Taken verbatim from this newspaper of December 27, 2012; ‘Ihsan’ is Ihsanullah Ihsan, the spokesman for the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan, the terrorist group that targets at will Pakistani assets such as military installations and soldiers; the police; paramilitaries; health workers and teachers, in a show of great gallantry specially women teachers; and this poor country’s hapless people, little children not excluded.
Why, just yesterday it was reported that another seven soldiers were kidnapped off a bus at Jand in District Attock, as they were proceeding to their duty stations in and around Kohat. What fate awaits these unfortunates only the Almighty knows but judging from the terrorists’ chivalrous record, they will probably (may God prevent it) be shot in the back execution style and then have their heads lopped off.
A day earlier, seven women health workers and teachers, one of them travelling with her five-year-old child who miraculously survived but will now grow up an orphan, were mercilessly cut down at the Peshawar motorway’s Swabi exit, the pain of their family members best demonstrated by a newspaper photograph of a weeping old man mourning the death of his daughter. I don’t know about you, reader, but that picture made me cry out in anguish.
A day earlier, 21 Levies/Khasadars were taken from their post, 19 of whom were executed and two let go, one of them so seriously wounded that he too has met his Maker; and 20 Shia zaireen were killed when their bus was bombed in Mastung. We must note with alarm, of course, that in not one case of kidnapping/killing was any rescue mission launched to attempt to free the captives; not one raid conducted on the lairs of the murderers to apprehend them.
They have nothing to do with the mores of a kind and caring society, these murdering beasts; nothing to do with the culture of Pakistan and its tribal areas, for they are directed by foreign takfiris, many of them foot soldiers leading the fight against this country. Indeed, look at the reference to ‘Pakistan’ by Mr Ihsan, as if he represents a State inimical to this country: “We are ready to cease fire with Pakistan”, says he.
Let me here and now castigate those who conflate tribal traditions with what these savages do; as if to say that their utter cruelty and beastliness is rooted in tribal society. One sees through this attempt: it is designed to confuse the lay Pakistani into accepting these murderers as just so many other ‘tribals’ who have to be dealt with through talks. Nothing could be further from the truth, for I have gone to school and college with ‘tribals’; and have served in the army with them for many, many years.
They were/are as good and kind a people as any I have known; as well read and well travelled and worldly. This lie is perpetuated by the security establishment which even today looks on some of the terrorists as assets, as well as by political parties which think they can translate mollycoddling the terrorists into votes. They should smell the cordite before it is too late.
Meanwhile, back at the ranch we are being told that the Pakistan Army is changing its perception of who the enemy really is: home-grown terrorists in the growing of which it itself had a huge hand, Allah be praised, or a foreign country, let us not be afraid to name it: India. The penny has dropped, has it?
Whilst I cannot resist screaming out to our Rommels and Guderians to recall how many times I have beseeched them to see the light and recognise our own monsters as the biggest enemies ever, let me say that I am hugely relieved that the engines of the supertanker (aka the Deep State) ploughing towards sure disaster in uncharted seas are finally in reverse thrust.
It is to be seen, however, if the tanker can be stopped in time before it runs aground, for if you leave it too late ... For, if the security establishment even now does not move against the terrorists, it certainly WILL be too late. Even though he wrote it before the news of the army’s so-called ‘change of heart’, I am afraid I have to agree with my friend Dr Mohammad Taqi when he says in his piece in the Daily Times that the brass will even now drag its feet on action in North Waziristan. For, friends, there are wheels within wheels.
So then, even though the Deep State driven ‘Ghairat Brigades’ jumped down their throats at the time, President Asif Ali Zardari was right when he said India was not the principal enemy; and Mr Nawaz Sharif was right when he said the border was just a line separating a people who were quite like each other and that both countries should stop competing in arming themselves and start opening up to each other through trade to start with.
Now that the Pakistan Army is changing tack, could one ask the Deep State to stop blocking the granting of MFN status to India immediately if not sooner and to rein in its Difa-e-Pakistan Council proxies who dance to its tune?
On another note, I cannot help but end with an entreaty to Mr Sharif and Mr Zardari to please see the extent of the conspiracy against Constitutional democracy that is being mounted as I write this. I have to remind them that I have always advocated a civilised discourse among politicians so that the country may be guided towards fair elections.
‘Arm in arm’ is what I called it then; arm in arm is what I call it now, so that together they can stop this Canadian from helping subvert the Constitution. Who should know better than them that there are wheels within wheels?
Published in The Express Tribune, January 4th, 2013.
COMMENTS (15)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Great, very open and forceful. God bless you. Thanks
Nothing new except change in policy of the army that danger is with in, they knew it but did not make it public good they have spoken, but you can not close your eyes from real enemy.It is good to talk about operation against Taliban but its retaliation will be very severe. Our institutions can not extinguish simple fire in the building how will they control the complex situation. You have no government writ anywhere in the country and talk bigger things. Rule of law is missing, how will you fight the terrorists when you stand divided.Suggest some good solution that should be practicable
Shafi Sahab, Thanks for a great article. Additional thanks for naming India in the enemy list & then deleting it from that list!
India is not only NOT an enemy of Pakistan but it is Pakistan's (perhaps) only genuine friend. I, as an Indian, never feel any enmity towards any Pakistani citizen or the members of (poor) 'bloody' civilian governments.
I hate your armed forced though. Because even when the civilians are in power they are mere puppets in the hands of these puppeteers in khaki. That is why I appreciate your column.
In next 5 years we will be close friends. At 70, I don't know if I will live long enough to see that phase but nobody can stop it. I pray God that the day arrives ASAP. Amen!
Sarah Chayes says in an article in the Carnegi Endowment on 31 December 2012 says: "The government of Pakistan claims it desires a peaceful Afghanistan. And yet, as U.S. officials have conceded for months, the Pakistani military has not just been turning a blind eye to the development of insurgent groups on its territory, but has taken an active, sometimes fraught, role in helping develop them. Taliban control of southern and eastern Afghanistan, with no international troops on hand, will allow the Pakistani military to push its radicalized proxies, many of which are penetrated by a metastasized al-Qaeda, across the border into Afghanistan. While still able to influence these groups, Pakistan will no longer be held responsible for their actions." Pak army will NOT go after the TTP or Taliban. Pakistani military are simply making the right type of noises so that the Americans leave.
I salute you! Only brave & honest writer who has the guts to tell the real facts & truth. Rest are all fake.
Kamran Shafi is always clear in mind what he says is truly situation of Pakistan.........true there are wheels within wheels but its all intentional for making country in more confusion & complication...........
I agree with every word of Mr. Kamran Shafi. I hope the politicians and the army also do.
It is wise to recognize ones mistakes and make amends. Rearing monsters is never productive because they can never be kept under total control. Pakistan never ever had forward looking policies and has paid dearly for its shortsightedness. Welfare of its people was always a low priority for the State and the sooner this is remedied the better.
Shafi continues to miss the bigger picture that no matter how many operations you want to conduct against Taliban, they will not be defeated on the battlefield. They will only be defeated ideologically if the corrupt political class are honest and stop the killing and looting of the people through greed or foreign coercion.
The killings will only increase in tempo if we march into FATA thinking that we can subdue those people who Shafi incorrectly thinks are all under subjugation of the Taliban. Case in point is how Mullah Nazir was considered a hero by tribesmen despite being considered an enemy by Shafi and his allies.
Army has realised this and army has realised that and we, the civilions, are playing flute out of joy.that this realisation is going to strengthen democracy or finish terrorism. A young boy told mullah Nasirudin about a marriage cermoney in neighbourhood,mullah replied, 'menu ki'(what I have to do with that), boy said,you are also invited,mullah again replied, 'tenu ki' (what have you to do with that). Fact of the matter is,its not a realisation but possible shift in establishment's policy to ensure the contunity of its hold on this country with changing envoirnments. Excellant article as always.
I admire your courage. Telling the truth or speaking one's mind is a dangerous business in land of pure. May the force be with you and others like you.
In my view, there is an out of the system support from within the system for TTP and Co and that is a paralyzing issue for the deep state and the government machinery. The of the system support is ideologue driven and not driven by deep state design per se and hence could likely be a rebellion or mutiny if the state and the institutions move against the TTP supporting empire within the system.
It is unlikely that the PAK army echelons are capable of controlling the roaming TTP demagogues on a purely tactical basis within an electoral system of government.
Tragically, no electoral system of government in PAK is capable of a march against the TTP and the armed unit of deep state that can force TTP &Co out of business is restrained by the chaos in the electoral system.
Extremely forcefully said Shafi Sir. The army 'say' they see the real enemy and have to adjust their new doctrines to suit the changed threat perceptions. You can be sure that the killings will go on for quite some time yet. Army top brass are simply waiting out the US departure from Afghanistan and then they will try to 'deploy' these savages to do some killings on their behalf. The more you tell them, the less they realise.
A superb Op Ed, thanks ET for that. I agree with the analysis completely. Even though the deep state has finally seen the light and woke up from sound sleep there is a difference in words and actions. The entire world wanted to see some action on the part of Pakistani army now most Pakistanis want to see that as well. Hence this change in the attitude of army bosses. How many more deaths would it take for an action against these terrorists, is 40,000 not enough?
Good as usual. Liked the supertanker analogy, it fits perfectly. Let's hope that those responsible will take the right decisions because if they fail again, we including them, will all in for the ' high jump '.