Not too much of a Commando, what? His conduct recalled to mind the elegant way in which Zulfikar Ali Bhutto suffered at the hands of another army dictator, even going to the gallows eventually.
On August 18, 2009 I wrote in Dawn: “My advice to the Commando will be to come back to the country and face the music like a man. He has badmouthed ZAB much, and far too frequently when he ruled the roost, once going to the extent of calling him “the worst thing to have happened to Pakistan”! Well, let us see if he is half the man that Bhutto was.” He isn’t, is he?
I went on: “Let’s not forget the tribulations of another elected prime minister, Nawaz Sharif, who was thrown out of office by the army acting at the behest of the Commando and his rufaqaa and then, quite disgracefully, locked up in Attock Fort before being taken in shackles and chains to Karachi to stand trial for that so-called hijacking which many today say was a fraud played out by the ‘agencies’ to provide grounds for the removal of a constitutional government.” And the Commando himself scarpers when threatened with arrest?
So then, mayhem escalates in the Citadel of Islam, the good Taliban suicide-bombing the ANP day in and day out, and killing MQM candidates as far south as Hyderabad; the tally after the caretakers took over a few days ago, rising to over 60 dead and countless others maimed for life. In Peshawar’s bombing targeting the Bilours, even children were killed.
But thank God for little mercies: the gracious spokesman for the TTP apologised to Ghulam Ahmad Bilour for his getting hurt in the bombing in Yakatoot, Peshawar, saying they had no intention of harming him; that their target was his nephew Haroon Bilour, son of the late Bashir Bilour who the TTP blew up some months ago. By God, the brass of these murdering terrorists.
Earlier that day, in Balochistan, the PML-N’s Sardar Sanaullah Zehri’s convoy came under IED attack, killing his son, brother and nephew, and their guard. Amid all this chaos and anarchy, the political parties who are not on the TTP’s hit list are merrily campaigning away with nary a thought that their counterparts in the ANP, the PPP, and the MQM are hamstrung, not being able to campaign openly because of the TTP’s threat to attack them and their supporters if they hold any public meetings: witness the ANP’s tribulations in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa.
Isn’t it time that all politicians got together and condemned the TTP? Do those that are not threatened realise that if the parties that formed the last government are today under threat, the shoe may well be on the other foot tomorrow? Do they really think that the TTP is a nationalist movement, how many times must I say this, which will turn their Kalashnikovs into ball-pens and their knives and axes into notebooks?
What will happen when those who consider themselves in the “good books” of the Taliban come into power themselves and have to fight them? Do all the portents not point to a Taliban takeover of the whole blessed country? As I tweeted the other day, the TTP are but a few hundred beheadings away from complete power: just you wait until headless bodies are found on successive mornings hanging upside down in Faisalabad; Gujranwala; Multan; Hyderabad; Lahore, and why not, Rawalpindi and Islamabad. Recall Swat and Buner, gentlemen, and pull your heads out of the sand.
More than anything else, do these political leaders not consider the fact that even if they swept the elections, theirs would be a pyrrhic victory? And let alone our own people, even the rest of the world will not respect their mandate? I have to add my voice to that of my friend, Abbas Nasir, who used the word “disgusting” in describing the loud silence emanating from the “kosher” parties in his piece in Dawn of last week.
Let me also say that it boggles the senses that two of Musharraf’s stalwarts, Major (retd) Tahir Iqbal and Tariq Azeem, are going places in the PML-N. Iqbal replacing Ayaz Amir as the party’s candidate for NA-60 Chakwal, and Azeem becoming head information honcho.
While Iqbal’s tenure as a minister in the Commando’s cabinet was singularly unremarkable, Azeem excelled himself as chief spokesperson for the dictator during the judicial crisis when the Commando had locked up the chief justice and other members of the superior judiciary and even stopped their children from going to school. He was thrashed by lawyers during one of the big demos in Islamabad for his pains.
More importantly, I have to add that Ayaz Amir was a credible MNA, whose articles, critical of his own party’s government, showed the party to be democratic and open-minded. There should always be criticism within political parties such as there is abroad, particularly in the UK. I would freely equate Ayaz with Roy Hattersley of the Labour Party (Deputy Leader ’84 – ’92) who too was critical of his party in his writings, yet was elevated to the Lords. Oh well. As an aside, Roy and I had some memorable “lunches” in London.
Let me end by refuting all news to the effect that I am even contemplating co-hosting a television show alongside “Hazrat” Zaid Hamid as Tweeted the other day by a friend. Nothing could be further from the truth: I wouldn’t give the nutjob the time of day let alone be in such close proximity with him.
Finally, respect to the ANP. May their party workers be safe.
Published in The Express Tribune, April 19th, 2013.
COMMENTS (33)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Ladies & gentlemen
What the Commando did was of no consequence. What is going to happen is more important.
In Hindi there is a saying; "Vinash kaale vipreet buddhi". (When the end is nigh, the mind fails). What we all say is that understand the gravity of the situation and learn that TTP will take over Pakistan if people do not wake up.
ET happily publishes Indian's comments but does not publish my comments. SHAME ON ET.
@HK: Surprised, the way commando is worshiped by people like you.
http://www.thenews.com.pk/Todays-News-9-172240-Sour-grapes-or-an-end-foretold
A must read!
Kamran Sahib
Ur article would have carried more weight if u could have also commented on the judiciousness or otherwise of the apparent high handed and biased actions of the judiciary during the last two days. In the absence of such balance, ur article just turns into a rant.
@Nadir: Funny logic. Is COAS is another word for God in Pakistan. Why tears in your eyes? Why?
@naeem khan Manhattan,Ks: Why there is no contempt of court issued to those police man.. or those were only meant for PPP.
@Proud Pakistani: That is the reason Musharuf could escape or allowed to escape..
everybody is fueling hatred and nobody is talking about reconciliation. God Save us from these animals
'Fleeing from IHC' is a phrase coined by vindictive people who wanted to humiliate Musharraf and take revenge.This is what perhaps you also want.That is the reason episodes of Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif also figured out.Had you been interested in rule of law,the stance should have been that Musharraf be treated as per law and not otherwise.Perhaps it was also wanted that Musharraf should have arrested himself and handed himself over to Police.Perhaps it was not police or civil administration job which took him to his house and arrested him later.This time it is judicial dictatorship which will make a political leader.
Kamran Shafi a sane voice in mad world, sir first of all thanks for your kind well-wishes and prayers for innocent workers of ANP on a basis of human values and then billion thanks for highlighting the very hypocrite polices of our politicians and establishment. what they want to make of our society? do they love and enjoy blood-shedding and killings of innocent humans in our society?why they can't stop or don't want to stop barbarism deliberately.Its now a time for every true peace lover and values lover should raise and stand-up against militarization of our society.
Condemning politicians for their painful silence on Terrorism ignoring pressure of their electorates makes little sense. Respected Ayaz Amir has been denied party ticket because of the reservations of religious minded voters to whom criticism on Talibans is like criticizing religion itself. What about religiously obsessed sizable majority that votes rightist parties, who lack rationality and balanced approach. To such electorates "Commando" deserves capital punishment not because he violated constitution twice, removed superior judiciary and put them under house arrest, responsible for killing of Akber Bugti or Benazir Bhutto; instead they believe "Commando" must tried and awarded capital punishment because he is killer of angles of Lal Masjid, taking U-Turn about Afghan Policy hence removal of pure rather true model Islamic rule in Afghanistan etc.
Dear Sir
Well thought out article and well written. Irony & wit are not lost on one. Truly it is in the face of extreme tribulation (arrest) or in the face of death that a man may be summed up in all his or her parts. The nobility in accepting the inevitable with grace and honour. As for comments from our journalists or expats who live abroad in their safe environs and smugly tell us what's wrong with our country I have nothing but complete disdain.
Yes, Kamran, SALAM ANP!
The so called secular trio of MQM-ANP-PPP held power for five long years and failed to eradicate Taliban or at least decrease their power. Now it is useless of them or anybody else to call the caretakers to reign them in. I consider the three as much criminal as much the Taliban.
Sir, I too believe that the decisive round(s) on the war on terror will be fought in the streets of Pakistani cities. The more ominous contradiction persists at the intrafaith level in Pakistan, not between the West and ultra right wing formations.
What ever he is, he has shown a wrong precedence to the future generations, the man just does not have any decency or even courage to stand up for the law of the land which he has trampled for 9 years. It is really a very sad day for this unfortunate nation that his departure from the court just showed to the world that the laws of Pakistan are meant for the common people and not the elite of Pakistan. He is not the only one who has negated the laws of land and consider themselves to be above the law. I still think that the Supreme Court of Pakistan must decide his fate judicially and with out any prejudice and show the world that the Pakistani judiciary is not there to take revenge but hand a fair judgment based on law and constitution. ZAB was never given that chance. The Constitution of Pakistan must be upheld at all cost even if they have to let him go free. Mr.Shafi fallen off from his chair laughing when he heard the news but I was driving this morning when I heard the news and it really made me very very sad that the laws of the land has been trashed time after time and specially by those who took oath to protect the citizens and uphold the laws but they just stood there dumbfounded while Mush exited with out any hindrance. Prosecute those police officers who just stood there and may be even fire them and let them find another job which suits their temperament.
With all due respect sir, ZAB did not attain divinity when he came to office so I fail to understand this personal vandetta against someone based on their opinion. I am no fan of Musharraf but the way you opened your article is rather schoolboyish in nature. He badmouthed ZAB for what he did to the country and quite rightly too in most cases, but it does not warrant a jeering stick-in-the-mud attitude apparent through your writing.
@ Nadir
" I hope jawans are not demotivated seeing their chiefs treated like civilians "
Do you mean to say that civilians are someone from a lower rank and creed as compared to army. How ignorant are you ?
@Nadir: I read there was some fracas with Marvi Sirmed. What exactly was said about Kayani and what was the context? When people can openly criticize Zardari and Nawaz, why is it considered sacrilegious to criticize Kayani? Does the blasphemy act also cover the COAS?
Kamran Shafi Sahib, judiciary seems to be absent from your laundry list of issues endangering Pakistani democracy. Is the Judiciary trying to show who is boss or daring establishment?
@Nadir:
"I have tears in my eyes! In one day not only have judges defame a former COAS, the current COAS has also been defamed on television! I hope jawans are not demotivated seeing their chiefs treated like civilians :(
Really Nadir?
Abbottabad, Mehran airbase, Kargil war, war on terror...you are not worried that these failures wouldn't demotivate your troops? But the court admonishing a BULLY demotivates your troops?
Like I said in my comment above, Pakistanis like yourself have everything backwards. Your priorities are messed up. Your sense of good/bad is in reverse. You have been confused too much by your Mullah/Military combination.
An excellent and well written article! Musharaf was born in Delhi, but was made a General in Pakistan. He haslearnt n the staf college about the military tactics of British Gen. Montgomery. Given the situation that he is in on account of branching out into politics it is time that some one tells him what the Generals do in such situtions. Feld Marshal Rommel action is the military way..
Rex Minor
Kaun bhaga, Musharraf bhaga Who is running, Musharraf is running
Poor chap, he sleeps alone Commando pretends to be strong Justices know he is wrong Raving and ranting about Pakistan First Today his balloon has burst
I have tears in my eyes! In one day not only have judges defame a former COAS, the current COAS has also been defamed on television! I hope jawans are not demotivated seeing their chiefs treated like civilians :(
What happened to the case of Chief Justice's son?
Now Commando will come to know how great Bhuttos were when coming face to face with hardships. Unfortunately our generals are not made of that great stuff and commando is no different.
An excellent write up. KS has rightly concluded that real music will be faced by the new rulers in Islamabad but I would go one step further that they(ruling party and military) would be facing both Taliban brothers together who will join hands in not so distant future.
Musharraf wanted all the attention and he got it, even if it is all negative attention. The caretakers should not get distracted from their main mission of conducting fair election and handing over power to the elected representatives. The courts know better than rushing to sentencing Musharraf. Let the judicial process take its due course. The public should be prepared mentally to accept if not endorse their verdict because this is no ordinary case. Will Musharraf regret his decision to defy and come back to Pakistan when so many would like to see his back. It seems he never understood what was meant by "Go Musharraf go!" He may not get a second chance. If he does then my suggestion is: Run Musharraf! Just like he decamped from the Islamabad High Court today.