Making a ‘victim’ out of the culprit

This is a reflection of how indifferent we are to the physical, psychological trauma that countless people go through

Editorial July 04, 2015
This attitude of state organs is nothing more than a reflection of our society that as a whole keeps finding ‘reasons’ behind sex crimes, which amounts to making a ‘victim’ out of the culprit. PHOTO: AFP

Four women are raped in Pakistan every day. Let this figure sink in. For too many, this might just sink in rather easily because rape and other forms of sexual violence are such a frequent occurrence in Pakistan that they almost seem to have become an accepted reality of life here. The latest statistics on sexual assault were released recently in a report by War Against Rape (WAR), which has, once again, revealed the abysmal state of affairs with respect to the prevalence of sex crimes in the country. Reported cases of sexual assault nearly doubled last year, with 772 cases reported in 2013 and 1,582 cases in 2014. There was also an increase in cases of child sexual abuse with 3,003 cases of child sexual abuse in 2013, which rose by nearly 500 to 3,508 in 2014. While this indicates a substantial increase in the number of reported cases, it is still only a small minority that chooses to do so.

Referring to statistics from Karachi, the WAR report says there were over 380 cases of sexual assault reported in three major public hospitals in the city last year, but the percentage of FIRs filed was only 27.67 per cent. This brings us to a most important question: why do people choose not to report such cases and when will women in particular have better access to justice? The percentage reporting such cases is abysmal and it clearly indicates not only the procedural problems with reporting sexual abuse, but more so the insensitivity with which survivors are treated by the legal system. It does not matter how many anti-rape laws are made, although legislation in this area is important. If the state machinery is out of reach and getting justice a distant hope for most, how can this violence possibly be curbed? All around us are rape survivors and all around us are their perpetrators, who go by with their lives unaffected, and who face no consequences because it is the rape survivor who is stigmatised.

The attitude of the police, the judiciary and the media remains the same, where it is the survivors of sexual abuse who are looked down upon rather than those who wronged them. The little progress that has been made in the media, and that too only in some sections, is to avoid naming survivors of sexual violence, and to refer to them as ‘survivors’ rather than as ‘victims’. The rest pretty much remains the same with there being more concern about a woman’s character than the crime itself. This attitude of state organs is nothing more than a reflection of our society that as a whole keeps finding ‘reasons’ behind sex crimes, which amounts to making a ‘victim’ out of the culprit; a ‘victim’ who loses control of himself when he sees a woman late at night; a ‘victim’ who feels he has the right to abuse or assault someone because of the way someone is dressed.

The figures in the WAR report include those on rape, gang-rape, sodomy and incest. Other cases of sexual abuse have not been factored in and it can only be imagined what the figures would look like if all forms of abuse are accounted for. In the 45 cases investigated by WAR, it found that the age group most vulnerable to sexual assault was between five and 13 years. In this regard, children from low-income neighbourhoods living in dense localities are the most vulnerable.

Such reports come out every year, but unfortunately do not have the kind of hard-hitting impact they should. This is the value that we, as a society, give to human life, the importance we give to those most vulnerable to sexual violence. This is a reflection of how indifferent we are to the physical and psychological trauma that countless people go through. What are we doing as a society, as a state, to stop this? Does widespread sexual abuse even factor in as a societal concern? Are we having the necessary conversations in our homes to save our children? These are questions we must ask ourselves. We must ask ourselves how long this violation will continue and how many more lives will be ruined in this manner.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 5th, 2015.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.


Toticalling | 6 years ago | Reply @Ih: The editorial is talking about 'reported' rape cases and not the actual number. Obviously it is common knowledge that many cases of rapes are hushed up by women for various reasons.Other than fear of getting a bad name in the neighbourhood, the other reason is lack of trust in the judicial system, where the powerful get away with 'murder most of the time. There was a report in The Economist that even the definition of rape differs in many cultures. In many countries, even husbands can be tried for rape if the wife says no to a sexual act. Other cultures like Pakistan, many husbands claim that husband the right for intercourse and wives cannot say no. It appears some cultures have a long way to go to give women the equal rights.
Ih | 6 years ago | Reply This probably grossly underestimated number. Studies in other countries have shown actual incidence is much higher and burden of proof resting with victims discourages reporting it. The social and family issues further cloud the picture. Need to approach in a more realistic fashion.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read