We are all metaphors and symbols, our identities rendered into abstraction. What we have is a nation populated by representations. Each and every one of us is no longer the sum of certain parts, no longer an individual with personal hopes, dreams, ambitions and aspirations. Instead, we each represent singular ideologies. Our National Identity Cards need no longer bother with photographs and fingerprints, instead should just state a philosophical position. Because everything we do, every word we say and every activity we partake in symbolises something larger than us. Or smaller.
Mumtaz Qadri, is the perfect example. He is not just a lone unique character who occupies a certain position in space and time. His actions are not personal to his deeply flawed understanding of religious belief, nor are his thoughts a singular example of extreme violent tendencies rattling around in a head full of bad wiring. Instead, the self-confessed murderer, represents so much more. He is now a living and breathing logo for a movement that will destroy anything that it perceives as contrary to its beliefs. Mumtaz Qadri’s face is, to extremist illiterates with no appreciation for the complexity of Islamic jurisprudence, what the peace symbol is was to the anti-war protestors of the 60s. His entire being has been condensed into a point of debate. Alternately, Judge Pervez Ali Shah who gave a decision that is in accordance with the legal framework he took an oath to uphold, is no longer an individual doing his job nor a man in hiding in fear for his life, but represents the potential for fair and true judgments in the Pakistani courts of law. The focal point of this entire event, Salmaan Taseer, can never again be seen by us as a politician or a business man or a father or a husband. His bullet riddled body, the moment it gave up the last breath of life, became a rallying point for secularists and a tragic representation of sacrifice for an ideal.
This rendering of us all into simplistic representations doesn’t even have to invoke such nationally focused figures. To give a more self-obsessed example: I am no longer Sami Shah, a struggling comedian with blatant and farcical aspirations towards intellectualism, nor am I a man who struggles to make ends meet in a time of rising expenses so he can provide for his child. Those are real and human descriptions that no one has any interest in. To Western journalists I am a warrior who wields punch lines to defeat the Talibanisation of this country and to locals I am an uninspired Liberal Secularist, which means I represent a doomed ideology. If you read this and other English papers then you are a Westernised Elitist and if you don’t read it you are a Fundamentalist Conservative with tendencies towards Conspiracy Theorist. This game, if you want to play it, is fairly easy. Rehman Malik, for example, with his newly awarded Doctorate degree, is representative of the Privileged Elite. Or he can also represent a Mockery of PhD Students Everywhere. A more tragic example is that the men who raided a school in Rawalpindi represent Growing Extremism and the innocent girls they beat for not wearing hijabs represent the Continued Collapse of Female Education. Similarly, the growing number of dead journalists are cumulative representations of Curbs on the Freedom of Press. Saleem Shahzad became an iconographic representation of Military Abuse. The massacred Hazara Shias are symbols of Governmental Discounting of Religious Persecution. And so on. Ad infinitum.
What is lost in all this wanton slinging of lazy descriptors is the human. The person who was once an Individual and a Life to be Valued and Considered. That is a representation no one is interested in any more. Even though it represents a Tragedy.
Published in The Express Tribune, October 13th, 2011.
COMMENTS (15)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Have always enjoyed reading Sami Shah's articles. Would refer to this one as 'perfectly said'! Our individuality really doesn't matter anymore. In fact it ceases to exist.
This is, as always, a nicely written piece.
But I will keep my lips closed on the case of Mumtaz Qadri. Here I will disagree. He represents much more than the liberals have been able to see. Unfortunately for us, so-called intellectuals and liberals have simply not understood the entire history behind this killing. I hope they do. Someday.
Do any one of the 'enlightened moderate liberal' scholars of our society ever write about or cry over the non-implementation of court orders when it is about the death sentences to Sarbajjeet SIngh or Asia Bibi? Why single out? If you respect the court, do not do it with such an obvious bias.
I always love your posts - this is no exception. The constant labelling definitely defeats the purpose - in the war of the causes, the individual is long-lost and forgotten. And that is a tragedy.
no comments.
all i want to say that if we want to save pakistan.
if we want to continue with the same name islamic jamhuria pakistan then we must practice islam
In this case the liberals and seculars are handicapped. They cannot kill to enforce their point, if they do they wont be liberals and the fair mined. Only the extremists kill. They have greater power this way.
In Modern Democracies like India and the US, the power has always was with the liberals, yes, even the BJP and Republicsns can be considered as liberals, when compared to the Islamists in Pakistan. The institutions in these 2 Countries are thoroughly secular, liberal and its foundations are derived from the wonderfully worded Constitutions. The problem with Pakistan lies here. Its Constitution is not worthy to be even compared to India's or the US's.
A refreshing insight, quite rare in a jungle of inane profanities.
Sami, a bold and truthful Op Ed, I appreciate it a lot. It is sad to see the millitants attacking young kids for not wearing Hijab. If there were any liberals or even moderate Muslims in Pakistan, they would have gone out to protest against this cowardly attack on kids and demonstrated "without" hijab. Take the hijab off as a protest would send the clear message that terrorism can backfire on the fanatics. Instead of promoting Islam and hijab it would create hatred against it. The fact is before 9/11 the fundementalism was increasing in the mosques even in the US. However, the mullah who used to taunt the young girls got the answer that it is none of their business and they better keep their mouth shut. Sad to say that the little girls cannot say that in Pakistan because the police and establishment would not protect them.
The are no laws in the jungle. Carnivores are the top of food cycle.
Different way of looking at it. This would be true to a greater or lesser degree with others. Liked the originality of thought.
Profound Mr.Shah, really profound! i think that is precisely the reason for our society's drift towards extremism. In our search for finding a greater meaning in our lives we've just found a different way of dehumanizing each other. I wish you would write in Urdu or find a translator so your thoughts can reach a wider audience.
To a dying nation, a failing state-Pakistan. I hope to see you in one peace.