While Bengalis in the erstwhile eastern wing of Pakistan were rejoicing their hard-earned liberation, people in the western wing were in a state of stunned shock and utter disbelief. What had gone wrong? There was, however, the inevitable conclusion that there could be no military solution to a political problem.
December 16, 1971 takes me back to my impressionable years at Dhaka University. Everything around was enchanting. A morning drive from the hostel to the campus on a rickety cycle rickshaw was a fascinating experience while coming across sari-clad girls with beaming smiles on their faces.
Ayub Khan’s long era was drawing to a close. The sense of alienation in the eastern part of the country had reached its heights. Despite all this, I had never come across the word ‘secession’. Hardcore Bengali nationalists would only talk about regional autonomy. Imperatives of nation-building had made it evident that we were essentially a polity. This required varying dispensations to move the country forward but the leadership refused to believe this and we clung to centrist policies in the name of ideology, denying the fact that an ideology is like a steady tide with ebbs and flows and not a concrete mass. It is an ever-evolving paradigm.
The Dhaka Racecourse, which proved to be our Granada in 1971, was the same place where I got the chance to have a close view of Sheikh Mujeebur Rehman. It was March 1969. The Racecourse ground, popularly known as the Ramna Green, was milling with a jostling crowd. I was struggling to find a vantage point that could enable me to glimpse Sheikh Mujeeb. By now, he was the sole voice of the Bengalis and symbolised the aspirations of the people. He had been released from jail after a long incarceration, having been witch-hunted for propounding his famous six points and subsequently, tried in the Agartala Conspiracy case. That evening, Sheikh Mujeeb was in an upbeat mood, captivating the charged crowd with his histrionics. He talked about the rights of his people and vowed to shed his blood for ‘Sonar Bangla’. On that very day, a student leader of Dhaka University, Tofail Ahmed, named Sheikh Mujeeb ‘Bangla Bundhu’ — friend of Bengal. Even today, the nation remembers him with this appellation.
I had many friends in that rally. They had been close friends for many years. We laughed and shared our concerns together. We dined and moved together, engaged in long discourses, at times agreed, but more often than not, were quite different from each other. In March 1971, after the Pakistan Army’s crackdown, some of my Bengali friends took up arms and joined the liberation force. One-time friends were now estranged fellows.
Lately, I have been able to pick up the thread and revive old contacts. We have all mellowed down. In my reckoning, our erstwhile compatriots may well forgive us but can never forget what was done to them. While Bangladesh is on the move, bonding together as a nation-state, we still appear to be in a state of smugness, refusing to learn from our painful history.
Published in The Express Tribune, December 16th, 2012.
COMMENTS (56)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Lala Gee: @Brig Harwant Singh (Retd): "The links mentioned in my 2nd comment (posted 2012-12-16 12:24:17 GMT) are more enough to bust your claims of your humanity." How, in the name of fairness, can you dare to challenge his claims to humanity? In his post, the gentleman referred to his personal feelings. So, tell us how could you have busted his "claims of your humanity" in your 2012-12-16 12:24:17 GMT post when his post is dated Dec 17, 2012 - 7:43PM ? Are you a clairvoyant of sorts? Is there any method to your crazy thought processes? Look at the number of the posts that repudiate you in this thread alone. At other places, I have read comments of your own compatriots to the effect that they will not deign to read any of your comments in future. Take a break from ET, will you? It seems to unhinge you!
@Lala Gee: Sirji, with due respect, how can you defend the indefensible ? I am a proud Indian Sikh and I for company sake will take your word so you will not be alone in your delusional world. USA hates Muslims , Israel is your worst enemy. India is a pet baby for hatred. All hail Saudi Arabia. I am with you , please give a Kafir a chance. Where do you live by the way ? I hope not in a western country by chance ? We live in the Indian sub continent and face the problems here. If you live in pakistan then hats off to you in the way you create lala history. 1984 is history for me because congress apologized about it.live and let live. Sat sri akal
@Brig Harwant Singh (Retd):
We can write better and more dreadful scripts of Indians brutalities than this, because it takes only ones imagination and a pen to write whatever you like. That does not mean every word you write is true and unbiased unless substantiated by credible sources. The whole world has witnessed, and very well documented in dozens of reports, Indians craving for humanity during Sikh massacre, and pogroms of Muslims of Gujarat, Bombay, Ayodhiya, and Indian Occupied Kashmir. Please keep your rhetoric of humanity to yourself, We very well know how humane Indians are. The links mentioned in my 2nd comment (posted 2012-12-16 12:24:17 GMT) are more enough to bust your claims of your humanity.
@MSS:
"I reside in UK."
I guess, I have read this before also. You reside in UK, some in USA, and yet some others in rest the world. Fortunately, I my self have lived both in UK and North America for some time, and visited EU countries as well. Due to my personal exposure, I am very well aware of the life style there. Unless you guys are paid full time for what you do on these blogs, it is unimaginable for a normal working person to spare this much time and energy as you guys do. I wonder how, and more importantly why, do you spend this much time for all this hate mongering. Do you guys have any life there, or live in a dungeon.
@MSS:
Come on man, some time we have to confess. Particularly when we could not beat the genius of our Mohsin-e-Aala@lala gee. We have been caught red handed. . Well, it is like this. We whom you already named and a selected few from the ET staff, are members of the Literati, registered with a Lodge (Can't reveal the name), as we you have noticed all of us have our left hands' ring-fingers missing. you guessed it we are member of Yakuza, though only of the Pakistani franchise. . For our meetings we visit a Thai Massage parlor, where a secret door leads us to the sauna for having our tete a tete.
During the '71 War , I was in Jessore - Khulna Sector of (now) Bangladesh . Before the War we were located at Kanchrarapara , on the outskirts of Calcutta and had to concentrate towards the border for the war . Given below is what I recorded then about the refugees.
" Build up for 1971 War involved passing through areas which resembled an ocean with paddy and an odd village sticking out of it .The only high grounds were the roads which were occupied by countless refugees from East Pakistan who were forced to flee to escape alleged atrocities of the Pakistani Army. Monsoons were still active and the refugees had hardly any shelter against the elements. They were in an utterly pathetic state. Many of them, specially the children were reduced to skeletons due to mal-nutrition. Women were in tattered saris exposing almost all their skeletal bodies and many bore marks of physical abuse, especially on their faces. We had to drive thro’ these swarms of refugees at a snails pace in nauseating stink created by worst sanitary conditions imaginable. The whole spectacle was revolting and dehumanizing . Passing through a linear sea of that miserable humanity forced one to think to end their misery at the earliest by enabling them to return to their homes after liberation of their country. When the war really started, the ‘Motive’ of “Enabling them to return to their homes” was strong enough to do one’s best. More than any thing else , ‘Humanitarianism’ worked as a ‘Motive’ for me in the ’71 War ".
@lala gee, Ever heard of the expression "Burying your head in the sand"? If not look it up. I have never met the other gentlemen (or could be a lady) in my life. I reside in UK. Others might be in Pakistan, India, USA or your next door neighbour. The conspiracy theory again eh? I hope you are not in politics.
@MSS:
"“Telepathic link”? No. Intellectual link?"
Does this link also share the same Keyboard and CPU as explained by @wonderer:? "The Link" needs better shielding as the cross distortion is causing the duplication of whole sentences and paragraphs.
@MSS: "@Lala Gee, “... No. Intellectual link? ..." . Dear @Lala Gee, it is one more term invented by these fascist-liberal-intellectuals. Please don't panic.
@Lala Gee, "Telepathic link"? No. Intellectual link? Yes. We all seem to be looking at reality and then doing our best to help people do the same, with respect of course.
@wonderer:
"You are very smart, but not smart enough. There are many more of us besides the ones you have listed. We are not the “same” but certainly “similar”. We are united in our endeavor to make the best use of the time we spend on blogosphere, exchange relevant information on topical matters to make a positive contribution, in a civil manner, ensuring harmony of thought and action. We also ensure that nay-sayers who try to vitiate the harmonious atmosphere are put in their place."
Thank you for succinctly explaining in your own words the kind of syber-alliance you guys have to the rest of the ET readers. Believe me, I know much better than that. And the bad thing is you don't have to be smarter than a person of average intelligence to figure out all this. Good luck in your endeavors, only if they are fair and for the betterment of the whole humanity.
@Lala Gee:
@All Readers: Please help me verifying if @wonderer:, @pakiindi:, @Abid P. Khan:, and @MSS: are mentally connected through ‘Telepathic Link’, or, otherwise, after reading their rebutal to my comment, they more likely than not look one and the same guy using different monikers.
You are very smart, but not smart enough. There are many more of us besides the ones you have listed. We are not the "same" but certainly "similar". We are united in our endeavor to make the best use of the time we spend on blogosphere, exchange relevant information on topical matters to make a positive contribution, in a civil manner, ensuring harmony of thought and action. We also ensure that nay-sayers who try to vitiate the harmonious atmosphere are put in their place.
I do not speak for everyone of us.
@gp65:
"Sir, If I may ask, were you part of this migration?"
Sorry Madam, I sent a reply to you yesterday late at night, but sent it from one of my daughter's accounts (pakiindi) by mistake. There was a similar mixup when she wanted to write to Lala Gee. We have a common computer at home.
You are requested to take the reply to you by "pakiindi" as from me. I copy and paste the same below:
“Sir, If I may ask, were you part of this migration?” No Madam. I was in Bangladesh with a UN mission overseeing the return of these refugees from all across the neighboring Indian states. It was a huge task to get everyone back to their homes in Bangladesh. Movement was mostly by road and involved a number of agencies from all across the world. The return of millions of refugees to their country was very important in the eyes of Indira Gandhi. See her interview here: Indira Gandhi – 1971 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nRAfs_LPFI4&feature=endscreen
@gp65:
"Sir, If I may ask, were you part of this migration?"
No Madam. I was in Bangladesh with a UN mission overseeing the return of these refugees from all across the neighboring Indian states. It was a huge task to get everyone back to their homes in Bangladesh. Movement was mostly by road and involved a number of agencies from all across the world.
The return of millions of refugees to their country was very important in the eyes of Indira Gandhi. See her interview here:
Indira Gandhi – 1971
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nRAfs_LPFI4&feature=endscreen
@Lala Gee: Hakeem Lukman is supposed to have said,"Wahem ka koi ilaaj nahin!
@All Readers:
Please help me verifying if @wonderer:, @pakiindi:, @Abid P. Khan:, and @MSS: are mentally connected through 'Telepathic Link', or, otherwise, after reading their rebutal to my comment, they more likely than not look one and the same guy using different monikers.
@BruteForce:
"The population of Kashmir valley is 4 Million. How is it even possible to kill 9 Million in Kashmir? Does that even make sense?"
Exactly. This was the point I was trying to make. Exaggeration has limits (I can only hope that you didn't think, even for moment, I don't know the population of the IOK). The Time Magazine put the total death toll to 300,000, which is still a little on the higher side and includes all those tens of thousands of non-Bengalis killed by Mukti Bahini. You cannot compare the insurgency of IOK with the full scale war fought between two countries (in fact three countries). In real wars people unfortunately get killed. How many got killed in Iraq for no reason - around 1 million. But the Indian's sycophancy for the USA sees no limits. You hardly ever see a comment against US in this forum, let alone crucifying US actions, as you do in case of Pakistan.
"Just this year more than 5000 dead in Karachi alone."
Isn't this another miracle of your counting skills. Where do get your figures? Or, just make them as you please.
@wonderer:
"@Lala Gee: I have just noted your rejoinder to @wonderer: It is not at all clear what objection you had to the post by @wonderer:, which has been appreciated by many. I have noted similar posts by you earlier as well."
Oops. You forgot to change your moniker before clicking "Post".
"You pick on one comment by a respected person, and then go off on a tangent and list a number of sited which have no connection whatever either with the topic, or are the comment you chose to question."
If you will try to verbally lynch Pakistanis for their ills - real and concocted, which are by comparison nothing to your own - from a self assumed high position of righteousness, then it I feel the strong urge to demystify the reality of your pretentious superiority, moral or otherwise. When your own house is made of fragile glass, you don't throw stones at others. This is simple common sense. Anyway, the real purpose of this forum is to bring out truth. Isn't it? You bring out ours, I expose yours. No heart-feelings.
@Lala Gee, Your rejoinder to wonderer is out of depth. There may have been incidents like you refer to, they are no different to indiscriminate killings and beheadings by extremist forces anywhere in the world. For removing your rather opaque to reality glasses I give an example from an extremly reliable Pakistani source: Chapter II Alleged atrocities by the Pakistan Army: 15. Lt Col. Mansoorul Haq, GSO-I, Division, appearing as Witness No 260, has made detailed and specific allegations as follows: “A Bengali, who was alleged to be a Mukti Bahini or Awami Leaguer, was being sent to Bangladesh—a code name for death without trial, without detailed investigations and without any written order by any authorised authority.” Indiscriminate killing and looting could only serve the cause of the enemies of Pakistan. In the harshness, we lost the support of the silent majority of the people of East Pakistan. The Comilla Cantt massacre (on 27th/28th of March, 1971) under the orders of CO 53 Field Regiment, Lt. Gen.Yakub Malik, in which 17 Bengali Officers and 915 men were just slain by a flick of one Officer’s fingers should suffice as an example.
If this does not open your mind then nothing will.
@Lala Gee:
"Apparently your counting skills need some polishing. Weren’t those numbers “90″ and “30 million”?"
Why don't you read about how many were killed in gory detail in the Justice Hamoodar Rahman Commission report. A report commissioned by the Pakistani Govt, which was not released by Pakistan, till an Indian Publication leaked it! (Again India has to expose the truth which Pakistan was not willing to admit)
http://www.bangla2000.com/bangladesh/Independence-War/Report-Hamoodur-Rahman/default.shtm
I'll help you:
"What about those 90,000, oops 9 million, killed in Indian Occupied Kashmir by Indian Army?"
In your endeavour to embarrass me and throw me off guard, you have shown what a genius you are..
The population of Kashmir valley is 4 Million. How is it even possible to kill 9 Million in Kashmir? Does that even make sense?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kashmir
Even the 90k figure is bloated by the Urdu Media of Pakistan. Even if its not, its relatively minute compared to the 3 Million dead/raped in Bangladesh. As I told you, you guys are much much better at it than we are.. Just this year more than 5000 dead in Karachi alone. And, all you can get to talk about India is Gujarat riots which happened more than a decade ago.
Besides, if the figures were any closer to what you claim, why are Kashmiris voting in Indian Elections so overwhelmingly?
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123048366626337803.html
@Anwar Shahid: ".....The Wonderer. seems to have an indepth knowledge of the event.He appears to have a skill to analyse with a fair mind too..." . Majority of participants on different fora on ET are either interested in mauling their opponent to death or start churning out the standard fair they have. One cannot be easily ignore, the horde of so-called trolls who may be defined as harmless but they certainly are of great annoyance. . @wonderer: surely sees things and has seen them with different eyes. Hope he gets a chance to write a book with details about what he has seen and experienced, specially once the people are more receptive and would accept the truth. One cannot go on feeding generations after generations with half lies or white lies.
@Lala Gee:
I have just noted your rejoinder to @wonderer: It is not at all clear what objection you had to the post by @wonderer:, which has been appreciated by many. I have noted similar posts by you earlier as well. The subject under discussion is the Bangladesh question on which the writer has penned a marvelous piece. You pick on one comment by a respected person, and then go off on a tangent and list a number of sites which have no connection whatever either with the topic, or are the comment you chose to question. You bring in the Hindu-Muslim question for no rhyme or reason and vitiate the exchange of ideas by others. Why do you do this? If you have taken it upon yourself to single handedly prove to the world that Hindus are the scum of the earth, why not find another platform, or at least wait for an Op/Ed on the subject? I request you to desist from such activity in future in the interest of all concerned.
@Lala Gee:
I have just noted your rejoinder to @wonderer: It is not at all clear what objection you had to the post by @wonderer:, which has been appreciated by many. I have noted similar posts by you earlier as well. The subject under discussion is the Bangladesh question on which the writer has penned a marvelous piece. You pick on one comment by a respected person, and then go off on a tangent and list a number of sited which have no connection whatever either with the topic, or are the comment you chose to question. You bring in the Hindu-Muslim question for no rhyme or reason and vitiate the exchange of ideas by others. Why do you do this?
If you have taken it upon yourself to single handedly prove to the world that Hindus are the scum of the earth, why not find another platform, or at least wait for an Op/Ed on the subject? I request you to desist from such activity in future in the interest of all concerned.
@wonderer:
"@Lala Gee: My long lost dear friend Lala Geeeeeee,.... Because you are in the habit of following this negative policy, I shall not entertain any remarks by you in future, which please note."
In fact, I am in a habit of exposing truth with credible online references, which, of course, Indians don't like because it does not suit their purpose on this forums. Not entertaining my remarks is your choice that would certainly not deter me showing the truth to the readers where ever I feel is necessary.
We still after passing 41 years stick to Hindi/ Urdu as our national language which was the main and first cause of breakup of the country. Hegemonic role of this North Indian language has divided people in 1947, in 1971 and continues to divide us. When will we recognise the rightfullbplace of all the national languages spoken by our masses.
They say that the Truth frees us from the follies and the ghosts of the Past.When this nation learns that, shall any good come out of this debate.As long as elements among us remain steeped in chauvinism,militant supremacy and outright arrogance I can see no movement towards sanity.We always considered the Eastern part as an albatross around our neck.I remember the days at the Karachi University in 1970 when our Head of the English Department,a Bengali Professor,Dr. Ashraf would talk to us about the impending crisis.His tenor and tone would depict the grief and the agony.Most of us were very fond of him but once the crisis started and the army entered the foray one could see a change in attitudes towards the Bengali faculty.I remember writing somewhere that if this was the state of affairs at seats of Higher learning what would it be like among the masses.Sure enough the Hate brigades lead by the Right wingers had swooped though the country ripping it apart both soul and Body.Even after 41 years we have remained the 'ostrich state' .Instead of an effort at Reconciliation we opted to rewrite History rather than exorcise the spirits of that tragedy.I am afraid, given our dexterity to beguile Truths,nothing will ever come out of this except perhaps, the banal commemoration of this day,talk shows on the media and a lot of chest beating by the very perpetrators of the tragedy, who today appear the most vociferous supporters of 'Jai Bangla' Happy Independence Day,Bangla desh! Had we heeded the call of that prophetic Maulana Abul Kalam Azad,millions of lives could have been saved.
@BruteForce:
"900 people dead(on both sides) cannot be compared to 3 Million people dead."
Apparently your counting skills need some polishing. Weren't those numbers "90" and "30 million"? Or, perhaps "9" and "300 million"? OK. 300 millions seems fair. What about those 90,000, oops 9 million, killed in Indian Occupied Kashmir by Indian Army?
Bangaldesh has a vibrant textile industry and is one of the largest exporters in world for textiles. Enlightened policies that could have transformed us into a major economic power if only we will open our minds.
@Anwar Shahid:
Please Sir, accept my thanks for appreciating my comment. What I find heartening is that it was allowed by the moderators. I tried to say the same thing earlier too, but it never got past the moderators. This is a welcome sign of free thinking emerging gradually in our society. We are becoming less and less fearful of the truth and the Big Boss.
@Lala Gee:
900 people dead(on both sides) cannot be compared to 3 Million people dead. Nobody is saying Gujrat riots never happened, but perspective is important. Don't you think @Lala Gee?
Even 5000 dead in Karachi this year is much greater than what happened in Gujrat 11 years ago, after which there have been ZERO incidents..
However you look at it, you guys take the cake in violent behaviour(Shocking for a population only 1/8th of India). Talking about once in a decade incidents in a population that represents 1/6th of the Humanity is pretty silly..
In this race of violence, you guys win hands down!
@Lala Gee:
My long lost dear friend Lala Geeeeeee,
Be kind enough to read this again. “I saw this with my own eyes; and wish I never had.”
You must be a grown up person because I have been seeing your comments for quite sometime on the blogosphere. Why is it necessary for me to point out to you that there is a world of difference between seeing an event "with my own eyes" and seeing it on a video? Please keep this in mind for ever, even if you find it difficult.
In view of the above, I am not seeing the videos you have recommended. (I have a fair idea of what they contain.)
In case you thought my statement, “I saw this with my own eyes; and wish I never had.” was false, you could have told me so directly. Because you are in the habit of following this negative policy, I shall not entertain any remarks by you in future, which please note.
@wonderer:
"I saw this with my own eyes; and wish I never had."
Lets see how you feel after watching the Indian Hindus brutalities as exhibited in these photographs available on the Human Rights Watch website. And after reading the interviews of the culprits of the genocide with Tehelka reporters.
1- BABU BAJRANGI: ‘After Killing Them, I Felt L ike Maharana Pratap’ 2- MADAN CHAWAL: ‘They Hacked Him Bit By Bit, Then Burnt Him Alive' 3- MANGILAL JAIN: ‘We Dragged Them Out Of Their Houses’ 4- ANIL PATEL: ‘The Smallest Village Wasn’t Spared’ 5- DEEPAK SHAH: ‘It Should Be Something History Has Never Seen’
The democratic ratio of East Pakistan Vs the rest of Pakistan made it a * necessity * to not allow numerical democracy in the two UNITS .
Its the disinclination to share democratically with all citizens , irrespective of race,religion , region, skin color or ethnic links.
(Dear Moderator: I guess I am banned in this article. What wrong did I say in my comment against the 'Comments Guidelines'?)
I have so many things to say, but don't know how to say in a paragraph or two. Should I elaborate on the stupidities of our "10 class pass" Generals, who think themselves omniscient, or the shortsightedness of our political leadership resulting from the utmost greed for self interests, or our collective intellectual barrenness. All of the three failed the nation by not recognizing one simple thing that you cannot continue injustices, or go against the wishes of your people, for indefinite period of time. Of course, the enemies would do what enemies do, but perhaps we ourselves are the worst enemies of ourselves. And the bad thing is we didn't learn a thing yet, and continue to do the same blunders with the remaining country. Generals are still busy churning-out NROs, politicians are only interested in loot, plunder, and graft, the (fake) intellectuals are anything but intellectuals, devoid of scholarship and severely lacking in-depth knowledge (their only interest is how much they can make, even if that means selling themselves and the nation), and the rest of the nation is so ignorant that they are unable to see farther than their noses. So, the present is bleak, is there any hope of improvement in future? Yes, no doubt about it. But the key is held by the Generals, the self assumed guardians of everything - from 'Nazriya-Pakistan' to Pakistan's borders, and miserably failed to protect any. Stop producing fake, corrupt-to-the-core leadership like Nawaz Sharif, and so many others, and supporting the most corrupt ever regime imposed on the nation through illegitimate NRO, just because that would ensure your own unabated corruption and luxury life style. Until then, there is little hope for the betterment, but further destruction is assured.
An excellect recollection of the good old days which reminds us of the fact the people of East Pakistan wanted autonomy and not seperation..but they were left with no other alternative after the Operation search light...I fully admire the comments of the wanderer in this regard...... .....It was a political movement to start with, but what changed it to a demand for secession was what Pakistanis army did there. I shudder to even think about it. Immediately after taking off from Jessore airport for Dhaka in a UN plane, a number of fields littered with human skeletons could be sighted in January 1972. Also, a room next to a Railway bridge filled with one inch thick layer of dried and stinking human blood was there for all to see.I saw this with my own eyes; and wish I never had........
This is the most important aspect of the tragedy which needs to brought forward if we really are interested to draw the right conclution or for that matter to learn a lesson.. The Wonderer. seems to have an indepth knowledge of the event.He appears to have a skill to analyse with a fair mind too....I would like to read more from him as well..
@wonderer: Thanks for the response. That is so sad. I don't have words to express my grief over this brutality.
I have been able to dig out from my collection a few videos on the subject under discussion here, and I hope all of you will find them of interest. Here they are:
President Yahya Khan of Pakistan talks on 1971 War.....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rTp0wkOm3-o&feature=endscreen
Zulfikar Bhutto Interview on Bangladesh
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xu4MTv5wgys&feature=fvwp
Yahya Khan address's to the Nation on the occasion of India's attack on Pakistan(4-12-1971).wmv (He is drunk as often)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?NR=1&feature=endscreen&v=z1ZoV3nZspg
Happy listening!
@MSS:
Yes Sir, I agree with you. Thanks for pointing out.
a very well written thought provoking article!!
@Wonderer The day of shame was not 16 Dec 1971, it was March 1971 when Gen. Tikka Khan unleashed his soldiers on unarmed people to 'change their race'. When he ordered that any non-muslim officers be shot dead. The rest was a natural course of events.
@Falcon:
".... if hard-core nationalists were just looking for regional autonomy, then what led to political build-up of secession? .... "
May I inform you Sir? It was a political movement to start with, but what changed it to a demand for secession was what Pakistanis army did there. I shudder to even think about it.
Immediately after taking off from Jessore airport for Dhaka in a UN plane, a number of fields littered with human skeletons could be sighted in January 1972. Also, a room next to a Railway bridge filled with one inch thick layer of dried and stinking human blood was there for all to see.
I saw this with my own eyes; and wish I never had.
The large scale migration to India as a result of army brutalities, was also one reason.
Sir, Punjab will never get straight and still 80% Punjab supports military rule , thus it would be feasible for them to get out of Pakistan and impose marital law on themselves forever!
Bangladesh seems to be on the right track in its quest to build a brighter future for its citizens. Having seen the ravages caused by religious fundamentalism it has wisely decided not to pander to these obscurantists and remain secular. As long as it is able to keep its Military under tight controls and away devious games and hunger for Power, it will flourish. Guns cannot take its people where it wants to go, an educated and progressive work force definitely will.
It has all the ingredients for becoming an admired, moderate, progressive and peace loving country but it must keep the Mullahs and their propensity for mischief under close watch and tight control. Bengal has produced great poets, writers, musicians and artists and it must build on these foundations to project its Soft Power far and wide. I wish and pray for a glorious future that will wash away the wounds from atrocities suffered, Inshah Allah.
shame on us pakistanis for ever, to have massacered 3 million innocent bengali women, children and adults.... shame on each one of us living in this cursed land...
" While Bangladesh is on the move, bonding together as a nation-state, we still appear to be in a state of smugness, refusing to learn from our painful history." -Perfect history of these two notions in a single sentence!
Is it not surprising that as noon time arrives, there is not a single comment on this most topical of subjects? It is the Day-of-National-Shame (I call it that) for all of us, and the writer has done us a favour by reminding us that we have still learn no lessons despite the 41 years (no less) that have gone by. That is because we have been fooled all along. We were never told the truth.
Now that our nation is gradually gathering the strength to face the facts, it is time for us to demand the truth about our past, for two reasons. Firstly, truth makes for a strong democracy, and secondly, we want to learn from our past. LET US AGITATE FOR OUR DEMAND OF THE TRUTH.
I suggest we start commenting now, and then wait for the Indians to appear.
Some points are as following in addition to the erudite expression in the article:
1:Dec 16, 1971=>our failure in understanding functioning of 'federation' & power of 'regional disparities'. 18th amend was needed before that!
2:State sponsored private militias Albadar et al are no answer to real conflicts owing to horizontal inequalities & regional disparities
3: Economic growth which does not generate equality amongst its people & regions is no guarantee of peace & harmony
4: All federating units must be treated equally & pluralism helps people keep faith in federal structures.
5: A state wishing to thrive in economic and social development must generate actions of an #entrepreneur & #conflict manager of the highest order.
6: The reality of December 16, 1979 boils down to a basic fact => Happy Independence (Birth) Day Bangladesh!
It is better to apologise to Bangladesh and improve friendly relations rather than lamenting over the past and doing nothing about the perpetrators of the crimes by the culprits in pak army.
Sir,
As a fellow Dhaka University alumnus, it is heartening to read your article. In 1962, one of Dhaka's finest VCs, the venerable Dr. Mahmud Hussain invited Field Marshal Ayub Khan to address the year's convocation. Ayub Khan cancelled due to 'security purposes', at a time when Pakistan was a far cry from what it is now in terms of law and order. Dr. Mahmud Hussain could read the writing on the wall, and prayed that when the eastern and western wing would inevitably separate, it would be a peaceful parting of ways. What actually happened is now history, and it has hurt and shocked us all. May you continue to have fond and shining memories of the Bangladesh that was. God bless you.
An enlightening glimpse into the past. I think that if we had civilian government in place through 1950s and 60s, we would not have lost Bangladesh and if the secession did happen, it won't have been as brutal as it turned out to be. Out of curiosity, if hard-core nationalists were just looking for regional autonomy, then what led to political build-up of secession? Was it any event in specific that changed the sentiment of the whole region? May be it would help if you could expand on related parts of the history in the future.
Isn't it time we overcome our mourning over "loss" of East Pakistan , and start empathising with Bangladeshis on attaining their independence after colossal sacrifices. This will help us focus better on present-day Pakistan .
o
Pak dug grave for herself. Bengalis have a language and culture which is much more rich and older than Islamic language and culture in Indian subcontinent. It's self explanatory because muslims or Islam isn't native to subcontinent. In the name of religion , when pakistanis forced bengalis to speak a language or follow a culture which is alien to Bengalis , they opposed it.They showed the handsome pakistanis their way.
Well at last some facts are coming out now!