- 17 Aug 2012
Eid moon spotted in North Waziristan - 17 Aug 2012
Moon-sighting — a persistent controversy
- 18 Aug 2012
Saudi to celebrate Eidul Fitr on Sunday
The central and local Ruet-e-Hilal committees will assemble today for sighting the moon. PHOTO: FILE
SHABQADAR: The Charsadda police, on the directives of the district government, arrested the cleric who announced Eidul Fitr in certain areas of Charsadda on Saturday.
Certain areas of Charsadda are celebrating Eidul Fitr today, one day before Saudi Arabia, following a late night sighting of the Shawwal moon by Barelvi sect clerics. The arrested cleric has been identified as Lal Rehman.
According to a police official of Shabqadar Police Station, Rehman has been arrested from his house in Matta Mughal Khel, Shabqadar, and has been put behind bars in the police station.
Last night, some clerics of the the union council of Matta and Panjpao reported that the Eidul Fitr moon had been sighted in other parts of Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa.
A total of 10 percent of the province will be celebrating Eid today, while the majority Deobandi sect will assemble for moon sighting today evening.
The people living in these areas have demanded that the government ensure unity among Pakistani Muslims.
The central and local Ruet-e-Hilal committees will assemble today for sighting the moon as well.
More in KP & FATA
Kurram Agency: One killed, 16 hurt in a string of blasts
eid mubarak …!!!!
Recommend
Well done .No one can stop them.They are addicted to this.
Recommend
let them do whatever they want. it is their rozas that will be broken. quran and sunnah have strict direction in these matters. if they want to violet them , let them. pakistan govt has done its best , but illiterate people won’t listen.
Recommend
lol good people at the part of the world are stupid generally
Recommend
the cleric….blasphemous….Recommend
This one takes the cake really!!!
Recommend
Ban the clerics from looking at the moon !
Recommend
Pashtuns don’t have to wait for the word from Bedouin camel herders that they have sighted the new moon.
Recommend
Eid Mubarak to those who are cebrating,
Recommend
This is unconstitutional. Iftikhar Muhammad choudry should take suo moto notice of this clear contempt. Only the judges should determine when the moon has or has not been sighted.
Recommend
the state has nothing to do with religious affairs and festivals of theh people. The foremost duty of the state is establishing security and rendering justic, but regrettably the state has failed in providing both of them to the people. Worship and in that sense fasting is something personal, so interfering with the personal lives of the people is a worst kind of despotism.
Recommend
@Molvi Iqbal: .. please try to be rational and prove people who criticize your first name wrongRecommend
It will be interesting to see that under which law has he been arrested.. freedom of speech and belief??
Recommend
Well done Police.
These clerics should be severely punished.
Such announcements should also come under blasphemy law, as this is tantamount to provoking people not to fast during the holy month of Ramadan and celebrate Eid without sighting the Eid Moon and without having few credible witnesses in the area.
Recommend
Let him spend one behind bars.
Recommend
it is quite right act to handle the tendency of stepping forward from others.Recommend
what’s so serious about it?
Recommend
@patriot:
RELAX, buddy. Ever heard of sarcasm?
Recommend
they are not muslimRecommend
I think we should first decide the exact day for Eid-UL fITER AND then decide to celeberate it combinely. I think it will show our unity.
Recommend
@Khan of Jandul
Which world you are living in? If these matters are left to clerics, soon there would be 100 eids.All such matters plus management of mosques are assigned to state in S.Arabia, malaysia,Turkey, UAE and many other countries.Recommend
I am loving it !!! I am getting addicted to Pakistani news for best entertainment…
Recommend
!Certain parts of Charsadda are celebrating Eid to day
Recommendafter late night sighting of moon by some clerics!
Any comments please but without laughing
The people living in these areas have demanded that the government ensure unity among Pakistani Muslims.
Are you people insane?? Why on earth you follow those people? Are you addicts ??Recommend
he should be hanged upside down for creating rift in the ranks of Muslims. members of un-official and so-called moon-sighting committee in peshawar must also be punished for their own state within a state.
Recommend
Why there is State’s intervention in someone’s religious believes. If people of some area want to celeberate Eid, then let them celeberate and enjoy. In old days, there were different Eid days within few miles apart.
Recommend
Exploitation of provisional rights, freedom and constitutional rights. The Govt. After the 1971 Bangladesh then the present crisis in Balochistan still is exploiting provisional rights and basic constitutional and human freedom.
Recommend
Comedic indeed. Late night sighting wouldn’t be possible at all. Astronomically, the moon would have already extended past the western horizon shortly after sunset. Forget the arrests though, these people need a psychological evaluation!
Recommend
Ruet-e-Hilal committees should be declared illegal. In this day and age of scientific development, the stages of moon can be acurately calculated. A trusted science and space organization should be assigned this task, so that there is ONE EID throughout the Country. It is ridiculous to practice moon sigting ritual any more
Recommend
Leave it to the Express Tribune to always try to drive a wedge between Barelvis and Deobandis. We are all Muslims, and I for one am neither Barelvi nor Deobandi.
Recommend
BLASPHEMY! How can a Mullah be arrested! FREE THE MULLAHS!
Recommend
moon seen in the middle of the night
Recommend
This is Popalzai’s Popalzai !
We hope they are consistent in observing other religious days like Ashura, Eid Milad etc ahead of rest of the country.
Recommend
@patriot:
Please learn to appreciate sarcasm and have a good laugh over it. It is ur religious complexes that prevent u from seeing the message for what it is..
Recommend
Are they going to arrest the clerics from the entire Middle East who have already celebrated the Eid?
Recommend
Thank you Mufti muneeb and all maulanas; you have invited such lunacy for us.
Recommend
@ather khan: They can also purple, magenta, yellow or red themRecommend
Why should we beliece other clerics.
Recommend
Is there a law against seeing the moon earlier than it should be seen?? How is it the clerics fault. Recommend
Let me get this straight – a cleric is arrested for looking at the moon? Is this for real? Are you people still in the Dark Ages???
Recommend
We need to criticize any such act of arresting clerics because law needs to equally implemented for everyone and not for only clerics in Charsadda.Recommend
We always focus on useless matters. Law should be imposed and practiced by eveyone, without any objection in respect of our religion.
Recommend