For the last 13 years the elderly mother of Aashiq Ali Baloch, a Pakistani inmate languishing in an Indian jail, has been waiting to see her son return home.
Aashiq’s father, Khameso Khan Baloch, died a few years ago nurturing the same hope. And now his mother, Pathani Baloch, is also advancing down her declining years.
“My last wish is to see him back home and to arrange his marriage,” says Pathani pointing to the trunk in which she has collected clothes and jewelry for her would-be daughter-in-law.
As tears roll down her cheeks, she recalls the day her son left for India. “Most of the family members were opposed to his visit due to the prevailing tension between India and Pakistan then. But Aashiq was very keen on touring that country and he compelled us to give him permission,” she tells The Express Tribune.
Aashiq was 22 years old when he went to India in 2001 on a visit visa. He travelled through the Wagah border to reach Mumbai where he stayed with his relatives, whom the family does not want to identify in view of their safety in India.
In January 2002 he was detained while touring Hyderabad Deccan, Andhra Pradesh state, and was charged with espionage.
Initially he was kept in Darjeeling prison in West Bengal while the criminal case registered against him proceeded in a Deccan court, according to his elder brother Tariq Baloch, a journalist working for a regional newspaper. The family claims that they were not even given a copy of the verdict.
“We couldn’t even provide him a defence lawyer. His case lasted for over four years till he was awarded life imprisonment in 2006,” says Tariq, regretting their inability to defend Aashiq in the court.
After pronouncement of the verdict, he added, his brother was shifted to Cherlapalli prison in Hyderabad Deccan, where he continues to serve his term. Since his arrest, the family has lost all verbal communication with Aashiq. They only infrequently exchange letters, which are first screened by the Indian security authorities.
According to a list of prisoners given by the Indian government in January this year, some 396 Pakistanis, including 257 civilians and 139 fishermen, are incarcerated in Indian jails.
“He lost prime of his youth languishing in Indian jails, far from family and joys of life. But I want him to be free now,” says his elder brother Muhammad Haroon Baloch.
The family’s hope for Aashiq’s freedom and, subsequent repatriation, hinges on the provision in the law which commutes the life term to 14 or 20 years’ imprisonment.
However, a November 2012 judgment by the bench of Justice KS Radhakrishnan and Madan B Lokur interpreted the life sentence as an imprisonment for ‘entire life’. However, they left the power for remission to the government functionaries.
Haroon maintains that his brother has completed a cumulative period of 24 years and eight months, based on the day and night count of a day, in confinement since his arrest.
Published in The Express Tribune, May 19th, 2014.
COMMENTS (20)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@ raj @ rajan
Polio virus was found mainly in israel, israel friend of india, raw agency of india, india active in afghanistan, ttp links with raw, simple math. Now don't tell me why we ask you to do maths.
@rudra, @piyush: if he happened to be violating terms in his visa and was found in other parts of the country where he was not supposed to be and he did not commit any crime, a decent, civilized and honorable thing would be to arrest and deport him back, instead of putting him in jail for the rest of his life! What proof do you have hat he was a spy/terrorist?? amazing. I don't know what laws are in place in your country but this is a grave violation of human rights! if you know of any indians suffering the same, you should consider raising your voice and requesting Pak govt to consider your pleas instead of hate mongering here.
@kashif what about rapes in your country don't you read your news daily? Or you just read other country news?.
Shame on the new elected government and every government which has been in power since Pakistan's creation. You should learn some lesson from you neighbour India. They can cross any limit to protect their population inside and outside their country. Pakistani government as it is in my knowledge released over 100 fishermen did India the same thing? No they can't even dream of doing anything in favour of Pakistan another shameful act which our government is doing is being silence over this situation and every situation they show there incompetent.
@Kasif focus on your country gang rapes and polio that's in news daily why are you worried about india? How we handle our internal matters is our concern you handle yours. If you violate visa norms in USA will you ask USA to to look into local crimes since USA is currently number 1 at rape crimes happening in the world? Your theory is bizarre. It's shocking you turn blind eye and have no empathy to rapes happening daily in your country but have to point fingers at others. ET be fair and publish this.
Pakistan is kicking out two Indian spies who worked in Islamabad as journalists - Meena Menon of The Hindu newspaper and Snehesh Philip of the Press Trust of India on May 20. But both these spies-cum-journalists are begging for an expansion of their visa so that they can keep spying.
@ Piyush
Gang rapes in buses, Goa Beach unsafe for expatriate woman. What do you talk about countrymen, lets talk about countrywomen who face horror by being raped.
@HA there's a difference between live caught terrorist video taped confession and speculated assumptions without proofs or person caught.
@Usman what's hateful and ruthless in what he is saying? Isn't protecting country people from possible threats a prerogative specially after sponsored attacks that resulted deaths we have faced continuously yet they enjoy free reign there in your country? One bitten twice shy you know. Forgive us for being so skeptical after being burnt several times by making same mistake of "having a heart". By the way what about those indian mothers awaiting their sons from Pakistan? No sympathies for them? It works both side you know.
@a " their only crime is being pakistani" stop doing attacks like Mumbai and we will think about changing our policy. Till then jail all who land in different city on pretext of visa for other city altogether. No shady-fishy business will be tolerated here keep those to your country geographical limits.
@a Tell us that when you stop doing Mumbai,kargil,parliament type events. Till that any person violating his visa for one city found in another city totally different part of india when he has no purpose being there deserves jail. If we want to protect Hyderabad from another Mumbai like event. Sorry, national security and safety of our countrymen matters first and foremost to us not infiltrators(coz he violated visa norms accidentally or on purpose) "Commit atrocities against defenceless visitors and poor fishermen" well show this concern and charity to jailed indian people in Pakistani jails release all to india first then lecture us.
What was the purpose of Mr Baloch's visit to India has not been explained nor who financed the trip. Was he overstaying in India when he was apprehended and why ? For which location in India was his visa valid and did he violate the geographical restriction ? Did the Pakistani Embassy hire any lawyer to represent him, if not why not ? When any accused does not have a lawyer to represent him in a case or cannot afford one he must approach the Legal Aid Cell, who in turn will provide a Defense lawyer -- this is available to any litigant, Indian or Foreign.
@Rahul
Have some heart for God sake Rahul. What if he was an innocent 22 years old son who was full of life wanting to explore the country that inherits the same culture as Pakistan.
Why so ruthless buddy? You make such speculation over few incidents; we ourselves condemn such acts; have a look at Pakistan too - we are not even fighting out own war and yet losing so many civilians on daily basis. I don't expect you understand this situation but that doesn't mean you should bring your level of hatred to such an extent that you become blindfolded.
Anyhow coming back to the point - she is a mother and there are lots of what ifs that revolve around the story.
And frankly speaking (gesture), I think the only time we wouldn't support India would be in cricket - apart from that we treat you all the same. The sooner we all realize this the better it is!
Cheers
Shame on you India for keeping all hose poor people behind bars for only crime that they happen to be Pakistanis. Let them go!!. If there are any innocent Indians being kept in Pakistani Jails they should freed as well. Don,t let your hatred for each other make you commit atrocities against defenseless visitors and poor fishermen
E.T please publish
Amazingly, no comments at all???
His place is in jail. When is visa was only for western part of india that is mumbai. What was he doing in Hyderabad city 3states away at eastern part of india? Did he think this is his country where everything's works and he can get away with it? Or was he a spy on purpose? After those ten people they sent mumbai for mumbai 11 event. No need to show any leniency on people who take visa for one city than land up in other city in totally different part of india to do god knows what. And btw what happened to all those indian prisoners that are languished in Pakistan jails? No tears for that? As expected.