- RSS
- Today's Paper
- Subscribe
- beta 2.1
Alerts
Privacy rights: BlackBerry maker vows privacy
Research In Motion vows to defend legal privacy rights of smartphone users.
Haqqani resigned over the affair and the Supreme Court has stopped him from leaving Pakistan. PHOTO: AFP/FILE
OTTAWA: Research In Motion has vowed to defend the legal privacy rights of BlackBerry users after the judicial commission ordered copies of smartphone communications for the Memogate scandal probe.
On Monday, the commission directed Pakistan government officials to obtain the BlackBerry ‘record of conversation’ between Mansoor Ijaz and Husain Haqqani. Canada-based RIM, which makes the BlackBerry, said: “Like others in our industry, from time to time, we may receive requests from legal authorities for lawful access assistance.”
The statement added: “We are guided by appropriate legal processes and publicly disclosed lawful access principles in this regard as we balance any such requests against our priority of maintaining the privacy rights of our users.”
Published in The Express Tribune, January 5th, 2012.
Read more:
memogate
Reader Comments (47)
World Latest Stories
Bilateral Trade: Sherry Rehman urges Pak-US cooperation
Ambassador Rehman underscored the need for trade to be the foundation of Pakistan-US relations.
First Saudi woman summits the Everest
First Qatari and first Palestinian man to summit the Everest along with Saudi Raha Moharrak.
Cricket: Despair over spread of spot-fixing 'cancer'
Police who arrested three Indian cricketers for spot-fixing say they were acting under orders from crime bosses.
Sanjay Dutt held in 'terrorist' jail cell: Report
Dutt's lawyer demands his transfer from the jail cell once occupied by Mumbai attacks gunman Ajmal Kasab.
Sherry Rehman urges end to drone strikes
Farewell reception for Rehman attended by top US officials, think tank experts and journalists.
Yahoo to vote on $1.1 billion Tumblr buy: AllThingsD
Yahoo is keen on Tumblr because its younger user base would enhance the older website's 'cool factor'.
US chides Russia over missiles
Most senior US military officer describes Russia's recent delivery of anti-ship missiles to Assad as very unfortunate.
Commuter trains collide in Connecticut, injuring up to 60 people
Three people were critically injured and 60 people were transported to area hospitals.
Shots fired at Cannes film festival, actors flee for cover
Police arrested the man at the scene and found he was carrying a dummy grenade and a knife.
IPL investigation ‘Sweaty’ Sreesanth’s towel trouble
More than 20 people have also been arrested all over India in connection to the scandal for questioning.
Recent Slideshows
More in World
Soaring tensions: Iran warns US warship in Gulf
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, redistributed or derived from.
Unless otherwise stated, all content is copyrighted © 2013 The Express Tribune News Network.
Technical feedback? [email protected]
ooops, happy now. How will ISI investigate now…..
Recommend
Had this been a US security issue, RIM would have taken no time to allow access to any client
Recommend
Blackberry will not provide required information. they all united to protect Haqqani.Its a typical western style. West disregards all values,ethics and rules to protect their own interests.
Recommend
The PCO SC has no jurisdiction over any global businesses. On one foreign double agent’s testimony our generals and SC can move but the whole world would not. According to International law an unsigned memo has no value especially when a decorated US general Jones has told the court that the memo had nothing to do with Pakistani govt or HH. “You can fool some of the people some of the time but not all the people all the time”. Looking at its history Pakistani SC has no legal or ethical standing in the world.
Recommend
Read the fine print…
They are not denying access to the messages.
Plus they have already earlier stated that a judicial probe / order from a court would probably lead them to allow access.
Recommend
@sam
If the entire ‘Western world’ had wanted to protect Haqqani, then Admiral Mullen would simply have denied the existence of memo
Recommend
@sam : They are all united tio protect ISI charade
Recommend
BAN Blackberry in Pakistan … We are sovereign country and our authorities have all the right to request details on any kind of suspicion charges. AND, yes had it been a US national security issue, RIM would have allowed access into Obama’s blackberry as well. The only way to get RIM to get their act right is to BAN blackberries in Pakistan. Haqqani could be an angel in the aftermath of this judicial follow up.
Recommend
will we ever stop making utter fools of ourselves on the world stage …. over and over again???
Recommend
Threaten to ban BB services in Pakistan (like the Gulf states did if access was not provided to government) and RIM will toe the line. Nobody is above business ;)
Recommend
If RIM cannot respect Pakistan’s sovereignty (and this IS a question of sovereignty) then RIM should cease doing business in Pakistan… Android is better anyway.
Recommend
I think RIM will have to provide access , otherwise SC can impose a ban on sale of RIM products in Pakistan. And this will hurt the already troubled smartphone maker.
SC is in a position to dictate terms….They have no choice but to allow access!
Recommend
@Amir:
Things like that tend to happen when you want favors from people you’re simultaneously preaching the death of.
Recommend
Commission should ask for authority letter from Mansoor Ijaz and Hussain Haqqani stating that the commission should be allowed to access blackberry communication between these two people.
Recommend
@Mirza
Pakistani SC has no legal or ethical standing in the world’.
Seems you are way more impressed from the western and american judicial system. FYI
The Harvard Law School awarded its highest honour, the Medal of Freedom, to Justice Iftikhar Chaudhry. He is the first Pakistani to be presented with such honour and a third person in world to receive this award other than Nelson Mandela and Oliver Hill.
Recommend
should ban RIM and all its services if they refuse to cooperate with the judicial probe
Recommend
RIM are not denying any request just saying they receive requests such as this and will deal with them as per their guidelines. Nothing else.Recommend
Easy, block blackberry sales in Pakistan. This is not an individual who is requesting, its the court of law.
Recommend
^^
Pakistani SC has no legal or ethical standing in the world’.
Seems you are way more impressed from the western and american judicial system. FYI
The Harvard Law School awarded its highest honour, the Medal of Freedom, to Justice Iftikhar Chaudhry. He is the first Pakistani to be presented with such honour and a third person in world to receive this award.
Recommend
Oh please yaar..RIM has been banned from number of countries because of this issue. RIM states that if they start giving conversation out…there utmost power will be lost…nothing to do with western style …PLEASE
Recommend
I see no reason why a Chinese company can replace RIM services in Pakistan …. And that too at a fraction of the attitude!!
Recommend
Ban sales and current operations BB in Pakistan. Androids and Apple is better than it anyway. I will protest by leaving BB here in UK and urge other fellows as well if RIM can not respect the law of my countryRecommend
Ha ha ha all are parhay likhay Jahils .
cant even use technology
Recommend
court should prepare a legal request with signs of Masoor Ejaz and Hussain Haqani that they have no objection over giving the record to SC
Recommend
CJ should ban BB services and sale in Pakistan. soon you will see the results……
Recommend
If hussain Haqani is innocent then he should request himself to RIM to allow access.
Recommend
@Hammad:
Agree completely. Ban Blackberry in Pakistan. Apple iPhone is already eating into RIM’s market and Pakistan should aid in RIM’s demise. India once ordered access to Blackberry traffic in India and RIM yielded only when India announced a complete shutdown of Blackberry services. The same should happen in Pakistan.
Recommend
@Gul Khan:
No need to get emotional about these things. It is true that the Pakistani courts have historically had very low credibility levels.
Hope this time it is different!
Recommend
@sam:
This is not a matter of protecting “interests”. This is their LAW.
Some countries do have and abide by the law.
Recommend
With Americans backing Haqqani, RIM will never give the required data to Pakistan
Recommend
If RIM refuses, boycott and ream RIM.
If they refuse to obey jurisdiction of the court in Pak, they should not operate here.
Recommend
“If hussain Haqani is innocent then he should request himself to RIM to allow access”
Correct me if I am wrong, the onus is on the people who accuses to prove that a person is guilty and not on the accused to prove his innocence.
Recommend
Where was BlackBerry’s privacy when they gave the BBMs of hundreds of its users to UK Home ministry during the riots?
<>Recommend
@Sam
West disregards all values,ethics and rules to protect their own interests.
While the ‘memo’ continues to be unsigned and unestablished, the terrorist attack on Mumbai is an established fact.
India has been seeking ‘voice samples’ of the accused from Pakistan,for 3 years, without any success. Do remind the Pakistani judiciary about ‘values,ethics and rules’. PLEASE.
Recommend
I have read the non sense idea of banning BB services in pakistan.people with out understanding write down the facts that pak cant afford any foolishness with international investors.More over,RIM has asked to follow the legal procedure to access any data.After all, every individual wants his personal call records to be maintained as classified..Otherwise there would be law of jungle on the roads!!
Recommend
Banning Blackberry won’t matter.. Pakistan is not a big market for Blackberry. Remember you are not India or china where revenues in dollars will matter for company like BB
Recommend
Hussain Haqqani and other diplomats have communication with the world including the double and triple agents. However, unless RIM (Research In Motion) record can show beyond a reasonable doubt (which is minimum standard to implicate) that Hussain Haqqani clearly asked Mansoor Ijaz to write the full contents of the memo and deliver it to the US general on his behalf, there is no case even worth hearing in the lowest court. There has to be full burden of proof with smoking gun to implicate one for treason. A shady, shifty double agent’s testimony is not going to cut in any western court of law. He said, she said is not a credible witness especially when Mansoor Ijaz has been spitting venom against Pakistan and ISI and has admitted having contacts with a dozen foreign intelligence agencies. On the other hand a decorated US general Jones is a lot more credible and respectable who has denied that Hussain Haqqani or Pakistani Govt was involved. Let us hope that North American courts and companies are not kangaroo courts.Recommend
Blackberry did not refuse, they just explained the law and most of us are after their blood.. Great message to International Business Entities. This is the attitude nobody wants to do business with us.
Recommend
Even SHOs respect each others jurisdiction. RIM is an Ontario corporation governed by the laws of that province. You don’t have to be a judge or lawyer to figure that out.
Recommend
@Ameri
If this was a US security issue NSA would have already accessed the info without needing RIM.
Recommend
I don’t think so this generic statement leads to denial by RIM. RIM is supposed to respond to legal notice that would be served meantime. More importantly cell phone data given by Ijaz himself can also lead to the conclusion.
Recommend
Hypocrisy and discrimination by RIM . What about the recent probes in UK when RIM supplied all private info head over heels !
Recommend
@Gul Khan:
CJ was honored by many including Harvard for his fight against the army dictator. Just like Obama, Y. Arfat, and I. Rabin were awarded Nobel prizes. What happened after the awards?Did any of these achieve the peace? Many leaders have been recognized by their services before they become dictator, or a war monger like Obama. We have all supported CJ when he was for democracy and against the army rule and its victim in the hope that despite being a PCO judge, he would provide justice to all including common man.
Regards,
Mirza
Recommend
Haqqani resign in order to clear his name. He must submit affidavit allowing his privacy rights to Research in Motion to disclose all communication between him and Mansoor Ejaz.
Recommend
No RIM ban is required. Just a simple legal request to the company asking them to reveal the conversations of the two involved people that took place between some defined period. That legal request than be signed by mansoor Ejaz, hussain huqqani and pakistan government official.
That’s all but the question is ” will Mr. Haqqani give permission to such revelation ” He has to do because he is also pleading innocence
Recommend
@Bee:
Sir this is Zia’s Pakistan…. where 90 days mean 90 months after reciting from holy book
where elections cannot be held untill positive results are expected.
one is guilty unless proven innocent and may be after their death.
Recommend
It is Supreme Court of Pakistan’s Judicial Commission which has asked for the record of communication, if Black Berry makers declines to follow the orders, they should be included in list of accused. Appropriate action should be taken to block this system at least in Pakistan forthwith, for not adhering to law of the land.
Recommend