The BJP rears its ugly head

India’s moniker of ‘the world’s largest democracy’ will mean little if its Hindu majority targets its Muslim...


Editorial April 22, 2014
If Modi wants to allay the fears of minorities, especially Muslims, he would have to do better than just terming statements by BJP leaders as "irresponsible". PHOTO: AFP/FILE

A couple of statements by right-wing Hindu leaders maybe a harbinger for what a Narendra Modi-led government may look like. First, Giriraj Singh, a BJP candidate from Bihar, stated at a campaign rally that those opposed to Modi… have a place in Pakistan, not India, darkly alluding to Muslim voters. Despite the controversy his statements have stirred, Singh has refused to apologise or even soften his words. Then, Pravin Togadia, president of the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, the BJP’s sister organisation, was caught on camera addressing a rally about how to prevent Muslims from buying property in Hindu areas. It didn’t help that he made these statements at a rally calling for the eviction of a Muslim man outside his house in Modi’s home state of Gujarat.

In both cases, the BJP’s response has been half-hearted at best. A tweet from a senior BJP leader called Singh’s statements ‘irresponsible’; Modi used the same adjective for Togadia in a separate tweet without referring to him directly. If Modi wants to allay the fears of minorities, especially Muslims, he would have to do better than that. And therein, perhaps, lies the problem: Modi has made absolutely no effort to distance himself from his communal past. He has compared the thousand Muslims killed in the 2002 Gujarat riots to a puppy being run over by car; he has refused to apologise for the carnage that took place under his watch as chief minister.

Since its independence, India has prided itself on the secular character of its people and constitution, despite numerous nationalist movements, communal riots and ethnic tensions. But now, with candidates and right-wing Hindu leaders talking of forcible evictions and no room for dissidence, this secular character is increasingly giving way to fascism. India’s moniker of ‘the world’s largest democracy’ will mean little if its Hindu majority targets its Muslim minority, which, worryingly, looks likely to take place under state sanction. Never have India’s secular credentials come under so much threat as they are now.

Published in The Express Tribune, April 23rd, 2014.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

COMMENTS (10)

3rdRockFromTheSun | 10 years ago | Reply This is not the first time the BJP has been in power. Remember Mr. Vajpayee? Guess what happened to Muslims in India when BJP was previously in power - NOTHING! They are as integral a part of India as any other community! Guess what will happen to the Muslims if Modi comes to power - NOTHING! They will continue to be as integral a part of India as any other community! Remember who came all the way to Lahore to make peace with Pakistan! And remember, even when this was happening, your soldiers were in Kargil, and had to be forcibly evicted. And also remember what happened to Mr Vajpayee at the next elections - he was voted OUT by the Hindu majority Indian voters who were dissappointed at the economic progress under his govt even though he was successful in winning Kargil! So 'religion' has nothing to do with getting 'elected' in India. If that were the case, the Hindu majority Indians would have had an 'Hindu' govt since independence. And guess what will happen to Modi if he fails to provide the economic benefits he claims he can - he will be voted OUT by the same Hindu majority populace at the next elections! So stop whippping up a storm when there exists none!
Raj - USA | 10 years ago | Reply

Indias hindu majority have never and shall not in the future also target any of its minority, be it muslims or anyone else. However, the majority shall not also sit by idle and let it be targeted by all others as in the past. Everyone, minority or majority, shall have equal and equitable rights and obligations. No right without corresponding obligation.

VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ