The US embassy official's expulsion was splashed over newspaper front pages along with photos of the Indian diplomat, Devyani Khobragade, arriving in New Delhi late Friday, her palms pressed together in a traditional Indian greeting.
"I am really thankful for all your support. My government will speak for me, my lawyers will speak for me," Khobragade, 39, who has left her husband and two children behind in the United States, told reporters Saturday.
The United States said late Friday it "deeply regrets" India's expulsion of the US embassy official and wanted to mend a partnership that Washington hopes could be a bulwark against China's growing might.
However, India's orders to the US diplomat to leave within 48 hours, just as the row appeared to be cooling, suggested New Delhi was still not in a forgiving mood.
With general elections due by May, politicians have pounced on US actions calling them a violation of national sovereignty and saying the United States should not be allowed to ride roughshod over Indian interests.
"India hits back with diplomat expulsion," said the Mail Today tabloid while the Indian Express newspaper said: "Delhi goes for revenge expulsion."
Ties have frayed since December 12 when Khobragade, India's deputy consul-general in New York, was arrested on charges of visa fraud involving her domestic servant and lying about how much she paid her.
She allegedly obtained a visa for her maid by promising to pay her $4,500 a month and then struck a secret deal to pay her 30,000 rupees a month, far below the US minimum wage.
But shortly before her US grand jury indictment Thursday, Washington granted the Indian officer - who has denied all charges - full diplomatic immunity, allowing her to return.
"Her head is held high. She knows she has done no wrong," Khobragade's lawyer Dan Arshack told AFP.
As the diplomat was flying back to New Delhi, India announced it had asked Washington to withdraw an embassy official in a fresh retaliatory measure.
"I can confirm a US official accredited to the mission in India will be leaving his post," US State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki, said.
The exact timing of his departure from India was unclear as the US embassy was not returning telephone calls.
"We deeply regret the Indian government felt it was necessary to expel one of our diplomatic personnel," Psaki said. "We're looking to move our relationship forward. We're looking to move past this challenging time."
At the same time, Psaki said Khobragade cannot return to the US unless she surrenders to the court.
The US embassy would not identify the expelled official but Indian newspapers named him as Wayne May, who managed security staff and was the US side to the anti-terrorism aid programme.
The expelled US diplomat was of "similar rank" to Khobragade and is suspected of having helped the maid's family travel to United States.
US prosecutors said the maid's family were evacuated from India because of alleged intimidation attempts, accusations that also riled India.
Khobragade's arrest outside her children's school and treatment in custody, where she was cavity searched, outraged India, which insisted she had diplomatic immunity.
US prosecutors disputed this, contending she was not a ranking embassy official, and filed charges.
India used bulldozers to remove security barriers at the US embassy in New Delhi and even stopped the mission importing duty-free alcohol.
Washington views India as a key ally in countering China's regional rise and has invested heavily in improving ties. In 2010, US President Barack Obama called relations with India "one of defining partnerships of the 21st century".
India has benefited from US backing to gain access to foreign nuclear energy technology.
While Americans took the maid's side, many affluent Indians who pay their servants far less than Khobragade was accused of paying hers, supported the diplomat and viewed her treatment as high-handed superpower behaviour.
Even traditional US supporters were angered by Washington's actions.
"The US is so good at arm-twisting - India is just playing their game," the national president of the Indo-American Chamber of Commerce, Chella Srinivasan, told AFP in a recent interview.
COMMENTS (64)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Mirza
She is earning $4200.
Right move by the US. Now let's see how the Indian courts see the case of forged documents.
4,500 a month for maid when Devyani's own income is about same or less. Interesting. Clearly a huge blunder the visa officer made in not scrutinizing that data right away.
Poor US-India ties are very good for Pakistan. This will allow us some breathing room for our own problems without external pressure, terrorism, etc.
I can only see the ties getting worse if Modi is elected. This means the situation is looking very favorable for Pakistan in all aspects. India is ruining its relations with every country.
It's one thing for Indians to hijack a Pakistani news website , but it's completely unacceptable to mascarade as Pakistanis !!
@Just: Wife of expelled American diplomat who is also a US embassy employee broke Indian tax laws by purchasing 3 Air Line tickets for maids family without paying tax. Tax exemption can be used by diplomats. She could have been arrested.
Expelled diplomat interfered with Indian court system by helping maid's family flee the country
@Mirza: Actually it is her (Devyani's) salary that was 4500. Besides salary in US, the maid got 30000 INR in India each month, free food, lodging and annual paid trip back to India. The calculation of the fact that she was paid 3.3$ per our was on the basis that she was working for 17 hours a day for 7 dayas a week. How a family of 4 living in US with all gadgets needs that kind of help is difficult to imagine. Basically they assumed that since she was a residential mild, all hours were working hours.
@F U: While they kill our citizens with drones. When they bombed your soldiers in Salala for 2 hours no PAF plane flew to give them protection.
@antanu: Political posturing is when there are speeches but no results. Like when Zardari and now Nawaz Sharif says we strongly object to the drones but the drones do not stop.
India said it would get the maid back and it did. Not just that it actually changed conditions of American diplomats in India withdrawing those facilities which were over and above the Vienna convention. Saying friends not masters and acting friends not masters is two different things.
You say US did not care. If it did not, it would not have granted her full diplomatic immunity retroactively. Nor would it have triggered a cross agency review to figure how things went so wrong.
@Nikki: Yes but Pakistani citizens are being droned by US.
@Mirza: I read elsewhere that the $4,500 / month salary was actually the amount of diplomat's salary and not what the promised to pay the maid. In the visa application the diplomat mentioned her salary of $4,500 per month to justify that she can afford to pay the maid the minimum hourly rate which comes out to approximately $1700 per month. $4,500/ month would amount to $26/hour. $4,500 /month would be $54,000 / year and there are 2080 hours in a year. Her lawyers have said that the US agencies mis-read / mis-understood the diplomat's statement on the visa application. The fact that the maid was provided an accommodation in the diplomats house could go either way. The diplomat can claim that this was an expensive perk provided but the maid would claim that she was working long hours and not just 8 hours / day. Additionally, paying the entire amount to the maid's family in India in Indian rupees and paying the maid nothing in USA would be viewed as keeping the maid as a slave, irrespective of the perks of free accommodation, free food and free air tickets to travel to India. Had the diplomat paid the maid in US the full amount and charged her separately for the rent, she may have landed in such a big issue. But the diplomat may have to pay taxes in US on the rental income. So, nothing is as clear as it looks. It could be also that the diplomat's house was owned by the Indian Embassy and that she could not rent it out.
@Ch. Allah Daad: Indians have ruined her life. She cannot enter USA, where her children and husband live and are US citizens. Wrong. She can still enter USA with a diplomatic passport that gives her immunity from arrest. I am sure she will be trying to get her family back to India. She can be posted in some other country. Husband is US citizen! So what? I am sure he can find a job anywhere.
Its disgusting the way pakistanis and indians hate each other. Rab akal davey enna nu.
@Ozair: This 'Nautanki' IS DEFINITELY for the 'Prestigious' IFS( Indian Foreign Service) officer, not to mention her feudal ( Her Father is an IAS officer) and her cast ( S.C.) credentials, They both own Ultra Luxurious flats in Aadarsh Building in Mumbai, originally built for widows of Kargill war Heros. For the more needy Indian workers languishing in Jails in Singapore ( Happened same week in Singapore last month) Government of India is Deaf and Dumb. I think they did the same lying, they do in India, but They did this in U.S. And thats the reason of Aam Aadmi, starting in New Delhi, Hope he ends this Feudal, cast and corruption demons once for all. There is a joke going round in India, Call Preet Bharara to India, He would be a true SON OF SOIL to kill the above said demons.
@Ch. Allah Daad: nope her husband also followed her . and her children will come back in no time.
Why does everything have to reduced to a India Pakistan fight ?
"promising to pay her $4,500 a month and then struck a secret deal to pay her 30,000 rupees a month" I am ultra liberal and socialist who believes in the rights of workers. However, it is hard to believe that an Indian vice counsel can afford to pay $4,500 to just one servant. To give this kind of money she would have to make much more than $10 thousand to be able to pay so much from her after tax income. Do middle level diplomats from India make this kind of money? I have no idea but I doubt that any such employ can afford to pay that kind of money to just one servant.
@Mard-e-Haq: I thought we followed Diyat and Qisas according to Sharia. I had wondered how come there was no police encounter and news that an unknown person was killed resisting arrest.
@Ch. Allah Daad:
Wrong!!!! She can enter the US as long as she has "immune status" from India.
Also, being the family of a top diplomat, they would have a far more "privileged" life than they can ever think of in the US!!!! Her family has been traveling with her so far on her assignments in various countries. Moreover, since she is a diplomat, she will soon be posted to another foreign location on assignment.
BTW, I think as soon as a Republican becomes President of US, you can be sure those charges would be dropped!!!!
All this were mere posturing by GOI in an election year. If they had to send a message to the US all it would have taken was to cancel couple of big ticket defense contracts. US defense contractors would have made sure Devyani issue was solved to India's terms.
@Sexton Blake
The situation most realistical described! The lack of coordination between the foreign office and the local administration in the US.
Rex Minor.
@Chulbul Pandey: Her life is ruined because she has been seperated from her family. It would be impossible for her in near future to go to USA and live with her family. Its a great price to pay for US citizens (her family is a US citizen) to come to India and live with her.
@Li Peng: "Asian unity is needed." India shall NEVER forget the stab-in-the-back of 1962. There is no such thing as "Asian unity".
@Justice:
They rather act like kids than punish their own who committed a crime. Indians are well known for visa frauds. They would go any mile to escape their country.
@Daddy: @Aamer Khawaja: You Pakistani’s will always remain illiterate and ignorant people consumed by conspiracy theories. FYI, One there is no caste system that exists in India. Second, just for record Devyani Khobragade herself belongs to a lower caste and not any higher caste like you claimed, which again makes your comment a sheer absurd and reinstate my point that no caste discrimination exist in India. Get out of that delusional bubble and get some international exposure. Period!
Why I dint reply to that absurdity from the Kamboja is because I felt bad.One must give Pakistanis a chance to "vent".No History, no culture, no pride, no religion(original one) and no guts.Contrast that with Bharat and they feel bad. They need to say something...just lol at em.Ironic, Dalits share a lot of common ancestry with Indo-Europeans, Roma Gypsies and being the genetic closest to Pakistan in a very genetic way.The oppression was because of the way of life gypsies had, not as Pakistanis assume.Now that way of life doesnt exist, so India is one.Who knows who is what, these guys live in medieval migratory ages and have not come to the maturity of nation states.
Us will start respect india only when india deploys its surya missile of 16k km range.
@Aamer Khawaja: Keep you bias to yourself. Do you know that Indian diplomat is from low caste
@Ch. Allah Daad: Wow! You can talk sense sometimes too!
@Daddy: Tell them too Daddy: We deny we have any flaws like; forced bride emulation, honour killing, child prostitution, serventhood below the standards of slavery, rape, incest, corruption to name a few. Also tell them they are so hated here in India, they should not point a finger at us, or...
Every freedom loving Human is Indian today, and yes a Pakistani like myself too.
@Ch. Allah Daad: Indians have ruined her life. She cannot enter USA, where her children and husband live and are US citizens. Daad ji, you might not have the complete information about the case. The whole India stood behind our diplomat because of the treatment she received. Please note that I am not contesting the fact whether she was right or wrong. You simply don't treat a diplomat like that, no matter who you think you are. Period. . It was US that asked her to leave, we didn't. Our actions stopped her arrest. I don't know how that amounts to ruining her life. Please enlighten me. . Sincerely
@Indian Reader: Yes, thats why hey only ciavity searched your diplomat.
@Pakistani: lol..Grapes are sour..eh? Atleast childish behavior is better than the subordinate behavior of Pakistan. And as far as male American officers are concerned they are busy stripping your fellow Pakistani Aafia Siddiqui..LMAO
@Aamer Khawaja: You Pakistani's will always remain illiterate and ignorant people consumed by conspiracy theories. FYI, One there is no caste system that exists in India. Second, just for record Devyani Khobragade herself belongs to a lower caste and not any higher caste like you claimed, which again makes your comment a sheer absurd and reinstate my point that no caste discrimination exist in India. Get out of that delusional bubble and get some international exposure. Period!
It's nothing but a posture for public during election season.its going to fizzle out.as for US it does not care about any one and is arrogant.we have been taught a lesson I respective of our being the largest democracy and blah blah.
Politicians of India took this matter in election year to score some points but at the end no one got anything, However Ms. Devyani Khobragade is clearly a loser. Indians have ruined her life. She cannot enter USA, where her children and husband live and are US citizens.
@Indian Reader: US must understand that India is not Pakitan!
I have seen a lot of Pakistani readers always comparing their country with India. It seems that the disease is on our side of the fence too.
@Mukund:
Yes, in case of Raymond we had inept "political" governments both in the province and centre who never stopped bashing a military general for siding with the US on war on terror.
If you ask them they will say Musharraf had already made an agreement to return Raymond in case raymond kills someone.
@Mukund,
What circumstances are you talking about? Is there extenuating circumstances for cold-blooded murder by the American Davis, and frozen-chicken cowardice by Pakistan's great custodians of Islamic law? The media even spun the circumstances behind Davis' release as due to "tribal customs" like "diya." "Diya is not Pakistani; it is Arabic and used in Sharia law.
Our Mullahs who get so worked up about niqabs and hijabs conveniently looked the other way when Sharia was lopsidedly applied to spring a release for the rich and mighty, as they always do.
"She allegedly obtained a visa for her maid by promising to pay her $4,500 a month and then struck a secret deal to pay her 30,000 rupees a month, far below the US minimum wage."
Why someone has to promise $4500 per month to a maid to obtain a visa for her while the minimum wage for 40 hours a week for a maid's job is 1400 USD in USA. in addition to the Rs. INR 30000( $ 500) the maid was given a decent accommodation , free meal, free phone calls , cozy comfort , entertainment and also the free air tickets. Minimum wage in USA does not include any perqs. the value of these perquisites are not added to the wages. while arriving at the wages. will anybody think why USA officials in new Delhi needed to evacuate the husband and children of the maid. Does it look like the case of underpayment of a maid.Actually the charges level led against the diplomat is trafficking of persons. that is why the official of USA embassy involving in shifting the maid's husband (a driver in some other embassy )and her children and air fare is paid by USA embassy, even availing tax exemption ( available for embassy officials only) . Probably this is the reason why the said embassy officials has been declared unwanted.
India's reaction to the case was extremely childish and doesn't prove anything. The only place Khobragade deserves is jail and further stripping by male American officers.
@IndiansRealityCheck Even I am feeling the same particularly when the person commenting against India has "IndiansRealityCheck" as his name.Atleast get a non-Indian name.
Let's not put down Pakistan unnecessarily. Raymond Davis circumstance was different. I wish there is peace and collaboration with Pakistan with no meddling from US.
@IndiansRealityCheck: Sunlight penetrates everywhere where darkness lingers !
@Lol: yep quite the style, im sure by style u mean caste, because all indians did with "style" was that they ignored the lower caste maid & stood up(wrongly) for an upper caste criminal with big political connection especially with the Home minister.
A dark day in Indian history. India will pay heavily worldwide of still having illegal & inhumane worker pay and benefits practices. Lets see how far and wide India has shook the world by supporting her visa & immigration frauds.
@Indian Reader: Actually you didn't get that...If India had taken that stand for a principle, I would definitely have appreciated them...To simply say that she lied on her visa form and on top of that she was an Indian Diplomat!!!!!!!...Atleast give the servants whats their due right, then come and bash Pakistan...Being the biggest democracy and ''shining India'', you couldn't even save your own women who are daily rapped and killed.
Reading the comments makes me feel i am in india, doesnt india have its own news site where you guys can leave your praises and hate against Pakistan?
Look at Indians getting all excited over getting one up on USA. They still don't give a damn about the underpaid maid and are completely in denial over the fact that the bare minimum expected of a diplomat representing your country abroad is to adhere to the laws of that country.
And enough with the 'Pakistan wouldn't dare to do so' arguments - I'd rather that our corrupt politicians be made an example of and shown their place (even if by an international country) than stand behind them and let them continue with their superiority complex.
And in Pakistan, we handed that American murderer Raymond Davis,who was supposedly a "US diplomat," a free ticket home. No charges, no sentencing. Nothing.
Here, I must say: Well done, India!
@Indian Reader: "US must understand that India is not Pakistan" well, but not any Pakistani diplomat was ever treated in USA like Indian lady diplomat. Please think before you say anything on the news.
I did mention that US has to back down as a lot of there contracts r at stake & they cannot hurt India.Also they played a v dirty game by evacuating the maids family from India & after that arresting the Diplomat (treating her like criminal),.Also many US diplomats pay a pittance when they employ the local manpower but that is their right whereas in our case they talk about abuse & then go on attacking 1 country after another. So justice has been served & next time beware & do not do this to diplomats from India or else we have to take similar action.
@Justice: better start from Raymond davis, paki
Something Pakistanis can "never" dream of. We did it in style..lol, just lol.
this is how you deal with USA. I think we should deal with USA they way they deal with us
Typical indian response. isn't she committed any crime on american soil??
This incident reminds me of Raymond Davis where Americans had to beg Pakistan to release him. Thanks to our Nawaz Sharif who released him after getting paid handsomely.
Two countries came into being at the same time. But one country lets its innocent rot in American Jails whereas other stands up to what they believe is arrogant behavior by US. I am sure if it was a Pakistani diplomat, we would have disowned him and let him rot in jail.
When will we earn this much guts?
Pakistan should learn from it too
US got a diplomatic black eye. They could have handled this privately. Despite the accusations, looks good for India the way it stood up against US bullying. Asian unity is needed.
US must understand that India is not Pakitan!
Tit for tat! Dont knew about India but a tight slap on US Ego!