Argo and the physicist

Published: February 27, 2013
The writer is a Canada-based editorial cartoonist and his work has appeared in several international publications

The writer is a Canada-based editorial cartoonist and his work has appeared in several international publications

The Danish physicist, Niels Bohr, received the Nobel Prize in 1922 for his contributions to understanding atomic structure and quantum mechanics. Bohr was one of the founding fathers of CERN — the research centre for high-energy physics. He once said, “Everything we call real is made of things that cannot be regarded as real.” Bohr shows not only an understanding of the very limits of human inquiry but also what motivates physicists to seek solutions for all those unanswerable questions. It was this motivation that led to the confirmation of the existence of the Higgs Boson particle in 2012 after a decades-long search.

Argo, the film that received the best picture award at this year’s Oscars may be based on real fact but is also a compilation of snippets that simply cannot be regarded as real. Ben Affleck takes several liberties with history in the movie. In Canada, it is widely accepted that the movie gives the wrong impression that the rescue of the Americans was an operation run entirely by the US government in which Canadian diplomats are not given their rightful due. In the movie, Affleck plays a CIA agent who, while watching an episode of “Planet of the Apes”, gets the idea he can free American hostages in Iran by having them pose as a movie film crew. The inspirational patriotism has not settled well with either Canadians or Iranians. According to Iran’s state news agency, FARS, the ministry of culture criticised the film, stating, “The movie is an anti-Iranian film. It is not a valuable film from the artistic point of view. It won the prize by resorting to extended advertisement and investment.”

FARS has its own idea of what is considered real. FARS digitally altered photographs of Michelle Obama at the Oscars making her conform to local restrictions regarding how women can be shown in Iranian media. The news agency restyled Obama’s dress so it fully covered her upper body when she announced that Argo had won an Oscar for best picture.

Like FARS, the Egyptian state newspaper, Al Ahram, altered a photograph of then president Hosni Mubarak, when he met with President Barak Obama in 2010. The newspaper moved Mubarak from his position of walking behind President Obama and the other Middle East leaders to appearing in front of everyone. Bloggers around the world ridiculed this fabricated reality. No different than the physicists who fervently sought confirmation of the Higgs Boson particle, bloggers sought answers as well — exposing Mubarak, using satire and wit. Manipulated photographs of Mubarak walking on the moon with Neil Armstrong; triumphantly holding up the Fifa World Cup trophy; or comprehensively beating Usain Bolt at the 100-metre dash popped up on blog sites around the world. These altered photographs of Mubarak became part of an ongoing campaign of reform to oust Mubarak from office.

We no longer live in a world where realties can be manufactured simply through the manipulation of images or revising history. Egypt’s current president, Mohamed Morsi, sought to depict himself as a man of the people in a recent television appearance, his voice rising and tears welling in his eyes as he spoke of the country’s poor. Egyptians, nationwide, mocked him. As Bohr said, “There are some things so serious you have to laugh at them.” Satire provides a glimpse of the relationship that exists between criticism and patriotism. It clearly reveals how people view their nation and government.

Published in The Express Tribune, February 28th, 2013.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (7)

  • Yuri Kondratyuk
    Feb 28, 2013 - 9:02AM

    The author desperately wants to pull down Argo but is clueless on how to do that. The fact that Argo never pretended to be completely factual makes his job impossible.


  • zaid hameed
    Feb 28, 2013 - 11:33AM

    Very poor writing on the author’s part. Pray, do tell, how is the higgs boson connected to Argo? I think the author mistakenly cut and pasted the first paragraph from another article. Either that or the author can’t collect his thoughts.


  • Oppenheimer
    Feb 28, 2013 - 12:22PM

    I think the author needs to write an article on the Higgs Boson, and introduce it with a paragraph on Argo.


  • Salman
    Feb 28, 2013 - 2:45PM

    One of the best authors on tribune. Always a refreshing read. The first three commentators on this article are dimwits.


  • Parvez
    Feb 28, 2013 - 3:18PM

    Loved it……..that produced a chuckle.
    Starting with Neils Bohr and equating his thoughts to how Argo was put together was creative thinking stretched almost to breaking. At the end of the day it was just a Hollywood movie and Hollywood was, is and will remain one of Americas strongest methods of injecting Americana into the world at large, nothing new.Recommend

  • Rex Minor
    Feb 28, 2013 - 9:35PM

    Sorry, I have no knowledge of the #Argo’. What is being underplayed from the ‘Cern’ experiment is that the speed of Light is not what was previously accepted.

    Rex Minor


  • 1984
    Feb 28, 2013 - 11:57PM

    I dont know why there are so many negative remarks about Argo….First of all,how many who complain about Argo seen the movie themselves??? Is it just because someone told this movie hurts Iran and Muslims,people just jump on the bandwagon just like they did for Kamal Hasan’s Vishwaroopam

    This is not like “SlumDog Millionaire” or “Mighty Heart” or the Cold war movies where one country is brought down in the eyes of public

    The film just narrates the successful “exfiltration” made by CIA.There is no positive or negative potrayal of Iranian regime other than the fact that THEY DID CAPTURE THE AMERICAN DIPLOMATS.AS LEVERAGE. You want people to deny the actual history just because their sentiments will be affected???.In fact,the first 10 minutes of the movie was spent on how the Shah of Iran was wasting public money while the people starved..

    Regarding underplaying the efforts of Canada,it happens in every movie and directors take liberty…The soldiers who enacted the “Great Escape” hardly featured Americans..but the movie was filled with Steve McQueen’s motorbike stunts


More in Opinion