Twenty months later, rape survivor Kainat fights on

Published: December 18, 2012
Court issues arrest warrants against two suspects accused of gang rape.

Court issues arrest warrants against two suspects accused of gang rape.

KARACHI: The universe – as the name Kainat means – seems to be on her side. Although gang rape survivor Kainat Soomro lost her legal battle 20 months ago, there is still a ray of hope.

The Sindh High Court has issued warrants to arrest two of the four suspects, who were all acquitted of rape charges in May 2010. Only last month, the minor had won a case for compensation by the government.

In January 2007, Kainat – then 13 years old – was abducted from her hometown in Dadu district. Four men kept the minor with them for four days and repeatedly assaulted her, Kainat said. She later managed to escape. Instead of punishing the perpetrators, the tribal elders declared her “kari” [a woman liable to be killed for dishonouring customs].

Kainat Soomro

In a daring move, Kainat’s family refused to abide by the elders’ decision to murder their daughter. They even registered a case against the four suspects identified by the rape survivor – Shaban Sheikh, Kaleemullah Lashari, Ahsan Thebo and Roshan Ali Thebo – with the Meher police in Dadu.

In an unfortunate turn of events, Kainat lost her three-year-long legal battle when a sessions court dismissed her case on “conflicting” evidence. All the suspects, then jailed, were acquitted on “the benefit of the doubt”.

Soon after the court verdict, Kainat also lost her brother, who had been pursuing her case in courts. Sabir Soomro, 24, had been kidnapped from Meher, Dadu on March 28 and was killed three months later in Khuzdar, Balochistan, by unknown people and for unknown reasons. Reports suggested the young man had gone home to sell off the family house in order to fund the court expenses when he was abducted.

The Judges issued

The gang rape survivor has, however, still not lost hope. She has again taken her matter to court, challenging the acquittal of the four suspects nearly two years ago. “All the men were acquitted because the trial judge failed to realise the evidence placed on record,” she stated in her plea filed in the Sindh High Court.

On the last date of hearing, the judges had issued notices through the Dadu SSP to all the four defendants to appear before the court. None of them was at the court when the case was taken up on Monday. An official from the Dadu SSP office told the judges that two suspects – Ahsan Thebo and his father Roshan Ali Thebo – refused to receive the court summons when contacted. The judges took exception to the suspects’ behaviour.

Justice Aqeel Ahmed Abbasi, who headed the bench, ordered issuing bailable arrest warrants to the sum of Rs25,000 each against the two men. The Dadu SSP was ordered to ensure their attendance in court within three weeks.

Published in The Express Tribune, December 18th, 2012.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (10)

  • Dec 18, 2012 - 11:52AM

    Good step by Justice Aqeel Ahmad, no one have right to violate the court rules.


  • Muhammad Usama Aziz
    Dec 18, 2012 - 11:53AM

    May ALLAH help her and ease her sufferings.


  • dr shoaib khan afridi
    Dec 18, 2012 - 1:38PM

    Kainat somro is not the daughter of a session judge or high court judge. Nor she is the daughter of a lawyer of a bar association. Do you think her culprits were acquitted if she was daughter of a judge. Same happened with mukhtara mai. Pakistan judiciary has world record of acquittal of criminal. Judge do not decide case till all witness or those who pursue case are killed one by one. Later our honourable judiciary acquit them for lack of evidence. I have seen cases where persons are asked that how many bullets were fired. It is laughable. If some one fire at you then you will count butllets. Strange judiciary.Recommend

  • saleem
    Dec 18, 2012 - 2:58PM

    lets shoot the rapists


  • sgrr
    Dec 18, 2012 - 3:27PM

    The courts have no time to address these minor issue; they are busy in hifi cases liek suo motto on PM son in law appointment.

    Justice delayed is justice denied; so whether is there any accountability for the judicial system for delaying/denying the justice for the common man of Pakistan.


  • A Y
    Dec 18, 2012 - 6:36PM

    La illah illallah. Sitting outside of Pakistan, one is always disgusted by such stories. Sad……!


  • Mustafa Nemat Ali
    Dec 18, 2012 - 7:33PM

    “The universe – as the name Kainat means – seems to be on her side.”

    Please edit this out, the story is about a rape victim! What was the sub-editor thinking?!Recommend

  • sohail ahooja
    Dec 19, 2012 - 12:16AM

    point is only judiciary is not responsible for that because court has to follow the law which is written and codified so they can not avoid that. but in fact it is the duty of the govt to amend the laws according the current circumstances i.e. for terrorists n such rape incidents. but unfortunately it is not so, our courts are forced to use those laws that are more than 100 years ago. so it is parliament’s duty to legislate ane amend the laws in which that is badly failed.


  • sohail ahooja
    Dec 19, 2012 - 12:24AM

    only courts are responsible here. they are bound to follow the written law so it is parliament that has to legislate and amend the laws as par current circumstances. we are immensely in need of making new separate procedural and evidential laws for terrorists and such rape cases. otherwise such things will keep happening.


  • Mir
    Dec 19, 2012 - 10:49AM

    She was raped, she saw her rapists being freed by the judge, her brother was murdered. She has not been provided justice for 20 months and considering what this country is about I do see a tough battle for a brave girl trying to get justice. The universe is not on her side. You ask why people do not cry for our children when they die because of drones? Follow these countless examples and know that the world does not think of us as human beings.


More in Sindh