Officially, this will mark the end of what has been the US’s longest war, but it will by no means signal an immediate end to the Afghan conflict itself, nor will it mean the end of the US presence in Afghanistan. An unspecified number of US troops, with some estimates ranging to 12,000, will remain in Afghanistan indefinitely. These troops, although classified as being in a ‘support’ role, will retain a combat capability and will be backed by drones and aircraft, as well as Special Forces. However, the day-to-day job of securing and holding ground in the face of the Taliban will now be the primary responsibility of the Afghan National Army which, while having swelled in size, still has to truly prove its mettle on the battlefield.
It is an open question as to whether the Taliban, emboldened by the withdrawal, will redouble their efforts to dislodge the Karzai regime or whether they will now be more inclined to negotiate with Kabul, while claiming a propaganda victory by ‘forcing’ the US to pull out. Thankfully, it does seem that the prospect of a Taliban-controlled Afghanistan is no longer palatable to Pakistan’s strategic planners who have, with the recent release of Taliban prisoners, seemingly thrown their weight behind a negotiated settlement. The Taliban, too, are wary of Pakistan, which they perceive as having betrayed them post-9/11.
Pakistan has huge stakes in peace in Afghanistan. The fallout from 9/11 and the Afghan war deeply destabilised this country, and if Afghanistan descends into chaos following the US withdrawal, the effects for Pakistan will be disastrous.
Published in The Express Tribune, February 16th, 2013.
COMMENTS (6)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Pakistan joy of Afghan Taliban rule in Afghanistan is going to be short lived as both Talibans who have already announced their alliance are going to pounce upon Pakistan. Pak Taliban has only one objective on its mind ie to rule Pakistan one day which appears to be on the cards.
Withdrawl will be desastrous if Pak army failed to capture or surrender the illeagal arms and ammunition from pak Taliban . It is only then any talk with them could be possible but I think they will not like to follow any precondition for the talk .
1) Pakistanis are counting on the Taliban not turning on Pakistan, or hosting TTP on their soil.
Even if one happens, Pakistan is in BIG trouble. BIG!
2) Pakistan escaped sanctions because US needed it to supply materials to Afghanistan. But, that dependence ends in 2014.
Pak gets no aid, no special treatment and if it misbehaves, even with India, it will be threatened with Sanctions, Iran/North Korea style.
Double whammy. 2 is certain. 1 could very well happen - a strong possibility.
AQ and Taliban are gone for good. They cannot rule any country except Pakistan. There were no high value targets who chose to stay in Afghanistan they only felt safe in Pakistan. When the rightwing Pakistanis claim the US is defeated and Taliban would take over, they ignore the example of Iraq. The US would never fully leave the region and would never allow Taliban AQ to regroup. Long live Drones to keep the top Taliban in Pakistani bases and safe havens away from Afghanistan.
" ... The fallout from 9/11 and the Afghan war deeply destabilised this country, and if Afghanistan descends into chaos following the US withdrawal, the effects for Pakistan will be disastrous. ... "
When the Taliban take over, Hamid Gul and the entire DEP crowd will be the first to be tried for crimes against Islam.
"if Afghanistan descends into chaos following the US withdrawal, the effects for Pakistan will be disastrous."
Memory is too short: Afghanistan descended into chaos soon after Soviet withdrawal and it was disastrous only for Afghanistan and not for Pakistan.
The fall out PAK is afraid of is that if Taliban are resisted in AFG after the US withdrawal, will the Taliban turn their energy towards PAK which is already happening in many forms in PAK today. This is the real issue.
Conversely, as in the past, hoping that if the Taliban are busy in AFG, PAK will enjoy peace is long gone due to US pressure and emergence of TTP and their affiliates in PAK who have no interest in AFG.
AFG peace and PAK peace are unrelated today. This must be understood for peace in PAK. AFG Taliban has an option of joining the government, which they once maintained. Whereas, PAK Taliban never had a government of their own, and are hungry for the taste of it, and PAK is unlikely to give them the option of joining the government other than the carrots.
So, fall out in PAK has nothing to do with the US withdrawal from AFG.