News of Peshawar Electric Supply Company’s (Pesco) handover to the Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) government elicited mixed reactions from the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) led provincial apparatus. While some officials welcomed the transfer as a positive development, others rejected the transfer in its current guise.
Discussing Pesco’s transfer under the 18 Amendment, Minister for Finance Sirajul Haq told The Express Tribune, “K-P has not just asked for the handover of Pesco; the federal government will also have to bear the supply company’s liabilities and losses. This is not mentioned anywhere in the transfer process.”
The centre should devise a plan to bear Pesco’s liabilities and losses, insisted Haq. He added political parties in the government will discuss these issues at a cabinet meeting on Monday (today). However, “in previous meetings it was decided the federal government would bear these costs.”
K-P is like other provinces in Pakistan; it wants to move in line with the rest of the nation in terms of development, said Haq. It is the constitutional right of provinces to be given profits of whatever they produce, but “the federal government is not fulfilling its promises.”
The minister reiterated the centre needs to chalk out a “complete plan” regarding Pesco.
According to Haq, the Malakand-III hydel project was not completed by the federal government even though it possessed all resources needed; the project was ultimately finished by K-P, using its minimal means.
Talking about prolonged power outages faced by K-P, Haq said he understood the problem cannot be solved overnight.
Adviser to Chief Minister (CM) Shiraz Paracha told The Express Tribune CM Pervez Khattak welcomed the move of the federal government. “We do hope it will tackle this issue in a better manner by paying both liabilities and losses.”
All political parties will be taken onboard as stakeholders for this issue, claimed Paracha. “It’s a matter impacting all those living in K-P.” Yet, he argued, the issue of hydel profit, net errors and losses cannot be left untouched and will be discussed by the provincial government and politicos.
Pesco’s losses amount to over Rs100 billion; “a great amount which needs to be tackled. Electricity problems have to be resolved as energy is the lifeline of the country’s economy.”
However, positivity did not emanate from all PTI-led government quarters. Minister for Information Shah Farman rejected the federal government’s intended offer of handing over control of Pesco to the K-P government. “The PTI-led government will not accept the offer in its present form.”
Instead, Farman stated, K-P wants control of Pesco with “zero liability, and is not content with being handed over just the recovery and distribution system.” He said the K-P government wants all its outstanding electricity dues cleared, including net hydel profits.
Farman confirmed PTI’s protest against the power outages will commence from Monday (today).
Icy tiffs
Earlier, PTI had announced a demonstration with its coalition partners outside Wapda House, Peshawar on Monday. The decision was taken even though Pesco explained the latest round of load-shedding is due to the closure of canals and diversion of gas to industrial units.
“Excessive electricity and gas outages in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) have no logical grounds, ” said Ishtiaq Urmar, PTI’s information secretary, during a press conference at Peshawar Press Club on Sunday.
Allegations and counter-allegations between the federal and K-P government have been doing the rounds for the past several months. The state Minister for Water and Power Abid Sher Ali accused the province of having the highest power theft ratio while the K-P government states it should not be subjected to prolonged power outages as it produces excess electricity.
Pesco spokesperson Shaukat Afzal said: “The closure of canals and stoppage of gas to thermal power plants has led to prolonged power outages. This is happening throughout the country and not just in K-P.”
He said the public is requested to conserve energy especially during the peak hours of 6pm to 11pm, adding industrial consumers also need to switch off alternate street lights and billboards.
Of plans and protests
Similarly, hundreds of tribesmen held a demonstration against prolonged power outages in Khar, the headquarters of Bajaur Agency on Sunday. The protesters marched towards the office of the political administration. They warned the political administration and Wapda officials to solve the problem by January 5, 2014.
Meanwhile, at a meeting in Haripur on Sunday, All Pakistan Tanoli Ittehad decided it will take to the streets against Wapda and the government if load-shedding is not stopped in Hazara division soon.
Published in The Express Tribune, December 30th, 2013.
COMMENTS (34)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
I foresee more & more lame excuses from youthias of PTI. They are good for nothing!
The PTI is, and will always remain, a cry baby!
PTI MUST accept PML-N proposal of taking controle of PESCO. such a chance is hard to come anytime soon. The liabilities and net-hydel power profit issues could be resolved if both sides shows maturaty and sit on the table to discuss it further. Please no Politics prosperous K-P means prosperous Punjab and Pakistan. currently Pesco has 56% losses under federal govt if PTI claim they can bring it down to 18% they should take it and stop lame excuses
@Muslim Leaguer: I am a PTI supporter but I absolutely agree with your point here.
These losses are because of electricity theft and people not paying their bills. Logically, it should reside with KPK govt, it can be debated or they may settle for equal share. But it does not imply that federation is bound to pay the losses caused by a province inability to collect bills.
I always thought PMLN can't be that nice to just hand over the management of PESCO. Looks like my suspicion was correct. In place of giving them the authority they quietly handed them all the liabilities and defaults etc. KPK government should only take charge for problems after they take over. It is not their responsibility to fix federal governments previous liabilities.
PMLN shrewd and cunning as ever.
Nawaz Sharif behaves just like a Shaalmi shop keeper. He may not find this a good deal sooner than later. In any case Pakistan is being run by proxy, and that is what Nawaz is used to and likes too.
@A2Z: Sure brother,
1) Nandipur and CKM plants are going to be functional in 1.5 years producing 900 Watts combined. 2) Gaddani plants is one big project initiated, it has capacity of 6600 MW with coal. 3) With landmark deal of LNG import almost getting finalized with Qatar, there are chances that we will have gas available for power plants from next winter. 4) Bhasha and Dasu dams initial funding has been acquired, and they can produce more than 7000 MW. 5) There are some good news on Iran gas pipeline as well. 6) SS is keen on bio gas units in Punjab, they plan on 2000 MW for that, and India is helping in 15 MW test project currently. 7) From sugarcane, SS has planned to generate around 1800 MW, I dont know updates on that.
Not a big fan of PMN, but I am satisfied their energy measures.
How can the federal government handover PESCO and still bear all its previous liabilities and losses? The KPK finance minister is nuts! Either he forgot finance 101 or econ 101 basics or never took them...
PESCO is responsible for the all the liabilities and losses! They are all contained within the KPK province not in other parts of Pakistan... If KPK govt takes PESCO it will have to recover losses and pay all liabilities....
When you give the Finance ministry to someone who has an MA in Islamiat... these comments are bound to come!!!
@Power Would you like to mention those good steps? We are not interested in rhetoric.
If KP gets hydel royalty profits, and Baluchistan gets Gas royalty, why is Karachi or Sind not given Port royalty????
Now PTI supporters have started doing politics of hate and lingual differences. They are promoting provincialism. Imran will ruin KPK. I dont have words to express my disliking for PTI.
Lame excuses from PTI. They are worried from their decreasing popularity. They are planning some more Dharna / Tamasha.
Insha Allah, power shortage will end in Pakistan very soon as I believe that PML N is taking concrete and serious steps to address the issue. Situation will be much better within a year or two. But problem with PTI is that they cannot tolerate the success of PML N government; otherwise they will loose next elections as well. Good steps taken by federal government should be appreciated with open heart. PTI only sees one side of the coin. They do not look on the other side.
@Careless Whispers: its nt abt ethnic card, its about history, Bengali's are disgusted by us, and now we are doing same with pashtoons, with army comprising of 60% punjabis, how long do you think, it wouldnt take long for pashtoons to realize, that if their army cant defend them frm usa and even can invade them, whats the point of being associated with them.
PTI is trying its best to become political martyr. They have badly flopped in KPK.
Where is PTI? only on social media due to media cell of PTI. They are doing dirty politics that is not beneficial for Pakistan.
My dear CM KPK, "Can you please stop fooling the nation and do some constructive work."
The rule is simple.... Clear out all the liabilities and pay all the royalty due to KPK and then hand over PESCO to them.... It should be a complete handover !
punjab is also facing prolonged power outages! Its also 'illogical'. .
@Careless Whispers
Yes the term "narrrow minded" is always used to justify benefits of a particular cause...
Does anybody seriously think PMLN would dare hand over anything where there was even a remote chance PTI could make it work?!
They would never give them a fighting chance.... not this easily anyway!
@Muslim Leaguer: How about we start with LESCO and the Ittefaq default!
PTI is the threat for the democracy. Their actions may destabilize the political system of Pakistan.
@sheraz: objections are genuine. liabilities have to be cleared before transfer. what's wrong in the demand?
Why PTI is wasting the time in doing negative politics? There are many problems being faced by the nation. PMLn came into power after 14 years. Everything is destroyed in Pakistan. Some time is required to rectify the things. But PTI is continuously crying without any valid reason.
PTI will not be happy with any thing question being they intend to deliver nothing. If they are so very much willing to do so THEN DO IT, then will the public now for sure that despite of the constraints and limited resources they still managed to DELIVER which they are supposed to do so. WHICH THEY ARE NEVER GOING TO OR DON'T HAVE THE POTENTIAL TO DELIVER.
@Muslim Leaguer: Kindly justify. As it has been iterated by PTI leaders that if the electricity is to be handed over, it's generation should also be included. What this means is that they will also reap the fruit of better revenue collection. Government isn't willing to hand that over and is trying hard to make people think that PTI has backed out. On the other hand, if you follow the news reports it clearly identifies the shortcomings of the government's proposal. You blatantly misread and misinterpreted the article.
if govt is serious about its offer of handing over, it should implement 18th amendment completely with losses and liabilities, N league Govt should first pay the Royalty of previous years which is pending with Fed Govt, and then PTI led KPK should take a full control.
otherwise it looks like Fed Govt is just scoring political points, That's it.
@salman: Quit playing ethnic card & giving every thing ethnic touch, narrow minded people like u r the reason that we need to deal with to become one nation. Be Pakistani
Involve all the provincial & local governments in recoveries from the defaulters of PESCO, QESCO, HESCO and wherever the electricity losses are more than 40%. After all KESC is performing excellent in the private sector and the losses have significantly reduced. Why should the entire country pay for the electricity theft by these thieves?
It was an opportunity to WALK THE TALK but once again, the PTI Government has FAILED to deliver. Youthias have nothing to defend!
This is excellent decision by the Center government. PTI is only doing politics of agitation and wants to create unrest in society.
Punjab based federal govt. will never pay the losses as KP is not in their priorities.. Pak divided deeply on ethnic bases which is quite alarming and taking us towards 1971 scenario