Already suffering an acute shortage of gas — for cooking, heating on a domestic level — and used to living on load-shedd-ed electricity for more than a decade (my almost 15-year-old son doesn’t know a load-shedding-less Pakistan), not being able to get petrol for our everyday usage is so bad it’s almost unreal. Forget about luxuries most Pakistanis only dream of or see in movies; today, there is a stark scarcity of basics. Mourning the December 16 Peshawar tragedy, while much rhetoric is being spouted, and the National Action Plan is in the process of implementation, the goal is of provision of another basic: security of life. As schools raise walls (and fees, to pay for security requirements demanded by government — another governmental responsibility being placed on citizens), hire more guards, mount metal-detectors, post AK-47-wielding commandos on rooftops, parents are at a loss. How-to-send-children-to-school-without-petrol-in-their-cars/motorbikes is the new cry. The price of living in Pakistan, circa 2015.
At the time of writing (January 17), more than 40 Edhi ambulances are out of service, and only four 1,122 ambulances are available. Reason: unavailability of petrol. The dismal situation is merely another indictor of governance that is not just shoddy but a matter of criminal neglect. While the state is unable to provide basic security of life, clean water, affordable food, quality healthcare, uninterrupted electricity and gas, now it has one more gaping failure. Lines of vehicles on roads mark a huge wastage of human and, in turn, financial resources that form the bulwark of public, corporate and private sectors. These lines also indicate how the PML-N central government (with its third-time prime minister, and the PML-N Punjab government with its third-time chief minister — the Sharifs — are clueless, careless and, very, very short-sighted. The governance of adhocism, of crisis management.
The facts are staggering. There is no shortage of oil anywhere. Pakistan is not bound by any European or Middle Eastern quota. Oil prices are at a sparkling low. So what went wrong? Call it a bad mixture of truly bad policies by the ministry of petroleum & natural resources and the ministry of finance. The Pakistan State Oil (PSO) has over Rs215 billion in receivables, money owed among others by the main power company and PIA. All major banks are on a no-new-LC-for-PSO stance. While the PSO needs the immediate infusion of Rs100 billion and eight more weeks to get back in business, the top management’s interest in importing LPG for a cash-strapped company is bad business 101. On top of that, major oil companies like Shell, Caltex and Total face a petrol shortage too, whereas it is a basic requirement of business to have two-week stocks at any given time.
The PM’s dismissal of four federal secretaries and directors is a case of too-little-too-late. The onus is on the minister (of Petroleum & Natural Resources), Shahid Khaqan Abbasi, not his subordinates, who, reportedly, informed their boss of the alarming situation repeatedly.
While the PM’s “taking notice” of the shortage and public’s discomfort five days later (finally) is a glimmer of hope, the news of oil stocks drying up in three days is, to my mind, in a manner of speaking, a collective stimulus to anger, which may result in that one chant that haunts the PML-N, Nawaz Sharif and his supporters: “Go Nawaz Go.” I already hear the rumbling across Pakistan. Do you, Mr Prime Minister?
Published in The Express Tribune, January 20th, 2015.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (19)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Saadi Shirazi had a saying about three groups of people: 1. Afghans 2. Kashmiris 3. Kambohs
PSO has been facing a problem of circular debut for years. It needs to explore options for prompt payment. It is useful to note that petrol and diesel sales are mostly retail, and so money is collected at the point of sale. On the other hand, sale of jet fuel and furnace oil is made in advance against a line of credit. One possibility is to ask PIA, the power producers, Pakistan Rail, and other chemical industries to maintain an escrow account where they have to deposit funds every month, based on anticipated oil consumption for the next month. An escrow fund will allow PSO to collect funds and may ensure that circular debt does not occur. Perhaps I am naive but some creative solution is needed to break out of this vicious cycle of circular debt.
@Pataniya: Don’t really want to get in the middle of this, but there is no such thing as a Hindu gene, or a Muslim gene, or a Christian gene, etc. DNA is based on race and lineage. You can change your religion, you can’t change your DNA.
Saying that, it’s pretty obvious majority of Pakistanis and Indians share the same DNA. Those that are trying to project that having Arab lineage makes you a better Muslim are wrong….your actions make you a better Muslim, not your DNA.
Lahorewala almost hits the nail in the head, not just for Nawaz but for all of Pakistan.
As one can see, Indians are doing fine. Arabs are doing fine too. The genes of MOST Pakistani is Hindu as they are converts, not just Nawaz Sharif. However, they pretend to be Mughals or Arabs or whatever else. So the problem is not in the genes, Hindu or Arab, but in pretending what one is not. Hope Lahorewala gets this part right too!
@Lahore wala: Real Mongol Khans are reverting http://artoflivingsblog.com/travelling-with-sri-sri-in-mongolia/ and those who lost their way in India are here http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2424410/The-Mughal-emperor-ancestor-Sultana-Begum-forced-live-slum-washes-street-struggles-feed-children.html
Tribune please publish with links as it will educate your readers especially to wana be more Bedouini than bedouini themselves Poonjabis.
@Sashi: keep visiting pakistan websites , thank u for giving importance, you have no agenda just to spew venome when ever and where ever is possible
@Sashi: Wow! doing all this reading of newspapers, magazines and trolling websites and depositing bizarre comments, that must take 30 hours a day ! You must have multiple heads and arms, to be able to do all this reading and writing. As Modi said they were doing plastic surgery in Hindustan 5000 years ago. So no problem there.
ET please allow, responding tediously to addressed comment one again
@ Lahore wala : Amusing! Strange, convoluted and bizarre comment? Take a dipstick survey among the 11 commentators to check whose comment can be so described, yours or mine? As for visiting a Pakistani website, last I checked it wasn't anyone's exclusive property. I have been reading Pakistani papers everyday but so also Indian, American, British , Australian , Lankan among others. Helps one to be well informed, as opposed to being a frog in the well...... Point in case being the absurd comment posted by you.
P.S. I maybe an Indian Hindu but your assumption that I have to be pro Modi is not only completely off target but also symptomatic of your pre set default mode of reckless branding of people.
@khawaja nawaz: Bureaucrats were beating the drums about this crisis about a month ago. But Nawaz and his cabinet did not do anything. Very very incompetent cabal.... er...govt. AND there are 3 culprits, Dollar Dar, Finance,..Abbasi, Petroleum,..and Khawaja Asif Defense. But they are all related to Nawaz. He did nothing. Nawaz sacked the messengers,..but kept the bad news. All 3 of them.
@Sashi: It takes a hindu troll to come to a Pak website and rear up and leave a strange, convoluted, bizarre, comment. But then, this is par for Modi trained hindu trolls. Nothing new there.
ET please allow, responding to addressed comment
To add insult to injury the PM's committee ( yes, committee ) has declared OGRA as the culprit.........that's like blaming Uncle Sargam & Massi Museebat.
I believe all those who read the article and commented upon are well versed with the routine corporate working. A clerk is supposed to move a file and let it go to the top for instructions. If suddenly the file is misplaced in the process of movement, the whole issue turns into a chaos as the entire issue related matter is gone out of focus.The man on the top has so much over his shoulders that he can't keep tracking a certain file. That is how crisis in governance is made up and the responsibility squarely lies over the man in the lead. I do agree that Mr. Nawaz Sharif must take the responsibility as he had these men around him and had posted them too. But it is presumed that routine matters will be run in routine.I know it is no defence of Nawaz Sharif; but what I am pointing out is that someone somewhere is out to create troubles for the civilian government. That "someone" must be located and stopped from such facilitation. I know it is hard to do that; but it needs to be done. Lets not make it look such simple as it appears on the face of it.
To all the PMLN supporters, enjoy your PMLN government
@ Lahore wala "Even though he is descended from Jat hindus. And as they say, it’s all in the genes. Hindu genes simply cannot pretend to be Mughal. And therein lies the problem."
No, dear resident of Lahore. Pakistan's current standing in the comity of nations & the rapidly unravelling of its social fabric is due to mindset ( Syed Raza Abdi's takiakalaam ) like yours. And therein lies the problem. When such blanket statements are flippantly but convincingly used by its citizens to refer to a religious community ( doesn't matter if it is directed at Hindus, Muslims, Christians et al ), you know the nation is really, really scraping the bottom of the barrel.
Yeah, but democracy was saved right? So let's enjoy this pmln govt for next few years!
Pathetic governance by PML N. Globally fuel in abundant supply with dirt cheap prices and still we are facing this situation! Unbelievable. This clearly spells out what an incompetent lot is ruling us.
Wow, even your love fest with Noora League seems to have melted. There is nothing like a well aimed kick in the right place to wake people out of their pathetic slumber!
Well, Nawaz rules in a very palatial Mughal Darbar Style. Even though he is descended from Jat hindus. And as they say, it's all in the genes. Hindu genes simply cannot pretend to be Mughal. And therein lies the problem. Bad genes. And about hearing the rumble 'Go Nawaz Go' he has a severe hearing problem. Last time he had to be dragged off the throne by Gen. Musharraf.