Musharraf govt held responsible for Bhutto killing

Express April 16, 2010

NEW YORK: The UN Commission set up to inquire into the circumstances leading to the death of former prime minister Benazir Bhutto has blamed the Musharraf government for her killing, saying that inadequate security measures were in place to protect her.

By default, it also cleared President Zardari of any involvement by saying that there was no evidence of this. Chile’s U.N. Ambassador Heraldo Munoz who headed the commission said that the PPP security cordon supervised was inadequate and that Bhutto had died due to the suicide blast.

He addressed a press conference in New York on Thursday afternoon and delivered a damning indictment of the Musharraf government, the Punjab government, the Rawalpindi police and the “establishment” for failing to provide adequate security for the former premier. He also accused them of not following up on the murder and hindering subsequent investigations into the case.

Munoz said that Bhutto believed that the Musharraf government was using the security issue as a plot to prevent her from campaigning. But he added that there was a highlevel threat to her life and that the intelligence agencies were aware of this. He also highlighted the controversial government press conference by Brigadier Cheema of the interior ministry a day after Bhutto’s death.

In this presser, it was mentioned that Bhutto died by hitting her head on the “handle” of the car and that Baitullah Mehsud was linked to the assassination. This prejudiced the investigation, he said. Amongst the lapses Munoz pointed out were that a crowd was allowed to form around Ms Bhutto’s car and that shortly after the attack, the crime scene was hosed down causing immense loss of evidence.

He said that the initial government investigation led to the arrest of five low-ranking suspects but there was no focus on the cause of the attack. “Other perpetrators were ignored and there was no effort to identify the suicide bomber,” he added. He said that Bhutto faced threats from al Qaeda, Taliban and the establishment, comprising the military command and intelligence agencies, allied political parties and the business elite.

Munoz said that the Musharraf government did little more than pass on information regarding the threats and was not proactive in neutralising them. He pointed out that other former PMs were provided this protection by the same government.

“The attack could have been prevented if the Rawalpindi Police had done its work,” he also said. Hailing the heroic defence of Ms Bhutto by her party securitymen, he said it was inadequate and could not explain the hasty departure of the Mercedes back up vehicle from the crime scene.

Munoz blamed CPO Saud Aziz who delayed the post mortem for seven hours while the body was waiting in a coffin for Zardari at the Chaklala airbase. In conclusion, he said that the government should carry out a serious and credible investigation into the murder and her death was a loss not only to Pakistan but to the world at large.


Shahid Raza | 13 years ago | Reply UN report is just waste of money. It has revealed nothing that was not already known.The contents reveal to me two clear pointers: a) Clear Zardari's name (present darling of US )He may or may not have been involved (as Depicted by reports of Pro and Anti Zardari media) b)supporting long desired goal of Western Powers of discrediting our Inter Services Intelligence( they say if you want to kill a Dog give it a bad name). After all the these honorable men of the commission had to earn the uncalled for expenditure incurred by wise men of Pakistan. My country men they are all honorable men. How can a lowly man of the Public contradict their sagacity and Wisdom.
Shahid Raza | 13 years ago | Reply After the issuance of UN report, blame game has started as was expecting. Report is not conclusive and many ifs and buts have deliberately been created and left unanswered. Nation’s attention from poverty, price hike, power crisis and unemployment is being amicably diverted quite successfully by creating one issue after another. Soon ashes will be settled down.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ