For a handful of people who can deliver a speech in English on fiscal policy using a PowerPoint presentation, the last two weeks have been very busy. Be it pre-budget seminars or post-budget briefings held to influence the ensuing debate over the Finance Bill in parliament, one can expect the same old, familiar speakers to show up on nearly all such occasions.
The Institute of Cost and Management Accountants of Pakistan (ICMAP) and the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Pakistan (ICAP) – two of the three leading accounting bodies operating in Pakistan – held their post-budget seminars on Tuesday night and Wednesday, respectively. Although the two seminars had many renowned experts in common, the key speaker on both occasions was the much-celebrated corporate titan-turned-politician Asad Umar, who resigned as president of Engro Corporation in April to join the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI).
“The economic situation of the country is so scary that the government can’t even muddle through now,” said Umar, while referring to the gross domestic product (GDP) growth rate – which he called the lowest in the country’s history – and the soaring inflation, which he termed the highest in the past six decades of the country’s existence.
“Investment isn’t decreasing, it’s actually collapsing,” he said with reference to the investment-to-GDP ratio that has declined from 22.5% to 12.5% in the last four years. The per-year decline in investment, according to Umar, has been $20 billion, with foreign direct investment (FDI) dropping from $6 billion to $1 billion under the current government.
In view of the strong economic growth in neighbouring India, Umar claimed that per-capita income there would double in 12 years. However, Pakistan would take 70 years to achieve 100% growth in its per-capita income.
Making the economic situation sound further scary, Umar told the audience that the Sub-Saharan Africa – one of the least developed parts of the world – grew 50% faster than Pakistan in the last four years.
Calling him a ‘thorough professional’, Umar praised the federal finance minister lavishly at one of the seminars. “Hafeez Shaikh knows the economy far better than I do. But the problem is that he has no control over the economic situation.”
AF Ferguson & Co Partner Shabbar Zaidi, another sought-after speaker who participated in both seminars, was highly critical of the performance of the government’s economic team. Awash with words like ‘disaster’ and ‘crisis,’ the central theme of Zaidi’s speech was that the government, businessmen and the public at large were all responsible for the fiscal mess the nation finds itself in.
Noting that debt servicing, defence, subsidies and administrative expenses formed 31%, 16%, 25% and 11%, respectively, in the proposed budget, he said that 83% of the allocations were set aside for non-productive expenditure.
He stated that the increase in total debt was approximately Rs1.5 trillion per year. With the debt level reaching Rs13 trillion, he said the fiscal deficit would be around Rs1.8 trillion next year. “This country can’t be run with this kind of a fiscal deficit.”
Users of electricity, especially ‘commercial consumers,’ ask for electricity, but contribute nothing to the exchequer, he said, adding that the agriculture sector – both production and trading segments – paid little in taxes.
Criticising those calling for severing trade ties with the western world to make the country ‘sovereign,’ Zaidi said the United States would always remain the main buyer of Pakistani products.
Referring to a research study, he said US per-capita income was likely to be $88,000 in 2050 as opposed to China’s $39,000. “The aging populations of the European Union and the US are an asset for countries like ours.”
Published in The Express Tribune, June 7th, 2012.
COMMENTS (20)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
I agree with Zaid. Real change will only come if every Pakistani stops blaming everyone else for the country's problems, and start looking at how to improve themselves!
@Mohammad Kashif: .. What what what what what????... NO way no way!!!.......... IK is the one who has inspired the likes of Asad Umar to join politics and IK WILL BE THE PM.. Asad will be the finance minister!!!
Not much that is new, I'm afraid, but a good report all the same.
Please use ratio's boys; absolute numbers make no sense.
@Ammar: I am an Indian . Certainly not qualified to talk about who Pakistanis should elect. I also am not a fan of PTI. But I did see the you-tube presentation made by Jahangir Tareen and Asad Umar on the economy. They talked not just about the problems but solutions. It also made sense. The question is whether they would be able to get the policies implemented. Part of the reason why the current FM is unable to implement policies is that PPP does not have a majority and alliance partners refuse to vote for tough decisions. The media also gives a lot of coverage to tough decisions needed for long term improvement. The RGST was one example.
This is not an issue isolated to Pakistan, it also happens in india and USA. If and when PTI is elected, they wil realize the compulsions of parliamentary legislation and the fact that not everything that makes sense can actually get passed through the parliament.
Some of the current issues in some ministries with PPP could very well be attributed to their corruption or incompetence but Hafiz Sheikh is not known to be corrupt or incompetent as a prfessional. PPP simply is unable to pass laws that are needed whether on expense reduction or increased tax revenues.
I guess they are solving this problem by printing more fake Indian currency notes!
Proposing the policy to get rid off the problems which pertain in the country is the task which PTI must look for. They only criticize; come up with realistic approach PTI Cham.
This article should be front page news and not buried in the business section. If Pakistan is going to change it's going to need new leadership and people who have an understanding of economics/business need to lead that charge.
Pointing to the problems is easy. suggestion to solve the problems gives the credibility else this too will bound to be presumed as a political speech counting the failures. This presumption receives weights when the author says that the Sub-Saharan Africa – one of the least developed parts of the world – grew 50% faster than Pakistan in the last four years.m facts may be true but the percentile of growth of 50% is vague as the base of the sub Saharan countries is very low and small growth will also reflect in 100% growth but in absolute quantum it will be quite low when compared to that of Pakistan. These are Jugglery of words to emphasize a point. However , analysis of data is truly revealing elsewhere and reflects the depth. Pakistan urgently needs many reforms on land, taxation, power sector and governance .
He has the ability to become Prime Minister of country. Imran Khan should stay behind to control the party like Sonia Gandhi.
Author has well articulated the problems. Most folks miss the point that USA will have far higher per-capita income than most other top 10 economies of the world for another 50-100 years. That's 3 generations from now.
And USA has surplus land/water and other resources compared to most other countries, and can easily absorb another 20-30million top class, highly educated immigrants. i.e. an addition to their productivity as these guys are bound to produce high class economy.
So, to have a nation like that on your wrong side is plain stupid.
i am sure PTI can take us out from this destruction from corrupt leaders
Asad Umar should offer his expertises to any government who comes in power not confined to PTI since he is truly an asset to Pakistan. We honor & love you Asad!
Asad Umar will be IK's Finance minister and will resolve the economic woes of our country, Insha Allah!!! :)
Key point raised by Mr. Asad Umar is that our Finance Minister has no control over making policies. Our Minister is just giving the guidelines and not able to bring drastic changes in the policies which need to be taken by the political leadership. We have arrived now at a stage where current economic policies can not be continued and Aggressive Tax Reforms are must. This budget is just an Election Budget by the PPP Govt. A strong political mandate is required by the next Govt to bring the change, otherwise current situation will continue and as said by Mr. Zaidi that even it would not be possible to run this country next year.
Not one of the speakers has suggested what the solution is to the mess we are in> Everybody loves to criticize but whats the answer to solving the problems? When the rich and the politicians and the Armed forces find every conceivable way to avoid paying taxes and there is little if any security nothing will improve! Get the basics right and everything will fall into place. A simple example is the fact that someone buying a 18 million rupee SUV will not register the vehicle because it will cost 500,000! And the law will not ask him to do so.
Economic situation in the country is very bad .And one has to blame the economic team and dysfunctional FBR to a great degree for this. Some are predicting Rs/US$ at 100 by year end?!
Asad Umer is a gem of this country, what I have specially liked about his recent speeches is his ability to articulate and quantify complex economic concepts in an easy manner for the masses