A home for Dilip Kumar in Pakistan

Decision to turn Dilip Kumar’s house into a heritage site signals willingness by government to accept a shared history


Editorial July 18, 2014

The decision by the Pakistan government to turn the childhood home of venerable Indian actor Dilip Kumar into a heritage site is indeed a welcome one. Bollywood — and the music that comes with it — has been transcending South Asian borders since they were first put up, and Dilip Kumar has led the charge. Born Yousuf Khan in Qissa Khwani Bazaar, Peshawar, Kumar moved to Pune, and starred in his first film, Jwar Bhata, in 1944. Since then, he has established himself as one of South Asia’s greatest actors. Kumar has only come back to Pakistan twice since partition, but has signalled his willingness to attend the inauguration of the house.

Like Ivo Andric or Garcia Marquez, Kumar is not confined to his current national boundaries; his significance — and his life — spans the Subcontinent. While Kumar has already been awarded the Nishan-e-Imtiaz, Pakistan’s highest civilian honour, the move to declare his childhood home, currently dilapidated, a heritage site is one more step towards the recognition of those individuals on a regional scale. The house of Raj Kapoor, also in Qissa Khwani Bazaar, is also set to be declared a heritage site.

But beyond the deserved recognition of South Asia’s actors, the move signals a willingness by the government to accept a shared history, a pricklier idea. As far as Pakistan’s geography is concerned, ruins from the Indus Valley Civilisation, excavations in Bhambore, Buddhist relics in Peshawar all suggest a breathtaking unity within narratives of history which has been systematically shrouded from view. Our history writing is informed by the Two-Nation Theory, impossibly dissecting events, people and physical locations into ‘Pakistani’ and ‘Indian’ at a time when those divisions did not exist. To an extent, the laurels towards Kumar mitigate that charge. Kumar, a Muslim, chose to stay in India, but is being honoured all the same. A similar openness with other figures — Raj Kapoor is a start; Bhagat Singh also comes to mind — will only help bridge this historical and historiographical divide.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 19th, 2014.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

Our Publications

COMMENTS (8)

[email protected] | 6 years ago | Reply

We may be two or three nations but are one people ...

Gp65 | 6 years ago | Reply

The editorial is premature. The architecture department has said that this proposal is not feasible. This shows that forget ther army - Nawaz does not even have writ over civilians. Before announcing somethin like this, Pakistan should have confirmed its feasibility. No wonder Pakistan lacks credibility in negotiations with India. Even a commitment made by Pakistani PM cannot be trusted.

@G. Din: Dilip Kumar. Was born in (united) India and has lived as an Indian all his life. He is alreqdy in his mtherland. No need to go anywhere.

VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ