Pakistan denies Australian sheep mistreated

A local daily reported authorities used untrained workers who stabbed, clubbed the sheep to death.


Afp October 01, 2012

KARACHI: Pakistani authorities on Monday denied a report that thousands of Australian sheep culled over disease fears were killed improperly, insisting they were slaughtered in accordance with Islamic practice.

A court on Saturday halted the cull of 21,000 Australian sheep amid a dispute over whether or not they are sick, but a senior official insisted the 7,600 animals already killed had not been mistreated.

The shipment of sheep arrived in Pakistan almost a month ago after being turned away by Bahrain, and livestock officials ordered them to be culled after they tested positive for salmonella and actinomyces bacteria.

But after an appeal by importer PK Meat and Food Company, the Sindh High Court rejected the test results and ordered fresh samples to be taken and sent to Britain for analysis.

A report in Karachi-based newspaper The News International said the authorities had used untrained workers who had stabbed and clubbed the sheep to death and even buried some while still alive, prompting anger in Australia.

According to the report, which referred to video shot on a mobile phone, some of the animals were disposed of in shallow graves. AFP has not seen the video.

Roshan Shaikh, Karachi's top administrative official, said reports of the animals' mistreatment were untrue.

"We have slaughtered the sheep in Islamic manner and duly buried them deep in trenches ensuring that they could not cause danger to human population or animals," he said.

"There was just a single sheep, the throat of which was not properly cut, but that was a human error and not deliberate."

The Australian government has said it is looking into the reports.

The court will reconvene to decide on the sheep's fate on October 16, after receiving results from the British laboratory. Samples for the new tests were taken in the presence of Australian experts, Shaikh said.

Australia has insisted salmonella and actinomyces are part of normal bacteria found in sheep and pose no threat to human health.

The incident has renewed calls for a total end to Australia's live export trade, which is worth about US$1 billion a year and employs around 10,000 people.

Australia suspended live cattle exports to Indonesia for a month last year after a television documentary revealed mistreatment inside its abattoirs, only reinstating the trade under a strict new licensing system.

COMMENTS (13)

Tauqeer | 11 years ago | Reply

Australian govt should have the courtesy to explain why 22,000 of their sheep were brought to Pakistan, these sheep were not even destined to touch Pakistani port. Pakistan should lodge a high powered protest with the Australian Embassy in Pakistan & ask them to immediately take back all the remaining sheep. Additionally the govt should also take stern action against all those who helped in un-loading these infected sheep.

I'modesti | 11 years ago | Reply Most of the comments mirror our, typical, mindset which calls for denying your failures but also brazenly facing the onslaught of the righteous. This happens to be a simple case of a Pakistani trader who overestimated his own ability to make a profit out of peddling crap, from Bahrain in this instance. He overestimated his ability to bribe and - politically or otherwise, including religious incantations - influence his way out of the clutches of the "authorities". Partial proof being the report, never emphasised, that a few thousand of the lot had "mysteriously gone missing" upon arrival! I am sure the importer will now wangle pathological tests based on specimens drawn from this lot. Let's face it. "Eidul Adha" is at hand and many a sick, diseased animal will be 'sacrificad' and the not-so-affluent among us will gladly give and receive portions of such offerings. I humbly suggest that we should all 'pipe down' as Sailors say, and simply watch the tamasha until eid-time, for thereafter all this will have been swept under some carpet or otherwise forgotten. Let us however, sympathise with our Australian 'benefactors' who obviously were unable to buy out the official(s) in Bahrain, and had hoped to make an easy deal with our lot, being quite familiar with mores and practices of our baboos and sahibs.
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ