Pakistan — abandoned at birth

Pakistan doesn’t need rambling rhetoric or egoistic debate. What it needs is unconditional love.


Nabila Cowasjee October 20, 2010
Pakistan — abandoned at birth

One has been blessed with a fortunate life in a myriad of magical ways. But the greatest fortune is the experience of a childhood in Pakistan. The connection I have with this troubled land is an umbilicus that refuses to be severed and, despite what the media force-feeds me, nurtures me unlike any other encounter I have had. I seldom set foot on the land yet these invisible roots are the true song lines by which I live my current privileged life.

Many experience this passion for Pakistan, yet we feel we are being submerged in an alternate perception; the face of Pakistan that gets all the attention, the ugly apparent truth of a country ravaged, savaged and damaged by corruption, poverty, religious fundamentalism and hopelessness.

But there’s this thundering velvet voice, persistent and persuasive, that demands we listen to its innocent message. It insists that we turn our attention away from all the hatred that the world and the country’s own citizens focus on. It whispers frantically in our ear that this country doesn’t need hard-nosed politicians, clever economists or professors with infinite letters attached to their names. It doesn’t need rambling rhetoric or egoistic debate and it certainly doesn’t need punishing. What it needs is unconditional love.

They say that unlike normal birth where a child is organically pushed through the birth canal, a child of Caesarean beginnings is pulled into the cold air of an unfamiliar world without preparation or transition time. They need extra nurturing, close contact and patience in order to develop fully.

The birth of Pakistan is similar — a literal line drawn in the sand in August 1947, the surgeons cut. The terrifying exodus of a persecuted people from one world to another tainted with blood and guts, the unprotected transition, a massive shock. This country, this child, was born to immature teen parents, unprepared politicians, who were given the task of taking care of something new and fragile. These floundering leaders had little cultural confidence or pertinent history to reference, nor did they wish to turn to their subcontinental ‘grandmother’ for help because this was the source of the original wound.

The solitary hook the keepers of this precious newborn land had to hang its hat on was a religion and culture underpinned by honour and shame, but to raise a child with guilt and fear creates a dysfunctional adult.

Pakistan is an abandoned child with scant memory of a mother who held her with unconditional love, or a father who cared enough to protect her; a neglected child left alone whilst her ‘family’ went out to ‘work’, ‘pray’ and ‘party’, satisfying their own egos, forcing her to fend for herself too soon. The abused now abuses, unable to define right from wrong, functioning from a hollowed out abandoned space in her heart, the floods her long repressed tears of sadness and muted suffering.

Hate or political policy based in intellect won’t heal her. Religious fervour won’t save her soul. For the ever increasing circle of cynics such idealism might be too simplistic, trite or brown basmati rice and navel gazing, but the people of Pakistan are her mirror on the wall.

Each of us can change Pakistan’s reality. Focusing on her largely ignored prolific positive traits, and by loving all of her including her flaws, will release her pain and allow her to blossom into the potentially beautiful country we know she is.

Published in The Express Tribune, October 21st, 2010.

COMMENTS (32)

zarrar | 13 years ago | Reply not to hurt anyone feelings but in the view of pakistani people......before the partition ....during the political era of indian polititians when congress won the election of 1937...every muslim knows what they did to us... 1."bande Mataram" was an anti islamic song and it was made national anthem to be sung not only in public but in schools too...where innocent muslim children were getting education....now those who say that muslims are safe in india should answer why our identity was tried to be buried like this .....(jo ub such k dawaydar bntay hain...us wkht un kee gairat kahan thee jb un k ancestors hmain dbana chahtay thay) 2."cow protection committee" was formed and on national level slogans like "the cow mother"were raised....now muslims eat the meat of cow......but were being compelled not too.....now those who say that muslim community is independent and their rights were and now ,being respected.......should answer why they were enforced not to eat cow,s meat as its just an animal...punch it and it will run away(how they can be called G0d or mother).... human are superior to them ........also it proves that muslim and hindus are two seperate nations which can not co-exist as their believes are opposite to each other.. 3.wardha scheme 4.vidya mandir scheme 5.mass contact movement 6.communal riots.... 7.extermination of urdu etc etc etc every step taken by hindus was against the muslims.......which made us to live in a seperate homeland.....where we can live our own lives not by the rules of hindus...... now..lets come to today,s indian attitude towards pakistan....let me explain one thing cut and clear... “If Shabana Azmi and Javed Akhtar cannot buy a house in Bombay then what about ordinary Indian Muslims”. @vikas ranjan....... though they don,t live on footpath...but whatever they have earned till now....u already know how much struggle did they put to overcome the problems made by hindus...... even when shahrukh said something for the side of muslims...your famous party"shioraina or somethng" threatened him every time...... everytime you called pakistan a terrorist nation while hiding your own deeds in kashmir (80000+ people have been killed by your army and more than 10000+ women have beeen raped by ur army and u call us a terrorist....how lame.....and pathetic...????).....now i dont call all of hindus pathetic even my grandfather who is 95 years old used to tell us the storied of some good indian hindus about helping him migrating towars pakistan when most of the hindus were killing to get money,houses etc etc.....if u call it a lie .....than let me tell u...my own grandmother was killed by a hindu in front of my grand father.s eyes just because she had a bucket full of gold jewellery..........???
Saad | 13 years ago | Reply The one who sounds insane in the sanity of religious fanaticism, I've always advocated for a secular Pakistan, and will do so, have always advocated for friendly ties with all neighbors including India. But Indian folks, let me say that the way you guys are commenting here, is pathetic and even worse then that of the Pakistanis. How can i go and talk to a Pakistani and tell him/her to spit the anger about India, out ??? when the Indians prove what the Pakistani says about them. . Friendship is always on equal footings. If I was there in 1947, I would have been the strongest opposer of Pakistan's creation, but today’s Pakistan (with all her problems) I will not give up at any cost. Pakistan is having problems including terrorism, poverty, religious extremism etc, but don't tell me India is a heaven on earth or that she is even better then Pakistan. Check the PCI for both the countries on world bank website and don't just give links here. Pakistani is 3 times more then India. In as much as I like India, she has terrible problems to confront, the insurgencies not just in Kashmir but in Assam, Thamil nadu and Thri-pura. the terrible poverty, and aggressive and arrogant behavior to neighbors China and Pakistan, apart, what about Bangladesh and Sri-lanka? . If one think that India is bigger and Pakistan will beg for peace and friendship, I believe they are as much fools as the intelligence and religious fanatics of Pakistan who believe they can colonize Afghanistan. What matters are the resources, the economy, the human development - yes I know, as I mentioned that Pakistan has problems in all these, but the problems started in the last 3 years and will be over in the next 3 years as Pakistani have the will and the younger generation know the way ahead - a secular and economically strong Pakistan, but what about India. Yes India has a GDP growth rate of about 6 - 8 % in the last 15 - 20 years, but Pakistan enjoyed that for the last 55 years. Economy has grown a lot then, and India has yet to catch-up with that. . Again, I don't mean to hurt anyone, including Indians, but just to be realistic and not become so arrogant and foolish that China goes around and encircle all my country, building sea ports from Mombasa, Yemen, Gawadar, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Myanmar and I remain stuck with how to put down Pakistan on media. . In as much as I hate some things associated with Pakistan and like others associated with India, I find Pakistanis (specially the younger generation) being more practical, and not hate mongers. With all the problems they have, they have a will and vision to get out of them and develop their country. Pakistan is small but not too small and big but not too big, means it’s an easily manageable country. It can get up with the GDP growth rate of 8% in just a matter of time, when they are done with the elimination of Talibs and I can assure anyone, they are gonna do that in 1 – 3 years time. . So better we keep in mind that “respect is always reciprocal” and the relationships between Pakistan and India have to be on equal footing, no big no small, no upper no lower. If not then we can be satisfied with being hijacked by JI in Pakistan and by the fanatics in India. DO we want that??? I don’t think so.
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ