule" which I propose as follows:
No person may hold a senior, elected or selected position for more than two years. Immediate members of family of such persons are not eligible to ever hold elected office. Persons having held an office in the past cannot repeat a term. Such persons are required to stay within the country for a further period of two years so that any questions as to corruption or misappropriation of public funds are fully resolved.I agree the analysis to some extent, but Fahad has ignored the personality of leader behind the change altogether. There are two inputs for change here; the "system" which Fahad has assumed will remain static in future, and the catalyst for change ("the change agent"). In my opinion, the personality traits, past track record, determination & perseverance etc of change agent will play a major role in applying the thrust needed to make system dynamic. Even the composition of audience in the system has changed significantly. We now have a sizable segment which is ripe for participating, willing to come out, and insists on its role as stake holders for what should be the state of affairs in future. It did not exist in the past and will complement change agent's endeavors. No one can guarantee the future, but I am optimistic, since the "change agent" (IK) has some remarkably positive characteristics as exhibited during his long struggle and recent DHARNA movement.
u r right but to change the system the first step is to put it on right track.and surely thts just the beginning.atleast then we will have hope tht things can improve
Awesome analysis
Class!
This is perhaps one of the best if not the best piece to have come out during this whole episode. Terrific points! Syed Talat Hussain and his likes who think rather highly of themselves will do well to take a look at this example of how eloquence and sophistication are combined.
Excellent........that was needed to be said. The situation today is that the people are so frustrated with the inept and corrupt political system that thrives on patronage that they are willing to try anything else. They have come to a stage that they are willing to even cut their nose, in order to spite their face.
The reality is that we all get the system we deserve. Or the system we built. So one Modi or one Nawaz does not really matter in the larger picture. As the author says, if Tom goes and Harry comes, will the system magically change ?