Masquerading as a medical doctor

Complaints have arisen about a non-medical ‘doctor’ practicing medicine at a public hospital

Sameer Mandhro October 22, 2015
Complaints have arisen about a non-medical ‘doctor’ practicing medicine at a public hospital. DESIGN: TRIBUNE CREATIVE

KARACHI: 'Quacks' are common across the country, especially in Karachi where they run their clinics, hospitals and even maternity homes without any fear of repercussions. A case of an alleged quack has surfaced, who is masquerading as a medical doctor in a public-sector institution.

In July, 2013, a complaint was lodged against 'doctor' Syed Intesar Ahmed Burney who was working at the National Research Institute for Fertility Care (NRIFC) of the Sindh population welfare department's reproductive health centre at Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Centre. The complainant pointed out that the accused did not have an MBBS degree nor was he registered with the Pakistan Medical and Dental Council (PMDC) but he was nevertheless practicing medicine.

Doctor on the run after caught sexually molesting female patients

The complaint was registered with the Pakistan Medical Association's anti-quackery committee. The committee wrote a letter to the head of the institute, asking him why Burney was running a medical out-patients department (OPD) in the research clinic when he had not fulfilled the necessary requirements, including a one-year house job.

In response, the head of the NRIFC said that Burney was not an MBBS doctor, had not completed his house job nor was he registered with the PMDC.

He also mentioned that he was running an OPD, which he was not allowed to do by the ministry and the authorities had already been asked to take action against him.

Karachi doctor saves African patient from crutches

As per official records, Burney acquired his MSc and PhD qualifications in physiology and not in endocrinology.

Burney is a deputy director with a post of BPS-18 and the PMA's quackery committee said he is also affiliated with some prominent clinics in the city. He also conducts lectures in some institutions.

Burney has been dealing with patients for almost 20 years, a source in the institution disclosed, claiming that the authorities were aware of the situation. "He can only conduct research and is not allowed to deal with patients under the law," the official explained.

From ‘doctor brides’ to practicing physicians

The head of the institution also wrote a letter to the health director-general and minister of the national health services, regulation and coordination, Islamabad, last August to take disciplinary action against the accused but nothing has been done.

"These all are allegations against me," Burney told The Express Tribune. "I only conduct research," he maintained, accepting that he deals with patients in the institutions only for research purposes. "How can I conduct research without dealing with people?" he questioned.

He also denied visiting hospitals in the city but the administration and prescriptions tell another story. "It is a conspiracy against me and my brothers [Ansar Burney and Sarim Burney]," he believes. "It is a noble cause I am involved in," he added.

Fake doctors and fake medicines

"A person who has a doctorate in physiology or bio chemistry can run a clinic," he claimed.

"He is not entitled to practice in clinics," Dr Aziz Khan Tank, the chairperson of the PMA's anti-quackery committee said. He said that all relevant officials and hospitals where he practices as a medical doctor had been informed. "No one is serious about taking action against him," he said.

"I am not aware of this particular case," said the provincial health department's special secretary, Dr Khalid Hussain Shaikh. "I'll certainly take action if the case is genuine," he ensured.

PMDC suspends registration renewal criterion for doctors

Interestingly, Burney accepted that those couples visit him who have been unable to conceive for years. "I advise them on the basis of nutrition, environment and lifestyle," he said.

Published in The Express Tribune, October 23rd, 2015.


Ali S | 6 years ago | Reply Quacks are just the tip of the iceberg. There's no mechanism to check the clinical knowledge and skills of even those who have a MBBS degree - many of them are not much better than quacks in terms of knowledge. All developed countries have a grueling medical licensing examination that you need to pass in order to practice.
Thurzan | 6 years ago | Reply Quakery is rampant in pakistan where these quakes are doing irretrievable damage both to the patients as well as the medicines they prescribe to their unsuspecting patients. I have seen these quakes using injections, drips and even blood transfusions in extremely unhygienic conditions. They even resort to operations in conditions that would be comparable to barns. Their reuse of disposable syringes is adding to the already skyrocketing incidence of Hepatitis A, B and C as well as AIDS. The indiscrimate and wrong use of anti biotics is adding to resistant strains appearing which in the future are going to be very hard to treat. And the list goes on. The health authorities instead of curtailing these quakes are harassing the registered doctors and trying to extort money from them by threatening them of closing their clinics and work places. The present government should look into this matter seriously since a nation is built up by the people, and unhealthy people will only build a sick nation.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read