Mary Kom, is a bio-pic about the struggles of Mary Kom, a real life woman boxing world-champion from the Indian state of Manipur, which had a democratically elected state council that was bypassed when its constitutional head signed a merger agreement in 1949 with an Indian Union that was yet become a democratic republic. Different issues come into the Mary Kom story — some fleetingly, some prominently. They include, the socio-political instability in Manipur, the prejudicial behaviour of Hindustanis towards Manipuris, armed forces of the Indian Union, Manipuri terrorists (or armed insurgents — take your pick) and so on. If the personal trials and tribulations of Mary Kom is the meat of the story, these other issues are the masala. The meat may be of top quality but without the right amount of masala applied in the right way, the dish cannot be served. The masala has to be of a particular kind, given that the customers of the dish come primarily from the halls and multiplexes of the Indian Union’s small towns and big cities. Every day, Mother Hindi serves food cooked in her Bollywood kitchen to millions of her state-loving offsprings spread all across her nation. This is the kind of meat that adds to the muscle of the four lions atop the Ashokan pillar. Nowadays, everyone is a little experimentative and wants to try some variations in their cuisine — a little ‘unity in diversity’, if you will. Hence, Mary Kom is a hit — a daughter’s tale, a mother’s tale, a woman’s tale, the tale of a thoroughly Indian Manipuri’s eventual Indian acceptability, the tale of north-east taking centre-stage, the tale of mischievous daughter Manipur’s relationship with Mother India. The Indian state is a liberal one now. It can take stuff like this — a little self-critique here, a little dose of common humanity there. But not all meats can be served everywhere. I hear that some Nagas dishes are so out there that no amount of tri-colour garam masala makes their story palatable in Delhi, Mumbai, NOIDA and Gurgaon. Every snake-charmer knows that it is risky to show off a snake which still has its fangs intact.
In Mary Kom, the heavily pregnant heroine is going towards the hospital with her husband. She is nearing labour. There is curfew on the streets. The husband tells her to wait and advances a bit. He is in the middle of a group of khaki-clad Indian security force men out to weed out trouble-makers. He tells them about his wife. A jawan finds her. The story matches. They arrive safely at the hospital. Many such images of an agitated Manipur break into ‘Mary Kom’. I use the word ‘images’ very deliberately here, for some realities are somewhat different. In July 2009, Mary Kom was selected for the Rajiv Gandhi Khel Ratna award, the Indian Union’s highest sporting award. It was in the same July of 2009 that khaki-clad government forces surrounded an unarmed Chongkham Sanjit in a busy bazaar at Imphal, the capital of Manipur. Sanjit does not resist. He is whisked away to a dark area beside a roadside medicine shop. A few minutes later, the Khakis come out with Sanjit’s bullet-ridden dead body and throw it onto a truck. Wait. There is another corpse on the truck. It belongs to Rabina Devi, a pregnant bystander killed by police a short while ago. This whole sequence gets captured on camera, just like a film. A little Googling will do. Not all pregnant women and young men on Imphal streets get the ‘Mary Kom’ treatment. There is no market for these pictures of Manipur. The story of a decade-long hunger-striker protesting the ‘special powers’ granted to Indian Army in Manipur is no formula to Bollywood success. The picture of Irom Sharmila Chanu with the force-feeding tubes stuck to her nose is sure to take the pop out of popcorn. And if nothing else, the censor board will happily oblige in its mission of catering fairy-tales to citizens and protecting impressionable minds from such naked images. Sports are a better bet. A Manipuri woman’s struggle for legitimacy in Hindustan and Hindustan finally coming around to embrace her back. Mother India’s bosom is big enough for all. Taaliyan bacchon.
The day ‘Mary Kom’ was released, Indian Union’s prime minister gave a widely beamed ‘Teacher’s Day’ speech to school students. There was some Q and A too. A 17 year old school student Nickson Laisram of Imphal asked ‘How can I become the PM?’. Poor Nickson probably already knows that his ethnic origin unofficially rules that out already. The best he can hope is that his sisters will not have the fate of Thangjam Manorama, an insurgent who was picked up by security forces from her home in 2004. Her body, covered in sperm and bullets, was found the next day. 30 Manipuri mothers stripped themselves in protest outside an armed forces outpost with the banner ‘Indian Army, Rape Us’. I am waiting to stand up to the tune of the national anthem of the nation that will have the story of Manorama and her mothers in the night-show, without the garam masala.
Published in The Express Tribune, September 23rd, 2014.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (10)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Razzy: "Lets not wax eloquent on Bollywood here. That they chose an actress with ‘mainstream’ looks rather than opting for someone from the northeast (and yes they are quite pretty) tells a lot about what bollywood stands for…furthering the status quo that is.."
Most actors in the movie were from North East. The otion that a person from North east can only be represented by another person from North east is the opposite of what acting stands for. Mary Kom's story has reached far more people because Priyanka acted in it rather than some unknown person from North East. By the way, Manisha Koirala who is from Nepal and has North Eastern looks has also played characters from southern or western India in many movies.
In the end it was a movie not a documentary.
"Teachers' Day." Not "Teacher's Day." The apostrophe comes after the "s" in this case.
Lets not wax eloquent on Bollywood here. That they chose an actress with 'mainstream' looks rather than opting for someone from the northeast (and yes they are quite pretty) tells a lot about what bollywood stands for...furthering the status quo that is..
Time and again Delhi gives us horrid tales of sexual, physical and emotional abuse of north easterners and this movie will only re-inforce that. Since it tells them, "see u ain't good enuf for our movies so we had to put priyanka there"
ET mods - 2nd attempt. Everything is related directly to the OpEd and is factual. Why are you filtering it?
@Author:
Yes the discrimnation exists. But now there is an awareness of the problem which you chose not to allude to. Whether it is the KBC ad of ' jaante hain par maante kitne hain' or a movie like Mary Kom being made by mainstream Bollywood or PM ensuring that north east was represented on the calls with the kids or media higlighting issues of discrimnation against people from North east or a much higher development budget being assigned to the north east - their feelings of neglect and discrimination finally have a voice and there is a will in the center to address those feelings. Hence things will improve even though they are not ideal right now.
By the way you do know that Assamese people also have a concern about illegal Banladeshi migrants who are swamping their culture - something that politicians in Congress and TMC are turning a blind eye to for vote bank politics. Any thoughts on that?
@Strategic Asset: Correct. If a lower caste chaiwala can become a PM so can a kid from Imphal. Garga is transfering his own prejudices to others. The kid had the confidence enough to ask the question, so he clearly does not have a victim mentality and Modi only encouraged him.both these are good things. It must have been good for many people to hear that while some people maybe discriminating, not everyone in rest of India feels that way.
Nor is it something that Modi said just for this audience. In this incident which happened in 1991, http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-features/tp-openpage/a-train-journey-and-two-names-to-remember/article6071074.ece which was not in public visibility and he was not even an MLA at the time, just a karyakarta - he had encouraged two north east women to join the party saying that talent should not have barriers.
A 17 year old school student Nickson Laisram of Imphal asked ‘How can I become the PM?’. Poor Nickson probably already knows that his ethnic origin unofficially rules that out already.
Yet what Modi told the young student from Imphal is "Start preparing for 2024 elections. It also means till then I do not have any threat."
@Milind: I assure you he won't write about that. That would mean getting over flippancy.
The term 'racism' typically conjures images of discrimination by the white man on black/brown/yellow man here. We innocently forget that we're the worst type of racists here. Anybody who doesn't speak Hindi is an outsider. Anybody who's short, dark is not amongst us. Thankfully these attitudes are reducing atleast amongst the middle classes.
BTW, I would like the hear the views of the author on the Bengali (India and Bangladeshi/ Hindu & Muslim) influx in the north-eastern states, which is obliterating the local culture. Its ok to write on the dominance of the army, mainstream/middle class, conveniently forget something closer to home for the author.
ET - Please publish...
The discrimination against people from North Eastern states is very obvious in India. A sad state of affairs.
An average Indian is very racist against any Race which is not white skinned. Only by admitting can we fix an issue.
Next time a friend calls someone the 'C' word, remind them how insensitive it is. Not just that whenever we make fun of any fellow Indian who has a darker complexion, lets sit back and correct our Racist attitudes.
This obsession with uniformity is ludicrous. A bouquet needs different flowers to be beautiful.
You have to write about India in a certain way to get invited to write in Pakistani news papers. But the author has to be really ashamed for writing the ethnicity of the Manipuri child rules out her ever becoming PM of India. Writing like this does not lower the image of India, only the author's.
Sad, but true. The story of Manipur is far more complicated than Mary Kom the movie. Interestingly, the Manipuris are staunch Hindus- since the earliest times and find metion in the Mahabharata. It is perhaps the only Hindu state that has serious issues with Delhi.