Polio can be avoided if the government had some sort of direction. As in the case with other issues where terrorism is concerned, we have pushed ourselves into a corner, waiting for the other side to make most of the situation. No one comes out and protests polio related deaths.
In 2013, even before the start of December, we have had 68 confirmed cases of polio, one of the highest in the world. Two cases remain to be confirmed. This exceeds last year’s reported number of 58. Most of these cases are reported from FATA, followed by Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, Punjab and Sindh. FATA has so far reported 48 cases. Only some years back, we were winning the war against polio. Now we have started to lose once again.
This is just one side of the tragedy. The other is the story of the brave people who have tried to fight polio. Since July 2012, about thirty people associated with the anti-polio drive have been killed in Pakistan. Many more have been injured.
This week saw the death of Zakir Khan, a policeman who had joined the force only a year back, and was shot dead in Peshawar ostensibly for being part of a polio team escort duty. His colleague was seriously injured.
Once again a message has been given to not only workers who administer the polio drops but also to those who protect these workers. Despite the attacks, almost all in broad daylight, not one person has been arrested so far, which in turn has further emboldened those who commit such crimes.
The heroes of the anti-polio campaign remain unsung. These young men and women put their lives in danger by going out in the streets to deliver anti-polio drops to children from different backgrounds and localities. The danger to their lives is not restricted to FATA or KP where most of the attacks have taken place. Workers in Karachi have also been targeted. These workers are paid very little and the security they are offered is itself under threat as we saw again this week.
The polio campaign now seems to have been hijacked by international politics. There is anger in different parts of Pakistan because foreign aid agencies were used for hunting down the family of Osama Bin Ladin. What is interesting is that campaign did not involve polio workers given that DNA cannot be collected by drops administered orally. But the polio campaign has suffered the most as a consequence.
Taliban commanders last year announced a ban on polio vaccines as long as the drone strikes remain. This is an interesting position. While many others have termed polio vaccines anti-Muslim, by linking the same to the drone strikes, what we can understand is that the Taliban have said that while they are not opposed to the anti-polio campaign in principle, they are using it as leverage against the US administration in a bid to end drone strikes. Only time will tell whether we understood right.
Then there is the politics of the NGOs. If press reports and government leaks are to be believed, some well known and prestigious NGOs helped doctors like Shakil Afridi in his vaccination campaign to hunt the Bin Ladin family. As Pakistanis we are angry at being duped. More important now we see all foreign NGOs in the same light and are suspicious of their work here. Already the PML-N government is now looking at ways to monitor donor funding and put restrictions on this. This may prove counter-productive however. And polio is our problem. Not that of any NGO. When will we own up to it?
Now we are told that polio has travelled from Pakistan to as far as Syria via Egypt and Israel. Half a million children are not vaccinated in Syria and are at risk. Pakistanis travelling abroad will be subject to restrictions on account of polio. We continue to be our own worst enemies.
Published in The Express Tribune, December 2nd, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (25)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Malik Tariq:
Well said! Each Government should clean up the rubbish lying in front of their house. Let Bill Gates worry about the 20 odd million Americans who live on charities from the rich and have not the access to health care, let alone polio vaccine. Only a man from the medical profession knows about the consequences of having no medical tretment for the illness which humans suffer from. Let Obama care for his "obama care program" for 20 million Americans in the land of plenty which the rich are resisting and its implementation is facing hiccups and let the numbers man care for stopping the sterilisation of women and the bonded slavery in India. The Pashtun tribal leaders will not accept any foreign sponsored program unless an end is put to the drone program! This is my prognosis and the opinion about the people who have never accepted foreign occupation.
Rex Minor
Polio vaccination and health is the primary mandatory duty of both Federal and Provincial governments and should not have been outsourced to NGOs. It was and continues to be failure of the State to set their priorities right, and to work in accordance with their constitutional duties, that Pakistan today has been declared a Polio Hazard country. The PM himself should have headed such a Task Force. It is unfortunate that Bill Gates has the time and finances to spare to fight this War Against Polio, but not our own Government and our own Billionaires, who continue to get tax evasion benefits and concessions, but lack moral ethics to discharge their obligations to the country, which has offered them vast opportunities to prosper and thrive. Congrats Kamal S for highlighting this issue.
Would all please note that the slaughtering, maiming and orphaning of Pakistani children by the TTP (Resistance??) goes unnoticed by @Rex Minor in this postings!
@Raja Islam:
You are a Gentleman Sir. From neo-cons to neo-liberals none is trustworthy any more. The good old tradition of "do not trust a foreigner" is the best advice! The United Nations Organisation is the worst and the NGO's must be controlled by local Governments without any exception. Why oral and not a jab for Pakistani children? O'h, I do very much care for children.
Rex Minor
@np: For the Pshtuns, the non pashto speaking individual is a foreigner, and within the tribes the non Pashto dilect speaking individual is a foreigner as well. This gives the people a fool proof security system! This is no different in the UK or Germany where foreigners are recognisable from their dialects as well.
Rex Minor
@np & Raja Islam, Don't bother about Rex Minor as he is an European who is happy to see Pashtun children incapacitated by polio, if not killed by drones.
We'll done - Save The Children, CIA and Shakeel Afridi ... You three are what Mr. Siddiqui meant.
@np: You have not the scholarly knowledge of the Geography.. It matters not what names and labels and titles are bestowed upon the sixty million odd Afghan Pashtuns living in the triangular shaped territory who speak Pashto languages, are friendly to guests but allergic to foreign force. Those who do not condemn the droning of children in Afghan /Pakistan tribal land have not the right to decide for the good of children population. . Only the parents have this right!! Your narrative is simply a diversion.
Rex Minor
@Rex Minor: The gut feelings that you are referring to comes from illiteracy and fundamentalism. Any educated person would not connect a public benefit like polio vaccination to foreign imperialism.
As long as Pakistanis continue to believe in fairy tales and support the likes of the illiterate Taleban, you will continue to see problems with things like polio eradication campaigns.
Mr Siddiqi has adequately laid out the concerns of people in Pakistan with polio and the drones as well as the so called NGO's who are running around in the country like headless chickens and at times with police escort.. While the drones are operating at the orders of the USA supremo and can be instantly stopped by the Pakistan military, there is no cure against the polio infection but is preventable by multiple vaccination. Polio infection is caused by a virus that is mainly spread by person to person contact, eating or drinking and as long as a single child remains infected, the world at large is not safe from this virus. The scare mongering will not help nor the PR promotion of Bill Gates, unless the Government of Pakistan get rid of the foreign elements in the country whether they are the NGO's or the intelligence communties of its strategic allies. The reaction of the Pashtun tribesmen is very natural because of the gut feelings these people have against what is foreign: . Notwithstanding the number of reported cases of infection in Pakistan, as provided by Mr Siddiqi, there were only 223 reported cases worldwide.
Rex Minor
ETBLOGS1987
ET Mod - please allow response to someone who has written to me.
@Rex Minor: "The Talibans are a ‘Resistance’ against the alien invasion of their homeland."
This description maybe used arguably for the Afgan Taliban. But it is difficult to use this description for TTP. Pakistan certainly has not been occupied. It is TTP that is preventing immunisation.
Also you seemed to be justifying the violent prevention of immunisation of kids by making the rather callous comment that it would not matter since they would be droned anyway. Your attitude is shameful.
you find a geographic area with poilo resurgence,you will find TTP/Al-qaida terrorists .
@Stranger: You have used this 'joke' for the millionth time. Please stop. All regular/irregular readers must have seen this comment now. Haha. very witty. Now please get a life.
The DRONE- The new national bird of Pakistan.
@Rex Minor: There have been no drones in Karachi, Peshawar or Islamabad. But not just polio workers but those that protect polio workers are getting killed in these localities. How do you justify that?
@Rex Minor: You mean instead of being slaughtered (ON PURPOSE) in a Terrorist Attack by your beloved TTP "RESISTANCE"!!!
@Habib ur Rahman: @unbelievable:
Is it that important to vaccinate the child before being droned?
Rex Minor
Please make it mandatory for anti polio vaccination dates news in frontier province for all Urdu, pashtu newspapers and the information about the disease in pictures. Semi literate people think about polio vaccination as a fad. It happened in india but now it's over and polio is eradicated here. Rab rakha
Nicely spelt out......now all that is needed is for someone in Prime Ministers office to read this.
Polio is a killing and crippling disease. Thanks to development of an effective vaccine, the disease was successfully controlled in all countries. However, there is a resurgence of disease in three countries. They include two Muslim countries i.e. Pakistan and Afghanistan whereas the third country is Nigeria where about half of the population is Muslim. The reason for resurgence is defective and incomplete vaccination which was caused by incompetence and corruption of the government functionaries and the rumour-mongering and whispering campaigns launched by illiterate Mullahs and obscurantists. Recently, reports from Afghanistan suggest that incidence of polio is on the decline and there was no recorded case of polio this year. In Pakistan, on the other hand, there is an increase in the number of recorded cases, particularly in tribal areas, and parts of KPK, Punjab and Sindh, as the author has suggested. According to some newspaper reports, cases of polio have been detected in Syria where the disease was previously under control. Resurgence of polio in Syria is also being linked with the Pakistani terrorists who are fighting in Syria. Alas, we have earned the distinction of becoming a source of polio resurgence in other countries. Moreover, we have also earned the distinction of being the only country where polio workers are killed with impunity and the government is helpless.
Public health is not part of the madrassa curriculum. Sanitation is not taught in school. Author is dishonest with his readers as drones and polio are not related issues. They are mutually exclusive.
You don't have a strategy to deal with polio because your don't control the territories where polio inoculations are prohibited/resisted - ain't all that complicated.