The dissonance between India and the US, around the denial of a US visa to Modi since 2005 over his alleged role in the 2002 Gujarat riots, has been exacerbated in recent months. And yet, just look at the speed with which Modi is about to accept an invitation by US President Barack Obama for a visit to Washington, DC.
Is Delhi waking up to an exercise of real power? Certainly, there has been a frisson of excitement over the day-long visit of Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi as well as the US point person for South Asia, Nisha Biswal, over the last few days. The Americans are bending forwards and backwards and sideways to make amends with Mr Modi. It pleases us to no end, of course. But Mr Modi’s reaction is interesting: he is calmly accepting diplomatic apologies and proceeding to behave as if it is all business as usual.
This is unusual for Delhi too. We are so used to frothing and foaming and standing on the high moral ground that diplomats, supposed to be schooled in the business of hard diplomacy, are rediscovering the joys of, well, diplomacy without the moral ground.
Clearly, India’s new foreign policy will be revamped on the basis of economic fundamentals. Like Manmohan Singh, who hoped to use economics to pave the way for better political ties, Modi will push the business of making money on both sides.
On the India-China front, the contentious border dispute will be isolated so as to let the economies grow. The Chinese have been resisting the entry of Indian pharmaceutical as well as information technology-related companies. That opposition will likely vanish soon. On the US front, the Americans are pushing for a presidential-style leader like Modi to make hard choices in favour of US companies looking for new markets and newer ways of making money.
And then there is Japan. It is already clear that Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe will pave the way for a greater India-US-Japan relationship. For example, Japanese companies Toshiba and Hitachi have been holding up US companies General Electric and White Westinghouse from selling nuclear reactors to India, because of their own concerns around nuclear energy since the Fukushima disaster. That is also likely to end soon — when Modi makes his second foreign visit to Japan.
Are happy days here again? Kya achhe din aa gaye hain? Certainly, the members of the business community are walking around with permanent smiles plastered on their mouths.
Sajjan Jindal, the Indian businessman in power and steel, hosted Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif for tea just before Sharif went to Rashtrapati Bhawan to attend the swearing-in ceremony of Narendra Modi. Evidently, Nawaz’s son also met Jindal separately.
Could Jindal be the new economic back-channel between India and Pakistan? Could Jindal’s company be used to lay a few electricity transmission lines from India’s Punjab grid to Lahore?
The funny thing about India-Pakistan is that when Delhi suggests the idea of both sides making money, Islamabad wonders why it is doing so. Sure the Indians will make money, but guess what, 500 megawatts of Indian electricity into the Pakistani grid can also help reduce the 18-hour power cuts that Pakistan Punjab routinely faces.
Better to melt in the heat than buy bijli from India? That big question looms large, in the face of the general Pakistani read-out that Modi lectured Nawaz in Delhi. So what is Pakistan going to do now?
Published in The Express Tribune, June 11th, 2014.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (48)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Friends, why do you always talk about the potential. For instance, "if we Pakistanis unite, we can ...."; "Pakistan should never be underestimated ....;" etc. etc.
You never talk about ground realities. Each and every country has potential. If you just talk about potential in the air, then India has more potential than Pakistan will ever have.
Talk about reality. And only then will you notice where Pakistan is ... and where the rest of the world has gone.
@biwildered. If india is indeed stealing your water how come you lose all cases you file against us in international court under indus water treaty? Laws are laid down clearly in book when you and we signed it. If we violated the law, court would have stopped us from making electricity from the water under norms mentioned in treaty. They didn't, we follow all norms. Not mad enough to invest thousands of crores into it knowing we violated it knowing and it will be shot down once someone files complaint in court. This is not like your ip pipeline, that without taking laws/sanctions into consideration you signed it. Now facing penalty fines, if you don't follow rules and complete project under IP.
Pakistan must be highly satisfied nation. They wanted muslim nation they got it. They wanted nuclear bombs they got that. They wanted to control Afghanistan, they achieved once. Rest are smaller things like 18 hrs power cut in most prosperous province. Have to buy from kafir India, kafir Russia and have to have friendship with kafir China.
India's bijli shortage this year is estimated at 5%. India does not have spare bijli for anybody.
@Riz: In 1947 we have horses to travel now we have BMW & Mercedes. We achieve this with sheer hard work, not by handout.
@Zamrood: Hahaha FYI there is no shortfall but transmission line are down due to bad weather.
First of all, I am amazed and thrilled to see such a spectrum of diversified participants on this ET forum, especially the interest expressed by Indians and Bangladeshi participants. Secondly, I would like to suggest to my foreign participants that incompetence and mismanagement of electric power managers is the reason for extended periods of load shedding in my country, which is unfortunate especially in consideration of the fact that installed power is significantly more than power demand. Then why is this power shortage? Well, the outdated laws, one-sidedagreements favoring the blue-eyed boys, incomparable incompetence of high officials, corrupt practices (inspired from top level politicians and bureaucrats), and complete inability/insensitivity to recognize the issue is what is multiplying the problem exponentially. We do not need a single kilowatt of energy from outside. We have sufficient to cater for our needs and requirements if we just utilize the available active resources with contemporary management skills without political interference. However, it will require people to reject the politicians that they choose to elect repeatedly despite the burden of problems these politicians continue to burden over their voters. It's a catch 22 situation which need to be resolved from within. No need for any help from either Modi or Hasina!!
why does India want to sell Electricity to Pakistan....do we have the required infrastructure to do the same......let us say suppose there is infrastructure India does supply electricity...if due to some technical problems there is a power surge or failure Pakistanis will make it 9th point of Composite Dialogue....my 2 cents Indians keep away from Pakistanis.Let Pakistanis deal with there problems.
@Pity: it was your ( then west Pakistan) refusal to accept Sheikh Mujibur Rehman , a bengali to become prime minister of Pakistan in 1970 though he had majority, which led to division of Pakistan in 1971. why blame india probably if Pakistan National Assembly passes appropriate resolution making amends for past and inviting Sheikh Hasina to be Prime Minister of Pakistan may resolve problem
@faraz @queen the power cut in delhi is because of dust/wind storm that hit delhi and other parts and killed ten people, damaged 5 planes distroyed and damaged most of dehlis electricity transmission tower. There is no govt in delhi because AAP resigned. Its a orphan place till new election takes place. Still the central govt has said it will fix the damaged electric towers within ten days till that. People will have to face cuts caused by damaged towers destroyed by storm. As far as UP all states buy power from surplus states in india. UP is not buying it, they want to punish people not giving them nil vote and blaming centre led bjp govt, for not giving power to UP. Who's stopping UP govt to buy power from neighbouring states? No one. It's just plain politics as UP election is coming in 2 years.
Why on earth Indians compare their nation with Pakistan. Its a big big country can't compare with such a small one. If they still do, just go back to 1947 and compare the two territories considering the resources the two sides had, industries, factories, economy, etc. with the current ones. U wud easily conclude who has come far.
@PakistanZindabad: I live in one of the most under-developed districts of East Punjab, District Fazilka. Even we get 24 hour electricity on most days, there maybe a cut for 2 or 3 hour in the summer, but that's it. Punjab is only one of the power surplus states in India.
@Zamrood 1000-1300 MW Power is extra available for DELHI, problem is due to failure of Redundant Transmission system because Delhi State does not have any Government due to so called AAP, I have to admit that Last night there was 2.5 hour power-cut in my area(which i haven't seen in past 3 years), but Central Govt. has stepped up to resolve that issue and as per Tech. Comity issue will be solved in 21 days Time Limit. Some states does not want to purchase power from Central Grid just to maintain fund for Lollipop sachems.
@Faraz: there Is No Power Shortage in Gurgaon.... and 18 hours In Noida?? I Said There Is Problem In Uttar Pradesh But Not As much As Pakistan Punjab....the Most Developed Province Of Pakistan... LOL...and Dude Has It Become A Norm Of U Pakistanis To Speak Without Any research...the Shortage In The Ncr Region Is Coz Of The Storm That Damaged Cables And Transmission Towers...but If It Makes U Feel Good I Will Agree Dat WHOLE INDIA IS FACING 25 HOUR POWER SHORTAGE...YES EVEN MODI KA GUJARAT....HAPPY???? Regards
@Rakib: Snide remarks are fine but they do not stand the scrutiny of facts. Here is one article from a strong AAP supporter whose brother Mani Shankar Aiyer's antipathy for a choawallah becoming PM os well known. http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/swaminathan-s-a-aiyar/stock-market-boom-not-only-for-narendra-modi-cronies-benefited-small-mid-caps-swaminathan-s-aiyar/articleshow/36365294.cms
@Susane: There is a difference between shortage of electricity and problems in distribution due to underinvestment in distribution grids. http://www.veooz.com/news/zHFhlUQ.html
This is not to deny there is a prolem but point out that the prolem is nit sortage in generation but problems with distribution.
@Hunza wala:
First of all your postis not related to the OpEd bu just flows from your reflexive hate owards Modi.
Secondly, I question whether those who do not believe in innocent until proven guilty but rather believe in guilty because i say so even if exonerated by Supreme court can be considered civilized.
Further Shinzo Abe follows only 3 people on twitter of which one is Modi. So do you consider Japan uncivilized? What about your higher/sweeter/taller friend whose overnment welcomed him even when he was not a PM?
(Sajjan Jindal, the Indian businessman in power and steel, hosted Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif for tea) Author
Jindal may be good but talking to Gautam Adani of Ahmedabad would have been better! He has the password: "Iftah yaa Simsim"!
@*The funny thing about India-Pakistan is that when Delhi suggests the idea of both sides making money, Islamabad wonders why it is doing so".* Actually its a matter of concern why would India help Pakistan in the power sector when India is itself having electricity shortfall more than the hours in Pakistan. China is cooperating with Pakistan in power sector by constructing nuclear power plants in Karachi. Other than this country is also utilizing the wind and solar energy as a mode of generating power and to make the country full fill its energy demands. "
@ Author
The answer to your question is: No, Pakistan is not going to import electricity from Mr. Jindal. It will become another dossier in Pakistan-India trade talks. The 18-hours power cuts are due to low water level in the dams. It will improve with the oncoming monsoon.
This is really a reality or a fantasy that new administration in India is so much worried about Pakistani people? This is an astonishing moment that historic rival has so much high concerns about next door neighbor. Modi government should concentrate on its intrastate issues of home rather of some one else. There are lots of prevalent socio economic issues in India which are in dire need to address particularly the predicaments related with human security. Pakistan is on the way to use its nuclear credential for civilian power generation.
@lol: 18 hour power cuts in Noida, a technology development hub and a part of the National capital region and similar power cuts in Gurgaon, the millenium city. What a joke !
Does India really in a mood to supply electricity to neighbor but what about its own states plights? India is projected to see a power shortage of 5.1 per cent compared to demand in the current financial year with southern and north-eastern regions anticipated to witness high deficits. http://indianexpress.com/article/business/business-others/india-likely-to-see-over-5-power-shortage-this-fiscal/
@Zamrood: I wonder how India will offer “Sasti Bijili” to Pakistan
The author talks about giving "bijli" to Pakistan. If you want "sasti bijli", go talk to Sajjan Jindal.
@Queen: it would not make a difference even if get electricity from anywhere , just like the way you got your nuclear toys from N Korea . Point is you would always have to depend on some one to lead you out of the never ending tunnel of darkness and self denial.
@Pity: (India was behind the fall of Dhaka. ) India was not behind the fall of Dacca, it was in the forefront. Open & for all to see. The photographs involving Pakistani & Indian generals (General A A K Niazi & General Jagjit Singh Aurora) at Dacca's Ramna Race Course Grounds on December 16, 1971 document that!
@Pity: Of course, India helped Bangladesh. Why else would Lt. Niazi representing the Pak Army surrender to Lt. Aurora of the Indian Army? The question you need to ask is what caused the Bangladeshis to revolt in the first place. Read Wikipedia instead of your Pakistan Studies textbook to know the answer.
@Pity: Of course India helped Bangladesh achieve its independence. The difference though is in the narrative, you have been taught that poor Pakistan was a victim of Indian aggression, while the rest of the world believes that Bengalis were the victims of the state turning against it's own citizens, and India intervened to liberate them.
@Rahul: Well, even if ate grass, we became the nuclear power, didn't we? Never underestimate the Pakistani nation. When we become united, we can create nightmares for our neighbors.
On the other hand, why don't you tell this to mr Jindal who is so keen to do business with Pakistan that he hosted our Prime Minister for tea. Mr Jindal is a businessman and he wants to avail a good business opportunity in his neighboring country. Pakistan is already working in cooperation with China and Turkey in the energy sector and believe me it will not create any difference if we do not get electricity from your country. Have a nice day!
I wonder how India will offer "Sasti Bijili" to Pakistan when only New Delhi face above 3000MW of electric shortfall. India has more energy crisis than Pakistan and still unable to provide uninterrupted power flow to its Industries.
@lol If government will start free laptop types Lollipop schemes (just for votebank bribes) How on earth it will have money to buy Power from Central Grid system? For your answer Agra City (Area under the Torrent Power, Private Sector distribution Company) have 23-24 hour power supply, My parents live there & They don't have Battery for Inverter since 2011. Hence it is matter of Money not the shortage or Distribution fault. Choose state government wisely next time.
@Tausif: As a Pakistani, I am thankful to Allah that after years and years of denying, finally a Bangladeshi has accepted that India was behind the fall of Dhaka.
It always good to hear from anyone of world's largest democracy with a convicted/exonerated PM talking about traditionalities of a regular nation (Raj).
Being a Bangladeshi, I feel both proud and relieved that the founders of my country had chosen the right path of independence from Pakistan.Thanks to India for helping us in achieving independence!
@Author: " ... So what is Pakistan going to do now? ... "
PM Modi will be following a Pani-Bijli-Mandi diplomacy with West Punjab. He knows that the Sharif brothers are not good at bargaining - they give away way too much for too little in return.
@lol: if only that bijli could be given to UTTAR PRADESH
The problem with UP is that it has no money, otherwise it can buy power off the national grid.
Distribution losses in UP are a whopping 32% with certain cities like Noida, Agra, etc. accounting for distribution losses in excess of 63%!
Jyoti, thanks for joining the bandwagon to praise Modi now. Lot's of journalists like you who used and campaigned thru media to blame Modi for 2002 riots suddenly turned around. I would sure like to have good relationship between India and Pakistan. Without the Italian Maid at the helm, the corruption will reduce in India and peace and progress for both India and Pakistan will result into prosperity.
Pakistan is a country that has reached a point where it trusts absolutely no one, let alone India. Not even its perceived traditional allies and definitely not its political or religious leaders. Every border is tense and every internal societal fissure is under strain - be it political, geopolitical, religious, class or sectarian.
India should leave this troubled teen alone to untangle itself.
It is a known fact that Nawazullah and his brother Shahbazullah are interested in the welfare of Punjab only. It is not a secret. So funneling electricity straight to Punjab from India surprises no one. Even the 'Dehati Aurats' know this.
That big question looms large, in the face of the general Pakistani read-out that Modi lectured Nawaz in Delhi. So what is Pakistan going to do now? General feeling in Pakistan is,'we are better than India' buying electricity from India means hurting that ego.So I see no chance of electricity coming from India.Also no chance for Indian investors investing in Pakistan for the same reason.Aloo piyaz tomato or light items- no harm.
Scenarios change. Heads of states will do pandering. Kicked forward by the business end of their countries. After all selling anything and everything to 1.7 billion teeming Indians means money. Of course they may hold their noses, but diplomatic protocol requires you fawn feign and shake hands...One thing will not change,..exonerated by the Supreme Court But convicted and condemned by the civilized World.
Pakistan ate grass and got their bomb, let them eat grass and get their power plants too!
I think your quite right regarding India - China - USA etc both on the India - Pakistan front it read like something out of Harry Potter.
18 hour power cut in punjab?? and that is the most developed province in pakistan?? what a joke.... :)
if only that bijli could be given to UTTAR PRADESH.....more districts could have 24 hour supply and not just mainpuri,azamgarh,pratapgarh,rampur ,etawah,kannauj ,varanasi and a few others .... even the capital lucknow and developed industrial regions of noida and ghaziabad are facing like 8-10 hours...... a frustrated UP walaa ... :/
Pakistan is an ideological entity. It is a concept which the original ideologues had vague fantasie and the subsequent generations don't know what it is either. Hence Pakistan is not a regular nation state in the traditional sense. That's why they are not interested in trade, economic growth, people's welfare, etc.
About Modi and the US. Modiji is large hearted enough to put the priorities of the country ahead of personal feelings about US. Economic development and poverty alleviation should be our only goals. No use in joining any geo strategic games or alliances. Japan and China are richer than us, they can fight. We should look how we can work with US, China and Japan to rapidly grow economy.
If Pakistan is a traditional nation state, we could work with them also. But they are not.