The first notable change is that the old coalitions of the elite, assembled under two dynastic parties, have lost credibility and the trust and confidence of the larger number of Pakistani citizens. One may wonder why this isn’t reflected in the elections, since the same flock keeps getting elected. An explanation may be that the politics of patronage, at the expense of public interest and the public exchequer, along with the massive illegal wealth that most of the members of assemblies have made, are major factors in determining the outcome of electoral contests in their favour.
Thanks to the broad reach of the electronic media, from cities to villages and hamlets, the true character of the old elite stands exposed. In popular perceptions, the image and reality of the old coalitions as thugs, robber barons and thieves converge. Another factor that will definitely go against them is the pace of relative economic prosperity in the agricultural sector in the rural areas that has produced a very large rural middle class. This class is likely to vote independently of traditional family, clan or caste patterns and think of larger issues of governance, corruptions and who can provide better leadership.
Economic changes in other countries have translated into fresh social and political alignments; consider for example the rise of the Hindu right in India or the Justice and Development Party in Turkey. Both represent the rethinking of old political elites that survived on myths of charismatic leaders and their political legacies.
The second important change is the youth factor in Pakistan, which is not impressed by the quality and character of the political leadership dominating the major or even minor political parties, including the religious parties. They juxtapose Pakistan with the global landscape and see the failings of our traditional ruling elite. The youth in Pakistan is better educated, more enlightened and deeply patriotic, more so than previous generations; they want to get their country back on the rails of progress and modernity. Young people disregard locality, province, region and ethnicity to support Imran Khan, and look toward him as the only hope. This is a big loss for the traditional ruling parties that can only assemble ruffian musclemen in party nurseries, who speak through wall chalking land and guns and cash are doled out to them by party bosses.
The third important change is that, according to a poll, Imran Khan today has emerged as the most popular leader of Pakistan (68 per cent), leaving Mian Nawaz Sharif (63 per cent) and Asif Ali Zardari (11 per cent) miles behind, according to the Pew Research Centre, one of the most credible institutions for global opinion polls.
The question is if and how Imran Khan will convert these changes into a political advantage in the next parliamentary elections. My gut feeling is he will. He has energy, commitment and popular appeal. The great kaptaan presents a very clear agenda of change that no other leader or party can match. Change, credibility and popular appeal will define the new politics of Pakistan, which the kaptaan represents.
Published in The Express Tribune, July 14th, 2011.
COMMENTS (140)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Bhuttos as well as Brathrans past & present role is being detailed to masses by their own people (PERSON LIKE NABEEL GABOOL,SHAH MAHMOOD QURESHI & JAVEED HASHMI here & there through media.Public has only one way out at its disposal that is CHANGE.The person who is commiting for it is IMRAN KHAN.Therefore masses has to go for him & they should go for him.
i wish that happens and the much awaited change take place but that would be very much unrealistic to say that it will be in the coming election. i would say that the change needs at least 3 consecutive election means 12 to 15 years of continuous democracy and then change would be possible even then i don't see Imran Khan rather someone else. if Imran Wins his NA seat 2nd time that would be enough for him.
@Ahmed: Ok you narrowed the problems...and we all know that ..so it was full of redundancy....but anyhow he is the best amongst what we got now.....and i ll vote the lesser evil :p
@ibrar: Another blind otter following his master ;)
@Meekal Ahmed: You know your criticism is shallow too and you know why...? You failed to mention the alternatives.Speak relatively to be fair and quit spamming your biased opinions.
Agreed, there is not doubt that Imran Khan is the only hope for the greater Pakistan. He is sincere, visionary and commited towards his agenda and goals. Rest of the parties have shown us very clearly that THEY simply know one thing "to grab and to loot". I really don't understand one thing that why SOME people have soft corner for these tested elite (who every time failed miserably)? why THEY can't see what these looters has done to our nation and why can't THEY see sincerity, honesty, vision and leadership qualities in Imran Khan. So in my view either THEY are one of them or naive. I hope THOSE guys who are against Imran Khan would read something about Imran Khan and his policies. I request you all please get united because it's now or never!!
@Shahid Khan: Tell me who is the the last option for Pakistan..I promise you that i will leave my support for Imran...Sitting on keyboard will not save Pakistan....
Welldone professor.U r absolutely right...Imran is the only hope now left in Pakistan.Inshallah God will gift imran khan as ruler of Pakistan and i will see that beautiful day in my life...
Imran Khan is our only hope. I can't say about any one else, but at least me and my family will vote for him.
No doubt that Imran Khan is the only choice but look at the mess, all the institutions are almost collapsed, culprits are more stronger and powerful, lootmar at its peaks, consequently nation is headindg towards the dead end. Job is very tough. Can Imran Khan handle??
@ahmed man u r the comentator of the article and ur reply carry more weight than this hollow piece. Countries are run practicaly and not imaginary. When IK can not take along any party or political leader along how would he manage this mix of 200 million ppl country. I am at lost to understand his manifesto of magic wand!!! Come 2013 and u ll see if he win 10 seats wud b a big achievment.
Yes Imran Khan will sweep InshahAllah
We have not try them , we have not tsted them
InshaAllah IMran Khan Will be proved himself a best leader.
its the duty of people from all walks of life to rise and join Imran khan in his struggle to save Pakistan...........it belongs to all of us
Both right and left realising that the have been duped by the current lot of politicians.and they are truely understantding the meaning of the sentence by Kaptaan "The choice for pakistani people is not between right and left but it is between Right and wrong".
we love IMRAN KHAN........ he is our LEADER
my vote for PTI , because they well educated and honest .
Imran Khan is the only hope for Pakistan,he is very popular among youth and can definatley bring a change,Pml N has been tested before PPP has been tested before and now its time for a change because the two parties i mentioned have never ever tried to change the system if they were that credible they wouldve change the system in their last regiems,so we youth are looking forward to the next elections and and hoping PTI gains majority,INSHA ALLAH.
great article .. the middle class youth in indeed with Imran Khan
@White Russian: I wish we could import some leaders. In the meanwhile he should have a chance, even if he takes the country for a rough ride
@Bangash: We don't mind, establishments are also Pakistanis, and this time I think they are right!
All those genius who complain or confused, please state the solutions rather than well known problems ...............................A man is known by his deeds rather than words..................For me, IMRAN KHAN is the only hope, for sure...................just do your part to induce positive change by voting the right man (Imran Khan)............otherwise STF up & live your own life
All the other politicians who speak "half truth-half lie (Hypocrites)" can go to hell along with all their supporters.
@zaiba: u need to count the comments and recommendations in favor of I K, that would help you to realize otherwise i can't help, cause i m not a psychiatrist.
Give him a chance too, let's see what he can do. Can he walk the talk ?
@Shahid Khan: and i strongly believe mr.shahid khan that you would have realized here in this post and by all the replies to your comment that what masses want.. take it as sample and find out the percentage .. IF YOU SEE WITH CLARITY otherwise you are most welcome with your own confusion
@Shahid Khan: sir with respect to your opinion , i guess you havnt talked to any one around you... cause i meet doznz of people daily who talk about and recommend KAPTAN.. and really sorry if would have been clear yourself you would have seen KAPTAN'S multan jalsa.. n if not then you must see KAPTAN'S faisl abad jalsa coming up next .. you would see what masses want
@Ahmed:
No offence but you start your talk with a wrong tag sir. How does IK remind you of people who return as failures from the west? Did he have parents waiting for him so he can come & run their industries? If your answer is yes, i'd like to know how many companies IK is running currently which he inherited from his parents please. I'm afraid you tell all the stories of losers like kohinoor, mansha & what not lol... & somehow in a very funny way, you connect it all to kill Imran khan's struggle. Your comparison is very offensive, It is as if somebody says "Mufti Muneeb ur Rehman reminds me of Michael Jackson"
However, if you replace the name of IK with Bilawal Bhutto or Hamza Shareef, I have no problem with your thesis. Finally, you can argue & question about the time scale to end corruption & solve other problems, there's no problem with that but you can't disagree with his commitment & intention to end this mess A-S-A-P.
@ White Russian There is nothing in your post that anyone can agree with since all your allegations are not factual. Nothing to do with reality. In fact, its quite the opposite. Imran's ideology talks in favour for freedom for all citizens with reference to Islam & our constitution, not against. In his statements on record, there's no reference where he has denied social freedom for anyone.
Furthermore, its absolutely needless to make any comments on your suggestions for Khan or rather your 'mocking attitude' which demands his potential contained with making hospitals. It would be an absolute nonsense to not let his abilities get unleashed for supervising the organizations on a large scale. I believe IK can introduce the culture of Meritocracy, transparency & accountability which Zardari & Shareef have failed on despite having extensive experience in running industries.
I don't see how supervising PIA, PR, Steel Mill, PMTF etc have a different principle of being governed as organizations than Shokat Khanam, Namal & other projects. The scale of management may vary BUT... principle is the same.
@nafees ahmad: hmmm which is a dismaal situation cause it essentially means that there is only one kind in pakistan...."people with no brain".....
I dont really know who is good or who is bad. But i remember last time IK also had lots of support and rallies etc. but he never won any seats, can someone explain to me how it may be different this time? Why did he not get seats last time and how will he get those seats this time?
thanks
The kind of transformation that Kaptan is promising requires him to amend the constituton. Does he have even 350+ candidates to run for national assembly seats leaving aside the majority in provincial assemblies required for amending relevant laws?
@TightChuddi: That's right! ------ "Kaptaan will make Pakistaan Kaput…thats why he is the Kaptaan …" ---- No they they don't understand and wish to live this horrible experience.
@fatima:
Thanks for your comments.Mr. Meekal Aziz Ahmed is an economist by profession but our economic woos are not because we did not have good economic managers but because we had a very corrupt political leadership. Our intelligentsia should realize now that staying indifferent in current day politics is not the solution but they have to support the tight party with full vigor.That party in turn will bring on the right people and implement the right solutions.
@ghulam khan: bogus votes and NRO is my answer to ur essay!!!! lol.........
@wsd: well done sir! great answer..should shut them up..hopefully!:)
Imran has integrity and a vision for Pakistan. What has Nawaz Sharif or Zardari given to Pakistan? All they can think of is loot and plunder. I cannot believe that after 15years PML (N) has launched the FAILED Yellow Cab scheme again. These goofs look for cheap publicity at the expense of the exchequer.
I hope the elections are fair and on the new electoral roll. In that case PTI will sweep urban Punjab and Kyber Pakhtoonkhwa.
If it's the time for him, so be it. It can't get any worse.
Dr. Rais was my professor at uni and i cannot agree more wid his views regarding change in pakistan and hope the kaptaan can lead us in the next elections. imran khan is the only hope right now.
Imran Khan said...."Such leaders have contacted me for the ticket in next elections that if I name them their party leaders will suffer a heart attack" Javed Hashmi,Shah Mehmood Qureshi,Marvi Memon are the few of many who r going to join PTI in the near future...It's an inside story... Vote for IK...Vote for prosperous Pakistan!!
@shahid khan: it is the university professors like him who at least know what they are talking about and have some knowledge on the topic rather than "guestroom critics" like you and probably many of us here who do not know anything and yet like to talk as they know everything.
and yes.. imran khan may not be our only hope but i believe that as a Pakistani i would like to see a new face like that of imran khan who has to bring something new to the political dynamic of pakistan
Kaptaan will make Pakistaan Kaput...thats why he is the Kaptaan ...understand?
Delusional really. The writer has conveniently ignored the feudalism factor which is what has kept the old elite in power, and is likely to continue to do so. Regardless of Khan's ability, there is nothing in the air to suggest that he can win anything near to the seats required to even be a significant part of the government. As for the research quoted, it can hardly be used to gauge public sentiment or ground reality, which dictates that little will change. The image of the old elite as thieves and all has been there for the last few decades, and nothing has changed.
@Brown Pakistani There is nothing in your post I can agree with. Imran enjoys personal and social freedoms with impunity, but in his political ideology he denies same freedoms to ordinary Pakistanis in the name of Ghairat and Islam. For the political agenda he is advocating, why do we need him? He is nothing more than jhankar edition of Jamat-Islami. What else explains these large contradictions except the fact that he is just another front-man for secret agencies.
He ruined 17 years of his life in the vague hope that one day he 'll be made PM by agencies. Okay, he may become PM for a fortnight, one day. So what? We had bogra, and chaudry mohammad ali, and moeen qureshi, and jatoi, and chaudry shujat, and zafarulla jamali, and shokat aziz, and .... finally imran.
Had he continued with his philanthropy, Pakistan would have had by now few more quality hospitals. This is unfortunate that all ambitious people are so obsessed with becoming a dummy PM, while GHQ calls the shot.
I yet have to listen to Imran's words in which he unequivocally condemns suicide bombing and terror, without dishonestly invoking amreeki hath. Fact is that few members of mehsud tribe wo have resorted to terrorism, perfectly fit into what Imran described as ghairatmand pathan in his book about a couple of decades ago. What he leaves out as amreeki agent are not so ghairatmand (according to him) pathans, who are in majority and who love peace, and want to have good life and progress.
I would prefer Nawaz Sharif or Zardari or Asfandyar, even if they have been declared devils, to someone with such fake machismo, desperately trying to make a political career out of a mere anti-American rhetoric.
It's about the ideology of hate and extremism in the name of Islam these talibans and other religious parties follow who imran associates with@Ghazanfar Ali Khan:
@ Fawad Azam
Plz use independant mind to analyze his view. IK never sided with Taliban but always said that US is not sincere with us, so why fight Taliban coz US wants so. were there any of these killings you numbered before war with Taliban started. He said start talks in 2004, everyone said, he is insane. Now US is doing it and you guyz dont have a word to say. I believe He is what we call, visionary.
Not sure if Khan,s party could win the next general elections, but sure enough that he is the honest and dedicated politicians of his time. so my vote will go in favor of honesty and dedication.
Imran Khan has been in political limelight for almost 15 years, enough of time to form a party and become a formidable force to reckon with. However, so far he's still only alone. He is the only person who speaks on PTI's behalf and the only person that media knows. How many times has he let anybody else in his party take the center stage or at last to have projected somebody? In politics, all around the world, you've to compromise and take positions which can be sustained and are solid enough to have a standing, however, Imran Khan keeps jumping off one bandwagon to another. Musharraf gave chaudrys of Gujrat a party to lead and let them become leaders of national level, why could Imran not gain that opportunity? Why could he not take that an opportunity? and with his charisma, brought about a change in the system? I think he could. He could, very easily he could but then he keeps making and breaking alliances, and all of them being very weird ones. Therefore, I do not trust him to lead Pakistan.
@White Russian: He is a nationalist not a Taliban sympathizer and he is definitively not known for his conservative outlook but people who seek to define their nation on how the white man sees it wont understand. Imran Khan's manifesto is about peace and trade with India and about Pakistan as a state having a monopoly over the use of Arms in its own territory which is something being a state is all about. And something that some of our elitist minds still stuck in the colonial age fail to understand; living under the presumption that the Amrikans can solve all our problems even if it means handing over our sovereignty to them is naive so is calling your nation a terrorist state because CNN and FOX say so. We need to stop defining our selves on how others think of us.
Democracy is the name of gradual change. At Present, Khan is the best. He is better than Zardari, Nawaz and Altaf etc. Lets support him. Once a better option is available, we can re think. For the moment, IK Zindabad, PTI Zindabad
@Meekal Ahmed:
Collect tax from the rich and cut in lavish expenditures of government officals is stage one of the 100 days program. Is that not good economic advice?
@Shahid Khan: @Meekal Ahmed: @Ahmed: I'm appalled at your short-sightedness...what have the previous or current political regimes given us in terms of economics! We've had big names doing our economics for us and look where they've landed us. And giving Imran a chance at rooting out corruption is way more important than thinking of how he doesn't have any big economists on his team. For siding with taliban: do you know who they are and who created them and what they are doing to our very own people. Our own people are dying each day at their hands so yes we must take steps for the interest of our own people and talk to them...how has terror ever ended terror before ?
We all know that our current leaders are all corrupt and inept.... yet we can't give up voting for the same PPP, PML and MQM....!
Vote for Imran Khan and save Pakistan..the rest are tried and failed!
@Mirza:
(Sorry Nazar, apologies yet again. How else to get through this negativity?)
Poor Mirza . . . so focussed on the messenger that he actually missed the message!
Will you not support the truth and the good struggle . . . or do you prefer to criticise from the sidelines?
Join a good party Mirza (doesn't have to be the PTI) and demand that your leaders work for the betterment of you and all your countryfolk (and not for just some ethnic or narrowly defined interest group)!
@Sarah Khan: The Taliban being referenced is not the same one. The US is talking with the separate group that has been involved politically in the past in Afghanistan. The one being referred to is the one who wants to overthrow the Pakistani government and officials to gain power to impose "Sharia law" on Pakistan by force and stated they will settle for nothing less than that outcome with intentions of spreading it outside Pakistan's borders afterwards.
Neither are good. But, a Pakistani politician siding with the Afghanistan group would be more or less based on politics. A Pakistani politician supporting TTP means supporting the destruction of any freedoms you enjoy.
TTP has taken the "Taliban" title on their own "unofficially." The Afghanistan Taliban rejects them and their use of it.
@nazar muhammad: Nazar, if you accept the current reality as permanent, we are already doomed! I prefer to struggle for improvement. Inshallah my children will live in a society where speaking truthfully, behaving decently, discouraging violence and pursuing knowledge is the norm. Apologies if anything I have said comes across as a personal attack.
Its nice to see people talking abt chances of Kaptan,,,but i feel that at the moment,,he is short of good & commited team,,In Pakistani culture you need to have heavy weights to win elections but his candidates are not so strong publically & financially(becoz finance plays a huge role in pak elections).I am a big supporter of his but i wish that he could get a nice team then definitely youth are all with him....Without a well organized team its once again going to be either PPP OR PML(N).
Imran khan is the best available option for Pakistani people's right now. IK is merely an option or his popularity is such like which help him in getting the most productive seat, but this is not simple the above writer just depict the phenomena of urban-middle class ignoring the fact that large chunk of Pakistan population lives rural areas. Above all, without any doubt IK is the best option available who has the ability to change the dynamics of Pakistan polity, at least he is worthy enough to get a chance. Good article though
Guys thumbs for khan and those who praise him which mean praising the facts and this show the patriotism in them . Any how you will see me as the PM some times off course after kaptan :P
Great article, welldone Mr. Rasul Bakhsh Rais. Imran khan is the only hope for Pakistan, everyone must register their vote.
@Rahul Kumar: good to see indian interest in pak politics!!!!!!!!!
Ignore the first two comment guys!!
If people vote for Imran Khan, he should implement what he preaches. It is easy to talk relaxing in your coffee tables. But when "you say: he youth in Pakistan is better educated, more enlightened and deeply patriotic, more so than previous generations; they want to get their country back on the rails of progress and modernity", you are probably having day dreams. The eduction levels in Pakistan are among the worst in the world. Majority are obsessed with finding solutions in faith than modern thinking. Just because your views tally with IK, do not use arguments which have no reality.
Great work sir,I think the comments have already proved what professor sb has said.Go Kaptan go....
The Prof. is right. 2013 is when all you IK doubter's will fall flat on your face. Kaptaan will prevail.
As always your present an clear & insightful knowledge of our society Dr. sahab. I would surely like to be led by Imran Khan one day.We're all sick and tired of these shallow, unpresentatable, corrupt rulers that seem to be sitting on a merri-go-round. What's worse, they don't have the spine to defend our national interests and have made the nation addicted to foreign aid. As for economic policy ? well as they say 'if you put all economists end- to-end, you would never reach a conclusion'...and one of my professor of economics once said 'economics is nothing without politics'. so Imran has the critical ingredient right, rest would follow. In any case one doesn't need to have elaborate economic theories to make things work. what you need is committment for social, political and economic uplift, willingness to do the hard word and integrity.If Imran provides the chance, a lot of expat/local economists would gladly help him indigenously solve our problem which can easily be resolved in less than a decade.
As Imran Khan(Taliban Khan) is a mullah without a beard, the honorable prof. Sahib seems a re-carnation of Haroon ur Rasheed (yes without beard). Externally pathetic and disgusting "faraeshi" piece of prof sahib. Congrats Prof sahib for jumping on the bandwagon of cheap popular-ism. GOshhhhhhhh
@ Rahul Kumar
Thanx buddy. u r absolutely right. actually any logical and reasonable person would like and support IK's ideologies. what he has done and is still doing for the people of Pakistan we couldn't thank him more and don't have any words to express our gratitude to Almighty ALLAH for giving us such a great person. u see people who disagree with IK are either beneficiaries or part of status quo or are illiterate and brainless zombies. they don't have any logic to argue with IK's vision.
&
Thanks Rasul sab for a well thought article.
P:S Its time for change ... Its time for PTI
How many seats has PTI won in any of the by-elections? They lost them all where they contested. I did not want to make any comment and waste my time but thought to bring it on record the following: PTI would win no seat from Sind, GB or Baluchistan. Except IK, there is no other leader who can win any seat. IK has his following in the upper middle class, and there are not enough of them in any single constituency except large cities. He would not win more than a total of less than 10 national assembly seats in the next elections, unless the elections are selections by the ISI. A while back there was so much talk about IK as the next PM of Pakistan. There was a conference in India and a close friend of mine was asked about the possibility of IK. He told them that he would lose his security money and would not win even his own seat. The election night Indian TV was repeatedly playing his forecast. Actually the correct forecast of my late friend (a Pakistani labor leader) has made me interested to put my estimate down in black and white. "IK on his own without a major rightwing alliance of mullah would remain in single digits".
I agree that Imran Khan should be the next prime minister but it'll only be happened if we go out to caste vote. Next Elections are two years away. My question is how to bear two years with this PPP government?? What's the plan of Imran Khan to get rid of this government?? Small Dharna's and Strikes are not enough. A large LONG MARCH will be effective in this sense!! We're with you Mr. Khan. Take the right step at right time!! And it's the time!!!
@Shahid Khan: He is not just a university professor but an internationally renowned political scientist who has worked in the US before moving to Pakistan. Now go on and find a fault with this fact as well.
I think Pti must work in rural area. speccially in southern punjab..
bz in villages of pak a Taneedar and Patwari will play their game... and they willl be hired again for bogus votes... so dont take it easy to win the next election......
It seems that before next election a big media war will be launched against PTI and imran khan so all of you be prepair for that....
what now needs to be done is to arrange electronic voting with NADRA card in overseas Pak embassies. so that we can also vote for PTI.
Kaptaan is the last hope..Educated, determined and honest..
A wishful summation of the educated people whose hopes are budding on the plants of credibility, change and popular support. The mentor of Iqbal, Friedrich W. Nietzsche knew a lot about the realities of the chains of kinship, ethnicity and religious fanaticism( quite fervent in Pakistan) and he wrote these words of advice for those who will be devasted if Kaptaan fails to take them to the promised land of 'Corruption Free' country," The worst of evils, for it prolongs the torment of man".
When only the gut feeling of the educated elite can predict the outcome of public wishes, it is generally a sign that emotions have overpowered the realities of real politics in Pakistan. I hope and wish that Imran should win, and will be frustrated if he looses ,but frustrations alone can not change the political landscape of the country.
All those who believe in the invincibility of Kaptaan, the following enlightening words of Richard Feynman should suffice: The easiest person to fool is yourself.
do you think that Imran Khan, if elected, can deliver, given that public, who may be ready to vote him, but may not be prepared to act when time comes to do their share?
If this is correct, isn't your article need a addendum so that IK does not get a false impression of overwhelming and out right support in elections and beyond, making his decisions less cautious.
Do you think that Imran Khan, if elected, can deliver, given that the public, who may be ready to vote him, but may not be prepared to act when time comes to do their share?
If this is correct, isn't your article need a addendum so that IK does not get a false impression of overwhelming and out right support in elections and beyond, making his decisions less cautious.
"Allah Nay Zaika Dia Ahmad Nay Mahfooz Kia". Our Military establishment is now shifting to a liberal face of Imran Khan from Qazi. Rasool Bakhsh Raes among his other 'co-analysts' are now just coloring that face. Imran Khan lovers just want him to be the next head of their state by whatever means no matter how bogus is that.
Prof. Sahib.How do you explain the wins of PPP and PML(N) in the recent elections?The supporters of TI are likely to get a shock of their life, on the outcome of the next elections.I do not visualize Imran Khan getting more than 2 to 5 seats.The other parties are so well entrenched in rural areas,and are experts at contesting elections, that it is difficult to dislodge them.Only two parties,formed after creation of Pakistan, have succeeded in electoral politics,PPP and MQM.The other parties are branches of those formed before partition.Imran main focus is on rhetorics about corruption.He does not have winnable candidates.he has never presented any alternative program.Like Army Dictators,he will realize the complexities of problems confronted by this country.Every Military government's first step has been accountability.Have they succeeded in eradication of corruption,with all the power at their disposal,which Imran will not have?Imran has little idea about the threat terrorist are posing,and their ultimate goal.He has no economic agenda .He can not be compared to Bhutto as he had been in government for a long time and was much more mentally educated,well read,shrewd and charismatic.Supporters of TI, be mentally prepared, for taking out thinly attended processions that elections have been rigged once results of next elections are announced.
Fantastic piece Professor. Your analysis is most poignant as always. May your prediction be true and the Kaptaan come to power in the next elections!
You all , so called educated class and young Class of Pakistan will sleep at home on the day of election and watch TV in your comfortable room , wait for election result , and never will go out to cast vote and convince other people to vote , then you will see the same results as usual .
There was only one step remaining for Khan to attract the genuine intelligentsia of Pakistan and with grace of God he has done with it. Now the coming age is for Khan.....
@Ahmed: hahaha this is what i called limited knowledge and imran o phobia lol. Well in the start i want to say that "aapne apne comment bhi bht bari chawalein mari hai" which needs to be clear first, you compared Imran wid Z.A bhutto, agreed. But in the end you said he will destroy Pakistan, do you think that at this stage, Pakistan is stable? do you have common sense? you guys are always criticize Imran for no reason (and ratio who disagree with Imran and his supporters are 100:2, 2 maybe the supporters of PMLN lol) you guys will never come up with the solution, you guys will never cast your vote by saying this " ki farq painda hai yar " but you don't know the importance of your vote, anyhow, i feel sad for you and it shows your mentality, Pakistan are now wid PTI and Imran khan and it shows in current polls (and talk shows, street shows). But if you still looking for "genuine politican" so keep on looking and when you come up with any name, do post here so other will follow you, haha, silly boy.
Thanks God there are some people who are not SOLD , it is really a nice and based on facts article ........Well Done
ahmed...and who are u??..u seem to know everything...u dismissed imran khan just like this..u talked about za bhutto...but let me ask u one simple question??.. how bad can imran khan be??...zardari and nawaz seem ok to u ..they they ruled the country...no brain...and on top of that..corruption....man..i give up..can't write any more...do watever u people want..
@Rafi:
lol.. u seem to live in ur own world of fancies and make personal attacks , rather than accepting the reality that is contrary to your ideas
its easy to write such articles that appeal people's common prejudices , but its tough to accept and describe the real situation out there
so go on & keep writing :P
seems to be some wish-fullfilment prophecy of the author who lives in his own theoritical world :P everyone knows how imran khan has been trying for years now , and since he could hardly win a few seats , it is unlikely that he will win the elections :-( voting patterns of people are determined by other factors also.the author shall visit rural sindh and tombs of bhutto family to get an idea how popular PPPP still is
@Meekal Ahmed: very rightly put .agree with u
@Meekal Ahmed: What do other parties have? gangsters.. thugs..mafias..corrupt leadership
Imran Khan will prevail..Inshallah!
I think Shahid and Meekal are paid supporters of PPP/MQM/PML (N). I am Indian but I admire him as a leader,cricketer and politician.This is the beauty of the person that he has been admired all over the world not only in Pakistan. Shahid I think you are the most confused pakistani if you can not recognize a true leader who is honest brave and intelligent. We have lot of celebraties in India like SRK,Salman Khan,Aamir khan but they can not achieved what Imran did all alone. He exceled in almost all the field education,Sports.Health Care & now in Politics. How many people you see in this world who excel in different fields? No one. If your leaders are Zardari,Nawaz and Altaf then no comments .. Do u think people in villages are idiots? They are more educated politically than your burger boys..Same situiation in India most of the big leaders come from villages .. If you want to see your country in the list of educated and civilized country then you should vote and support great khan otherwise Nawaz and Zaradri company will destroy this country.
An Indian fan of Imran
Need the Kaptaan to lead the Pakistanis team again, lead from the front, play a Kaptaan's innings to ensure victory.
@Sarah Khan
US dialogue with Taliban will bring them into power. Mullah Umer ruled Kabul before US invasion. Do you want Hakeemullah Mehsood sitting in the parliament? US will pack their bags and leave, but we can’t hand over territory to these fanatics. US is a foreign force, but our army represents the state. If FATA is handed over to TTP, then many other groups will emerge to capture state territory. Negotiations leading to anything less than unconditional surrender would be a disaster.
@Meekal Ahmed: Dear for your kind information, Imran khan is the only who have all the talented people from every profession. Above all he is honest and has energy and commitment to move our country onto the right track. At this time we need new brains and young people to lead our country. And simply, we don't want to test those people again who have proven corrupt and incompetent.
Imran Khan is the idea whose time has come. No amount of image distortion can prevent him from changing the fortune of our beloved country. Prof. Sahib has accurately measured the political temperature. Those of you who are finding faults in Imran Khan should either provide an alternative or join him to correct those faults. Do you have any alternative ?
Hope so great Kaptain will win 2013 election, But election commission said with new list its impossible to arrage election in 2013. Hope so more and more youth registered in voting list for giving vote to Imran Khan.
JEAY JEAY IMRAN KHAN! JEAY JEAY PTI!
inshallah next parliamentary elections PTI will sweep!
@Meekal Ahmed: I agree, but don't you think that is not his burden? I mean, he's not a technocrat, he's not a trained politician, people like him can serve to provide a platform where the rest of us can come forward, and the drains are clogged in other parties, you can't come up or make yourself heard. I admire Javed Hashmi, Ahsan Iqbal, Raza Rabbani, Aitzaz Ahsan, Shah Mahmood Qureshi, and a few others, but the only problem is if they come on tv to defend why NS paid 5k tax, or how sasti roti is justified, they lose all credibility. So, I say, IK knows nothing about the economy, but people should come up and support him, professors from LUMS and GC have a better understanding of the economy, enough of imported WB, IMF folks, they lack a basic understanding (not of economics) but of Pakistan's way of economics (which, not surprisingly, defies conventional textbook economics). Even otherwise, it should be the burden of the people to join an honest man in what should be seen as a common struggle. One man can't do anything, diplomats, political advisers, foreign policy experts, educationists, doctors, economists who are sincere to the nation should rise to the occasion. That aside, I support him on 3 main issues. 1) He's got it right on the war, 2) Honest (presently, honesty>competence, 3) stand against corruption and tax-collection, and only he has the credibility to do that. He's no Michaeveli, but he can provide a platform and a purging time period which brings forth our generation's Obama. So let's hear for Kaptaan folks.
There are only two kind of peoples in Pakistan,one who support Imran Khan and secondly those who have problem with their brain.
Totally agree with Fawad Azam & Aq. He is sure the only visible alternate choice and probably the best amongst the lot but he sure have to stay clear of religious extremists and should clearly denounce taliban actions.
I have no doubt in my mind, that IK will sweep the coming elections. After a rigorous struggle and persistant stance on various issues made IK a giant against the other pigmies. BTW, the N (nalaiq league) has copied IK again and are preparing to bring their own 100 days (fake) plan.
@Sarah Khan: First, we are not voting for US, we are voting for IK. Second, talking or negotiating is something else and vindicating their actions is something else. What I meant to say is that I (and many more like myself) would go for him if he CLEARLY controvert the killers of thousands of my compatriots.
I do not know a bit more about future than this Professor, and God knows Professor himself does not know much either. All I know is I am not going to vote for a naive and arrogant Taliban sympathiser. We need experienced leaders who can run the country, and not the dreamers who misguide the public by fuming about drones killing innocent people (e.g Ilyas Kashmiri).
Imran reminds me of the sons of textile tycoons who go to America for studies and come back empty handed, either with a basic undergraduate and sometimes not even that.
They come back with a good Enlish language accent and some simple solutions.Their parents help them set up industries to run and most of them fail fail. But during the rise to power, they have all the answers. When the companies default (Cres-knit, Ejaz Dyeing,, Kohinoor socks,need I say more) they always blame the interest rates, Pakistani workers and other factors. Lets see what happens to Smart Mian Mansha when his highly spoiled boys take over the rein. I hope for Pakistan's sake he creates a proffesional management team that will keep a leash on his boys and allow them to mature.
Imran says he will end corruption in100days. Most of the corruption in Pakistan is at lower level. 1) About half of the students in Pakistani colleges cheat.They pass and they become corruptable junior government officers. 2) Almost all of the policemen in Pakistan take bribes. So do most of the Pakistani tax and custom officals. So do the people in the army responsible for procurement. Look at the prices Pakistan paid for F-16, Freench military eqiuipment, and look at the prices Taiwan paid for similar planes and equipment. Many of the Forntier Corp junior offiers manging our check posts allow drug smugglers to pass from Afghanistan to Pakistan for a bribe. Our Supreme court is great. But lower courts are totally corrupt. Our City organiszations responsible for road building, drainage and water works are corrupt, WAPDA and Railways have corrupt officers. And I can go on and on. Where would Inmran get not only qualified people to replace these corrupt people, but also honest people. I remember one of my relatives who was a DSP of police. His son spent every month what was equal to the salary of his father. I also knew a student at Indiana University whose father worked in the steel mills and he spent over $150,000 on his child's education.
Politicans make money. But almost 80% is lost in local corruption. Musharraf was somewhat honest in the beginning. he put army jawans next to police in Karachi to stop police from taking bribes. In a few weeks the army jawans were looking the otherway. The police start sharing their loot with army jawans who could easily quadruple their montly salary..
Pakistan just needs to double and triple the money spent on eduction with most of the increase going to girls education. Paksitan needs to throw out IJT from universities so that girls can stand side by side with me. And learn to grow agressive and get into the work with courage and determination.
Imran is loved by ubran youth, mostly young men with limited knowledge, who want the power. They think they can run the countrey with Imran. They do not have the experience. Imran will jbe just like ZA Bhutto and come in with a powerful slogan of roti, kapra and Makaan and ending up destroying Pakistan. Imran has no economic team. He does not have 50 honest and seasoned politicians with him after more than a decade in politics. He really really scares me. . Look at Shaukat Tarin. before starting the honest or clean party he laid out a frame work and is trying to get a team of 50 good politicans and as many good technocrsats. I really like him.
Go Captain go we are with you.
Hahaha rural middle class, professor that so called middle class is the pillar of communal electorate. Karachi has the biggest middle class and people refuse to get out of ethnic mindset when it comes to polling votes there. So much for your middle class theory hahahahaha.
Kaptaan Zindabad! Voting for Imran Khan InshaAllah...
@Shahid Khan: will you please explain what type of confusion....i am from village and i am a supporter of PTI and I am very clear about.....and so do the other villagers.....you still think with this kind of governance system (the worst ever) people still need to be clear....people like have this only word CONFUSE about IK....have ever listen to him and and reasons and arguments....what the professor is saying is cent percent correct...the dynamics of politics in pakistan has been changing....and willingly or unwillingly you will have to accept it
@Fawad Azam: come on fawad... even US and Kiyani are going to talk with talban and urderstood Imran's stance was right and u r saying he must disassociate with talban ..he never said he z pro talban but no miltry solution for this so called war against terror,only Politcal talk... and u ppl blame he is pro talban ... plz think before write or talk .
@Shahid Khan... Announcement: Ladies and Gentlemen, Shahid Khan is the only not-confused person in Pakistan. He will save Pakistan for you... through his keyboard.
@Shahid Khan: @Meekal Ahmed: So you want everyting on a platter, served to perfection? No wonder Pakistan is deep in the proverbial. Imran, his team and supporters are struggling for every decent Pakistani and sadly he has cynics like you lot who prefer to wallow in the proverbial rather than join the struggle to make real progress. Kudos to Jehangir Tareen, who, with many other good people, has joined the effort.
@Fawad Azam: The vision of Imran Khan is completely disjoint from the Talibaan. The problem is that most people fail to comprehend the complexity and gravity of the the situation at hand. "Talibaan" is a very vague term, who are they? There have been reports that thugs, criminals and outlaws have been operating under the pseudo cover of 'Talibaan' and have been involved in kidnapping and bounty hunting. Thus a 'blanket' policy towards the so-called 'Tablibaan' would only exacerbate the issue, evident in the ever increasing recruit pool for these 'Talibaan'. An outright offensive, without any prospect for political solution involving the locals, is not only detrimental but naive. Imran Khan is not opposed to an armed operation against the insurgents; he only asks that the possibility of a political solution should also be kept opened.
Good one Professor Sahab! The great Kaptaan will win the next polls with a huge margin INSHALLLAH.
I agree with fawad only if he dissociate himself from Taliban and jamaat islami and other religious extremist.
PTI is the best option for Pakistan.
Rasool Baksh Rais is a very noted and distinguished political analyst, who understands the dynamics of Pakistan politics very well.
Pakistan needs a change and Pakistanis see that chnage in new leadership and vision of Imran Khan. A chnage that is important for Pakistanis and for the rest of the world also.
@Fawad Azam: why US is negotiating with Taliban? When Imran says, talk to them its wrong but if US does then no one speaks against them!
I think you managed to keep the article simple and straight. Very to the point and express ywhat you believe about Kaptaan without mixing it with controversies... and thanks for not letting us into what you doubt...!!!
Imran Khan is the only hope for Pakistan.
Brilliant article. You have very accurately articulated the thougts and feelings of millions of Pakistanis that call themselves the silent majority. Keeping fingers crossed for Kaptaan!
WOWWW brilliant read! well done.
Only if he disassociate himself from Taliban, the killers of 35000 Pakistanis!
Looks like Imran Khan is going to win in 2013 with help from Establishment rigging.
We want Imran khan and PTI in power. He is the hope of nation
all others are tried and tested
Inshallah!
I hope to see the 'change' in my life. (I am just 23 right now)
I believe you are a university professor. Had you ever done research in your life, the figures are meaningless unless samples are taken from all social groups. In PEW research results, its clearly mentioned that samples were taken from 'selected urban centers' only.
We all know that Urban middle class is as confused as Kaptan himself. But sorry to say that Professors like you are much more confused than Kaptan or intentionally hide facts rather than education public.
Well, I can't speak of his platform of change except from the economic side where I find him shallow, mis-directed and confused. He desperately needs cold, sober economic advice and I don't think he is getting any. Indeed, I don't know of any good economist aligned with him unless they are doing so incognito!