While environmentalists cheer the cancellation of a timber transportation order that they claimed was leading to deforestation in Gilgit-Baltistan’s (G-B) Diamer district, local authorities said they are not even aware of the cancellation notification.
G-B Council Joint Secretary Muhammad Amjad Gondal on Monday said the council has not received any notification from the Prime Minister’s office about the cancellation of the timber movement policy for Diamer.
Kashmir Affairs and Gilgit-Baltistan Secretary Shahidullah Baig refused to confirm or deny the new notification issued by the PM’s Office on July 5. Baig is also secretary of the G-B Council.
A copy of the notification, available with The Express Tribune, states that the prime minister, who is also the G-B Council chairman, has set aside a March 15 order for the disposal of timber lying in the forests of Diamer.
That controversial order — passed by former prime minister Raja Pervez Ashraf on his last day in office — had allowed the transportation of around 4 million cubic feet (cft) of legally and illegally cut timber from Diamer. The illegal timber was to be moved after paying a per cft fine that depended on the type of timber.
The deforestation in Chilas risks increasing silting in Tarbela Dam and also increase the country’s overall vulnerability to climate change-related events.
The latest notification, signed by Prime Minister’s Secretary Nasir Mahmood Khosa, also orders the implementation of an earlier Cabinet Division decision, according to which any illegal timber in the northern areas not transported by September 30, 2008, should be confiscated by the government.
The notification gave the G-B Council secretary one week to submit a report that incorporates the views of different stakeholders about the decision.
Both Baig and Gondal admitted that they had received instructions from the PM’s Office to prepare recommendations on the timber movement issue. They said the recommendations have been delayed because of other urgent assignments. A meeting to formulate these recommendations would be held by July 21 or 22, they said.
However, Federal minister for Kashmir Affairs and Gilgit-Baltistan Barjees Tahir had a different take on things.
Tahir said if any locals contact him with evidence about illegal felling or illegal movement of timber, he will push for action against violators. Some locals have alleged that freshly cut illegal timber is being transported despite the previous order being set aside.
G-B Chief Minister Mehdi Shah, the G-B Adviser on forests Aftab Haider and Chilas village elders have expressed outrage over the withdrawal of the timber movement policy, according to local media reports. They have said that the federal government should have consulted with the G-B Council and G-B government before taking the decision.
The forests in Diamer are owned by local village communities under the accession deal signed by the Government of Pakistan in 1952, but they are managed by the G-B Council. Some locals are riled up that the government is encroaching upon their rights by preventing them from moving the timber they own, according to local papers in G-B.
Published in The Express Tribune, July 16th, 2013.
COMMENTS (15)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Sanctioned environmental rape By Zahrah Nasir Published: April 9, 2013 is no more valid
All Parties conference on war on terror agenda must also have deforestation. We all suffer even our next generations
As part of oath for Ministers forests protection should be part of the oath
Things unfold as one goes deeper into this issue. The bottom line is that the elevated bureaucracy does not allow the exercise of the legal powers to the person defined in the GB Forest legislation of 1970 and 1975 resultant all this mess is here. So is the case the Federal Ministries hierarchies. It needs some real political leader to set the system right, give powers to those who should have and make them accountable before the peoples representatives
SO happy Tribune and a feww other papers like Dawn are keeping this issue alive
Writers in leading papers have called this as "sanctioned environmental rape" but the sanctity is gone after the orders were withdrawn twice by the present Prime Minister. So this be treated as a crime and must be dealt under law. One thing is confusing every one is the legal status: when the law of the GB province (forest Regulation 1970 and the rules of 1975) provide clear powers on who will approve the harvesting of forests and on what terms it is strange every body in federal ministries has been exercising the powers and enjoying the perks underhand. Self Regulation Orders of 2009 provide powers to GB Council to legislate on forests but not the executive powers to decide on how to convert illegal timber into legal. No other province refers the cases of forests to be decided by the sections officers of the federal government why this is done in GB is the question. The institution of Forests in the rules of business of the central government appears out of the decision making process THESE REAL ISSUES NEED TO BE SETTLED IF WE ARE SERIOUS
Because charity and donor money these days is not for forests so none of the NGOs will work on this issue,if someone can come and raise funds for this subject only then we can work meaningfully
I wonder where the stalwarts of environment are these days. When more complex issues are cropping up that need a cohort of dedicated well equipped persons I see them nowhere. It was expected that LEAD Pakistan will provide the critical mass who will help address environmental problems I hope they will prove their worth now in this issue
By involving universities and researchers independent views come forth else expect smae things for all times
What a wonderful PML governance we have, if the same thing is done by Ex PM it is crime, if it is done by present PM it is good. On and Off with or without cash transaction this is a national issue and must be dealt seriously
An easier solution would be to allow import of timber into country from countries like China and Brazil. Yes, China exports a lot of finished timber products. It will be cheaper making it economical to cut these trees in the country.
In next 20-30 years, Pakistan will be a barren, treeless place. Heavy rains will regularly cause landslides, due to lack of trees, resulting in silt in the rivers, reducing level of water in dams like Tarbela. This will have a dual impact of reducing power generation and reduction in water storage, which will directly affect the capacity to produce wheat/grain, the staple food. This is without taking into account that India is cutting off the water flow in many rivers as well. This will result in manifold increase in food prices as Pakistan imports food and has to compete against richer nations like China, Indonesia. This will threaten the very existence of the country.
The future looks pretty bleak unless drastic action is taken now. Forest cover needs to be increased manifold. A law is required that makes tree cutting akin to treason. If we can move mountains to try a general, surely we can pass this law and enforce it as well.
The transportation has not stopped so far and the timber mafia being the powerful is playing with GB Council and all the offices responsible.
Humnan resource Development Network must take u this issue if all others are gagged
The Minister of Parliamentary Affairs on the Assembly floor announced a probe on call attention notice moved by Senator Maryam Aurnagzeb. Now that nothing is doing some eyebrows are raised: 1. If the Minister has been silenced by the mafia as it did Maj Tahir Iqbal also of PML N 2. DO the PMLN not take Maryam as serious enough to keep the word or is 3. SOmething else has bene cooked The question will remain forever WHY CONTRACTOR SYSTEM THROUGH THE TIMBER MAFIA PREVAILS IN GILGIT FOREST DEPARTMENT WHEN ALL OTHER PROVINCES AND AJK HAVE ABOLISHED IT AND INTRODUCED DEPARTMENTAL SYSTEM. PAYMENTS TO PRIVATE OWNERS ARE MADE AFTER SALE OF TIMBER THROUGH OPEN AUCTION IN GOVERNMENT CONTROLLED DEPOTS IN THE PRESENCE OF MEDIA AND PRIVATE OWNERS NOT THE MAFIA
The profit margin is so great that everybody can be gagged. Lets see when the price of Ministry of Environment and MNA Meriam Aurangzaib is reached