You can’t deny that only cricket unites a divided nation like Pakistan. It gives us something to fist-pump and cheer for — the dream of a victory. A film like Main Hoon Shahid Afridi somewhat does justice to our obsession with cricket. But does it aptly portray the stature of poster boy Boom Boom himself? Not really.
The captain of Pakistani team Akbar Deen (Humayun Saaed) becomes a national disgrace when police in Dubai discover him intoxicated and in the possession of drugs in his hotel room. He is banned from the cricket arena and disowned by his lower middle-class elderly parents, wife (Mahnoor Baloch) and young son for bringing shame to the family.
Fast forward 15 years later. A small cricket club in Sialkot is in desperate need of a coach to prepare it for a local cricket competition. Enter Deen. From here on, the journey for Deen and Shahid Bhatti — the talented but raw cricket-loving youth who hopes to become the next Shahid Afridi — begins. But it is an unbalanced story between Deen and Shahid’s professional and personal life as they prepare to win the cup.
The younger lot of actors deserves special mention; individually and collectively, they take attention away from senior cast members. Noman Habib as Shahid is so immersed in his character that it often seems he is playing his natural self. Add a bit of Gohar Rasheed to his screen space and they give you one of the most immaculate chemistries on screen. Shafqat Cheema as Bhatti sahab is as impactful as always and Ismail Tara is a source of occasional humour with his animated portrayal of Chotay Malik sahab.
The biggest disappointment of the film is Humayun Saaed. Almost like the Voice of God in Hollywood movies, Saeed as Deen appears wherever he wants and however he likes — in his colourful Nike jackets and tracks or jeans (the idea of wearing jeans to training sessions is beyond us). He delivers his lines with monotony, leaving you to decipher the meaning of every spoken word. Whether it’s a serious discussion with Cheema or an intimate scene with Baloch, the mechanical consistency of his expressions is almost miraculous; just before the climax, he literally flies in an action sequence — a funny moment not to be missed. Sexy Mahnoor Baloch makes an appearance with limited scenes, whereas director Osama fails to capitalise on the potential of Javed Sheikh and Nadeem Baig.
Here’s the good news. No matter how done to death the story is, the dialogues stand out. Kudos to Vasay Chaudhry for some hilarious one-liners. One memorable moment is when the religious Pathan team-member (Hamza Ali Abbasi) refuses to play the match alongside a Christian player and someone pipes up, “Match khelna hai — milaad pae nahin jana”.
Areas that need work are choreography, which is pretty naïve, and the over-dramatised ‘party scene’ which is needlessly vulgar in places. Stylistically, the film is below average compared to other recent Pakistani releases. Most montages seem to be forced into the narrative just to try something ‘different’. Excessively bleached colour grading at places too seems without purpose. Logically, when the emotional pre-final match visit to Mazar-e-Quaid in Karachi was shown, one wonders why the match itself was played at the Moin Khan Academy instead of the National Stadium. The cricket shots, the essence of any film on cricket, are executed half- heartedly and without finesse.
The film makes a conscious effort to send out a positive message. It attempts to manufacture a ‘Great Pakistani Dream’, where individuals unite and fight for something irrespective of religion and ethnicity. It is heartwarming, but the director relies on a bucket full of stereotypes and childish narratives to convey it. For this very reason, the Christian wicket keeper (Michael Magnet) is selected in a beautiful church and always carries a cross in hand. The ‘maulana’ pacer is never seen without his keffiyeh and rosary as accessories. Here, we missed the kind of research we saw in Imran Yusuf’s cricket play Stumped.
From the item song to the dance sequences at ‘parties’ that look more like a glorified version of contemporary mehendis, MHSA is following the Bollywood formula, in that it is aiming for a wider audience. While it will undoubtedly make a considerable box office return and be successful commercially, aesthetically it is nothing more than a ‘Made in China’ version of a B-grade Bollywood film.
Verdict 2.5/5
MHSA is a film that has its heart in the right place but no soul. Do watch it to support Pakistani cinema but don’t be surprised if you get fed up of its pretense to achieve something larger than life.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 23rd, 2013.
Like Life & Style on Facebook, follow @ETLifeandStyle on Twitter for the latest in fashion, gossip and entertainment.
COMMENTS (54)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
I don't care what people say about the movie but honestly speaking this was a great effort. The movie has everything comedy, glamour, action and suspense. we should appreciate the effort and encourage them to make more movies like that. Thank God Humayun saeed didn't copy Indian movies that just only contain love stories.
I was very shocked to read this ridiculous review of MHSA, because it was a first for me. Every other newspaper has praised it incessantly, other than this one. And I personally feel that this is why this makes this review inaccurate and untrue. Secondly, you cannot help commending a Pakistani film and giving it individuality, since you are so inclined to Bollywood. Your love for Indian films(evident in this article) forms a bias in your head and prevents you from appreciating the revival of Pakistani cinema, almost making it seem like you have a personal whim against either the cast or the crew of this movie. I think the audience has clearly called this film a 'sixer', so I don't know where you are lost. I loved the film, as well as the witty dialogues blended in to it. The acting of each and every cast member was very natural, and Humayun Saeed's diversity and versitality shone throughout the movie. I beg to differ with your very cynical and biased article. I wish you would develop a love for your nation's achievements and not see others as superior and better.
@proudindian_bpl: The only reason why I watch your movies is because of item numbers. Nice way to market your ladies on the international stage!
You keep eulogizing SHOLAY and criticizing every pak movie that is about to bring a revolution. Its alright what salman does in ek tha tiger but when the same is done by Humayun Saeed, you say it childish. keep ex-cogitating B-Town as the masters where we are novices. You are actually not ready to embrace the beginning of success to lolly-wood eventually.
People are saying why she was wearing that type of clothes and this and that Mahnoor didnt did anything wrong about Mathira the dress she was wearing it was mostly used in our movies when our film industry was famous have you guys ever watched old Pakistanis movies??Watch Dahshat and Larki Punjaban these will change your mind this is a movie don't bring religion in it i am sure you guys watch indians movies and enjoy them but because this is a pakistani movie you guys have problem if you don like it dont watch it and yeah i would also like to say you guys are acting like an idiot it is like you want your wife to wear a burqa but you want the other women to dance
@rabia-u call indian masala movies brainless ..but the same masala of indian movies has been copied in mhsa...btw movies are meant for entertainment.
@BruteForce You obviously know Pakistan from the brief exposure you have from ET (or other online newspaper) which is very limited. It would be similar to me looking at India from a Bollywood lens, which is entirely constructed and escapist. We are pretty unique country in a sense that our culture is a melting pot of indian and persian traditions. So thank you for your advice but we will figure out what works for us. Just like we did for our TV and Music industry. Sure "Pakistan is no India" and it's not entirely a bad thing. No offense to Bollywood! :)
I was thinking about watching it but after reading this review.. naah, forget it
@Khurram: Why should a person who's job is to review with an unbiased view compliment a movie that is not very good. it his job to be fair and write what he thinks. I personally believe this movie is not good and by saying this movie is good when it actually it is not, it lowers the standard of the industry and less chances will be given to the talent that actually wants to make good quality movies.
the milad match quote is incorrect, shouldn't an official review get these things right?
Where is the originality?
In the entire world, only Indian movies, be it in any language - Hindi, Bengali, Bhojpuri, Tamil, etc., have song and dance sequences.
This is because Music, Dance, Art and now Movies are a part of our culture. That is why they are so successful. Even excellently made movies such as Lagaan had songs and hymns. Indian movies don't turn to other cultures to gain inspiration, which makes them truly unique and we Indians own it.
Pakistan did not have a Bollywood, because its a completely different society - Its no India.
Pakistan should look at inspiration from Iran, whose movies have won laurels all over the world. Pakistan has a lot of things in common with Iran, but not much with India, increasingly so.
Pakistan should not try to ape Indian movies, since Indians have first hand experience at Indian culture and will always make better ones. Pakistan should follow the brotherly country - Iran - as a role model.
Loved the film!!!
Dear Writer...please give a break of your critism on pakistani cinema and let the people decide on this film...u r calling it a "made in china" copy of bollywood but u urself would go to theatre to watch some B grade bollywood movie like CE or Dabangg...y cant u guys just give some positive reviews for Pak film industry so hat it can flourish...?..i watched the movie and its very good and entertaining
i have a problem with it, there was a lesbian kiss on screen which was unexpected and shocking! it was very disgusting also we were not told that movie is not for children at the theater when we bought tickets and our children watched the obscene scene, i have reservation against it! censor board should have done something about it! movie was good with good dialogues but it is not a family movie!
@Danish Mughal: Otherwise no sensible person can watch and bear “record breaking” movies like Chennai Express. Sorry, but Bollywood in general sucks! (though Aamir Khan and other genuine artists are exceptionally well and I do respect them all.) . Agree with you. I can't bring myself to watch Bollywood movies either, but I will watch the occasional "Bhaag Milkha Bhaag" and am a huge fan of Aamir Khan. I am pampered though as I not only watch Hollywood but current serials from the US and am a huge fan of "The Colbert Report". I haven't watched "Chennai Express" yet and doubt whether I will be able to bear the torture. The last SRK movie I watched in a theater was "Main Hoon Na" and that has scarred me for life. . On the other hand, I should let you know that Indian movies are not just Bollywood. I find regional movies such as Tamil, Telugu and Malayalam (these are languages I can understand) much more cerebral than the ordinary Bollywood blockbuster. I would sincerely urge you to watch these as well as Bengali cinema which I hear is really avant-garde..
@FRabia: and what after two years? again the same old 'revival of cinema in pakistan' mantra!
its a must watch movie simply awesome
@Azeez Ahmad Zai: Don't compare MHSD with other Pakistani movies.Frankly, Bol didn't appear to me as a film in totality, it was as if I was watching an extended drama serial( it was good though)
Wow at least a movie on some different topic in Pakistan :) Let's hope for its success.
mhsa is so very original that 7 years back yashraj films got to know about the script and copied it as chak de india! but wait a min., the script was inspirational that in '05 nagesh kukunoor made iqbal with naseeruddin shah as a down and out cricked coach! couldn't the makers/writer of mhsa come up with some other theme revolving around the game? to be honest i would prefer to buy a 'multiplex ticket' for madras cafe.
I guess all the Indians commenting on this site must be tired of their biased jingoistic media and now hooked on Pakistani news due to its vibrancy and independence.
I saw the movie and liked it. The audience wants entertainment and a relief from the real world woes and doesnot care about technical faults! Let the audience decide! Atleast they addressed the ethnic issues even if it was cliched. Please stop comparing with any other cinema because it will take us years to even compete with them. Great new releases lined up for Pakistani cinegoers and I for one wish the industry all the best for the next 2 years!
Rafay Mehmood has been critical of the best episodes of Coke Studio even..i doubt if his reviews matter much
@hbs: Agreed to u dear. Pak drama is much better than ours even comedy also like Lahori gate. Hasb e hal khabarnaama bt movies r realy 3rd grade aprt frm BOL N KHUDA K LIYE. Thnx to YouTube v can watch these. M fan of AZIZI :-)
@Sridhar: YEp all movies you stated as well as Lagaan. If you see 'making of lagaan' on youtube also it tells you about the issues they had to resolve to get the cricket scenes right in the context of the movie.
@Gappi: "@ Sridhar: So you want to say there is no sports choreographer in 1.2 billion strong India. And chak de india was an average movie. nothing classy."
No and there is no place to do post production work in 190 million people Pakistan, so pretty much all Pakistani movies, do their post production work ether in India or Thailand.
Should not be compared with Bollywood; if it is not comparable with 'made in Pakistan' Khuda k Liye or Bol sort of moveis, then its a failure.
It should be named "Mein Hon Hafeez" because the looks of main character portraying "Shahid Afridi". Shooting film without working on appearance/looks does not make sense. Poor resemblance exhibits the poor homework behind the scene that’s why local film maker are failed to generate footfall in theaters.
It was a dissapointing film
@hbs: Humsafar was shown on "Indian Rishtey Channel" [sister channel of Colors] for the UK audience ONLY.
@ Sridhar: So you want to say there is no sports choreographer in 1.2 billion strong India. And chak de india was an average movie. nothing classy.
By the way, since we are talking of sports movies (as MHSA is one), try to see movies like "Chuk De India", "Paan Singh Tomar" or the recent one "Bhaag Milka Bhaag". You will notice the difference between the bollywood movies and the rest from South Asia. I saw the making of "Chuk De India" on you tube. It had a sports choreographer (from Australia) as well as a hockey player to help make the movie. That is why that movie is class.
@Np: Not any more dear. Pakistani dramas have a class of their own. Although those Indian dramas had an appeal because of their luxurious sets and dresses, but originality and storyline is what has always been Pakistani dramas focal point. Our most recent hit, Humsafar is actually being aired on one of your TV channels (Colors, I believe). So long story short, STARPLUS is ages behind Pakistani dramas.
How could the article forget to mention the only good thing about this film, Summer Nicks as the captain of the Islamabad team. His performance alongside Gohar Rasheed and Hamza Ali Abbas was remarkable given the scope of the script, made me laugh and hate him, he also delivered the best line in the film. From audience reactions too, he was most loved.
Rafay Mahmood you have never written anything positive about recent Pakistani films. All I ever read is some overly critical hate speech about the smallest of things such "excessively bleached color". Really? Which reviewer does that?
I don't want anyone to compete, I think creating movies that entertains the family is more important. I think bollywood has lowered to skin show instead of creative writing. But let's not be too critical just have plain fun by watching movies. a good movie is a good movie, no matter where it is made. I personally can not wait to see this movie. & you are right Pakistani Dramas are the BEST
@Nana Patekar: That is why star plus is so popular in Pakistan I guess.
@Pappu: Really? Do you know who has won film aware award for best male actor for last 2 years running? Ranbir Kapoor for Rockstar and Barfi - both highly successful movies. This year too he has given a blockbuster zinc ago Na milegi dobara, student of the year, aashiqui 2, raanjhana, Vicky donor also have been hits with fairly young heroes.
But until viewers are happy to see older heroes also, why should producers stop signing them on?
Indian trolls. Argh. Ready to spoil every happy occasion for us.
Well, since its Humayun Sayeed one cannot expect something non-stereotypical. Humayun's last film, Main Aik Din Lout Kay Aoonga, was too a bizarre thing highly inspired by Bollywood, and included the same senselessly vulgar dance sequences. And I think Humayun & Reema should realize by now that they are too old and ill-trained to act as hero/heroine in a film!
Looks like neither the critic nor the commentators can talk about a Pakistani film without making it all about India and Bollywood.
Tells you something, doesn't it?
Why Pakistan need to compete with Indian cinema that produces only one or two watchable movies in a year.
@ lalagee: And India/ Bangladesh can never compete with Pakistani TV dramas although there is no language barrier.
For god sake bring some new faces. Bollywood is back to already rotten khans aksheys kapoors and ajay devgan. All the new lot from former actors have gone into hole in no time.
@danish mughal : you say bollywood sucks let i remind you what bollywood had produce films this year 2013 1) special 26 2) ship of thesus ( might be oscar entry from india) 3) raanjahnaa ( not released in pakistan ) 4) kai po che 5) lootera ( your'S critics says boring) 6) bhaag milka bhaag ( will bags all the awards in upcoming awards includig national awards) 7)Aashiqui 2 8) d day 9)Jolly LLB 10) Table No. 21 11) Saheb Biwi Aur Gangster Returns 12)Aurangzeb but 100 crore movies not in the list as far chennai express is concerned it was family entertainer and realeased in huge amount of screen that why chennai express collected huge & it was good not the great movie as far as SRK is concered he also done swades , chad de india which no one noticied and people say him a overrated actor , after a OSO he has some hardcore over the top movie and UNEDUCATED is not a thing dear , chennai express is collected 90 crore worldwide & i thought worldwide viewers are educated o i was wrong hasn't i????????
Truly, we are a nation overly critical of ourselves and profusely complimentary of others. We need to learn form others.
pakistanis should not and will not be able to develop its film industry...just like canada,australia,newzeland,europe etc....rely on hollywood..because they cant compete due to language barrier...similar is cASE with pakistan..they cant compete with India..they even cant compete with bangladeshi bangla movies...as simple as that...
I saw some very positive remarks by notable actors after watching the premiere. Every Pakistani should go out watch it with an open heart. 'allow' it to entertain you. If u'll go with this mind that this is a copy of Bollywood films, you will feel the same. SUPPORT PAKISTANi Cinema
@proudindian_bpl: Lack of Education my friend, Otherwise no sensible person can watch and bear "record breaking" movies like Chennai Express. Sorry, but Bollywood in general sucks! (though Aamir Khan and other genuine artists are exceptionally well and I do respect them all.)
why pakistan watch bollywood if they hate india or their's movies got postpone because of chennai express
Story is similar to chak de India. Don't wanna watch just bcoz its made in Pakistan.
Loved your critical review till you wrote: