Those that were not tourists often worked for NGOs; there was a scattering of missionary priests, some nuns working in the education sector and any number of consultants working for multinationals. And they are, for the most part, gone. There are still a few nuns from abroad — two live in my home city of Bahawalpur but they don’t go out and about much. I have not heard from the missionary family from Wales for years. They worked with the desperately poor Hindus in south Punjab and my assumption is that they have now gone as well. There are a few expatriates living long term in Islamabad and I occasionally bump into them, but they keep a low profile. Any consultants that there might be still kicking about do so very discreetly.
Now, the expat community has suffered another loss — Zahrah Nasir, an old friend, has left. She had been here for 27 years, was married and widowed here, and earned her living like me as a writer in the English-language press. She lived in a gloriously eccentric house perched on the side of the mountain below the Pearl Continental hotel in Bhurban. She was usually cut off by snow for at least two months of the year and after the death of her husband, devoted herself to her garden — which formed the basis of many of her columns over the years.
Things went pear-shaped for Zahrah after she ran afoul of some people you do not want to run afoul of in Afghanistan; there were credible death threats and it became clear that she was being hunted here in Pakistan. She lived incognito for months, only surfacing to deal with the practicalities of selling her house and arrived back in UK last week, safe and sound, from where she holds court on her Facebook page. No doubt she will chronicle the episode in detail herself and it is not my purpose to do so here.
Why bother to write about a Brit journo who writes gardening columns? Because her exit is symbolic of what Pakistan has become. Hers may be an extreme case, possibly unique even, but this is a place increasingly unsafe for foreigners.
Even though I have lived here for over 20 years and consider this my home, it is a house with hidden dark corners, a house with doors through which I never go, a house riddled with traps and pitfalls. It is a house that is getting smaller as well. There are no more trips to see friends and colleagues in Peshawar as the risk of getting kidnapped or killed — or both — has become unacceptably high.
Karachi is the same, where I once strolled around Saddar and went to the slightly seedy cinemas in the evening — the streets are no longer safe. Balochistan — fergeddit.
Northern Areas (I still have trouble getting my head around ‘Gilgit-Baltistan’) will feel my boots again later this summer, but even there, blood stains the campsites of foreign expeditions and most of the hotels that flourished in the 1980s and early ’90s are now echoingly empty, scratching a living.
Gradually this land is emptying itself of ‘the other’ — that which is different in some way, that which represents another perspective, a viewpoint that is at variance with the majority. Voices that are raised against injustice soften, drop to a whisper and then are silent — only to be heard again but from a place beyond these borders.
The greying of Pakistan is a slow process, the growth of a monoculture carefully nurtured by powerfully malign hands taking years to envelope all.
Thus, it is that I bid a fond adieu to Zahrah Nasir — eccentric to a fault, kind and generous, uber-gardener, savant and peacenik. She also writes rather well, too. Pakistan will miss you, a bright dot in a louring landscape. Right — next job... get the security cameras serviced.
Published in The Express Tribune, May 22nd, 2014.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (9)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Anis Rahman: Thnak you for your kind words Anis but please note: I did not leave of my own accord. I was forced to leave my home in order to survive & continue my work from elsewhere - for the time being. Pakistan is my home. I am proud of my green passport & proud of being a Pakistani national. I will be back - when circumstances permit. Having to leave broke my heart but if I hadn't left I would be dead now. Better to live to 'fight' & speak/write for truth & peace than to die by a bullet from an assassins gun.
SAD.....but does our government or our so called religious lot or our judiciary or those who matter.......... give two hoots ? SAD.
Always enjoy your columns Sir and have greatly enjoyed Zahra Nasir's articles as well. Words are not enough to express my outrage and anger at the dark forces (army? government? fundamentals? common people) which compel such brave, amazing people to leave this blighted country. How I wish things could be different or we could go back to the amazing times our grandparents speak of.
Zahra Nasir, I am angry. Because you were the best of Pakistan. Best in intellect, in truth, honesty and the best writer on gardens. And you left us. My home in the hills, and many many more were there for you to stay, not as a guest, but to call home. Your home will miss you, and all Pakistanis. Adios
Thanks to our beloved General Zia ul Haq
Nina Cassian:
With rational syllables
I try to clear up the occult mind
and promiscuous violence.
My linguistic protest has no power
The enemy is illiterate.
I don't think so ..the enemy is very smart it has defeated one super power and sent the other one packing ...and now get ready for their full and undivided attention...
The problem with Pakistan is that such articles do not move our hearts; we just gloss over the words and go to the next piece. Editors of Tribune print some comments which show anger, but they are too few compared to those who carry on discussing the evils of west and how great our motherland is. I was in a party with some people who have been living in the west for the last 30 years and they were all of the opinion that women in Pakistan have more rights than here in Europe. As I say, there are few who listen to the falling rain, the choice for our daughters here to walk in the streets at night without fear. But the majority is hard like a rock. It reminds me of these verses from Nina Cassian: With rational syllables I try to clear up the occult mind and promiscuous violence. My linguistic protest has no power The enemy is illiterate.
Yes, indeed its sad. Pakistan is no longer safe for foreigners and locals as well. I doubt if anyone knows where this country is headed to. So many people who worked hard to see Pakistan thrive have left it after seeing the utter mess we have managed to make of running this country. Foreigners can always return to the country of their origin but we who wanted a better, progressive Pakistan have no escape.
The real culprits behind the Pakistani Tragedy are the various governments who have ruled here since 1947..if only the population had been educated none of this would have happened ...Maybe a communist revolution would set things right ..because these Politicians are never going to create a class which can Judge them.