Census concerns

The census is already overdue by many years and we simply cannot afford to wait any longer.


Editorial December 18, 2013
The government must ensure that census is conducted in a manner that can lead to as little controversy as possible. PHOTO: FILE

The government has reportedly decided that after a 15-year gap, a population census should be held in the country. This is very good news. While the Constitution dictates a census every four years, this has, in recent decades, proved to be a virtually impossible task. A number of ethnic, lingual and political factors mean that simply counting the people of the country has become a task around which all kinds of complications have been wrapped.

Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, after studying a summary presented to him by the Inter-Provincial Coordination Division and a separate document from the Election Commission of Pakistan, decided to go ahead with the census. We must hope the exercise will be a success. It is after all essential, as the ECP has pointed out, not only to the carrying out of delimitations but also to planning and resource allocation. Without proper information as to where people live in the country, who they are or where population sizes have grown the most, it is obviously hard to move ahead in any decisive or meaningful fashion. The long gap between the census held in 1981 and then in 1998 led to a great many problems which were pointed out by planners on numerous occasions. We cannot afford more. This is especially true as our population has grown at around 2.3 per cent a year, meaning that all kinds of alterations in demographics may have occurred unseen and unnoted.

This is unacceptable. The decision to go ahead with the census is, therefore, very welcome. The next priority must be to ensure it is conducted in a manner that can lead to as little controversy as possible. The best way to do this is by following all the required rules, such as  convening a meeting of the Council of Common Interests. The opposition has already pointed out this has not happened as yet. A well-conducted census would take us a long way forward. It is already overdue by many years and we simply cannot afford to wait any longer.

Published in The Express Tribune, December 19th, 2013.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

COMMENTS (2)

Sri Varahadev | 10 years ago | Reply

There are no free lunches and the cost of nuclear weapons and other military toys has it would seem been partly paid by having highly irregular population censuses over multiple occasions!

gp65 | 10 years ago | Reply The need for a census every 4 years is unrealistic in any country. Even US conducts census only once every 10 years. The reason Pakistan constitution mandates is that it links money to be paid by finance commission and representatives from each province to the population. In doing so, the states that fail to control their population are rewarded. Precisely to deal with such situations, in India the ratio for dividing comon pool and for determining number of representatives is based on population as per 1971 census. Thus if a state fails to control its population then it will get a less than proportional increase in divisible pool of finances and is thus penalised as it rightly should. If the finances and numberof representatives are not linked to census, there will not be so much discussion and arguments about the census delaying it. You might wonder why you need census if finances and representation are not liked to it. That is because planning for all kinds of infrastrcture be it healthcare, education, electricity etc. depends on knowing how many people live where. Apart from a census every year, India also measures key health and education metrics with drill down to district level with a large sample of 100000+ every 3 years. This allows planners to deternine if the initiatives that they are taking re yielding the expected results or a course correction is needed.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ