Past experience, however, reveals that APCs only serve as occasions for the participants to reiterate their stated positions on an issue, which is now threatening the existence of the state and society. The core issue is pushed aside and is overtaken by a keenness on holding parleys with the militant outfits, which are spawning gruesome attacks without any let-up. The net outcome waters down the plan of action. This is more on account of the fact that certain political parties wish to stay relevant in terms of their anti-West narrative, which at the same time, unwittingly provides space to the militant outfits. Overtures of talks with these elements have often only provided them with a breather to regroup and re-gear their operations.
Militant movements and killing squads the world over present a negotiable agenda. Either they demand a chunk of territory or a charter of political rights. In Pakistan’s case, the situation is far more murky and complex. The dark forces we face are employing the most violent means to create their own make-believe world, in which the state and society operate according to their own perceived ideas.
After the US withdrawal from the region, in all likelihood, we are going to see a big surge in the Taliban’s operations on both sides of the Durand Line. With the Allied forces gone, the supportive networks of militants on both sides of the Durand Line will be acting in close concert. Convergence of sectarian outfits with the operations of the Taliban cannot be ruled out. This is what happened in the 1990s when the Taliban were ruling Afghanistan. With the American gloss having been removed from the scene, it will be interesting to watch the stance of our right-wing parties in case suicide bombings continue unabated.
The war on terror has to be won for the sake of establishing long-term peace and progress. It's time now to learn from the experience of others. There are always close analogies, notwithstanding the situational specificities. Sri Lanka, for instance, is an example close to home.
Problems faced by the battered Sri Lankan nation were highly daunting, which involved placating international sensitivities, dealing with alleged interference by a mighty next-door neighbour, emotive and material support from Tamil Nadu to the separatist Tamil Tigers etc. The country faced the vagaries of civil war and an unremitting spate of suicide attacks for nearly three decades. It, however, fought its way out of this quagmire.
Tamil separatists had turned into a professional combat machine and were able to raise a well-trained infantry, artillery, naval gunships and a fleet of stealth boats. They were also able to raise death squads of suicide bombers, which carried out the most chilling operations during these years. Commitment to the cause was so deep that the Tamil Tigers doyen, Villuplai Prabhakaran, had given a blank cheque to his followers to gun him down if he ever wavered in their cause. The Tamil separatists were able to gain control of the Jaffna peninsula. They imposed local taxes and ran their own affairs while unhinging peace on the main island. They had access to the international arms bazaar through brokers and agents located across the Palk Strait in Chennai.
How the Tamil Tigers sustained such a long-drawn war makes for an interesting reading. The Tamil diaspora, which is spread across the world from Australasia to the Carribbean, is known as one of the most industrious and enterprising ethnic stocks. One-time indentured labourers were now present on the political and business horizons of many countries. The community boasted of an elaborate and wealthy financial network spread over money markets, real estate and retail businesses. The Tamil Tigers had set up their offices wherever the Tamil diaspora was concentrated, which in turn, made generous contributions to their separatist movement and militant operations. Moves for truce and ceasefire through interlocutors never worked and agreements to this effect were often breached.
There was a turnaround in fortunes in 2006 when the Sri Lankan leadership and forces made a decisive move and successfully choked the Tamil separatists’ supply chain. Armed vessels were either seized or destroyed within the economic zone. The high seas were subjected to intrusive vigilance. A sizeable cargo fleet was owned by the Tigers, which was employed for shipment of arms; half of them were destroyed by the Sri Lankan Navy. The inflow of finances was tracked down and a constant trail was maintained. On the battlefront, the Tigers were underpinned and were taken under siege in the Jaffna peninsula, and their links with militants in the eastern region were not only severed but a creeping wedge within the Tigers’ leadership was played around to the advantage of the government. The Indians were now feeling the blowback of the fratricidal war and seemed less than enthused about bolstering the beleaguered Tamil Tigers. Neutralisation of a foreign force in the conflict zone also made the difference. The Tamil resistance fell like a house of cards. A multi-pronged strategy, in essence, was buttressed by an overarching firm resolve of chasing the terrorists to the hilt, no matter how noble the causes they espoused were.
Is our leadership prepared to display a similar resolve in the face of similar challenges? Do we have the same kind of resolve to fight out the battles our society faces and is our politico-religious leadership ready to deny the militants space? The answer to these questions do not seem to be forthcoming despite the deep concern writ large on the face of every Pakistani.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 8th, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (28)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
I too wish that we have he resolve of the Rajapakse's. The govt. and the army need to get on the same page and wipe out these creatures.
Parts of this analysis has validity, however does not do justice to the single minded resolve and dedication the Sri Lankan leadership managed to evoke in every man, woman and child in the face of this 'do or die' fight. It rallied around itself people from far and wide and even those who were skeptical of everything else the Rajapakse regime stood for. It is called visionary leadership and Sri Lanka's military victory against terrorism was the unflinching stance its larger population adopted as a result. Other factors helped.
Never underestimate the power of human resolve. Pakistan too has to resolve to put its entire house in order, and have its citizens buy into a 'do or die' fight to the finish in search of a stable nation in which every one can feel safe. Not doing so will definitely give reasons for external involvement, as is happening today.
@Nadir - You have 2 options - living under a non-violent autocratic (and possibly corrupt) ruler (with his cronies in top posts) or living under the Taliban rule (with floggings, amputations, beheadings - Stone Age in short)...
Which one would you prefer? I would go for the 1st option (Sri Lankan President.)
The world is not perfect, my dear friend... Live with the best possible option.
Tigers were easily crushed with the help of the West mostly because Sri Lanka s an island. Oppression of ethnic miorities is only etting worse after the war was won.
"@antanu: Stop calling “we” when you clearly are not…"
Surya, that is not fair. As a Muslim, Antanu should be able to call himself on any side he wants depending upon what suits him at a time. All my friends do so. Ha ha.
The author has misunderstood the negative role of India and completely ignored the positive role of Pakistan in Sri Lankan situation.
@antanu: Stop calling "we" when you clearly are not...
I think pakistan has more similarities with lebanon, than srilanka. in the 70s lebanon was a prosperous peaceful place, a place where hijab and miniskirts co-existed, and beirut was known as the paris of middle east, but there were 1/2 million palestinian refugees with armed militia a state within a state, they carried out occasional raids on israel.
israelis were there to exploit the fault lines between muslims and christians, syria jumped inas well, lebanon became a proxy war between syria and israel, in the end it became such a mess not many knew who was fighting whom, christians, muslims, sunnis, shias, palestians, druzes, i might have left some out, there were that many.
A once peaceful, sophisticated and cultured society was destroyed, we in pakistan don't even have the luxury of lebanon's prosperity or its small population. on a positive note we do have a large well organised army.
"There is no resolve,policy and strategy to deal with this menace of terrorism in Pakistan from any political and religious party/ leadership,because on thing is very clear that this issue is political and can not be redress from military action alone.Complete nation has to be on board to fix this problem."
Not necessary for the entire Nation to be "on board" In Sri Lanka the main Opposition Party, UNP did not give support to the military action against the LTTE, the Indian Tamil Tea Plantation workers were not supportive, many Sinhala people spoke against the military action, all the Western Governments including India were against deciding militarily. In 2009 the Government had a severe opposition to taking action against the LTTE. But the President and the Defence Secretary acted decisively and the Military Leadership gave their support and the men and women walked to victory dying on the way. That is the Resolve necessary in Pakistan or any other country. Even today the Western Countries are bringing in resolutions after resolutions against Sri Lanka for War Crimes. It is a disgrace.
LTTE was successful as long as it was solely an insurgent group. But, they moved on to become a professional Army, getting a private Navy and an Airforce. When they did that it was not a fight between an insurgent group and an Army, but a conventional warfare between 2 armies and the superior force won.
TTP are not an Army, their strength lies in belief in Jannat after death(which makes them dangerous as they truly believe death is not the end. Giving life for a cause will become much easier. LTTE never believed in such things) and guerrilla tactics.
To equate the Sri Lankan struggle against LTTE with Pakistani struggle against TTP is not right.
Its understandable that you quote the Sri Lankan success, but miss out on a more appropriate fight - India's fight against Pakistan-backed militants.
India too fought against insurgents, who got support from areas where the Army could not venture(POK). Like the TTP, Pakistani militants excel at guerrilla tactics. Like the TTP, Pak Militants too believed in Jannat and Fidayeen attacks were very common.
Today Kashmir is much quieter than Pakistan's biggest cities Karachi and Lahore. Indian success formula is easily applicable to Pakistan.
Americans have realised this and asking Indians help in anti-insurgency operations.
http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2013-08-04/us/410569461indian-army-counter-insurgency-joint-training
But, can anyone in Pakistan admit India's success? Especially considering that Pakistan's support to such groups is the reason why TTP exists today?
@Rajeev Nidumolu: "Sri Lankan Government could not have won the civil war without active and covert support from India" You call it support! I call it rectifying past mistakes!! Sri Lanka would have beaten the LTTE many times over if not for the interference of India.
Not only India helped to create the LTTE monster it fed nourished and protected it. So any assistance to eliminate it becomes just correting the past mistakes rather than support. The only support Sri Lanka needed to win the war was non intereference and the supprot it offered was loud and clear from M.K.Narayanan the security advisor to the Indian Govt.
Writer tries to compare Muslims with Tamils and LTTE's movement with Taliban . Taliban is a product of Islamic ideologies while LTTE was something different . But Terrorism is terrorism and must be condemned.
@khan ali: Ali, why not, Western governments towards the end of the War was too hostile against Sri Lanka. Do you know that the then British and French foreign ministers together visited Sri Lanka to push to end the war and got the very correct answer from our president who said that Sri Lanka is no more a colony and that Sri Lanka military is not occupying another country (refering to Iraq and Afghanistan) but trying to finish terrorism in own country. After the end of war the West is even more hostile for not listening to them to stop the war so as to give another life line to LTTE terrorists!!
@Nadir: The author writes about the defeat of Tamil Terrorism in Sri Lanka. Infact current political culture doesn't matter here. The politicians will have their dead end in next election if they are corrupt. And your imaginative figures such as 40,000 deaths (you know these figures are not established at all and were first written in TamilNet as 7,000 deaths then wrote as 20,000 and then as 40,000 from nowhere. Then this figure was picked up by human rights industry and then noted in UNSG's panel report. This was rather a classic document written and published by a four-member panel even without visiting Sri Lanka to find facts as required. So someone may say that 40,000 deaths are 'according to UN report') are nowhere established and anyway doesn't matter in the writers argumanet. Fact is that the SL Government with its definite aim and will, destroyed the LTTE terrorist outfit with its leader in Sri Lanka!!
This is just a repetition of many other "wise" pronouncements on this sad issue. The international community over the years turned a blind eye to a genuine grievance of the Tamils, the pogroms and discrimination which then allowed the LTTE to gain a foothold. Needless to say the LTTE was initially nurtured by India. The statement by the author " One-time indentured labourers were now present on the political and business horizons of many countries" simply brings out the lack of understanding by the so called experts and commentators. The Tamils of North and East of Sri Lanka are not descendants of the indentured labour (by the British), but can trace their ownership of the land to antiquity.
This article has been written without Complete analysis of the Srilankan Issue if you are not Sure, better don't write an misleading article like this This column is completely absurd. Most of the countries in the globe don't accept this massacre of common people, except few countries like Pakistan,china who want to have a political gain from it are still walking on the dead bodies of innocent common people. Shameless and ethic less countries are talking of TAMIL diaspora
@ Nadir......Taliban and their atrocities on the innocents of Pakistan Is the subject of the article not the family politics of Sri Lankan ruler . Please come back to the subject and advise how the Taliban should be dealt by the Govt and security forces .
Dear Nadir:
What you have mentioned on your comments are rumours and some are fabricated stories. Journalists are kidnapped, Who are the journalists you are talking about? If you are talking about a gang of people who received dollars and pounds from NGO's for their unwaivering support to them on tarnishing the image of Sri lanka and the president, then we have to say sorry. please go and check who went missing and who are still enjoying lavish lives in western countries as a gift for their achieved targets.
You are right! current president and his family in every sphere of Sri lankan life. It is not only president's wish, it is people of Sri lanka's wish to see them in every section. Why? Where ever Rajapaksha's are people are confident that they will do the job for the country. They have proved it by winning the war against terror which has destroyed whole Sri lankan nation during last three decades . And now by bringing the country to new phase of development. So don't worry about Rajapaksa's any more.
About former army commander. Have you ever heard about any legitimate government allowing their army generals to take political power in to their hand? then tell me the list please. Why you ask us to do that. He was a great hero and he will be in Sri lankans mind for ever for what he has done to eliminate terrorism. But people have never expected him to challenge our leader and involve in active politics while holding the uniform. He crossed his limits and as a result rule of law came forward. And later election results has shown what was then people's desire.
Investigations should be carried out for sure. But not only about the civilian deaths on last phase but also form the beginning of the conflict as I believe every human life has a same value. Including Tiger terrorists killings of innocent Sinhala villagers, Buddhist monks at Sri maha bodhiya and Arantalawa area. Also about blood baths caused by tiger suicide explosions in all over the country. Same time about the massacre conducted against innocent Muslims by LTTE terrorists at Kaththankudi and Matara mosques. why not about child soldiers who were recruited by force in Tamil tigers evil operations.
The president and the secretary of defense (Ghotahbaya Rajapaksha) are the saviors of our nation and the people have understood it very well. It was people's wish, It is people's wish and it will be people's wish to see them in power as long as they can.
Great write up on the subject so far . Religious lobby is extraordinarily strong in Pakistan today . The government and all the security organizations are on the backfoot and paralyzed . Nawaz govt is just not in a position to take on these thugs and criminals . It is a government suffering from cognitive dissonance , they don't see the leviathan that is devouring the state relentlessly and nothing is sacrosanct for them .
They talk of all parties conference for consensus when no two individuals can agree on anything in the country . This Govt has all the authority in lieu of its majority in the parliament ,why do they want to seek the consent of unrepresentatives . Time has come to unleash all the fire power on these savages and brutes if the Govt wishes to stem the rot .
@Rajeev Nidumolu: in this instance you are wrong.go and see the records to assess the truth.we still do not take it kindly and sided with US in UN to blame SRILANKA for human rights violation while fighting LTTE. and it is a recorded fact that we refused to supply arms to SL during their action against LTTE and pakis getting a chnce supplied arms to SL and came into their good books.
Dear Tariq, i also believe like you we must adopt a ' 'Sri Lanka solution'. Pakistan must learn from Sri Lanka if we ever going to rise as nation. here is what i mean by the this:
Pakistan needs a ‘Sri Lanka' solution. The low/high level war waged by Tamil terrorists was finally over when Sri Lankans decided to kill the top leadership and destroyed their sanctuaries...For 30 years Tamil tigers terrorized the country while pretending to be fighting for greater Tamil rights. During that time, they ravaged the country with suicide bombs and executions of innocents and mostly Tamils who disagreed with their tactics. Sound familiar?
For 30 years, Sri Lankans were like Pakistanis are today, they were paralyzed and believed in 'magic' that somehow if they could just put their heads in sands, Tigers and their many supporters would just go away and they could live happily ever after..... Remember it took them 30 years to finally have the courage to stand up against killers. Today, Sri Lanka is back on the world map...commerce, cricket, tourism is back and life is thriving again.
All we have to ask a simple question...how much time do we have and how many lives we can feed to monster?
But what's happening in Pakistan is different as the militants, government and the Pakistani Army share the same ideology.Its a nation created on hate for others.
There is no resolve,policy and strategy to deal with this menace of terrorism in Pakistan from any political and religious party/ leadership,because on thing is very clear that this issue is political and can not be redress from military action alone.Complete nation has to be on board to fix this problem.
Apart from the mildly racist statements and the stereotyping of an entire ethnic community, your views of Sri Lanka and its leadership is one sided. What happened in and is currently happening in Sri Lanka does teach us lessons. The current President has installed himself and his family in every sphere of Sri Lankan life. From his brother to son holding key offices. Newspaper editors are disappearing, journalists are being kidnapped, investigations into the death of thousands of Tamil civilians ignored, the list go's on and on. The power grab of egoistic President arrived to the point where the Army General who headed the war against the LTTE ended up under house arrest as he tried to run an opposition campaign against the sitting President. Now the troubles in Sri Lanka are simmering as Buddhist violence against Muslim's has increased and the President is happy to tolerate disenfranchising Muslims and Tamil's in the country. If this is a"model" that you think Pakistan should adopt, well things are not that far off, over 40,000 of our fellow countrymen have died, but our political and military leadership seem quite happy letting thousands more die as they serve their own interests. Just like Sri Lanka.
Sri Lankan Government could not have won the civil war without active and covert support from India. Indian navy enforced blockade of arms shipments to LTTE. Indian central government did not interfere in the last days of civil war despite coming under intense political pressure from state of Tamil Nadu. LTTE lost all sympathy in India after it carried out assassination of Rajeev Gandhi
"...Tamil diaspora was concentrated, which in turn, made generous contributions to their separatist movement ..." That's partly true - much of the "contributions" were not voluntary but extorted from the hardworking, regular folks - know of at least 3 professionals here in Toronto who got such threats "to contribute" .
"...Indians were now feeling the blowback of the fratricidal war and seemed less than enthused ..." India's enthusiasm waned immediately in the aftermath of Rajiv Gandhi's disastrous decision to send the IPKF into SL - making them the target of both the LTTE and SL. Had I not been rejected on medical grounds, would have probably got posted there. Know friends from my interview batch who died there.
The SL govt & army was single minded in eliminating the LTTE. However, had India not plugged/closed their end during the SL army's campaign, thereby denying the LTTE any material and other support; it would have had the same result as the Americans have today in Afg - remember, the Pak army was supposed to 'plug' their end so the Taliban would be caught between the American and Pak forces.
But we all know what happened. This piece now, while accurate is more like bolting the barn door after the horses have fled. No?
the western powers didn't support the tamil tigers, becuse they were urging turkey for reunification of cyprus, for them to have supported the tamil tigers cause would have been hypocracy. no insurgency can last without external support.