Asked on a religious website if it was permissible for fathers to build snowmen for their children after a snowstorm in the country's north, Sheikh Mohammed Saleh al-Munajjid replied: "It is not permitted to make a statue out of snow, even by way of play and fun."
Quoting from Muslim scholars, Sheikh Munajjid argued that to build a snowman was to create an image of a human being, an action considered sinful under the kingdom's strict interpretation of Sunni Islam.
"God has given people space to make whatever they want which does not have a soul, including trees, ships, fruits, buildings and so on," he wrote in his ruling.
That provoked swift responses from Twitter users writing in Arabic and identifying themselves with Arab names.
"They are afraid for their faith of everything ... sick minds," one Twitter user wrote.
Another posted a photo of a man in formal Arab garb holding the arm of a "snow bride" wearing a bra and lipstick. "The reason for the ban is fear of sedition," he wrote.
A third said the country was plagued by two types of people: "A people looking for a fatwa (religious ruling) for everything in their lives, and a cleric who wants to interfere in everything in the lives of others through a fatwa," the user wrote.
Sheikh Munajjid had some supporters, however. "It (building snowmen) is imitating the infidels, it promotes lustiness and eroticism," one wrote.
"May God preserve the scholars, for they enjoy sharp vision and recognise matters that even Satan does not think about."
Snow has covered upland areas of Tabuk province near Saudi Arabia's border with Jordan for the third consecutive year as cold weather swept across the Middle East.
COMMENTS (33)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
This is how the media show one part of the story.
Original Fatwa: "If the snowman does not have clear facial features such as eyes, a nose and a mouth, and it is merely a three-dimensional figure with no features, like the scarecrows that farmers set up to scare away birds, and signs that are put on roads as a warning of roadworks or construction, then there is nothing wrong with any of that. Similarly, there is nothing wrong with what children do for fun, because such figures are not usually treated with respect (unlike statues and idols) and it is well-known that children have a psychological need to play and have some fun and excitement, especially in places where snow only falls on rare occasions."
Read Further @ http://islamqa.info/en/226557
@chikoo: I agree. And the kids who construct them and their parents who allow this activity to go should be prosecuted for crimes against human nature. (They have snow in Saudi Arabia?)
@John B: I especially liked the part about snowmen (and snowwomen?) promoting "lustiness and eroticism". I'll have to start giving a second look at "smiling" snowmen in my snowy neighborhood: Coals for eyes, carrot for nose, no clothes on, etc. Oh, those naughty kids who look so innocent! That is what happens in a closed humorless/anal, "puritanical," sex-obsessed country where the sexes are strictly segregated. How did the militants who shot up Charlie Hebdo cartoonists last week in Paris know that the "offending" images were of a certain personage when no one in history has supposedly described or drawn that personage? What about all the human beings who are named after such a personage - aren't there really ugly ones or criminal ones among them? And what about the man in the moon (looks like the late Moammar Gaddafi to me)? Or the various objects that remind some people of various celebrities? This cleric shouldn't be gazing at those cloud formations or he will accusing Mother Nature for producing pornography. These clerics must not possess an excess of poetic and artistic sensibilities that contribute to the creation of works of art that hugely contribute to the creation of a rich culture.
"Believe it or Not" - sometime back one of our clerics proclaimed on tv that swimming was not to be learnt or done (for both males and females) except when it is required for jihad!!
Saudi clerics are much of idiots...
i am 100% with the esteemed cleric. these snowmen are a major threat and should be slayed wherever they are found. :P
This must be a Saudi Islamic view , Not necessarly an Islamic View, The Saudi clerics have been known to come up with Some wearied interpretions of the beliefs.
Islam may have survived 1500 years because of the Arabs.
The next 1500 years, however ...
What about scarecrows...
"God has given people space to make whatever they want which does not have a soul, including trees"
Plants Exhibit The Same Senses As Humans And See, Touch, Smell, Hear and Even Taste. Ignorance isn't just bliss, it seems to be the primary requirement if you want to pursue a career in Religion.
and these muslims shamelessly point fingers at other religions.
The journalist didn't present the actual reason for the ruling which is making images. please refer to the link:http://islamqa.info/en/226557 for the actual fatwa in english. actually the fatwa says: Similarly, there is nothing wrong with what children do for fun, because such figures are not usually treated with respect (unlike statues and idols) and it is well-known that children have a psychological need to play and have some fun and excitement, especially in places where snow only falls on rare occasions.
the ET should really correct this article before it gets more public.
What a joke, these fatwa people are. That means all the farmers cannot have a scarecrow now, and soon all toys resembling human beings will be called idols also in the same manner. May Allah save Islam from uneducated people.
I condemn these clerics as a curse to our religion
Now Pakistani Media is reporting these too and is it not Blasphemous?
Its wrong thats not what he said here see it by yourself http://islamqa.info/en/226557 He clearly stated and I quote from him "If the snowman does not have clear facial features such as eyes, a nose and a mouth, and it is merely a three-dimensional figure with no features, like the scarecrows that farmers set up to scare away birds, and signs that are put on roads as a warning of roadworks or construction, then there is nothing wrong with any of that.
Similarly, there is nothing wrong with what children do for fun, because such figures are not usually treated with respect (unlike statues and idols) and it is well-known that children have a psychological need to play and have some fun and excitement, especially in places where snow only falls on rare occasions. " Rest is upto you.
Hahaha are our mullahs really that bored that they are now bothering themselves with how to play with snow and what fatwas to pass on the basic elements of this earth?
Saudi clerics have always insulted Islam by issuing such kinds of fatwa by using their own interpretations - the fatwa is a gift for those who turn their heads to Saudi Arabia for Islam.
It would had been helpful if ET had provided a link to the fatwa also. I could only find the following: http://islamqa.info/en/226557 But this website does not provide any such statement that this article alleges. I am just a cultural Muslim and don't care much about these fatawas. But I am very much against propagating information without full proof. Just because Reuters reported something does not make the story correct. Hopefully some reader of ET can point to an article which has the person stating something like what is alleged in the article (which is stupid)?
At least they did not decree that the "showperson" must wear a hijab.
There is something seriously wrong with these people. Is building castles in the sand ok? What about mobile phones and tablets? Do these people travel back in time to get permission?
Is casting a shadow by light permissible? How come movies and TV are allowed? In the era of 3D TV, what is the stated position? 3D TV should be fatwaed ( a new verb here, sir),
“God has given people space to make whatever they want which does not have a soul, including trees, ships, fruits, buildings and so on,” he wrote in his ruling.
Technically Snowman is inorganic like ships, and buildings and does not have a ""soul"" (what is soul?) , whereas trees and fruits are as organic as men.
So, please help ! Your "so on and so on" conclusion is very ambiguous.
All Pakistanis must be feeling really proud and smart (pun intended) about their their Arabic descent!!
It is obviously un islamic because there is no snow in Saudi
I fail to understand how this helps us in becoming better muslims
Snow Man in no way resembles a Human in any form or way. The problem with these Clerics is that they just don't have anything better to do. Why doesn't this person condemn the Paris killings?
When will they come out of cave?
From where these thoughts come from ? This is one of the reason there is less creativity in muslim countries .
Thanks ET for sharing such a hilarious joke ;)
Some people just can't enjoy life - that's bad news because these same people go out of their way to make other people miserable.
Is Mirror anti-Islam because it reflects a soulless human image? Otherwise the clergy can never see himself!
LOL.....