I have been there a few times. My friends always ask me why I visit so often. Why not Malaysia or Thailand, they question. It is not easy to enunciate my reasons; one only has to look around at the people around me to understand why. It’s the sense of belonging and the commonalities that bind me to the town of my forefathers in Uttar Pradesh. It’s the call of my ancestors’ dilapidated havelis, to rediscover my roots and much more.
December 7, 2012, 8am: The bus is crossing the Wagah border. It’s difficult to believe that these two gates and the few metres of land between them causes so much grief to millions of people on both sides.
Yet, the border with its menacing walls and capricious gates is there. What Partition was meant to be or what could have been had it not happened is a futile debate. Oceans of ink could be bled on the subject but the fact is that there is no way of undoing what was done.
For eight centuries, the Muslims lived here absorbing culture and adding their own blend to the tapestry called Hindustan — Hindustan, named by the Arab traders, meaning land of beauty.
The political issues faced by the two countries are difficult but not insurmountable. Countries are made, nations get broken, and wars are fought but as history has shown, the commonality of interests and the desire for peace wins out.
December 7, 2012, 8pm: I am 40 kilometres from Delhi and the roads now look familiar. The excitement of the travellers is detectable and they are peering out of the windows. A middle-aged gentleman in front of me is going after 27 years and even though he is grinning, I can make out that his cheeks are wet. He tells me of rejected visas and numerous visits to the Indian consulate.
Pakistanis travel to Hyderabad and Bangalore for medical reasons and come back with glowing tales of hospitality. When the Indian cricket team visited Pakistan in 2004, restaurant owners refused to charge them. In Pakistan, saying you are a visiting Indian means discounts at shops and stories of common backgrounds.
January 2, 2013, 8am: I am almost at Pipri, two hours from Delhi back to Lahore. The crying of the young man next to me has subsided. He talks about his relatives who had come to say goodbye and how one of them gave him his shawl, his only protection against the frigid weather, just because he had commented on its workmanship. He tells me about how a visa rejection made him so desperate that he actually contemplated crossing the border illegally.
When will Pakistan and India relations normalise? When will I simply walk across Wagah and travel across the length and breadth of India?
I don’t know but I have hope that eventually, the common bonds of love, culture and mutual interests will win out and the dark stories of rejected visas and border disputes will be washed away by the sunny smiles and tears of joy of loved ones.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 16th, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (34)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Excellent work. Very well written
@gujranwala789: (The rest of the country do not have such emtions about india.) Etc
Your eager disclaimers & prudent protestations remind me of Shakeel Badayuni's words set to music by Naushad & sung by Rafi-Lata for Dilip-Vyjyantimala.
tere husn ki kya taarif karun kuchh kahate hue bhi darataa hun kahin bhool se tu na samajh baithe ki main tujhase mohabbat kartaa hun
mere dil me kasak si hoti hai teri raah se jab main guzarati hun is baat se yeh na samajh lenaa ki mai tujhase mohabbat karti hun
@Author Your good-self and your tribe are always welcome to India/Hindustan/Bharat. Pakistan too means land of the pure but the same has unfortunately been polluted by the hard-line Islam-lists and destructive policies of your military.
@author :- u r the best. CAs u r from UTTAR PRADESH hope u must belong to ALLAHABAD.ALLLHABADIs ROCKS :)
I really appreciate ur writing.
@Author
You are a blessed soul. Hope your wishes come true.
@Humaira
You rock. God bless you.
What ever emotions about india the autor has described in the article are restricted only to those people in pakistan who have migrated from bhayya lands of india. The rest of the country do not have such emtions about india.
"-----eventually, the common bonds of love, culture and mutual interests will win out and the dark stories of rejected visas and border disputes will be washed away by the sunny smiles and tears of joy of loved ones"
Yes it can happen . __- but there are hardline jingoists on both sides.
Do not forget that many Indian Muslims have realtives in Pakistan too.
Ca we not follow the US-Canada model or the Indo-Nepal practice.
The hearts are willing ; real politics and beauracracy are a bad combination.
If only Pak army reads this and puts a stop to all its nonstate actors .. sigh.....
I, as an Indian, am not against loosening the visa regime and restrictions for Pakistanis wanting to visit India. Not just me, but most Indians don't have any problem with that or even with "Pakistanis" in general. However, ironic as it may seem, most don't want to have any sort of engagement with the Pakistan state. This is because every Indian feels allowing Pakistanis to enter India "freely" or getting too friendly with Pakistan might result in spread of extremist ideology and disturb the internal peace of India. Just like the current ongoing "talks of peace talks" between the two countries. Pakistan's government says it wants peace, but it does not want to own up the responsibility for any cross border infiltration of militants who kill Indian soldiers and then run back into Pakistan. There is 99.9% communal harmony in India today and it has taken years to achieve that. Indians don't "usually" hate Pakistanis, but they don't want large influx of Pakistanis into India any time soon, either for tourism or anything else. And this is because Pakistan itself has lost control over its nation - India wants peace, but it does not want to become another Pakistan. India can't afford few religious fanatics creating tensions between its many communities.
Some welcome fresh air
@Humaira: thank you nicely put
"For eight centuries, the Muslims lived here absorbing culture and adding their own blend to the tapestry called Hindustan" The same is true for Pakistan also where for thousand of years people belonging to Hinduism lived and developed their culture and religion.In fact major parts of Vedas, Upanishads and even our sacred language Sanskrit itself, developed in the region which is now called Pakistan.... My neighbor who was forced to migrate from North west frontier province will reflect the same feeling as shared by you. In fact when he talks about his country he means the land of khyber pakhtunkhwa. Though he has been living in India since 1947 but his heart lies there in Khyber and he is waiting for the day when he can return back to see his land again.... I really loved the way you described my city,i.e. Delhi. Its really a wonderful place....
cute
@Ali Tanoli: It may be true for Punjab but not Delhi which had sizable Muslim population. Even today the walled city and other pockets in New Delhi like Jamia, Okhla, Trans Yamuna, Inderlok, Govindpuri, etc have large Muslim population. Today Muslims in Delhi have a population of 15%.
@Ali Tanoli: " ... Same happened to Muslims in eastern Punjab and around Dehli where 85% to 90% muslims ... "
Do you ever think of anything other than Islam or Muslims ?
@Humaira Appreciate your effort. You are doing exactly what linguists are meant to be. Building bridges :)
When will india and pakistan will have cordial relations ? and when will they live peacefully like civilized neighbors? It is all very much possible only if Pakistani army works firmly under pakistani civilian governments control, Secondly pakistan should promote secularism.These two things done,Problem solved.But i dont see much hope in this.
@Ali Tanoli
Today more Muslims live in and around Delhi than Hindus in all of Pakistan. What happened to Hindus and Sikhs all across Pakistan is comparable to what happened to Muslims only in eastern Punjab, which makes less than 10 pct of India. Anyway the past cannot be changed but what can be changed is the lies that continue to be propogated .
Pleasure to read mr. Naqvis stuff as always. Sibtains optimism is just what the doctor ordered in such negative times.
Best editorial piece of this week!
Some of the most beautiful places in the subcontinent are in Gilgit-Baltistan. I would love to visit them and would support easier and friendly VISA regime. If only Pakistan could moderate its obsession with religion , the sub-continent could be a better place.
@Babloo Same happened to Muslims in eastern Punjab and around Dehli where 85% to 90% muslims cleansed out lot of got killed and many left to promised land Pakistan.
A poignant article and a great human experience story. I could feel the author's emotions.
"I don’t know but I have hope that eventually, the common bonds of love, culture and mutual interests will win out and the dark stories of rejected visas and border disputes will be washed away by the sunny smiles and tears of joy of loved ones."
Unfortunately, we are not likely to see that day the author dreams of, definitely not in our life time.
Dear Sibtain, thanks for putting into words the emotions of hundreds of people. May we all live to day when India and Pakistan will be dear friends and put all their hostility back. Your writing skill is very commendable and even more commendable is your thought, your love for your true motherland. Keep up the good work.
Very nice article. But a linguistic correction.
Hindustan derives from:
a) Hindu - derived from Sindhu in Sanskrit which means "river". Sindu means river in sanskrit in a generic sense, as in saptasindhu - the land of the seven rivers - the ancient name for much of modern Sindh and Southern Punjab. However, over time, it also started to be a name for the largest river then known to ancient Indians (the Indus).
Also, India never had an organized religion in the sense of Abrahamic faiths. And Hindu was just a synonym for Indian for thousands of years denoting culture not religion. So, in the traditional sense, anyone from in the Indian subcontinent (from Afghanistan to bangladesh) were denoted Hindu.
b) Stan - derived from Stanam in Sanskrit which means "place". Which in turn derives from the Sanskrit root "Stha" meaaning to "stand". Interestingly, the english word "stand" itself derives from Vedic Sanskrit root "Stha" revealing the Indo-European origin of English.
Your resident linguist :-)
At least anybody above 67 years should be given visa on demand.
Pakistanis come and visit India because their relatives(Muslims) are in India. What will non-Muslims i.e. come to Pakistan for? All the non-muslims were driven out from Pakistan or have been systematically eliminated.
@Babloo: "Many Pakistanis, have relatives in India" *I talk about myself, I traced my ancestors village in Indian Punjab, two generation back Sikhs. I felt more at home at that village than in Pakistan of my birth country. And sure I feel more as a proud SIKH than some thing which I am not i.e. an ARAB. Needless to say, I am now frequent visitor of that place, where my great grand parents walked. SSA *
Many Pakistanis, have relatives in India. After all almost as many muslims live in India as in Pakistan. Only 10-15% of Muslims in 1947 , left India. Unfortunately, the opposite is true for Hindus as 85-90% of of Hindu-Sikhs left Pakistan. Hindu Punjabis, Sindhis, Peshwaris no longer have relatives whom they can visit in Pakistan.
"Hindustan, named by the Arab traders, meaning land of beauty."
First time I am hearing this meaning. Like many Pakistanis, we Indians will like to visit Pakistan as frequently as possible. let us hope better sense prevails on Jihadis and their backers and we have normal civilized relations.
There are two photographs on Google Image - One where gandhi has hi hand round Jinnah's shoulder and in another one Gandh has again his hand Jinnah's shoulder while walking behind him. These two photographs should be made into bill board and should be put up every prominent place starting with Parliament!