One of the reasons I left New Delhi in late 2009 after working there for four years was the state of its public transport. Though most middle class Delhi people owned, at least, a two-wheeler, many of its denizens negotiated the city through its dreaded bus services or overcharging auto rickshaws. I was one of those.
When I started working in a newspaper in Delhi, eking out a living and paying the rent was an achievement. Having a car or motorbike was a luxury. Even if you did possess one, acclimatising to Delhi’s driving culture was another horror. Here, people broke signals or overtook you from the left. For Delhi people, spotting a car or bike without a dent was an old joke. Because there weren’t any that weren’t violated.
Auto rickshaw drivers were the godfathers of Delhi. They made you offers you couldn’t refuse. (If you did refuse, you’d be stranded where you were). In my earliest months in the city, I would mentally prepare myself to brave them. I would rehearse how I would haggle before I left home. I would brace myself as if I were going to fight a battle. (Like many middle class Indians, I had a prejudice. The prospect of being conned by someone higher than you on the money chain could be handled. But by someone beneath you, like an auto rickshaw rider, was unfathomable).
When I went back to Delhi a month ago, I found an arc of emotion and experience that marked life in Delhi vanishing. The Delhi Metro rail, which had begun installation in the early 2000s, had now reached culmination. The subway lines zigzagged their way through town. Nearly every major corner of Delhi had been linked to the centre of town. Daily, two million citizens hopped onto a world-class public transport network. On the train, travellers were (surprisingly) polite. For people stereotyped for their rudeness, Delhi folks discovered decency underground. I also found the fangs of the snakes (auto rickshaw drivers) had been yanked out. Though the dependence on auto rickshaws still adheres, they aren’t the only option for the Delhi commuter anymore. This was the new New Delhi.
Years ago, when I worked there, I also saw the other side of auto rickshaw drivers. In time, I became friends with one of them, who lived by the slum near my residential colony. This man unmasked the lives of many like him.
Delhi auto drivers weren’t owners of their vehicles. They rented them. Drivers came from the rural boondocks of rural north India. They worked in Delhi and sent money home. Most would work from 8.30am to 9pm with a lunch and tea break thrown in. Spiralling fuel costs and an increasing cost of living and other factors impinged on their lives. Current auto metre rates did not reflect those concerns. So, they overcharged. Nighttime charges began after 10pm — it was an increase of 25 per cent over the metered fare. For many auto drivers in Delhi, that time of the evening could begin as early as 7pm, depending on where in the city you were in. “We have to overcharge because we cannot live otherwise,” the driver said.
After a point, I made peace with the lay of the auto drivers’ land. One day, I asked my driver friend why Delhi auto drivers were so rude when it came to money. He said if you are not aggressive, people take you for a ride. He hesitated, and told me not to take what he would say, personally. “These people spend so much money going to malls and restaurants,” he said. “An auto fare should mean nothing.” And then he countered me, “Why do these people not haggle at hotels or malls? Why do they haggle with us poor folk?”
I kept quiet. As the trip ended, I slipped an extra 10-rupee bill, more than the fare. He looked at me and said, “Maybe next time.”
Published in The Express Tribune, April 24th, 2013.
COMMENTS (20)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Thank you for the responses. Heartening.
@American Desi: India is secular and will remain so. If Pakistan should also choose that route - good for them. When we made no attempt to partially reverse partition with what was then East Pakistan in 1971, why would we now want to merge with present day Pakistan. If we can stay as good neighbors that is good enough. Unification is not desirable for either country.
@Arzoo: My dear. It is the wish of few desis like me that someday both these nation becomes one again into a larger secular country where people of every religion will have freedom to face the woes of auto rikshaws :)
@ Rahul Jayaram: You just shredded Mr. Jinnah's 'two-nation theory' to pieces. I just realized, after all, we are one nation, united in its' woes of auto-rickshaws. Here in Karachi, it's just a notch worse than what you have described the situation in New Delhi.
Not true that we don't haggle (argue) at Hotels and Malls... I was in Gurgaon in February...at a major hotel that added Rs. 824 as "facilitation fees", beyond all taxes and service charges...when questioned, the lady at counter promptly deleted that fees, without batting an eyelid. Speaking for myself, I am more vigilant at high charging places, and usually generous and lax with auto-rikshaw drivers...
It is very interesting to read.The situation here in Bangalore is the same.No doubt the Driver's feeling is correct,at the same time they should realize that all the customers are not the same.There could be some poor customers who are forced take an auto due to some emergency. Shivaraman Natrajan.
what has this to do with pakistan now??
It seems the author is writing about the auto-richshaw drivers of not Delhi but Karachi and Lahore. same attitude, same mentality and same problems.
In Karachi, many many years ago, autorickshaws and taxis had meters, and in the beginning you had to pay according to the meter (those who could afford it, gave a tip or asked the driver to keep the change). Then slowly they started charging more than the meter, and now of course either there are no meters or have been disconnected. You have to settle the fare before getting into the rickshaw or the taxi. The only time someone in authority checked whether payment was being done by meter or not was in Peshawer in 1973 (when the JUI-NAP) government was in power. Although I had agreed to pay the rickshaw driver what he had asked, I told the magistrate that I would pay him according to the meter. The rickshaw driver was very grateful and said that if I had told the truth, he'd have been in trouble.
Autodrivers all over India make an awful existence. Their pay is not much more than what the drivers make, and their work hours are far worse. They have to drive in polluted, congested roads leading to lot of stress.
But, this doesn't justify over charging. One has to remember that not everyone is going to malls & restaurants to blow money. Not everyone can afford a daily commute in Auto, and when they need to it is because the other choices are not convenient.
And there is absolutely no justification for them being violent or rude. It is the same justification politicians can give too - 'we need to be aggressive to avoid people from asking questions of our fleecing public'!!
Auto drivers need better deal - like they need loans to own vehicles (which will bring up their income).
But, we shouldn't forget the primary purpose they exist - The passenger convenience.
@Arindom: I hear you.
Same state of affairs in Bangalore. Metro is coming up here too.. We will soon be able to travel in peace.
Dear ET, The hypertext for 'Delhi Metro' is leading to a page related to Chenab rail bridge . The link for Delhi Metro is -> http://www.delhimetrorail.com/
Btw Thanks for the interesting article. Delhi Metro has indeed relieved some travelling stress and have had some civilising effect on Delhiwallahs. But most importantly Metro's calm (atleast at the off peak hours) and clean environment gives people like me time & space to reflect on the diversity of Delhiites (the colorful & varied dresses, sounds of various languages such as Hindi/Punjabi/Bihari/Telugu etc. with Posh Englishtanis sitting side by side with a core rural orthodox folks). It is an amazing experience. A big thankyou is owed to DMRC in general and Mr. Sridharan in particular.
I understand the viewpoint of Autowallahs. Their life is indeed tough & they do need to make a living. however, the main problem is lack of uniform rates. Bargaining happens because the exact market price of a service is not known to the customer or because Autowallahs (rightly or wrongly) have this popular image of quoting a higher price than the market price merely to test the waters. Only greater Uniformity and transparency in charges can solve the problem. Otherwise It will remain a 'Bazaar' type business.
In December 2012, I visited Delhi. It has changed. It looked cleaner than before but traffic jams are all over the city. The drivers of Delhi deserve Oscars for their skills.
@Gary: At fancy malls and restaurants we see people who we percieve as "equals" or even above our own station. In front of them we too want to be seen as "equals" or on par - we do this by showing off money - how better than to pay what is asked and some more too as tips. With the poor authorickshaw or vegetable vendor who we see as "below" us we show rudeness and donot pay him as way to show him that we are "above" and he is "below".
This typical hierarchical thinking is peculiar of India ( and South Asia I guess). Only once I lived long enough in the west; experiencing with the guy digging in the street outside jump into the McD to have lunch sitting beside me - did I realise what a farce of a people we really are in India.
@Gary: I doubt that anyone haggles with auto rickshaws in Mumbai since the meter are not tampered with. Someone who asks to pay the normal fare on the auto rickshaw is not necessarily haggling - they are just asking to pay what they owe legally. They may not even have the discretionary income to go to expensive hotels. It maybe a middle class Mom, whose second income is necessary and she is taking an auto from station to home where she will cook after she gets there.
Also people haggle (negotiate?) where they think the price is not fixed. Not a question of rich or poor. In US, I know that rack rates posted for hotels are not final, so if I am traveling on leisure, I will invariably negotiate (notice I do not call it haggling). People also negotiate when buying high priced cars - particularly if they are used cars, or when they buy homes.
“Why do these people not haggle at hotels or malls? Why do they haggle with us poor folk?”
I have been asked this few times. I have seen my mom haggle with poor vegetable vendors, but never at hotels or malls... wish i had an answer.
Metro has changed the culture of Delhi. Almost everyone in delhi travels through metro and it makes you behave, stand in line, keep clean, care for what govt provides for you and mind your business. This new training has spilled over in other walks of life as well.
Who knew that just a underground train would change the unchangeable.
That was not only interesting and insightful but was enjoyable as well.
Nice balance that takes into account both sides of the picture.