Pakistan protests but Nato defends airstrikes

Published: September 28, 2010
A file photo of a Nato-led coalition soldier firing during an operation against militants. PHOTO: REUTERS

A file photo of a Nato-led coalition soldier firing during an operation against militants. PHOTO: REUTERS


Nato-led International Security Assistance Force (Isaf) involved in air strikes in Pakistan near the Afghan border last week had the authority to defend themselves, a Nato official said on Monday.

The statement comes hours after Pakistan lodged a strong protest with Nato over air strikes by the alliance’s helicopters on its territory near the Afghan border. “Isaf forces must and will retain the authority, within their mandate, to defend themselves in carrying out their mission,” a Nato official told AFP in response.

The attack by the Nato-led Isaf helicopters on Friday left 30 “insurgents” dead, an ISAF statement issued in Kabul on Sunday said.

Pakistan conveyed to Nato forces that it can no longer guarantee the security of Nato supplies after they launched air strikes in the country’s tribal  belt, The Express Tribune has learnt. The rare overnight Nato air strikes in North Waziristan drew angry reaction from Pakistan, which has threatened to consider ‘response options’ if immediate steps were not taken to stop such raids.

“Between complete defiance and complete compliance, we have several options to stop Nato forces from violating our sovereignty,” said a senior military official, who wished not to be named. Military and Foreign Office sources say these attacks would make the battle against militancy more unpopular.

“In this situation we cannot guarantee security of the Nato supplies,” said another military official. This has been conveyed to Nato, he added.

Almost three quarter of the supplies to the Nato and Isaf forces stationed in Afghanistan pass through Pakistan. Separately, a statement issued by the Foreign Office spokesman said Pakistan had strongly protested with the Nato forces over the air strikes. “These incidents are a clear violation and breach of the UN mandate under which Isaf operates,” Abdul Basit said in a statement.

He said Pakistan had conveyed its protest to the Nato headquarters in Brussels. “There are no agreed hot pursuit rules. The UN mandate terminates at the Afghan border,” Basit insisted. The spokesman made clear that Nato had been asked not to participate in any military action violating the UN mandate and infringes upon Pakistan’s sovereignty. The spokesman called for capacity enhancement of the country’s armed forces saying Pakistan had ‘boldly and at great cost countered terrorists.’

“Pakistan has always emphasized the need for coordinated and joint action against forces inimical to regional and global peace,” he said. In disregard of Pakistan’s protest, Nato helicopters again violated Pakistan’s airspace on Monday and shelled a village in the Kurram Agency, killing five tribesmen.

Political authorities also confirmed the strike.

Two Nato helicopters killed 30 insurgents on Pakistani soil after a rare manned pursuit across the border from Afghanistan, Nato forces said on Sunday.

The two Apache attack helicopters from the Nato-led International Security Assistance Force (Isaf) crossed the border from eastern Afghanistan on Friday after the insurgents attacked a remote Afghan security outpost in Khost province.

Isaf spokesman Sergeant Matt Summers confirmed that the helicopters had attacked after crossing into Pakistan. He did not comment on which countries’ forces were involved, but the United States is the only coalition member that uses Apaches.

The United States regularly uses pilotless drone aircraft for missile strikes in Pakistan’s borderlands, known to be a haven for militant groups including the Afghan Taliban who launch cross-border attacks from Pakistan’s northwest. However, manned military flights across the border are extremely rare. Isaf said in a statement issued late on Sunday that the helicopters were following its rules of engagement when they crossed into Pakistan.

Two Kiowa helicopters returned to the area on Saturday and killed at least four more insurgents, the statement said.

Isaf was not immediately able to confirm whether the Kiowa helicopters had also crossed the border. US forces make up the majority of Isaf troops in Afghanistan’s east. The drone flights have caused resentment in Pakistan, where anti-American feeling runs high. US officials say the pilotless drones are one of the most effective weapons against militants.

The strikes have killed senior Taliban and al Qaeda figures. A new book by veteran US journalist Bob Woodward claims that the Central Intelligence Agency also has a 3,000-man “covert army” of elite, well-trained Afghans, who conduct secret operations in Pakistan, according to the Washington Post. The newspaper obtained an advance copy of the book, which is due for release on Monday. Despite the presence of almost 150,000 foreign troops, violence is at its worst across Afghanistan since US-backed Afghan forces ousted the Taliban in late 2001.

The Taliban-led insurgency has spread out of traditional strongholds in the south and east into once relatively stable areas in the north and west. Apart from the Afghan Taliban, the al Qaeda-linked Haqqani network also operates extensively in Afghanistan’s east and has launched a series of bold attacks against foreign forces and Afghan government targets in the past year.

(With additional reporting by Kamran Yousaf in Islamabad and Manzoor Ali in Peshawar)

This article has been revised to reflect the following correction:

Correction: September 27, 2010

The picture previously carried with the article showed a helicopter used for medical evacuations. The picture has been changed.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (15)

  • Sep 27, 2010 - 12:24PM

    The photograph above shows an unarmed helicopter used for medical evacuations. The smoke most probably originates from someone on the ground, showing where an injured person is located, and who could be a civilian.

    There are no national markings on this helicopter, but it is a type that is also in use by the Chinese Peoples’ Liberation Army. The vegetation shown in the photograph could be found in North America, where helicopter crews train.

    The caption of the photograph needs to be revised to state something along the lines of: A file photo of a medical evacuation helicopter. Recommend

  • Shahzad Ali
    Sep 27, 2010 - 2:35PM

    Who knows they were insurgents. Recommend

  • Zulfiqar Haider
    Sep 27, 2010 - 4:17PM

    This is a big achievement in the war on terror; the insurgency can be tackled by striking the right targets and on time.Recommend

  • AAD
    Sep 27, 2010 - 5:58PM

    What! This is outrageous! You’re talking about territorial violation. Is there any information whether the attacks were endorsed by Pak? If not, be prepared fellow countrymen to be treated like another AfghanistanRecommend

  • Aasia Sohail Mian
    Sep 27, 2010 - 9:56PM

    We condemn the Nato air strike which is carried out in NORTH WAZIRISTAN. This is the beginning see what happens next, Poor citizens of Pakistan will face the atrocities and elite class and rulers will fly away. Remember one thing that “Beggars are not choosers” Recommend

  • Sep 27, 2010 - 10:27PM

    Pakistan and its ‘protests’ – topi drama.Recommend

  • Anoop
    Sep 27, 2010 - 11:28PM

    FO protests, Army gives intelligence to NATO about TTP for drone strikes. How strange. People are misled into believe that Army doesn’t support drone strikes. It is after all supposed to protect sovereignty, which it has shamelessly allowed to be exploited.Recommend

  • Ali Haider
    Sep 28, 2010 - 4:01AM

    Was the army sleeping? And why did the air force not take them down? Rahman Malik and his protests…Recommend

  • Eeman
    Sep 28, 2010 - 9:25AM

    Don’t understand the “purpose” of protest. Pakistan is their country. We sold it long ago. They can kill and invade any part of it whenever they wish. Recommend

  • Subair.M
    Sep 29, 2010 - 12:06AM

    This an outrageous violation of Pakistani soverignity, with brazen arrogance of the usual imperialistic forces. Any country with dignity and self-respect should respond with stern action, including possible counter-strike. Else, it is Pakistan’s honour which is at stake and in spite of all the military capability it possesses, this country will be taken as too weak to defend against foreign incursions right into its soverrign terrritory. The choice is for the armed forces of Pakistan : to act or to hang its head in submission.Recommend

  • Ahmer Ali
    Sep 29, 2010 - 11:51AM

    Assalam-o-Allaikum Warahmatullah.Our leaders are the most modern beggars in the current world and they beg aids on the name of nation’s betterment but furtively for their own requirements from every country.Then how can you expect that USA and NATO forces shall not attack on their beggars?Always remember begging aids from the advanced non-muslim nations drive you towards slavery and slaves are only for obeying not for ruling and slaves and beggars don’t have their honor,dignity,grace,self-respect and courage.Now don’t surprise on these attacks and if our leaders want to stop these Drone and NATO attacks then our leaders must stop begging the aids and debts.These attacks are the commencement of killings just due to our leaders begging attitudes see what happens in the future with the innocent and sinless Pakistani people on the name of terrorism and fundamentalism?Recommend

  • Zia
    Sep 29, 2010 - 1:11PM

    What! NATO helicopters in Pakistan! We already allowed drone to do the job :P Besides, to all readers, NATO is there in ISB for a while. Dont act shocked!Recommend

  • Tony Singh
    Sep 29, 2010 - 5:42PM

    Today the Americans. Tomorrow the Chinese!!Recommend

  • Emmad
    Sep 30, 2010 - 10:15AM

    For God Sack hit them back at least once instead of protesting every time. Recommend

  • Hafsa Naik Bukht
    Oct 13, 2010 - 7:53PM

    Pakistan has become the slave of US now.It is a fact that Pakistan protests against NATO,but the government is just protesting not taking any reasonable action that why anyone is attacking on the independence of the country??Our government has still no answersRecommend

More in Pakistan