If Imran railed for the immediate dismissal of the whole blessed shoot: presidency, parliament and all for being the outcome of the NRO (about which I have written reams even naming those who today sit in positions of unquestioned authority who would not have been where they are if not for the NRO!); Master Tulli kept warning us of the “Biggal” (bugle, in English) that was about to blow from the Rawalpindi side of things.
As luck and foolishness and ineptness would have it, our brass-hats had their hands full with the antics of the demons of their own making: the jihadis who were/are going about wreaking havoc in the country; and the Osama Bin Ladens who kept getting shot/caught/rendered, in/from, their not-so-well-hidden lairs.
More than all else, and even after the PPP went back on its many promises to restore the superior judiciary, thus embarrassing now prime minister-elect Nawaz Sharif repeatedly, the astute politician and good man that he is, he stood firmly against all advice to make moves towards destabilising the federal government, even after the success of the Long March that restored the superior judiciary.
Many were the times that among 30 or 40 journos and columnists, mine was the only voice imploring, even begging Mr Sharif not to listen to those wanting confrontation because if that government did not complete its term, neither would the next, and so on and on we would go as heretofore, spiralling ever further into the political abyss cheered on by an ecstatic Deep State and its toadies, the Paknationalist types.
“If this government is as bad as these people are suggesting,” I said, “Let the voters throw it out, but let there be a start where one elected government hands over to another without the jackboot!” Well, thank heavens a tradition has been started at least, and after elections, which were largely fair, new governments are set to take over in the provinces and at the centre. May they, too, complete their tenures so that they have enough time to implement their manifestoes and show the people that they are deserving of their votes the next time around, too.
I must also felicitate Mr Nawaz Sharif for visiting Mr Imran Khan in hospital to let bygones be bygones and for saying that it was the PTI’s perfect right to form a government in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa since it was the majority party in the province. I am not surprised, though, that Mr Khan’s trolls on the social media, surely overseen by his handlers, gave more importance to Mr Khan’s acquiescing to meet Mr Sharif than the latter’s visiting Mr Khan. I ask you.
This arrogance, coupled with their extreme rudeness and crassness: abusing the PTI’s detractors and their families (some imagined) in the vilest language, only leads me to believe that these young folk are completely foreign to this country’s social mores and traditions. In our way of life, even enemies are treated as honoured guests once under our roof: you don’t congratulate yourself for allowing him in.
In any event, and as we well know, it was always Imran Khan who aimed abuse at Mr Sharif , who did not even answer any of it, except to say he was not willing to debate anything at all with a rude and uncivilised person. It is high time that the PTI and its trolls, most of all its Kaptaan, learnt that abusing other people only turns them against you and makes you look like an ill-bred Yahoo. He must know, too, that in a cult-like situation, it is the leader who most leads his flock astray.
This is important for the PTI because it has proved that it is not an insignificant player in Pakistan’s politics. Getting enough seats to make a (hopefully) stable government in the important province of K-P, and 30-odd seats competing with the PPP in the National Assembly, is no mean feat. It should, therefore, grow up fast, eschew self-indulgent behaviour and do well enough in government to become a credible force in the 2018 elections.
And now, appreciation for President Asif Ali Zardari for soldiering on in the presidency despite the slings and arrows aimed at him from all sides. He needs to be appreciated greatly for relinquishing those powers arrogated to themselves by dictators by which they could dismiss elected governments at the drop of a hat and for devolving many powers to the provinces so that they can better run their affairs themselves.
It is great to see, too, that the prime minister-elect and the president had a pleasant meeting on the sidelines of the luncheon hosted by the president for the Chinese premier. And to see that Nawaz Sharif still has regard for the Charter of Democracy signed between him and the late and much-lamented Benazir Bhutto. Here’s hoping that not only these two political parties, but others, including the PTI, work together for the good of this, our country.
A report in this newspaper of record of April 3, 2013 states: “The country’s top antitrust watchdog has slapped a maximum collective penalty of Rs8.6 billion on Fauji Fertilizer and Engro Fertilizers — the two largest urea manufacturers in the country — after both entities were found involved in the ‘excessive’ pricing of urea.
“‘Given the nature of [the] crime, the CCP has decided to impose the maximum penalty of 10 per cent of the turnover on each company for unreasonable, unjustified and unfair increase in prices of urea in 2010,’ the CCP chairperson said both companies had raised the price of urea from Rs850 per 50kg bag to Rs1,580 in 2010 — an 86 per cent increase — without proper justification.
“The bench felt restrained [in] that it could not impose a fine of more than 10 per cent of turnover’, she added.”
Er, since Asad Umar, another “leader” of the PTI was head of Engro then, would he care to comment please?
Published in The Express Tribune, May 24th, 2013.
COMMENTS (37)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@SGN: "Wow. The sun must have risen in the west today. A whole article from Mr. Shafi without the word “Commando” in it." . @SGN: Sure you caught KS with his pants down. KS, is not being true to his salt for letting the "Commando" remain unmentioned. . On the other hand, KS has been too kind in his treatment of IK, whose smugness is becoming an irritant. He thinks once one can get away with it you are made. This is neither a game of cricket or pillow talk. Despite being a tougher cookie than Bhutto, as many have already pointed out, the disenchantment may set in much earlier.
@gp65: My original comment was a one line cryptic comment. Madam, you flatter me...............and as you know it works. :-)
'for relinquishing those powers arrogated to themselves by dictators by which they could dismiss elected governments at the drop of a hat and for devolving many powers to the provinces so that they can better run their affairs themselves.'
hahaha..what a joke. 58(2b) was never meant to be used at the drop of a hat. it was meant to be a part of a largre system of checks and balances and likewise the check on the president was that he could be impeached with 2/3rd majority inside parliament. so mr. shafi are you for democraacy but not for the requisite checks and balances? the NSC and 58(2b) are requirements for pakistans democracy, regardless of your opinions on the 'dictator' or anyone else. your PPP love can be seen right through.
@Parvez: Oh gosh, I certainly did not mean to question your political leaning - was simply acknowledging it. What I was surprised by is the tone. It's relative of course - a lot of people use much more aggressive language but I am not surprised. Your posts normally make a point very subtly and in a understated manner, so such a strident tone was a bit of surprise
@gulfam: I respectfully disagree with you. PTI supporters are only intolerant if your criticism is baseless. The author made it seem like PTI is a bunch of babies that have no manners and cry all the time. Why did he forget to mention Mushadirullah Khan here, I don't think I've ever seen a old man talk in the manner he does. And Why'd he fail to mention Altaf Hussain, the king of foul language and intolerance. Point is, if your unbiased and use the same scale of criticism for everyone then go ahead..criticize away. Give PTI a break. They aren't your 'professional' politicians..they are regular young adults. Give them a chance to take charge and be the future of this nation. They were told to shut up and sit down for all these years while these old men played 'politics'. IK woke them up and asked them to take charge. Why doesn't anyone appreciate that?
Writer is a staunch believer of status quo..now that Parvez Musharraf is getting bail after bail in every case, the writer has shifted his guns towards Imran Khan.
Mr writer..write it down..Imran Khan is our next PM and Parvez Musharraf next President.
Dear Shafi,excellent article and appreciation for committing a sin of admiring Mr.Zardari for shedding off the power that was inherited from a series of previous presidents.Great
well done Kamran sb. PTI supporters are the most intolerant bunch and think its blasphemy to critize their party and their leader.
Beauty of an article, Shafi sahib. Keep it up!
@gp65: It was all over the place and shallow at best. If I come across as a PTI supporter it's more because I criticise and abhor the last government's performance and do not expect much from the coming one ( it's priorities and past performance are visible ) but they will be better than the last, hopefully....................so what option am I left with ?
Excellent as always! Keep it up Sir!
Wow. The sun must have risen in the west today. A whole article from Mr. Shafi without the word "Commando" in it.
Well done author for bringing up the little question of Asad Umar's previous occupation. Several hours have passed without any reaction on his behalf. We wait to hear what he has to say. He should make his services available to PML-N, most business-friendly lot in the country.
Not defending PTI or Imran Khan but if you're gonna mention 'foul language' and all that then why leave out the statements Shahbaz Sharif makes. Or Ahsan Iqbal. PTI is a new political party, it'll take time to grow and mature. I commend them for bringing out the youth of Pakistan, almost all of which had given up on Pakistan. Everyone just wanted out but now they want to make a change..And I know they'll do it!
it was really nice article.......
Very good article, Shafisahab! It is true that Imran was hoping to come to power but came third. So his actions are out of his sheer frustration!
PTI really has some really misguided youth on its side. They just fail to see the contradiction that is Imran Khan. He really needs to mature as a politician before he can be taken seriously. although I don't agree with lot of PML-N stands for, but Nawaz is a far more mature and experienced Politician. Kudos Mr. Shafi for speaking the truth.
Why in the world the trolls dont realise they are called trolls bcoz they jist do ranting and no reasoning. I am exasperated by some comments here. You can take the time to write suggestions for the author to start gardening. Why could nt you give just one counter argument? Like an educated and civil person? But i guess that would be stretching the trolls too far...
I remember Najam Sethi's show, the one in which he complained about aiding and supporting banned outfits like LeJ, and I still remember how the PMLN trolls reacted to it on twitter. Mr. Kamran Shafi should have just seen that reaction and he wouldn't be saying all this. I can not even sit in the same room with the religious supporters of any of these political parties except for PPPs, cos they're funny and you end up laughing at them for being so apologetic yet persistent in defending PPP. They're all the same; and that makes all the IK bashing gang also a bunch of trolls cos in order to do what they do, they completely ignore the other side and put the entire blame on IK for turning his supporters into trolls, but no Mian Nawaz Shareef is a pious and humble man.
A very mature and democratic analysis by KS, thanks ET for this Op Ed. Some are countering and justifying the foul language used by IK against all other leaders. The argument that one leader of PML-N used that kind of language gives IK the right to go postal is bogus. IK is the head of a party and as such he should behave like one. PML-N has many leaders and they talk differently but NS behaves like a PM material. As much as I hate the victory of TTP endorsed and protected PML-N my belief in democracy makes me to bow down the will of people of my country. The elections are over and let us make the country move forward. The habit of de-legitimizing elected govts must be stopped if PTI wants to have any chance in the next elections. KS is right this kind of arrogance is not going to win them too many friends among the natives of rural heartland of Sindh and Punjab.
Dear author please stop.
@Cynic: In your comment, you neglected to tell us which media outlet you write for so that we could also comment about YOUR work that must be so far superior!!!!! NOT!
@Parvez: Really? I do get that you are a PTI supporter. But such strong reaction to what for the most part is factual (I grant you cherry picked facts - but facts nevertheless).
@Usman: Maybe YOU could be more mature and point out where (and why) you disagree with the author's work instead of just throwing stones (though that would require some intellect)!!! By the way, if you think the authors column is "a piece of crap", then please tell us where we can all read YOUR VASTLY SUPERIOR COLUMN!!!! NOT!
I, for one reason, applaude IK who has exposed hiden but mean nature of a wide section(young generation) of our society.This section has no moral,no politicle awareness,no knowldge of basic values and ground realities.These Aflatoons have nothing in their pockets but jahliyat, jealousy,dishonesty and selfishness.Such people have no hearts but little brain.The poor people of Pakistan have decided to defeat this section with their hearts and hearts have decided a right path i.e democracy and no to tsunami.I salute to the poor but intelegent people of Pakistan who have foiled a great conspiracy against their homeland.
After reading this I wrinkled up my nose, shook my head and said..................noooooo.
@Usman: Mr Sahifi overlooks the abusive language used against IK (and even his ex-wife) by respected PML-N folks like Ahsan Iqbal.
Mr Shafi forgets for example the abuse hurled at IK by the honorable member-elect from Narowal, Ahsan Iqbal,deriding a convert to be a "Jew," etc. Your love for Nawaz Sahib should not overlook the truth.
I have always maintained that the author is senile, with deep humble apologies. Only ET would give him and his jibberish any space. It would be prudent fir him to recluse himself from ally and all comments and devote himself to gardening at best.
Top class Mr Kamran Shafi I agree with you.As far PTI walas are concerned there is absolutely no chance of these people learning any positive thing.A tree is known by its fruits. However there is strong likelyhood that this cult may well vanish before next election.
Well-written! I see trolls coming for you Mr Shafi...
So PTI has its first hater in the media. I think before the elections this writer was always trying to portray himself as unbiased afterwards his true colors are being shown. What else to expect from a former PPP press secretary. Great title by the way expecting to read something about conditions after elections all we got was more bashing and a sob story of your precious feelings being hurt. How Ironic is it that you lambast Imran for name calling while calling others the same. Pitiful Pakistani "writers."
As usual, a piece of crap.
As usual sane words.
The aftermath of elections has given a lot of hope for us Indians. We are seeing a lot of maturity among Pakistani politicians and also among Pakistani public.
Pakistanis, for whatever reasons, have started seeing things for what they are. Ex :
1) Taliban (good or bad) are internal creations.
2) PTI is an immature party.
3) The success of Pakistan lies in democracy.
4) India is not Pakistan's enemy, equally as China is not Pakistan's friend.
5) No problem of Pakistan can be solved in a few weeks, few months or even a few years.
The future looks good for Pakistan. Let's see how it plays out.