PTI puts Google on notice for not removing anti-Islam film
The announcement was made by PTI’s Secretary General Dr Arif Alvi after Google’s statement was published in New York Times saying that the film would stay on YouTube as it did not violate its policies describing hate speech.
The PTI demanded immediate removal of the video from YouTube and also asked the video sharing website to avoid such a repetition in future.
The statement said:
The party has put Google Inc. on notice and reserves the right to initiate legal action against the company in accordance with law in each and every jurisdiction where Google has a physical and/or virtual presence and where it can be deemed to have indulged in, abetted, provoked or incited any wrongdoing, including but not limited to causation of loss to life and property.
The PTI demanded Google to review its policy otherwise “more criminals and crackpots would create such videos and find YouTube a safe platform to promote hate.”
Alvi said that even after millions have protested in the Muslim world including Pakistan and with so many deaths and billions in losses to property and production, it was shameful that Google still considered that the video does not violate its policy of hate speech.
He further said that, in contrast, the company removed 10 films and 1700 video clips on Holocaust denial earlier this year.
The PTI secretary general said that with the threats of positioning US marines in many countries to protect US citizens, such incidents have the potential of rousing international conflicts. He added that Article 19 and 20 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) is explicit in defining freedom of speech with respect to the rights of others and also limited by issues that create public disorder.
He said that although the ‘hate bullet’ was prepared by a criminal residing in the US, the gun to fire the ‘hate bullet’ has been provided by YouTube as a Google-owned website and controlled affiliate.
COMMENTS (71)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
pti your talk very well this the stand up
PTI stand for openness and liberty but it shouldn't mean hurting masses and create hatred. We don't curse people on street because it hurts. I think emotional torture is recognized fact and everyone should respect PTI for having a principle stand. Way to go PTI
Some observations: 1. After May 2007, PTI had promised action in London against MQM. Status - zilch. 2. More recently PTI promised action against Sharif family from a money laundering perspective in London courts. Status : zilch 3. Now they promise legal action against youtube. Likely status? you guessed it. 4. Stoking anti-Americanism whether on the drones issue or this issue is a successful political gimmick but if and when Khan comes to power, it will cost him dearly by narrowing his foreign policy options seriouslysignificantly.
Take them to court, that's the only option left now.
We must worry about future of some grand heritage churches of Pakistan. If hateful people make insane movies and half crazy youtube staff won.t take them down then one day we can lose those cathedrals and gothic buildings and it will be an unrecoverable loss. No government can control angry mobs joined by looters and gangsters.
Pakistan Govt is failed BUT not the PEOPLE of Pakistan. Well done PTI !!!
I dont think this will get anywhere, and it is a good way for PTI to do drama in front of the public.
But, then I look at it another way, this action is so much better than bilours bounty, rajas vague call for a new international law and the protesters actions on a day of love and reverence.
So well done PTI, although this movie is very diffferent from holocaust denial and glorification laws. Those laws are more akin to hate speech and incitement to violence laws. While the movie in question is pathetic, it cannot qualify as one that incites people.
It seems some people here dont like the step taken by PTI May be they want what we saw on friday.
@all If u can not understand the depth people have for our beloved prophet pbuh, then please dont comment here. Removal of such hate films is the fastest and the most correct way to put this riots off. Great move by PTI. A true representative of Youth in Pakistan.
When/If Imraan Khan comes to power he should have Google banned in Pakistan and much good it will to everyone.
Even if, for the sake of argument, they are hypocrites. It's still not illegal to be a hypocrite. If it's not illegal, they're not obligated to change a thing. You can lose respect and shun a hypocrite. But, that's it as far as laws and rules of business are concerned.
Another Notice from Pakistan
Guys,
If PTI thinks it can force Google into a corner via legal means and impact the 1st Amendment of the United States, it must be the most delusional party in Pakistan, and its followers equally delusional. There are many videos and anti-semitic hate speeches uploaded onto youtube in the United States by the week. This may be illegal in Germany because of its Nazi past but it is pretty much legal elsewhere. In any case, there are calls to kills Jews and Christians by Islamic clerics in the Gulf countries, and which, are uploaded on youtube.
All in all, I didn't see the killing of fellow Muslims on Ishq-e-Rasool day as a sign of piousness. Rather it was an opportunity for looting, arson and rioting. Unfortunately, Kaaptan Khan is worshiped like a saviour in Pakistan.
as usual typical simpletons coming up with simpleton arguments. I dont think pti people can even understand that it is the freedom of speech that allows muslims to not only live freely in the US but to be able to preach Islam, if christians had started to say that they are engaging in blasphemy by calling Christ as prophet rather than Son of God than just imagine what could have they done in the US? I just wish that Muslims grow up, I know it is the youngest of the three big religions but its about time to grow up and react more maturely when some one insults them. Mature people do no react the way Muslims react. Instead of bragging about we being emotional or having high temperature of love with your prophet, you should start recognizing this that this is not something to be proud of or to be praised on. When someone like bilour gives the reasons why he declared the 100000 bounty he should be ridiculed and sent to a mental institution on live TV so that people can stop idolizing immature behaviors!
Im, kinda shocked to read some of the comments. Even our govt. has an ISSUE with youtube, hence the blocking of it. Taking to court is something what our govt. should've done. You force them to change their laws and solve alot of the issue because youtube IS something 'worldwide'. Appreciate the decision whoever took it be it PTI, PMLN whatever (because you cant really expect anything from this so called govt. now). Whats left to see now is whether they DO actually take them to court or is it just one of those things.
@Najeebullah: The relationship between TTP and PTI is the same as it is between IRA and Sinn Fein in Northern Ireland. PTI is just the political face of TTP and Taliban.
It is true what he said. Google promptly removes all videos which stir hatred of this type against Jews especially when it comes to holocaust denial. Google et all are hypocrites.
The wanna-be westerners supporting the "first amendment" and "freedom of speech" will unfortunately not get a U.S. visa even after doing this. Tough luck, I guess.
Could you please have a link to PTI's statement? Is this the letter from Arif Alvi to Eric Schmidt you're referring to?
A bold step by PTI. At least it claimed to take such a step unlike other parties including Government of Pakistan who remained speechless. Looking forward for implementation.
The statement said:
"The party has put Google Inc. on notice and reserves the right to initiate legal action against the company in accordance with law in each and every jurisdiction where Google has a physical and/or virtual presence and where it can be deemed to have indulged in, abetted, provoked or incited any wrongdoing, including but not limited to causation of loss to life and property."
And what about the life and property of your fellow Pakistanis and more importantly Muslims? more than 20 killed, many injured, 76bn in property loss, who is going to pay for that you dolt.
So sad at few comments for whom this video against Prophet (PBUH) is a non issue and they dont want anybody to raise voice against it even peacefully...Whts the difference between you people and those Mullahs you people keep bashing upon??
@Mard-e-Haq: taking notice of double standards of google isnt equal to overturning first ammendment of US..
PTI has a history of making these statements and then backing off. Can PTI tell us in which court its fighting against MQM, PML(N) and others. Nobody believes anymore in PTI's claims.
The only option to stop Google from airing its anti-Islamic video is to convert Google and Youtube to Islam.....
PTI supporters of India can'r dare to protest on street . Now they are protesting from iinside the mosque and maderssas .
Hindu should take notice of it .
@mindless: Thank you for your research and information.
Don't like Google? Don't use it! PTI is protesting what Taliban would protest without guns.
SC of Pakistan will only admit this case and no where in the world , Try.....
Such non sense expected from tsunami khan party. What a bunch of jokers.
A good move. If video against Holocaust can be removed then why not the video against Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). As a party of representing Pakistani People PTI has every right to demand this on behalf of their millions of supporters.
Appreciate this step by PTI.
Can't understand why people are feeling such a heart burn on PTI's step. There is no hatred against anyone and no violence at all. What is insane, stupidity and cheap in it? Representing and amplifying people voices is not the right but the basic duty of people's representative.
Great step PTI
@Khurram Malik: Just read the whole statement carefully and you will find it very relevant, I have life long conviction for freedom of speech but one can not call "fire" in a crowded movie theater or any gatherings because it is not free speech but looks as it is. This films was made deliberately with malicious intent to spread hate, it is the responsibility of a corporation to curtail it because it impinges on the rights of others. They won't allow anything against Jewish Holocaust and rightly so but they should also respect the rights of billions of Muslims around the world. Pakistan is becoming a the laughing stock of the world not because of the proposed law suit by PTI but the rampage that went on killing and destroying the country because of this convicted criminal in California bated the Pakistanis and they fall for it. The enemies of Pakistan are laughing and taking lots of solace for the stupidity of these people and even the minister of this outfit in Islamabad.
that's the way to go!
totally support PTI on this, legal action should be taken if google doesn't comply.
i think that those who are making joke of this initiative should look into their own collar,that what they want to show,like they say that its a joke,when you are fighting your case in peaceful and thru dialague,and in other case when you are protesting in manner in which we saw on YAUM ISHQI RASOOL S.A.W.W,then also are you people on fore front who like the west say that you are non civilized,so my question from those who have on objection on pti,do you know better way what to follow as to come to a better solution.
The people that love prophet pbuh ,are quiet. no processions no threats ,no watching this film no comments ,
Now I am confused what is the difference between PTI and TTP. both are extremists and work for the protection of strategic assets (Taliban, al-Qaeda and haqqani network).
People who have been offended by this movie have every right to protest and use court of law. People who are not they can continue to live their lives as normal. No one has any right over the other and there is no obligation. Its ironic that we consider west as educated and civilized, yet they are insensitive towards this issue and keep defaming muslims and defending themselves. I am wondering what have actually muslims done to them for all this hate. Has any muslim country attacked any western country in the last century, none. Then why do they hate us so much and make fun of us. Please tell me.
Or the whole Muslim world could grow up and join the rest of us in the 21st century. Rioting and killing over a badly made 13 minute video or a cartoon is pathetic.
its a saner reaction...instead of violent protests and destruction of lives and prperty taking legal route is sensible and must be supported by all irrespective of their political alliances
A cheap political stunt which unfortunately seems to work in Pakistan. For those witless people who think this threat has substance let me remind you that Google turned down a request from the President of the USA and won't give a hoot about a threat from a Pakistani politician. Issue hasn't changed a lick -- if you don't like Google or Utube then don't use it - no one forces you to use those services.
excellent move...PTI ZINDABAD!!
Very nice .. legal action should be taken against google and youtube. They're not "gods" and are answerable.
i do not understand what is real problem with ET and some people.what is wrong with this statment. . . why are some people showing anger
Under international jurisdiction what actions PTI will take, will have far reaching impact on Google globally. Those Bigots who are laughing at PTI should read the privacy policy of Google. Just a mere member of PTI living in US or Europe let say for start can take injunction against search results on Google and You tube. For this i present the case of Japanese Business man who's name appeared with criminals and he recently won the damages for wrong search results and the impact which it caused to his personnel life and so on.
Though one can say the Google is registered in US so why they cared about Japanese court ruling so guys go back and Read Al Khwarizmi Algorithm (gr8 Muslim scientist Abū ʿAbdallāh Muḥammad ibn Mūsā al-Khwārizmī) you should learn that these algorithm runs Google Inc to block one geographical area Google has to change tremendously the Algorithms, and in doing so will end up completely removing the whole search result as that is more easy for them. Also i will mention a case related to fraud by a UK based company which ran away with million of pounds of Pakistan based company. All what clever Manager of Pakistani company did, went to UK walked to lawyer office, filed a case of fraud and got his money back in 3 months. Now please learn how the world law works around it, Based on Extradition treaty 1935 between Then British India and US, Pakistan inherited such treaty and is part of 73 constitution, so if one of you files a case in High court, and high court summons Google CEO, the treaty between US and Pakistan Kicks in, State Department of US is obliged to produce Google CEO or carry out the court orders.
By the way these are same muslims scientist algorithms which are used in super high volume trading in US and Europe, future's contract trading and so on. If PTI is standing up to do so we should support them, at last we as muslims have lost our fortune of knowledge to these Gora's.
Nice work PTI, you have the sense to ensure our mutual respect.
The most sensible reaction I have seen till now! Good going PTI! the criticisers of PTI have lost all sense and logic and don't even know what they are criticising about! U ppl are the real enemies of Pakistan! In RUSSIA People make fun of PAKISTANIS!! And U know why?? Bcz they think we are a NATION, who's people would try everything to Stop & Criticise a Person who is on a road to success and to bring him back where he was before. It was just a Saying but not completely out of context! I pray to Allah that we get back on the Right Track!
Only PTI is a party which can react like that, Even Jamat e Islami didn't think on this issue. And expecting some good from other parties of Pakistani & current govt is just useless.
Well done Imran.You are blowing the senses of rivals!
PTI must be appreciated for their efforts, as we know Imran Khan is the first Pakistani leader, who participated in the protest, instead of staying at home like Nawaz Sharif, Maulana Fazul-rehman etc. Had these political and religious leaders played their due role, the angry protesters would not have been crossed the line on protest day.
PTI Rocks!! My Vote is for PTI!
First, PTI should tell Google about itself by ordinary mail because this party is not in their data base.
are you kidding me!??
Stupidity has no limits
@Mard-e-Haq
Its not overturning the amendment of US they can keep it in US but block in other countries or remove it from other countries. Google has done that before for China and has blocked the same video in other countries. So plz think.
weldone PTI. u truly represent muslims of the world. we all know u can defend us in the best possible way. Thanks PTI
Another cheap way of political point scoring...
This made my jaws drop. The PTI is trying to overturn the 1st Amendment of the United States? What a laugh!!! Kaaptan Khan is getting more delusional by the day.
Great initiative by PTI because puppet Pakistani govt is not doing it.There is a will there is a way.
I expected PTI to react more responsibly
How about putting Google on notice for videos showing the beheading of Pakistani soldiers by PTI's friends namely the TTP? Or it is "Amereeca kee jang"??
While you are at it, ask Google to remove the video of Tyrian Khan as well.