Not all remakes are successful, and Chashme Baddoor happens to be one of them.
A chaotic, colourful mess, the film is a remake of the 1981 classic hit of the same title (different spelling) directed by king of comedy David Dhawan, who has a reputation of remaking Hollywood and South Indian films. To remake an old Bollywood gem, it is crucial to do justice to the original — which Dhawan clearly failed to do. Still, if you are in for mindless entertainment and some genuine laugh-out-loud moments, this is the film to watch.
Director Sai Paranjpye’s 31-year-old film Chashme Buddoor (note spelling) starred veteran actors Farooq Shaikh and Deepti Naval in the lead roles with Rakesh Bedi and Ravi Baswani in the supporting roles. While the original bro-com film was a bagful of laughs with a story of three friends and the new girl on the block, followed by everything that happens when a boy meets a girl; the remake which follows the same plot, goes overboard with cheap jokes and double meaning dialogues, written by Sajid Farhad.
The movie begins with three cheesy friends living in Goa, two of which are struggling to strike gold in their careers — a flop poet Omi (Divyendu Sharma) and a miserable actor Jai (Siddharth Narayan). Besides their over-exaggerated stupidity and shameful acts, they also try their luck with girls, however they never succeed. The third friend Sid (Ali Zafar) is a physics student, shown as an innocent and respectful boy who is loved by everyone. Sooner than expected, Seema (Taapsee Pannu) moves into their neighbourhood after running away from a pathetic army officer father (Anupam Kher). After trying their cheap antics with Seema, the two friends back away while Sid accidentally meets her and their romance begins.
It was refreshing to see the South Indian actor Taapsee Pannu as the lead girl. She had a spark in her eyes and a bright smile throughout the film. But the film-makers definitely needed some weight and variety for the audience to stay in their seats for the story that was almost dragging to an end. Thankfully, there were other supporting characters like the legendary Rishi Kapoor as Mr Joseph, opposite the sexy LIlette Dubey in a romance of their own. Bharti Achrekar is brilliant as an obnoxious and controlling mother of twins (Anupam Kher).
While the lead role is a notch up in Pakistani singer and actor Ali Zafar’s career, the movie itself is less than average in terms of entertainment and experience. His acting skills were no different from any superstar in Bollywood, with a noticeably Indian tinge in his English dialogues. With his pretty-boy looks and Salman Khan-inspired no-shirt tricks, Ali is probably the only reason to watch the film.
The sound track was entertaining, with most songs in Ali’s voice and fun dance moves. The film made references to old songs, movies, veteran actors, army-civilian quarrels and terrorists. There were some hilarious moments, however most humorous lines were just word-play like: “Kamre me matlab camera me qaid ho jao”, “Ki gal hai, girl hai?” or “When you can’t change the girl; change the girl”.
Veteran actor Farooque Shaikh was right when he said people are often tempted to revisit something popular because you don’t need to put much effort into it.
Red Carpet
Ali Zafar’s Chashme Baddoor premiered at Atrium Mall in Karachi on April 4. To show support of their fellow Pakistani actor, numerous celebrities were spotted including actors Behroz Sabzwari, Mohib Mirza, Komal Rizvi, Hasan Rizvi and Danish Nawaz.
Verdict: If you want to see a Pakistani actor in a lead role in an Indian film, then do go watch Chashme Baddoor. It’s light, and the songs are brilliant!
Published in The Express Tribune, April 6th, 2013.
Like Life & Style on Facebook for the latest in fashion, gossip and entertainment.
COMMENTS (15)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
I would have to agree once in a life time with an Indian and that is @kingkhan about Ali Z acting. I see his movies no expressions no real acting. He has talent but he has to learn to use it. It seems Ranbir is the best young actor. I saw him some movie as mime and he was brilliant. I thought he was just Bollywood but he was fantastic. Ali needs to get out of skin and learn from masters like Daniel Day Lewis. He started with small part like Haneef Kuraishi 's my beautiful launderette and he was fantastic in it. Ali needs to get down and dirty in the role he plays.
ali ji ur movie was just 2 awsm
i saw your movie chasme buddur its very good & happier movie i like it,even i like your voice. the movie its on frnds ,but your work its to good. Please add me at in FB
This movie is really pathetic. Ali Zafar looks pretends like is a big time actor but the acting overall is poor. May be due to bad direction as well. Why does Ali Zafar not act in any films here? He can do well if he comes back and improves his acting here. A complete over the top unbearable comedy.. Ak
It is surprising that such a pathetic movie is doing well in both Pakistan and India in terms of box office collections.
This review is over the top. The movie really is a joke. not sure what to say. you sit there in the movie and wait for one good moment that never comes. This was poorly made acting of all the four over the top and direction .... cant say much here. Ali Zafar tries hard to make it look like he is a pro but falls flat. for me this is a total flop. Had expected much more
Watched the movie...and very much disappointed,,,,, complete waste of time. Not sure if it was due to the high expectations created by reviews like these and the hype. Ali Zafar really can not act... not natural to him and most of the times it shows. If you really want to spend money go ahead and watch.. otherwise this will disappoint you if you have high expectations. conclusion . Very average, over the top poor jokes and direction... we less said the better
On one hand Indian media make fun of Pakistani Actor/Actresses, and, here we are giving them full coverage. Shame on you guys. It's time you revive Pakistan's film industry and compete with Indians. BTW, just leave Veena Malik behind, she is not wanted.
Most reviewers assign stars, this reviewer should assign a "Pakistan versus Bollywood" score to the movie.
completly biased review,author is only prasing ali and bashing indian actors, ali will be 10% of what he is now without bollywood, he is gud singer,composer, gud looking but his acting is expressionless
If you go by the recent "Salman Khanized Bollywood" the movie is a 7/10...dialogues are fun thats probably the USP as shown in the trailers...However, the a better heroine would have added an edge to the movie...Ali as usual being Ali dashes the audience with looks but the heroine is average at best...her acting skills ?...there wasnt much margin for her to act !
Ali Zafar definitely raised the bar for other bollywood actors I just don't know what to say!
Didn't Ali zafar get the visa to premier it in India?
I watched the film with 6 friends today, I must say it's a hilarious movie and Ali Zafar definitely raised the bar for other bollywood actors. I would rate the film 9/10