The writer is a finance graduate who blogs about life at kohenida.wordpress.com
In the aftermath of this incident, Ghulam Rasul has been apprehended and four other Rangers have been suspended due to their involvement in the incident.
Before we delve into debates about the morality, or the legality of this incident, let us take a moment to acknowledge the many human lives that will be affected by this one incident alone — Murad’s four-year-old son, who witnessed this trauma; Murad’s other dependants; Rasul and his family who will be reminded of his actions for the rest of their lives. We cannot value a human life as an economic utility function — if the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan reported 1,726 official deaths in Karachi within the first six months of this year, it does not make additional deaths any less significant.
It is an indisputable fact that the Rangers’ duty is to protect the citizens yet clearly this was not the case here. Ghulam Haider’s unfortunate death at the hands of another Rangers soldier, roughly a month and a half ago, still runs fresh in the minds of the public.
It is retrospect, which allows us to analyse these incidents and the facts, and strongly form an opinion one way or the other. However, Rasul did not have that luxury. He had moments after a vehicle he flagged to stop reversed towards him. Rangers are no strangers to being attacked themselves — perhaps, Rasul acted instinctively and in self-defence. Did he need a defence when he was armed and surrounded by other Rangers? It’s subjective. We have seen solitary suicide bombers attack Rangers before through the medium of vehicles (North Nazimabad attack on Rangers) and if we argue that Rasul should have waited, we are lending credence to lack of action we bemoan when suicide bombers are able to carry out their activities.
Such incidents can also easily be caused by a rogue mind. In that case, rather than simply inspecting the action, we need to analyse the aftermath of such actions rigorously — who was Rasul taken into custody by? Was it his colleagues? Was it the police? Will he be shielded by his institution or hung out to dry? Will the state provide for Murad’s young son to go through a recovery process? Will the Rangers do the same? Will we vilify the Rangers for this incident as being abusive or will we look at it fairly? Are the Rangers indeed being abusive? Are there internal checks to prevent potential abuses of power? Do we even train our Rangers for special civilian protection tailored specifically for cities like Karachi and Quetta?
Just like we chastise a few bad seeds for giving Pakistan a bad name globally, we cannot be hypocritical and blame the entire institution of Rangers for the actions of a few elements. It is easy to forget the many violent outcomes averted because of the proactive actions of the Rangers because they never make the popular media. Rangers do their job discreetly — had Murad indeed been a terrorist, then this incident would have been glossed over and forgotten soon. We should not treat this as a case against the Rangers — Rasul should be tried on the basis of the incident alone. His role as a Ranger cannot be undermined but extra care should be taken that it does not protect him either.
Published in The Express Tribune, July 19th, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (10)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
1721805490-0/BeFunky-collage-(14)1721805490-0-165x106.webp "article")
@ SAL: The Ranger did the right thing.
No blood was found inside the Taxi.
No bullet holes in the driver seat.
No blood inside the Taxi means the driver was shot outside the Taxi.
4 Rangers with automatic weapons could not arrest an innocent man with no weapons.
There is no police record of the person who was murdered in cold blood.
Driver did not understand. Later when he realized Rangers want him to stop. He stopped and even backed up his Taxi. He was shot outside the cab.
That makes me think why 4 pious Muslim men are who actually saw penetration/sexual act to prove a rape.
Shame on all those people who are supporting the murderer(s). Even Ranger's bosses after investigation have handed over guilty rangers to police
The Ranger did the right thing. They are trained and disciplined to take action if one does not follow there orders. If the taxi driver did not stop, the Ranger must have thought that it is a bomb laden taxi coming in to explode. In fraction of seconds he could not have seen a small occupant (son) sitting in the vehicle. Oh come on Karachites don't try 'chit bhee apnee put bhee apnee'.
It is a lamentable incident. I understand the dilemma which this throws up. Well written article but his role as a ranger* should be taken into account as like Nzaar said so well, it is no wonder that with such utter lawlessness, dangerous incidents of suicide bombings and brazen attacks as well the condition of rangers who are underpaid and overworked does contribute to these incidents.
Questions like "will the state provide for the son to go through a recovery process" and "do we even train our rangers..." are niceties & luxuries that we have picked up from western media. Pakistan does not have the money/resources to do such activities. Our security forces are underpaid, undertrained, overworked, overwhelmed and constantly in fear of being blown up.
This event could happen to anyone - vilifying the rangers is not fair either. There are hundreds of bomb blasts & suicide bombings a year; it's natural for the rangers to be paranoid.
If I was a ranger who on a DAILY basis has to deal with the highly probable chance that I'll be the target of a bomb blast, I may also shoot at a taxi driver who suspiciously tries to bring his car close to me.
When given a choice, the Ranger will always choose for someone else's kid to become orphaned than his own.
It needs to be investigated whether it was a case of being "trigger happy rangers" or defiance by the taxi driver to allow checking
Well written. And well what can be really said... I mean REALLY.
If Rangers and Police are not properly trained, the common people are also not trained nor show any good judgement. The real culprits are authorities who verbally order to take strict action but do not stand behind their subordinates. Shame on them..
sad
Whenever there's trouble in Karachi, Rangers abandon their posts and run away to the barracks. Never seen during riots. Ever.
They have brilliant image management and PR departments and terrible at their job.