There are three important signs of change that the Kaptaan’s perseverance, hard work and appeal of the ideology of change have brought about. Whatever number of seats his party gets, no party, leader or traditional political manoeuvring can so easily erase the impact of these changes. The first change is mass mobilisation through grass-root politics. No leader or other party has done this since the 1970 elections. The benefit that Zulfikar Ali Bhutto had was that he rode on the wave of a popular mass movement and he captured the leadership of that by his charisma. He was already an established national politician. Imran Khan started fresh. He was a new player in a new game — politics. Neither the dynastic party leaders nor the general public took him seriously. The traditional political establishment of the country thought he would leave the scene exhausted, frustrated without a dynastic political network on his side. They thought he would fade off like Asghar Khan. Instead, Imran has awakened the people. How it will translate into numbers in the assemblies is another matter. Although numbers would be significant, the impact of the political awakening might be seen through the many elections to come and the political behaviour of the traditional political establishment if it is able to retain its dominance, which is very doubtful.
The second major change is galvanising the youth of Pakistan. No other leader, after Bhutto, has ever attracted the youth of Pakistan. Nor was it a priority for the traditional political class, as it has developed an electoral politics based on biradari networks, electable individuals and influential political dynasties. Imran Khan has challenged the dynastic, biradari based politics. He has been able to win the support of the young voter. Never have we seen any elections of Pakistan, including the first one in 1970, with so many young men and women campaigning vigorously and in so many constituencies. The Kaptaan has achieved a miracle in giving hope and self-confidence to the youth that they can bring about change — a revolution — by voting. If you see unexpected results on May 11 for the traditional parties, it will be due to the young voter stamping on the bat.
Also, the Kaptaan has succeeded greatly in delegitimising the old politics of Pakistan — the dynastic politics. The ordinary citizen of Pakistan, in general, and the urban middle class, in particular, views politics as corrupt, dysfunctional, status quo-oriented and frozen in time. They don’t see any hope for them and for the country if the two established political parties — the PPP and the PML-N — continue their turns in office. The Kaptaan’s catchphrase that both parties had four to five terms in office and have done little for the country has made an impression.
Finally, the silent majority this time around is going to vote. If it does, it is because of the message of change, the ideology of Naya Pakistan and the confidence and motivation that the Kaptaan has generated. Whatever the ranking of the PTI in the numbers game, it has already changed Pakistan and the politics of the country very positively.
Published in The Express Tribune, May 13th, 2013.
COMMENTS (10)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@John the Baptist: I think it is unfair to conclude that only urban elite living in Defense & Clifton voted for PTI. Going by the numbers (even though runners-up in many places), it is apparent that support for PTI was evenly distributed with obvious higher levels of support in urban centers (but that too spread across multiple socio-economic classes). However, I agree that PTI needs to do a better job next time to connect with the rural masses. Taxation reforms, fiscal management, industrial development, human capacity development, foreign policy re-alignment are all great concepts but a layman finds it difficult to relate how these abstract concepts affect his / her daily life.
Very good analysis
The election may have ended but the battle has just begun. Forward Pakistan.
What was MQM contribution in last 5 years? other than playing counter strike on streets of karachi and switching between govt and opposition dozens of times. I will be surprised if they get reelected from here. A person like Dr Arif Alvi represent us!
Great write-up! This is what I've been trying to tell the disappointed (read emotional) PTI youth that making such an impact in the national politics to get seat count head to head with PPPP is itself a great achievement. Compare that to any other party and you'll see the difference. What disgruntled PTI supporters need to know is that "you have to be IN the system to change the system", so this is PTI's best chance to show how well they can manage the areas they won the seats from and by being a quality opposition. The change is here; they've ousted all the PPPP jokers who have been damaging the national economy for the past 5 years, and now they need to keep PML-N on their toes so that they HAVE TO perform in order to get re-elected. Result? win win situation for Pakistan! Better to have MULTIPLE great performing parties than a single one =)
This is precisely why PTI needs to take this election as a success,perform in KPK set a model and rule Pakistan in the next term.Crying foul of all over Pakistan will only bring disgrace to their positive performance
It turns out that the youth overwhelming voted for Nawaz Sharif. Social media created an echo chamber of familiar voices of the ubran elite. It insisted that the only youth that mattered was the youth that would vote for Imran Khan. And by doing so, they disenfranchised the actual youth of the country- those that live in the rural areas, who work back-breaking jobs for little reward, who vote in every single election but do so quietly and without the self-congratulatory back-patting exercise that was so prevalent by the teens of the cities.
Voting isn't just a right that you should be proud of. It's a responsibility that only the rural side knows of. Because let's be honest, whatever the outcome of the election, the young rich residents of Defence and Clifton were never going to feel any effects.
One question:
Grass root politics? How ?
Isnt he only awakening the mobile middle class or the elite ? How is that grass root?
great article
Excellent article Sir. People might not understand at this point but he certainly has changed so many things. I believe his will the most established party in years and years to come. When had you seen in the past, burger families of the elite class protesting against rigging, protesting against their stolen mandate, protesting for their future generations. Mind you these are the ones who spend hours on social media lying in their luxury bedroom in air conditioned environment. If these people are out there protesting fearlessly that too against MQM then its a change, its a change no one could bring but Kaptaan