Neighbourhood watch: Afghan media deeply divided over Sartaj Aziz’s visit

Some analysts feel sceptical about Pakistan’s intentions of restarting peace talks.

Tahir Khan July 26, 2013
Adviser to the Prime Minister on Foreign Affairs and National Security Sartaz Aziz. PHOTO: REUTERS


Security and Foreign Affairs Adviser Sartaj Aziz’s visit to Kabul has been viewed with much scepticism in Afghanistan.

In a move to lessen diplomatic tensions, Pakistan on Sunday sent its top foreign affairs official to Afghanistan to deliver a formal invitation to President Hamid Karzai to visit Islamabad.

Earlier in the month when Prime Minister (PM) Nawaz Sharif phoned Karzai to invite him to Islamabad, he insisted that first Pakistan’s security adviser should visit Kabul to discuss the agenda for talks between both sides.

Islamabad agreed to Karzai’s proposal and thus Aziz paid a visit to Kabul handing him a formal invitation letter from PM Sharif. Karzai reportedly accepted the invitation, but attached some conditions to the visit.

The Pakistan Foreign Ministry is satisfied with the outcome of Aziz’s visit. The ministry’s spokesperson Aizaz Ahmad Chaudhry said on Thursday the meetings in Kabul were held in a cordial atmosphere. Chaudhry expressed hope the two countries would work together on an agenda that leads to lasting peace, stability, and prosperity in Afghanistan and the region.

In Kabul on the other hand, the approach to the visit is completely different. The presidential palace had stated, “President Hamid Karzai accepted the invitation in principle with thanks, however, he had stressed that a high-level Afghan delegation would visit Pakistan when the agenda of the visit includes serious and effective campaign against terrorism and towards the Afghan peace process.”

Afghan media and analysts, who are always critical of Pakistan’s policy towards the country, are deeply divided over Aziz’s visit and his statement that ‘though Pakistan has contacts with the Taliban, the Taliban are not under its control.’ Aziz’s other remark that Pakistan can support the peace process, but cannot guarantee its success has also drawn criticism.

All major Afghan TV channels extensively debated the visit and almost all newspapers published editorials on the matter.

The independent newspaper, Afghan Mandegar Daily, described Sartaj Aziz’s visit to Kabul as “bargaining to bring Taliban back to the scene,”  while the independent Cheragh Daily in its editorial said: “We all know the current crisis in Afghanistan stems from Pakistan’s interference in Afghanistan’s domestic affairs.”

Meanwhile, the Hasht-e-Sobh Daily on July 22 wrote: “Pakistan will not use its influence on the Taliban for launching peace talks but to intensify the war in Afghanistan.”

However, Daily Afghanistan expressed optimism about the matter. It said the visit shows that Pakistan wants to take positive steps in strengthening the two countries’ political and trade relations.

The state-run Anis Daily has followed a similar line. “The people of Afghanistan hope that with the establishment of the new Pakistani government, a new page of friendship and neighbourliness will be opened,” it said.

During TV debates, Wahid Mozhda, a popular analyst said, “Pakistan maintains its influence on the Taliban, Islamabad wants to gain privileges from the Afghan government and the international community.”

Zubair Shafiqi, a writer and journalist, told Shamshad TV he did not see anything new in Aziz’s remarks. While other political experts were optimistic over the visit and said the foreign affairs adviser’s visit reflects Islamabad’s intentions that it wants to help in the peace process.

Waqef Hakimi said the visit was an opportunity to change the tense atmosphere. He urged the Afghan government to take this positively, adding all problems in Afghanistan were not caused by Pakistan.

The time is ripe for the two countries to cooperate and put the peace process back on track. Instead of only looking at its interests in Afghanistan, Pakistan will have to take practical steps to facilitate reconciliation. Time is running out and Islamabad will also have to act now to avoid instability in Afghanistan following the withdrawal of foreign troops next year.

On the other hand, Kabul must stop using its media to blame Islamabad for all ills. Instead, it must take up its reservations through diplomatic channels and existing bilateral forums.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 27th, 2013.


Alann | 10 years ago | Reply

@Ussama and everyone "Pakistan is not responsible for your problems, Afghans!"

Who else is responsible for lack of trust if not Pakistan? Afghanistan's Army is very small but it is effectively killing terrorists in Afghanistan. Is Pakistan doing the same? No, Pakistan is not concerned about the thousands of terrorists inside its territory. If only Pakistan starts showing some real action against ALL terrorists inside its border, not only Afghanistan, but also India and many other countries will start trusting Pakistan. Pakistan's Army gets the most money in every budget, isn't it? For what exactly is the money used? To make more nuclear weapons?

Asad | 10 years ago | Reply

All Afghanistan can do is to blame Pakistan for whatever happens in their country. They themselves should monitor their country. They should stop giving all their support to India and USA and help Pakistan instead. USA will leave in 2014 anyway. India only has to use Afghanistan as a RAW substation to create insurgencies in Pakistan. While we, Pakistan support Afghan peace, they let their country being used as an area hostile to Pakistani nation. AND THAT IS UNACCEPTABLE

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ