It says: “Of the 7,000 soldiers wounded in the War on Terror many have had their limbs blown off or been severely handicapped due to brain injuries. Captain Qasim Abbas had finished a six-month stint fighting the Taliban close to the Afghan border and was heading home to get engaged when the militants struck, ambushing his convoy, pitching his vehicle off a 90-foot cliff and leaving him with brain injuries that make speaking and walking a daily battle.”
The report goes on: “Abbas and the other soldiers recovering at Pakistan’s only military rehabilitation hospital are a testament to the human toll from Pakistan’s fight against Islamist militants. Their plight receives little attention from Pakistani politicians, possibly because they are afraid of associating themselves with an unpopular fight that many citizens see as driven by the United States.
“Fight, fight, keep fighting, Abbas said slowly but with purpose when asked if he had a message for his colleagues still battling the Taliban. He raised his fist in the air to drive home his point.
“Captain Kaleem Nasar was part of an operation elsewhere in the northwest in January of this year when he stepped on a bomb. The explosion blew off one of his legs, and the other had to be amputated below the knee. He visited the rehab hospital recently so doctors could work on his artificial limbs. Despite his injuries, he does not regret going to war against the Taliban and hopes he can return to active duty.
“I am satisfied I have done something for my country, said the 27-year-old soldier. If I can go back to that area and serve my country, God willing I will. But Major-General Waheed, the head of the hospital, is worried that Pakistani troops wounded in battle don’t receive enough recognition in the country. None of Pakistan’s civilian leaders or other politicians have visited the hospital in the five years he has been running it, he said.
“They need much more recognition because they have done so much sacrifice for the cause,’ said Waheed (who) contrasted the lack of political attention in Pakistan with a visit he made to Walter Reed Army Medical Centre in the US. He was there for only five days but saw a stream of officials and reporters come to the facility to meet with US soldiers wounded in Afghanistan and Iraq, he said.”
Now then, how very shameful is it that not one political leader has visited the facility that rehabilitates brave young men like Captains Qasim Abbas and Kaleem Nasar, and many other officers and men similarly handicapped by the War on Terror? Far more than this, why has this story not been covered by our media, even official? Might I here and now ask the good Murtaza Solangi, the brilliant DG of Radio Pakistan, and the people over at PTV to immediately do the needful to honour these heroes and inform the country of their sacrifice?
However, while we heap scorn on politicians and ‘bloody civilians’, we must not lose sight of the fact that the War on Terror has been bad-mouthed, there is no more suitable word, by the Deep State through its own organs, as well as through its paid journalists in the extreme right media, both electronic and print.
Every single day, there are reams written on how this war has been thrust upon our poor country with nary a thought to the fact that the Pakistani Deep State is the Mai Baap (the Mother and the Father) of the extremists who are running riot in the country and killing and maiming our soldiers and civilians alike.
Indeed, the unceasing propaganda (with no supporting evidence whatsoever), that foreign powers are running the TTP adds to the confusion in the minds of lay Pakistanis. This especially when the Taliban are one day portrayed as foreign-inspired killers and the very next, as the saviours of Islam fighting the infidel. It is little wonder then that polls conducted on these matters show wildly different results in successive weeks.
It is high time that we Pakistanis realised our hour-glass is running out rather fast; that a huge miscalculation has been made as to the consistency of the sand which is running through it. It is time we got together and realised that this is a fight for the very soul of this country. Let me belabour the point: make no mistake that the enemy is within us and is threatening to take over our very lives. If anyone has any doubts, let her or him read the young and intrepid Munizae Jehangir interviewing Syed Mohammad Akbar Agha, the chief negotiator of the Afghan Taliban in this newspaper of record of February 28, 2013. Just two points made by Akbar Agha should send the shivers up the geniuses (aka the Rommels and the Guderians) who control Pakistan’s foreign and security policies, and up those politicians, who are falling over one another advocating immediate talks with the terrorists.
One, that enforcement of the Taliban’s hard-line version of Sharia was ‘not negotiable’. And two, that Akbar Agha “also indirectly condoned the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP)’s bloody insurgency. Pakistani Taliban only retaliate against their government in support of their Afghan namesakes, he said, adding that the Afghan Taliban would always support them”.
So then, friends, the games are about to begin, only this time, the Afghan Taliban and their Pakistani (and Chechen, and Uighur, and Somali, and Arab, and Egyptian, and Uzbek, and Tajik) cousins will be far better armed and mounted than the last time around.
I do not think anyone is listening, by the by ...
Published in The Express Tribune, March 1st, 2013.
COMMENTS (47)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Mr Shafi please donot the forget the Syrian Talibs in the gathering storm ...After Bashar we shall see them take the helm of affairs and with the blessings of the West ...Has the world really gone mad ..?
@Zalmai: The afroam Colin powel says on CNN, that the American Gvt. had no problems with the Taliban Govt., it was only that when they refused to hand over the AQ boss, that compelled us to invade Afghanistan. He for once said the truth, since the Talibans were regular visitors to George W Texas ranch. Afghanistan has always been ruled by force in history and the force is with the Pashtuns. Those who are not powerful must appease or abdicate or perish. You call Talibans peasants with Guns, yet they are the ones who have confined the foreign armada to protected cantonments and declassified the Super power to a force of Night time Prowlers looking for defenseless civilians. The world will soon see the Pashtun faces of the peasants with Guns or the Talibans as they are known..They are no enemies of Pakistan nor of any muslim country, if you are an afghan then a bit of your compassion towards Pakistani people would be appropriate. You could also explain to us what is behind the name of Hindukush mountains?
Rex Minor
GP65, I have answered your question, but ET has apparantly trashed it! Afghanistan is not the subject!
I can understand your curiosity but there are no short cuts to gain knowledge! I am not an Afghan nor am I an Asian from south East. You must learn the Pashto language and the Afghan culture to unerstand the people called Afghans, Pashtuns, Talibans, or whatever. They are tribesmen, and live as tribe each in their indiviual enclave. The Pashtuns are the majorities and the great warriors. They determine who the Mayor of Kabul would be, whose task is to represent Afghanistan in the outside world. The waziris are the one who installed the last king, an it was the waziris who marched into Sirinagar in 1948 and it is them who are being droned.
Rex Minor .
@gp65
Rex Minor is delusional and indulges in wishful thinking and I don't think he is Afghan. Afghans across the board abhor stooges in the guise of Taliban or Mujahidin for attempting to destroy the very fabric of Afghan culture by importing alien and obscure ideologies that are in direct conflict with the moderate Sufi traditions of Afghanistan.
Taliban are peasants with guns and they have nothing to offer towards progress and development and their previous attempt at governing Afghanistan was a disastrous affair and nobody wants to revisit or relive that traumatic period. Only the uneducated, brainwashed zealots from Madrasas support the Taliban and that too mostly by non Pashtun Pakistanis.
The biggest misconception and lie propagated by some media outlets is that most Pashtuns are pro Taliban, nothing could be further from the truth. Poverty and hunger will turn you into a communist one day, an Islamist the next day and a capitalist the day after depending on who is peddling ideologies with how much firepower and money, and that in a nutshell is Afghanistan. Weak ideologies cannot survive in a harsh nation like Afghanistan whose people have a strong and ancient identity.
@gp65: Some one said that there could be a few sympathizes of Sharia and Ummah preferers in India. If the few is even as few as 1% ( and all indications are that there are a lot more than that) then by your calculations there are 1.7 to 2 million who could be recruited by the Taliban when the time arises. That is significantly larger than the Naxalites that give you guys heartburn. If you think IM is a problem now wait when the Taliban actually start recruiting the willing. But then as Dilli is so far away that you do not have to worry at all if Pakistan falls under the sway of the Taliban. As I said, the lack of comprehension displayed is truly awesome, and so this is my last word on this topic.
Been thru Kamran's article and the responses. Wonderfull article and equally wonderfull responses. My only question is why Pakistan?. Why was this state created? to bring in so much hate, so much despair, can Pakistan be proud of what has been said in the article, and its responses?.
I am responding to 3 people who wrote directly to me. Please allow.
@Ejaaze: "@gp65: The realistic estimate of the Muslim population in India is 200 million at the moment (legal and illegal residents)."
Maybe so. You said one in seven Indians are Muslims and I agreed with you. That would put the total at around 171 million. Now you say they are around 200 million - perhaps so. No one denies that India has a large Muslim population. So what's your point?
@Rex Minor: "The Talibans are estimated to a total of 6o million."
Are you implying that all Pushtuns are Taliban? This is the only way you could come up with such a fantastic number.
"There are no Afghan or Pakistan Talibans, they are just Talibans"
Clearly the Pakistani establishment does not believe that for it provides safe havens tto Afghan Talibans and fights TTP.
@Zalmai : Ok thanks for clarifying. I must have misunderstood your comment. BTW, what do you are an Afghan too. Would like to hear your take on Rex Minor's comment that there are 60 million Taliban.
@Foreign Leg: I marvel at the level of comprehension or the lack of it; As far as your claim I know how successful you guys have been in Kashmir, or in Gujrat, or even as demonstrated by your MP the Owaisi Brothers in AP. But Then the self delusionary abilities of the Indians are world renowned.
@gp65: The Talibans are estimated to a total of 6o million, all under arms. There are no Afghan or Pakistan Talibans, they are just Talibans. They have declassified the Soviet Union and now the USA.military. The world will witness the trim down of USA armada as we witnessed the break up of Warsaw pact.
Rex Minor
@Ali Wali: Any task for yourself as well! Are you the commander to allocate task for everyone but yourself.
Rex Minor
@Ejaaze: If you agree on 200 million, India has the 2nd largest Muslim population on Earth. Yet we are not members of the OIC, ever wonder why? . My neighbor is a Muslim working for Infosys. He cares more about me and my family than the Ummah. In fact, he and his family is leaving for an assignment to the UK and he wants me to look after his house. Stop having hopeless dreams. Educated and working Muslims in India want nothing to do with Pakistan. In places like Delhi, it is easier for a Pakistani to use a cybercafe run by a Hindu than one by a Muslim.
KS is spot on in his observation that the soldier who is fighting an enemy whether internal or external should receive backing from the civilian govt and people as well to keep his motivation going. However in Pakistan, both civilian govt and military are hand in glove with various militant organisations and even giving active support to them in order to utilise their services for political and military purposes respectively for several decades. Some of these assets have now turned against the state and fighting their own mentors and it has become a daunting task for army officers to motivate their men to fight against Taliban whom they had trained as well defy the Islamic tradition of killing a fellow Muslim. It is for the same reason many a times soldiers surrendered to Taliban who showed no mercy and killed them brutally. The military commanders paramount task is to motivate their jawans to fight Taliban whom they should consider as their enemy who are acting against the Islamic traditions. The country is already on the brink and motivated Afghan Taliban joining hands with Pak Taliban would be a gigantic task to tackle by the miltary in the coming months.
@gp65: The realistic estimate of the Muslim population in India is 200 million at the moment (legal and illegal residents).
@gp65
I totally realize that it was Ejaaze and I agreed with you that dreams are indeed free.
Salute to our brave soldiers who are defending us from animal Talibans. To overcome this menace, firstly govt should devise a mechanism to repatriate the illegal Afghan refugees who are involved in terrorism, robberies, car jacking, smuggling weapons and narcotics, then we can talk about other things. Long live rank and file officers of Pak Army once again.
@Zalmai: You responded to me but you do realize that I am not the one who made the Dilli dorast comment, it was @Ejaaze. I simply responded to his comment.
@Ejaaze: "How many Pakistanis do you think are Taliban? ” a few like that”. How many out of the 200 million do you think?"
I have never implied that all Pakistanis are Taliban or even that most Pakistanis are Taliban. Not sure why you asked me that question.
Before that can we at least differentiate between ENEMIES and FRIENDS.. ???
The army is only perceived as heroes in Punjab and by Punjabis, as for the Pashtuns and Baloch they see them as oppressors that still follow colonial policies that uses them as front line proxies in the great game.
@gp65
@Ejaaze: “Dilli Doorast is a very historically accurate attitude. Who said history does not repeat itself?”
"Keep dreaming buddy. Dreams are free."
Dilli Doorast wali Islamabad nazdiktar hast. Islamabad is a lot closer to Waziristan and the first beheading and subsequent inquisition followed by ethnic cleansing will begin in Islamabad. Dreams are indeed free.
Excellent article, Shafisahab. Could you please write an article on money spent by The Armed Forces to keep their Image of "sole saviour of Pakistan" intact thought they don't deserve to be called in such Glorified terms having never won a single war in its 65 years of existence and having lost half the country in 1971! Sometimes I see it clearly that Armed Forces cultivate their Image by spending a fortune from their budget and thus retain their importance in eyes of ill-informed awam. It is time Pakistani Awam also understands how badly & deeply corroded their so-called Ironman is!
just to elaborate on my previous comment, Bin Qasim (an Arab) is a hero whereas Raja Dhir (a Sindhi) is an enemy and Alexander is a "prophet"(as he fought "Hindus") and the Hindus (who happen to be the actual ancestors of present day Pakistani) are villains!
@ Kamran Shafi
Sir, given the fact that Pakistani convention of naming its missiles after the people who subjugated it and claiming them to be their ancestors, it shouldn't come across as a surprise. Especially for an army-man like yourself.
How many times our President and PM visiten our brave jawans.....? How many times do we remember them on media....we should get some clue from American forces network which should put us in shame, the way American soldiers are encouraged for their fight in Iraq and Afghanistan....thousands of miles away..... The lást time I suggested this net work to KS...it was brushed aside and today he seem to hv realized that these brave jawans and officers need recognition.....it is better to be late than never....thank you....it is our duty and responsibility to support these brave fighting unit....may Allah swt protect them....pls do not critise them but support them....
@Ejaaze You nailed it. It is not fair to paint every muslim as Taliban/Terrorist. Although I agree with gp65 that majority of Indian Muslim are patriotic and wont do anything against interest of India.
A very thought provoking and pragmatic Op Ed, thanks ET for that. After the misadventure of Kargil we have stopped talking about the dead soldiers as if they never existed. Some of us still love the extremist terrorists that they do not want to honor the dead and wounded at the hands of TTP and their allies. The political leaders are either in the pockets of the terrorists or afraid of them. ANP and PPP have taken most casualties and are most fearful!
@gp65; as I said make sure who is dreaming. What fraction of the Afghanis do you think are Taliban? How many Pakistanis do you think are Taliban? " a few like that". How many out of the 200 million do you think?
@gp65: True dreams are free. Just make sure you are certain who is dreaming. One out of ever seven of your fellow citizens desire to live under Sharia. That is soon to be one of every five by your own Governments Projections. But then indulging in some Schadenfreude is always so enjoyable.
@Ejaaze: Spot on !
@Ejaaze: "Dilli Doorast is a very historically accurate attitude. Who said history does not repeat itself?"
Keep dreaming buddy. Dreams are free.
@Ejaaze: Still negotiating with a gun to your head, are you? Delhi only needs to contain which it has been doing ever since the fence came up.
While reading the caption, I thought you are going to touch upon the subject of 1971 war heroes, who are getting death sentences in Bangladesh today. (one country's war heroes are some times traitors for another country). But you were talking about today's heroes. Who knows how these guys would be looked upon ten years from now. Remember the gallant jawans of Kargil are getting no mention anywhere, though they were merely carrying out orders.
Soldiers killing own brothers including Taliban for rule of absurd reasons are criminals not Heroes ..?
Mr Shafi is a great story teller and specialy of the horrors of war. We can all cry with him or suggest that steps be taken to stop further carnage in the land! Let me take him out of his world and show him the grave of General Gordon in Iraq, which has the inscription, " He fought well and kept his faith". And then take him to the cemetries of several french villages which has graves of those who lost their lives during Algerian occupation, with inscriptions that they died for France. Is it fair to say that soldiers wearing khakis have more rights in civil wars than the civilians in white or grey dress? Pakistan mlitary should be reformed into a National army with the constitutional right to refuse illegal orders. Those who ordered the charge against the civies of the land must be held to account. This is the short cut to unite the people of the land into ONE, or gradualy break up into the land of tribes.
Rex Minor
@gp65: "As an Indian I am only marginally impacted to the extent that India too sees some of these people visiting us from time to time."
Dilli Doorast is a very historically accurate attitude. Who said history does not repeat itself?
Million thanks for the services of young officers and Jawans of the our armed forces. I must mention here that they are not alone in their sentiments regarding political leaders. Many civilians also hate those politicians who have never recongnized the services of these brave men. But respectfully I would like to ask one question to these brave soldiers. How many times retired Generals have visited facility for injured and appreciated their services, (openly and in front of media)? How many articles these Generals have written against terrorists, (in Urdu media)? No doubt, Politicians are cowards but they are not fools.
On the surface it looks great that American news-makers care so much for wounded soldiers. However, the politicians and think-tank (often making huge bundles from wars) do not consider why they start wars? In reality, it seems all this emotive moments are glorify war so more people become ready to fight; the more the wars, the politicians' and think-tanks' get more attention and cash from the arms/war industries.
International relations theory posits that a negotiated settlement occurs from a position of strength, compromise from a position of weakness. Is the Pakistani leadership aiming for a compromise or a negotiated settlement with the likes of Mr. Agha? There is overwhelming evidence to show, including the interview you have referred to, that the only flexibility the Taliban are likely to afford their interlocutors is that if you do not adhere to our version of Islam, we will use only one bullet not six.
Hi KS, Either you are lying or that Lt.Gen lying who had of late had bite of conscience and wrote a book about other things also about Kargil!He said in one of the evening blabbering show(I don't call it Talk show as most people blabber all in one time at height of their vocal power. What this General was trying to speak that when Jawans come home and visit him,they say that they pray that they pray each day that their rifle/weapon don't fire as person who is firing is also a muslim and the one who is fired at is also muslim.The "learned" General now blames who else but Amrika and Idia for all the conflicts in India exonerating his brother in arm who consistently made wrong choices and has pushed Pakistan to the brink. can you clarify Mr KS? Who is right?
The jawans and young offers crippled or injured in interviews on CNN a couple of years ago said that the Taliban and its allies are well equipped, well trained and motivated. They must be crushed and destroyed. The powers that be at the top however have grander plans involving string pulling and blackmailing, which has left us isolated internationally and sceptical internally. Years of peddling propaganda at the behest of Generals and ISI has meant that we as a nation are more than happy to allow parts of the country be overrun by non state actors. Rhetoric of "Pakistan Army zindabad" "I have tears in my eyes" "salute to brave jawans" is only good for emotional blackmail and justifying military excesses. When push comes to shove, so called champions of the military wont even pay their taxes to fund the salaries and treatment of injured soldiers.
Your rambling doesn't change the fact that talks are the only solution. Don't like it? tough luck. The government should create a paramilitary force consisting of brave columnists like yourself and your supporters (the fearsome internet warriors) and let you guys fight and destroy the TTP.
You could not have been more clear and direct wih regards to the call for action. Sadly, it is exactly opposite to what the PAC asked for today.
As an Indian I am only marginally impacted to the extent that India too sees some of these people visiting us from time to time. But Pakistan is the one that is most impacted and it looks like there is no will (fr whatever reason) to fight these people that are trying to impose their value systems upon you on pain of death.
It is one of the biggest tragedy of times to come that the nation is not aware of the sacrifices of their soldiers on the mere fact that this war on terror is not our war. I very vehemently oppose this notion. Yes indeed this is by all means our war. Our sons, fathers, brothers and husbands are being killed by the invisible enemy supported by our visible enemy and we say that this is not our war. If they are made to fight in this war then they will come to know whose war is this. Sir, you talked of politicians, they will never go to rehab centres, because votes and money are not available there. One who is tax defaulter, how can he is faithful to the country that he visits the faithfuls in rehab centre. When ex President Pervaiz Musharaf said on his departure speech " Pakistan ka Allah Hafiz", I laughed on him. But now it seems true. God bless our country.
Kamran, you are the one who has a major issue with our establishment. If you ask any person on the street, he will let you know, how much all Muslims, from Pakistan, love and make duaa, for our soldiers. Yet at the same time, we hate Zardari, and his spoons, along with Nawaz Shareef, and the other secular, bigots, who have almost taken Pakistan, to destruction.
How can one fault what you have said because the signs are visible to anyone willing to look. The frightening part is those whom we believed in, seem themselves to be at a loss and unable to come out of their comfort zone.
This area used to be part of the Afghan empire. So we will revert back to it. This time we will be sitting in the shura of the Pak-Afghania Emirate and not be merely subjugated by Lords of Kabul. The version of Sharia will change with time, but it will be Sharia and that is what we all want, don't we? It will be the seed from which the world wide Khilafat will grow.