The Motorway is not just a road. It is a system with a structure, an environment that impacts behaviour and is in turn affected by it. To put it another way, the Motorway is a physical communication system, which allows for uninterrupted, relatively high-speed travel through a number of road safety measures that are both physical (rest areas, eateries, restrooms, petrol pumps, ATMs, a culture of cleanliness) and legal (rules and regulations about speed levels for different vehicles, where and when to stop and rest, lane discipline, road signs, reflectors, mobile workshops, ambulances, et cetera).
The efficient functioning of this system rests on two pillars: normative and coercive. The normative aspect of the Motorway, the internalisation of the culture, has developed to a point where occasional morons are either scoffed at or proactively chided by other commuters. This is complemented by the coercive aspect, i.e., through the enforcement of rules and regulations. The Motorway Police, decidedly the best component of the police force in Pakistan, acts with alacrity, enforces rules and does not like influence peddling. (NB: Sadly, some of their sheen is going but that is another story.)
This is what makes travelling on the Motorway a pleasant and much less tiring experience even though it is a roughly 110-km longer stretch between Lahore and Islamabad than the Grand Trunk Road.
On that fateful day, it being a sunny Sunday, I left Lahore with a book, comfortably ensconced in the back seat, looking forward to a nice, productive four-hour cruise. Instead, my journey became a nearly six-hour harrowing experience home to home. Reason: the Motorway had been assailed by thousands of medieval faithful returning from the Tableeghi Jamaat’s ijtama at Raiwind. They were in trucks, buses, big and small vans, mini-vans, cars, jalopies, jeeps and anything that could move on four wheels. They were sitting inside and on the roofs of the vehicles, with buckets, cooking stoves, utensils, the ubiquitous lotas, bedding, etc. often dangling outside — a hazard to themselves and others.
The vehicles, for the most part, could not have passed the fitness standards required for the Motorway and the manner in which vehicles were packed was against Motorway rules. This was bad enough. Worse, the drivers and the passengers showed no respect for the system’s rules and regulations. They parked on the sides, alighted and loitered around, sat cooking and prayed in collections of 20-25 at various points on the Motorway, throwing safety and security to the wind. They drove their vehicles with no regard for lane discipline, zigzagging and cutting into lanes. I sat in the back, the book forgotten, seething at the ugly spectacle unfolding before me.
This was as far as the road itself was concerned. The other component of the system, the rest areas were also chock-a-block with more of these people sans brains and civic sense. The usually serene and clean places were littered and many faithful spat around, pursing their lips and ejecting spittle with the precision of a guided missile.
Here, too, they sat eating, squatting, performing ablutions, some of them doing it in the open, others in the restrooms, noisily clearing their throats and blowing their noses, putting their feet in the basin to wash off the grime, making the washrooms unusable for all others. It was difficult to figure out whether those doing the ‘needful’ inside were worse than those who sat, often scattered, just off the roadside, squatting and pissing. Micturating in the open is an exercise that requires years of practice and also the ability to squat and bend one leg at a certain obscene angle before (un)doing oneself. And if there is no water, one can do what is known as — though I am sure completely unknown to the 20-something upper-crust urbanites — butwani where the ‘u’ in ‘but’ is to be pronounced as the ‘u’ in ‘put’, thank you.
This incredible exercise in cleaning the musty underpinnings cannot be described here but readers are welcome to make their discreet, individual inquiries. For once, they will find Google at a complete loss!
The Motorway Police were nowhere to be seen. Throughout the agonising journey, I spotted one officer leaning against the median, his patrol car parked on the opposite side, looking on helplessly while a group set out mats to pray by the roadside.
On that day, dear reader, the Motorway was a microcosm of this country. As happens in our beloved country, laws go out the window the moment someone demonstrates piety. And the enforcers tuck tail when those that demonstrate piety descend on civilisation in hordes. This is how states lose their writ and with it their sovereignty. That loss was a fact poking one in the eye that day.
Where were the police? Was there a policy to let the uncouth faithful be, more interested as they are in the life hereafter than civilised, decent behaviour in this world? Did the government tell the police to make themselves scarce or did the police high-ups recommend this strategy to the government? Why was my right to travel safely on the Motorway ignored?
Someone must answer these questions or else I am growing a beard, losing my brains, raising a religious militia and telling the state to piss off.
Will some cleric tell us why piety doesn’t equal civic sense and regard for the laws and why the supposed spirituality of such congregations as the Tableeghi ijtama doesn’t translate into responsible civic behaviour?
Thomas C Schelling wrote in Micromotives and Macrobehavior: “How well each [individual] does for himself in adapting to his social environment is not the same thing as how satisfactory a social environment they collectively create for themselves.” He was talking about us.
Unlettered zealots, lacking the spirit of religion, pushed the Motorway back to the Dark Ages. If we don’t take heed, they will throw this entire country back in time. When that happens, we will end up a monument to oblivion like Ozymandias’ half-sunk, shattered statue.
Published in The Express Tribune, November 14th, 2012.
COMMENTS (154)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Good
Dear Sir,
I am just a bit confused was your article about the motorway or the pilgrims returning from Raiwind ? I do agree with your frustration of having no regard for road rules or the law for that matter. But I am sure you know you can't touch a religious issue and the mob mentality of our Pakistani brothers. I will give you a scenario if anyone daring enough from the police tried to stop them we all know what would have happened. The policeman being thrashed and your 6 hour journey turning into a 12 hour one as they would have blocked the road. It all comes don't to one thing and one thing alone literacy.
To attend an Ijthima at Raiwind does not automatically guarantee us a place in heaven it is only fulfilling a requirement told to us by Almighty Allah. But Mr. Abdullah must remember that there is "Haqooq-ul-Allah" and "Haqooq-ul-Ibaad" which Allah asks every muslim to comply with. We muslims in Pakistan are not a fine example of good muslim as given in the Quran and the Hadith. People going and coming from Raiwind are mainly poor and unfortunately uneducated and do not present an example of a good musalmaan. Breaking the Motorway laws is a very poor example of a good muslim. However having said all this I feel the Government is duty bound to run state-of-the-art buses between Raiwind and the major cities of Pakistan at very subsidised rates for those performing Ijthima. Then proper residential quarters and toilets/restrooms must be built in Riawind to accomodate the faithfuls. In this way those that have the money help those who do not have the means to live a decent respectful life. At the same time the Govt. must build rest areas along the Motorway with adequate toilets and parking lots to make it possible for those returning to get the basic requirements.
If the driver is driving zigzag or his vehicle is not fit for motor way its the fault of Raiwind Tablighi Jammaat???? It time to grow up Mr Haider. Completely biased article and the anger comes from the fact that you got home 2 hours latter and couldn't read a book, shame.So where does the litter from your home go to a recycle plant is it???
I'm shocked how many people here are taking an article about the lack of basic civic decency in the religious segments of our society and turning it into something about an elitist man dissing the downtrodden commoner.
Excuse me, but if these so-called downtrodden righteous commoner servants of Allah and His Prophet (PBUH) can't bring themselves to obey the rules of the Motorway then they have no business traveling on it! It's that simple.
Besides, I am supporting this article even though I'm no elitist, I'm a regular Rawalpindi middle-class commoner without even a car to call my own so please knock it off with the whining about elitism.
This article is a perfect example of why people should not be allowed to put their faith above their basic civic responsibilities to the society and their duty to the law of the land. This is NOT piety, this is plain simple fascism.
And @Ch. Allah Daad: It's a MOTORWAY for heaven's sake! How in the name of the hooris of Paradise is a motorway supposed to have "special arrangements" for the "biggest gathering of Muslims after Hajj"???? What on earth were you blabbering on about???
And to all those of you calling it a result of the Establishment's actions, you should know that Jihadism in Punjab is being supported by the PML-N provincial government, which is a rabidly anti-Establishment party. Why do you people always excuse the behavior of our civilian politicians in your eagerness to lambaste the Establishment?
Most of these uncouth uncivilised herds are kaam chors, who prefer to remain absent from their workplaces and offices for months and even for years under the pretext of tableegh. Instead of raising their voices against drug smugglers, profiteers and influential people in their localities, muhallas, they travell hundreds of kilomters faraway cities and countries.
@Abdullah: Haider's scarcastic and snobbish comment however carries alot of weight. Islam believes in 'cleanliness is half holiness.' Before prayers every believeing muslim must do abulation i.e. wash major parts of your body 3 times. This is the degree of cleanliness wanted by Islam. To seek knowledge a Muslim must travel to the other end of the world (China). What Haider describes is a total lack of a decent way of living which is the very essence of Islam. To be poor doesnt mean living like animals. Yes I agree, to be poor means one cannot be chauffer driven in a posh car but the 'Ijthima' can be organised by the State. Instead of travelling in jalopies and on the roof of buses the govt. can provide modern state-of-the-art buses to carry the worshippers to Riawind. At Raiwind the state must build decent living quarters with well organised modern clean toilets and a mosque to cater for the millions who turn up for prayers five times a day. We may be a poor nation but nothing prevents us from getting free education in state organised schools so that we know how to respect the law and live by the rules. Yes, use the motorway a thousand times but abide by the rules. Islam does not advocate breaking the law. How long under the pretence of religion must we continue to live in the stone age.
We, in Pakistan have apparently become more religious i.e.more people are offering prayers,more and more numbers are going for Hajj,more people keep fast.More religious parties or sects,more Islamic slogans and quotations from Quran and Hadith. But ironically there are more crimes,cheating ,crookery ,corruption,dishonesty,and disgaceful acts.Why so??? Are we hypocrites and bigots of the lowest category ???
@Abdullah: Is Pious means doing the things as explained. I had first hand experience of this nonsense and trust me that does not reflect Islam in any manner. IS behaving normally against Islam or does it preaches to do whatever and where ever since you are coming from a religious gathering.
It is every one's divine right to follow their religion but not by inconveniencing others. The problems enumerated in the article were not becasue of "piety" gone berserk but lack of education and upbringing which is the major problem for the large part of population in underdeveloped/developing countries. If only children are taught from an early age about their civic duties and to act in a manner as not to incinvenience others - which indeed Islam teaches - than these problems would disappear. However countries like Pakistan are lagging far behind in educating their masses in this respect and it would take some time before the nation as a whole catches up with these decent ways of living. Having said that I still think that the tone of the article was too derogetary and inconsiderate and very condescending which is not the way to go about resolving a problem. With a tone like this people get turned off rather than listen to the main message. A good journalist is one who keeps within those boundaries in order to ensure maximum impact on his/her readers.
I once took a train From Delhi to Agra early in the morning. The sight on the railway tracks of people conducting their morning 'business' was truly amazing. Why the railway tracks!
"On that fateful day, it being a sunny Sunday, I left Lahore with a book, comfortably ensconced in the back seat, looking forward to a nice, productive four-hour cruise. Instead, my journey became a nearly six-hour harrowing experience home to home."
While Pakistan is trying to emulate erstwhile fascist Nazi Germany, let not the elite snobs think they are like Germans when it comes to punctuality!
The article itself, and the comments are a clear sign that we are a divided nation, and the divide is deep. May the good times dawn upon us someday.
This article, more than anything else, shows the writer's disgust for the poor and the people going to a religious gathering. This disgust would always have been there in the writer; his motorway ordeal just pushed it out of his pen. The worst of us don't tolerate 'others': if we are rich, than the 'others' are poor; if we are not the religious-type than the religious-type are 'others' for us. The writer, while showing his disgust for the religious-type and the poor, could not hide his disgust for religion and poverty. He did not stop to think for a second that those people were trained by their elders and fellowmen to be what the writer described them to have been on the motorway and the tableeghi ijtema or the people organizing the ijtema were not responsible for the way they upset the writer on the road. I once went to such an ijtema with a friend and what i can say with authority is that those ijtema molvis were trying their best with improving everything, including civic sense and respect for local laws, in the average Pakistani from 'the dark ages'. What those molvis could have done more was only to have strictly enforced laws upon the crowd, but then the writer would equate them with Taliban. Pity, that these molvis, or anyone trying to 'tame' the poor of our nation, will never be able to 'please' the writer. I would say that we should blame all of us, with the exception of the likes of this sophisticated writer ofcourse, for being from 'the dark ages' rather than branding a segment of us as molvis or religious-types and then lashing at them for what we all are.
The writer was lucky that he covered the 400 KMs patch with a delay of only 2 hours. Muharram is approaching shortly and then Rabi-Ul-Awwal in 2 months time. I hope that this writer doesn't try to traverse M.A. Jinnah road, Karachi, on 10th of Muharram or 12th of Rabi-Ul-Awwal. Because if he did, he would have to encounter a delay of much over 2 hours in traveling a 4 KMs patch. Then, this writer will be penning down (as in gunning down) molvis, allamas and the religious-types for those rallies. I guarantee one thing to the writer though, that in our Muharram rally, we will atleast offer him drinks to kill the sun:) And I also suggest that he keeps more than just one book with him.
Witer would have no problem if those toti phuti buses with dirty human beings traveled by GT road and did not disturbed his spiritual journey with his book
@Ghilzai: You have no right to ridicule the religion. It seems as if you did not have proper civilized schooling.
brilliant piece of writing
Eradicate some of religious zealots seeking 72 virgins and who have no respect for law and human life. JINNAH will be pleased in heaven!
you forgot to mention how much trash/cigarrets you threw out of your car window and how many times you vshunned pedestrian rights in your pleasant journey of yours?
I am sure mr. ijaz haider would never have written a similar article about the carvan of political party on GT road or motorway. he would have rejoiced it by saying that it is a good sign for the democracy. Liberal fascism only notices lotas of tabligee jamaat and ignores teen dabas of everyone else. Resoucres on the motorway are scarce and when thousands of people move, system gets chocked. what requires in these times is PATIENCE, which Mr. Ejaz haider could not observe. and please sir next time when you want to move on motorway, make sure its not ijtimah time., happy journey!
Typical upper class snobbish attitude of the our elite towards 99% of Pakistanis. This is how common Pakistanis live and behave; and it has nothing to do with their religion or piousness.
Instead of questioning about why Government is not facilitating a million people every year with temporary rest areas, ablution and praying areas, parking facilities etc. he is fussed over his 2 hours.
In a nutshell, author is expecting ethics (civilization) level of Jamat e Sahaba(Sahaba Karam(r.a)) from common people of society. For general public ethics depends on well being and economical condition, when you are traveling in cruiser, observing society and then criticize it, it’s not fair. If you cannot do anything for the well being of exploited people of society then you don’t deserve to criticize these people. Second thing, you are the part of that society, whatever happens in the society, society as a whole(including you) will be affected by this.
Ejaz Haider is praising Taliban victory for many years than why he disturb their companions
This article was in bad taste. Smells of snobbery and contempt.
@Falcon: My sentiments exactly! I do agree with Mr. Haider, but the contempt for the uncouth masses that is held by the elites of our society comes across at full display here. The frustration seems to be more not at what the attendees of ijtima were doing, but where they were doing it. Violating the sacred 'gated communities'!
@H2A: "....I fail to see that why do our so called pious people chose to take refuge in Islamic teachings only to declare others infidel and not to learn any good civic behaviors to live a peaceful and pious life. ... . Everyone with a beard was elevated to the status of pious. The educated class handed it over to them. It is not a matter of elitist attitude, those who monopolise religion today are the least enlightened ones. Unless this aberration is corrected there is going to be more suffering and bloodshed. The nation would be divided even further.
@sabi: "That was on a lighter note" Ofcourse. And I was also responding on a lighter note but thought that this might be a good opportunity to provide some relevant information in an area where there potentially could be misconceptions.
We have tolerated the liberals like you sir! I think its time you return the favour. Pakistan belongs to the 99%. Pakistan is for the 99%. Nobody cares for one unfortunate car journey.
Mr. Ejaz Why are you singling out the attendees of the Ijtama for this? Have you tried travelling via the motorway just before or after Eid? It's the same, except you won't see people praying by the road side. Your singling out of Ijtama attendees is an indication that you want to blame their religion for this. As is apparent from your wording "Medieval faithful". That's plain and simple wrong. If there was a similar massive crowd of people returning via the motorway after attending some music concert, you would see similar scenes. So please refrain from blaming their religion for this or that they did this because they were "medieval faithful". All your modern men and youth would have done the same. It is the fault of collective mentality and values that our society has developed, which, mind you, are against our religion. Had they been following the teachings of religion, they wouldn't have caused inconvenience to their fellow travelers
An excellent exposition but the writer has presented a highly exaggerated picture. Again this is not some thing we face on the motorway every day. Once in a blue moon should not have prompted the writer to write this otherwise good piece of literature.
@gp65: sabi: “It’s not clear whether holy cow has more liberties in India or mullah in Pakistan" That was on a lighter note.However point was level of tollerance on roaming cows on public places in india.It is said beating these cows is not telerated in parts of India and can result in serious violance.It is encouraging to know from your post that cow is allowed to salaughter in India.This shows state is not inclined to overwhelming hindus religious sentiments.
The usual apologists are in streangh today, it was not the cars or the poverty of those coming from the ijtima it was the sheer disregard of the rules and regulations by this who claim to be the gardens of our morality. As for those saying things about jalsas and concert , the two don't compare because of the very high moral ground our mullas think themselves to be perched on , I mean no rock star can announce that i am an infidel and have me killed, can they. And politition "ever one knows" are thieves but Ulmas are the leaders of the ummah according to them so they should be judges accordingly not like a rock star or a politition is.
Simply Buhahaha i had this experience last year they are simply worth to watch.......Stone age clerics:P
Unlettered zealots, lacking the spirit of religion, will throw this entire country back in time with the help of Pakistani establishment.
Crazy people, who altogether missed the writer's whole point about an ironic relationship between a "supposedly" pious and spiritual activity and such a lack of civic behavior. The main point to understand here was that Islam preaches and highly promotes cleanliness and discipline. But unfortunately the Tablighis totally ignored the basic and beautiful teachings of Islam. It's like killing the essence of holding a tablighi ijtima, if they haven't learnt the basics of living a clean and disciplined life. Unfortunately, the people who cannot differentiate between a rich behavior and clean behavior, also suffers from the same dilemma. How can people forget that to offer Namaz, one should not only have to do Wadhu to clean your body, but also make sure that his\her clothes and the place of worship should also be clean. Not only this, Muslims are encouraged to put some sort of perfume before going to Masjid, so that people are not bothered by a bad odor. Lastly, one should not go to Masjid after eating Garlic or anything which causes bad odor, and would be disturbing for other prayer-men. I fail to see that why do our so called pious people chose to take refuge in Islamic teachings only to declare others infidel and not to learn any good civic behaviors to live a peaceful and pious life.
Unfortunately, majority of the people who commented here, have missed the whole point of a strong relationship between a spiritual activity and lack of displaying a pious behavior publicly, which eventually hijacked a well disciplined motorway. Instead, their mental capacity could only lead them to label it as a clash of rich and poor.
@WB I expect that the Motorway police would have enforced their rules more diligently for people coming from a concert. This article was meant to be an emotional rant, not an objective, pious critique, that is why it catches interest and comments.
I am disgusted at such a biased article....If the author has gone for Hajj even there the motorways are stuck with traffic...it is just normal.....I do not understand why the author has problems with people praying in 20-25....stupid article but a stupid person
Nice and valiant effort to highlight the pathetic & hopeless situation in Islamic Republic Of Pakistan. It demonstrates the thinking of so called intellects in that country. You are quick to let the world know about being inconvenienced by these evil creatures. But my friend, where were you and others when the same bunch was murdering innocent worshipers in the mosques. When the minorities are denied their basic rights everyday. Because it was not you who were directly effected, thus no condemnation. This is just the beginning. The termites are already there. Just read some of the carpet beggars justifying and defending their uncivilized behavior with their twisted logic, here on this blog. ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF PAKISTAN IS ALREADY ON ITS WAY TOWARDS MONUMENT TO OBLIVION.
Now this is why Ijaz Haider is my favourite journalist.
@avrom yarushalmi: This lot is the other half; a much bigger half than that representing cleanliness. Is it just a coincidence they have their housing and production unit in Raiwind; the hub of our pious Punjab!!!!
Even here in the UK The Tablighis are showing Islam in a bad cultural light - but who will tell these people to do what they wish to do without interfering in the lives of others?
Dear Sir, Your stress and focus on the Good Civic Sense is some thing that should be appreciated but as for your assumption that the only Tableeghee Jumate is laking the required Civic Sense is something beyond reality .All the followers of the Tableeghe Jumate are amongst us and we all know how much we are civilized is evident to every one .Its not specific to Tableegh Jumate and any specification made in this matter called a Specification Bias .I do not defend them for not following the rules but i am only concern with your perspective of seeing the things and about all your premise which is fair demonstration of some sort of Obsession with these people .I am daily traveller of Motorway and i used to commute on daily basis on motor way and often came across with some frightening scenes demonstrated by fairly looking Descent People .Then why to locate and Specify only these people with indecent look .Why sir . ?
What a hypocrite. I totally agree with WB, the author needs to get his perspective clear... and do something about it for once rather than sit in the back seat & get the driver to drive & just talk utter nonsense.
Dear Mr Haider ,
I have been a great fan of your writing since long time ,however for this one unfortunately i have to say you lost it .I agree with you that all the behaviors you have mentioned at length may not the most appropriate one but as a writer you should not have let your Emotions take over your writing and convey that these people were some other creatures .I would quote your words below ,
The Motorway had been assailed by thousands of medieval faithful returning from the Tableeghi Jamaat’s ijtama
Your choice of words could have been better ,i would suggest that you seek Allah's forgiveness for your sake .
Oh dear, dear, dear..... did those pesky Pakistanis take over the beloved Motorway too? Damn those barbarians!! Must they make EVERYTHING like the rest of Pakistan?? Must they insist on taking our cake and turning it into their bread??
The bitter, harsh and sad truth is we sit comfortably in our homes whining away about how messed up the system is, relying only on the power of words. Which unfortunately are only empty blows without any action. I recall someone saying: "The people should not be afraid of the government, the government should be afraid of it's people." Point being if really wanted for this system to go away, it would not have existed in the first place. We are just too lazy, or lack the will-power or the heart for a radical change. Sloth is OUR sin.
@Al Those complaining rules were broken: Someone has explained quite clearly what happened. The highway infrastructure was not built to accommodate so many travellers. Hence, - parking spots in rest areas were filled and people had to park on roads - washrooms were grossly inadequate necessitating some people to do it outside. People wouldn't do it outside if a cleam washroom was available. - Lotas were being used because running water was not available.
Have a heart and do think once in a while - there but for the grace of God go I.
I do not see the problem. The members of the Muslim ummah were performing their ablutions the same way it has been done since 600 AD. Also, it is a historical fact that Muslim armies never missed a prayer even in the midst of a battle. Why complain now if they pray in the midst of an express way?!
I bet they behave like this on highway here in Toronto. The thing is when they come out of la la land, they pretend to be behaving like civil citizens with all of their lotas tucked in and all...LOL.
@Abdullah: It has nothing to do about being rich or poor. It has to do about following certain rules when driving out on a road. These rules are more stringent for highway driving. And it has to do with following and displaying certain social etiquette. Unfortunately, the illiterate masses of this country think it is their right to drive on the roads. It is NOT. It is a privilege. But to enjoy this privilege one has to observe certain rules, with no exception. It doesn't matter who you are or how pious or un-pious you are.
A similar scene may b witness again on Sunday 18 Nov 2012, as 2nd Leg of the 3 day Ijtema concludes
This Sunday ( 18 Nov 2012) may witness a similar scene ..........as 2nd Leg of the 3 day Ijtema concludes
I guess why most people are angry because you hinted that peeing in the street and spitting on it is uncivil and they must have done one or all of the above.
This Sunday ( 18 Nov 2012) may again witness a similar scene ........ 2nd leg of 3 day Ijetma concludes
Allah doesn't want to be worshiped by discommoding its creature.... Sad that Islamic values are presented in totally wrong way.....
Very nicely and conveniently we can corrupt and jeopardize any of the systems that are meant for optimizing the country's efficiency that to in the name of Islam. Where ever and who ever utters the word "Islam" every thing comes to a halt!
@WB: Actually if it was a crowd from a concert then the motorway police would have actually done something instead of hiding of the great mullahs of pakistan.
@ Ejaz Haider
the above comments gives me an insight into modern day Pakistan. If readers of Tribune are considered to be the most progressive Pakistanis, then we are in serious trouble.
your heading should read:
Pakistan : The Motorway for the the Dark Ages.
Brilliant sir not only for the substance but for moral courage to touch those who in the garb of piety pollute everything from roads to schools from politics to social norms. Religion has mercilessly been used and exploited in this country. I don't understand the very logic of these myriad congregation except being a clever attempt to indoctrinate the poor and illiterate. And what an attraction where one prayer in tablighi ijtima is equivalent to 490 millions of prayer-manyfold than the prayer offered in Kabaa and Madina. It is hard to conceive such an astronomical figure. Tablighi movement(TM) has paved the way for increased radicalization of our society. Though ostensibly declared to be apolitical TM is the religious wing of JUI and no wonder it wins in the areas where TM is strong.
i find your write-ups at times a little tedious but today you were at your best.you made my day.your 'the motorway and the dark ages' was absolutely hilarious exposing what the piety hides.now about 'butwani' Bing born in a village i know its all about .the word is WATWANI not butwani though 'bey' and 'wao' are interchangeable.WAT is derived from WATTA and wani from vehna[ to flow, to strike etc]
@Inzimam Ahmed: Well said.
@WB: here lies the mind set , to let u know a concert does not claimpiety and reformation and guidance to mankind , a concert is a concert where people come to have fun and people leave after what ever fun that wish. Where as a tablighee ijtemaa claims that this gathering is for teaching of islam and for the purpose od human developement under islam, and wow the returnees display what they assimilated in there time spent in the ijtemaa
I heard that tabligi jamaat people are most friendly and well mannered in the same forum (some supporter of Ejaz pointed that out during debate on Parvez Hoodbhoy's removal from lums).
Also I don't understand how growing beard, losing your brains and raising a religious militia will help? Will you use this militia to stop such people from using motorways?
The traffic becomes three times as compared to this on the event of Hajj, but such events are there for a noble cause. What can someone do if these things irritate Mr. writer?
Last year I was at your place Haider! and believe me I had he same feelings :(
The motorway people should have adopted the IDEAS 2012 strategy adopted in Karachi from Nov.6 to Nov.11. Shut down all the access roads and let the traffic find its way on its own
They also have the right to use Motorway.
It has indeed facilitated their journey;
Have a heart for 1% of the year, let those brother citizens use it.
Why dont he say directly that these religious people are not accepted in our country.This man is turning it here and there and i can understand what he meant.Cleanliness is half of the faith.I had respect for this man but this column has changed my perception about this men.He is terming these people with different names.
The more they do cleaning the more they are dirty.We done Mr.Haider
@Abdullah: I totally agree with you and want add these questions which come my mind to disturb me
1-Do we elite exploit the resources of poor? 2-Do we elite not responsible for social gap? 3-Do we elite not responsible for poor education for poor and good education for rich? 4-Are we not responsible for poor health facilities for poor and five star for rich? 5-Can we live anymore with double standards for poor economy class in trains etc and for rich elite Luxury? 6-Do we feel comfortable by exploiting the poor labor with nominal wage to earn max profit and keep poor employees poor? and then read/write articles to show off how wisdom we have achieved and make satire of people who are not up to standard?
Was the Quaid an elitist snob for wearing suits,maintaining personal hygiene and not tolerating any rule-breaking?
Fun to read but this is the sub continent. Once in a year, the motorways must look like the rest of the country. You give them the facilities and education, they will get better. Thats a promise !!
@salman: Yes Sir, that is what a democracy is . The 1% listen to the 99%
Shame for us as a Nation. A foreigner is telling us 'See your face". Stewart Alex “The writer is a senior journalist and has held several editorial positions, including most recently at The Friday Times. He was a visiting fellow at the Brookings Institution and is currently senior adviser, outreach, at the Sustainable Development Policy Institute” education and awareness should bring humbleness, patience and tolerance, author lacks all of the above in his article, I am an overseas Pakistani and it was disgusting to read a view point that “dark” in its content. Try to be a Pakistani by loving your fellow countrymen rather then looking down upon them.
This is exactly what I am told happens in Mumbai on December 6, Ambedkar's (the first law minister who drafted the constitution and was a Dalit) birthday.On this day, exactly as described by Haider, thousands upon thousands of these Dalits free load themselves on all means of travel and pour into Mumbai and on the seafront. For the next 2 days it's mayhem for the residents there, as some of the best residential areas are laid waste and stink worse than a million toilets. Mush as I would like to avoid this statement, the caste system seems to be very much intact, whichever religion one may profess.
Bit worrying when most of the comments are actually defending the base, disgusting and criminal behaviour of the Jamaatis on the motorway as described by the author. I had the pleasure of visiting the Raiwand gathering myself a few years ago, and nothing about it was pious or spiritual. It was one of the most horrendous experiences of my life, and by the time I returned home I was unrecognisable - both physically, mentally and probably spiritually! Being poor and less educated does not mean not knowing basic hygiene, manners and civility. If "safaai nisf eman hai" then what is the point of attending all these religious gatherings and going with jamaats for 40 day trips. What will they teach others. And what impression do they give when they behave in such total disregard for others' feelings. Least we can do is condemn such behaviour rather than defend and condone it. Otherwise, we can forget any respect from other countries or tourism to Pakistan etc. Indeed, there are thousands of images and videos online depicting Pakistan and it's citizens behaving in most embarrassing ways which does incalculable damage to it's standing in the international community. Nowadays, few clicks on the mobile phone and the laundry is hanging out for the whole world to see on Facebook and Youtube etc. We can tell the author to be quiet and not be a 'snob', but unfortunately the scenes he has described are unacceptable amongst all the civilised societies of the world - unless we are just not interested in being part of that community of nations.
For your kind information, Motorway was initiated and completed during rule of “dark-age” follower. Nawaz Sharif’s association with Tablighi jamaet is open to all. This so called intellectual need to understand that people were not misbehaving because they were Tablighis------it was simply because of lack of education.
I suspect some other prejudice was main driving force behind this disgusting piece of writing. Did this man ever wrote on blockage of roads, safety hazards and other problems and markets during Ashura????????????
In all his eloquence and humour, Ejaz Haider is forgetting that M2 is not merely reserved for the elite of our society, traveling in fancy chauffeur driven cars, with a book to read for the 4.5-5 hours journey. A much greater percentage of our country is formed by the illiterate/not highly educated people who, according to Ejaz Haider, might not have the proper etiquettes to travel on the motorway. I think Ejaz Haider is dragging religion unnecessarily in it. It’s more to do with culture, education, than religion.
sir you are either very sensitive or highly complaining. it took you 6 hours to cover the distance in place reguler 4, just two extra hours. the writing is certainly elitist..we in delhi are used to such religious processions and large gatherings through the busy markets and office areas including connought place.and suddenly everything stops and half an hour turns into two hours. some of those are HINDU: processions at time of birth of Rama, JaganNath yatra, balmiki Birthday ,immersion of idol of durga and Chhat (15% of delhi is from BIHAR and east UP and Chhat is celebrated by them) MUSLIM Muharram, besides people coming to Delhi for annual Urs visiting Nizamudin and tombs of other sufi peers SIKHS procession before Guruparv (birthday of sikh Gurus). Delhi faces procession of various other religious and regional denomination. Delhi also takes toll of democratic processions around Parliament sessions, when all those who have some demand to make from government gather at jantar mantar. but i do grudge when super elite 'NSG protected VVIPS' are on move and city comes to stop. i always wish these VVIPS should travel by Helicopters and not by road
@Rashid Iqbal: Hate you for taking the words out of my mouth. Jeesh, so the Exalted One has been mugged by the reality of South Asia! It just ain't fair.
3 2 1 GO
Instead, my journey became a nearly six-hour harrowing experience home to home.
unfortunately this year Tableeghi Ijtima's ending and Ejaz Haider's journey taken place back to back . . . this never ever happened in last 50 years . not a single article related to this type of incident we can find in all newspapers of Pakistan since 1947 . . so Ejaz Haider thought that he should not miss the opportunity to bash and blame Tableeghi Jamat in very polite tone , after getting undesirable frustration in the start of his journey .
standing on the platform of Express Tribune Ejaz Haider asking
Will some cleric tell us why piety doesn’t equal civic sense and regard for the laws and why the supposed spirituality of such congregations as the Tableeghi ijtama doesn’t translate into responsible civic behaviour?
did you agree with any Cleric in your whole life ?? why are you asking from Clerics at all . . you much familiar with subdivisions of Muslims in Pakistan and affiliations of Clerics too.
I can understand and empathise with Ejaz's distress: on a flight from Colombo to Karachi, I watched with amazement as a handful of pious passengers took over the aisle to pray, blocking all access to the toilets, and making it impossible for the hapless crew to move around. But oddly, when the call to prayer sounded while we were waiting for our luggage in the arrival hall, not one of these show-offs were moved to pray.
@Abdullah: Most of those people were probably not poor (the poor don't take time off to sit around at ijtemas). And the law is meant to be applied equally, so praying on the side of the road remains a hazard to traffic and life even if it is praying. This is not upperclass snobbery, it is just common sense. Drop the chip on your shoulder and you might see it too.
Spot on, Mr Haider!
this article reminds me of an incident in my city New Delhi. A local bus shelter was erected in a rich neighbourhood of central delhi. the residents, all super rich, protested vehemently at what they called an "eyesore".The civil society came out in full force and the self-styled high and mighty had to bite the dust. the bus shelter stands there twenty years after the incident.
Had this been the outcome of a cultural event, the author wouldn't have written this article at all even though similar situation could have been created. His objection is purely to religion and the religious. Shame on you!
@TH: Well, did any of these intellectual discussions were taken onboard by the participants, if so why this behaviour?
@Ch. Allah Daad: then the prganiseers of this big event need to organise special facilities OR educate the participants with some civic sense.
Had he ever visited any busy street of Lahore any shrine or even Heera Mandi he would have seen more fuss around but there the "colours" would have overtaken the scenery and would certainly have not made him write such selective criticism. Had he seen the drunkard inside the bar he might not have raised eyebrows. May be I am wrong but this is how most of the liberal's attitude towards all things religious remains due to inherent bias. All what he witnesses was also witnessed by me and I can say with confidence that this no fault of the tableeghis if there were violation of any rules. I did not see buses and wagons overflowing with people. Yes they parked their buses for prayers and ablution on the road side but without violating any traffic rules that were meant to provide security and comfort to the travelers.
Therefore the problem the author of this article has is not with the hordes of people returning rather the label that they were carrying and this would certainly disturb people devoid of religious practice. A few days ago the crackpot Raza Rumi exclaimed that LUMS is getting "occupied" by tableeghis and Pervez Hoodboy tried to become a false "martyr" for ideolology without any solid basis. Such arrogance coming from the liberal section is a new wave of liberal facist tendencies that has devastated this nation for last 10 years and has allowed US to enslave us more. These icons of secular liberal fascism and arrogance are the perpetrators of Jamia Hafsa massacre and they pretend to forget it but it shall certainly come back haunting them. Rather than improving upon what people are already on these arrogant criticisms would only alienate these self-styled liberal champions among populace and would squeeze space for them in coming days. The problem with Pakistani liberals is that they are hypocrites too on the top of being arrogant and inconsiderate towards Islam, local culture and traditions and they are intellectually bankrupt as they have no correct idea as to how European experiences with Christianity could not be replicated in this part of region where Islam has been the force for excellence and civilization for most people in most parts of history and Muslim World is only coming out of colonization phase. The devastation of liberalism and materialism in the form of World Wars do not really bother them and they are also very clueless about the ugly problems of modernity in the developed nations and how religion is still has vast acceptance in US.
EH writes ... "If we don’t take heed, they will throw this entire country back in time."
Too late for that, isn't it ... If we were not already in the dark ages - none of this would be happening!
Mr. Haider. You are seriously living in some lala land. You probably have enough money to wipe your poop if you want but these people are cash starved and probably on occasions do not have enough money to feed themselves. They are not educated in elitist schools and colleges like yourself. They are probably not even educated at all. They probably have spent 99% of their lives in rural villages. Where would they learn the civic sense from??
Any by the way, I would really like you to visit Raiwind seminars atleast once. The intellectual level of discussions there are probably like you would find something in the board room of an MNC. I had a chance to visit once and the topic of discussion was waqt ki ehmiyat. And the cleric started off by giving example of the Just in Time Management systems of the Japanese. I am myself a Supply chain professional and I was taken aback.
@Rashid Hasan:
"As long as we don’t go to the root of the problem,we are not going to find any solution."
The "roots" my dear Sir, are buried 65 years deep.
Hunn kee kariye?
Mr Ejaz, wondefully done, the way laws become an uknown entity and how directly relative this is with the moment somebody starts practising religion, is a monster situatin that would face our beloved country forever i guess. people say there is a difference between a nation and a mob, and we as Pakistanis are still a mob, but with every passing day i just am forced to believe that we still have a long way to go before we evolve from being barbarians to a mob, and if we survive hopefully a nation. The one wonders as well is the system employed by us and chanted so enthusiatically by some media gurus,( because its benefitting them ) is that system really going to work for barbarians? or we need a "Danda" to first ourselves as humans? Anyhow brilliant done Ejaz. cheers
Answering your questions Mr. Haider so do not grow beard as it is such a bad thing. Religion is directly rooted with the culture and all religions have the social norms embedded. I understand you mentioned twice in the article the back seat of your car, Haider sahib not all people going to the Ijtimah are as lucky as you are for a cushy ride, reading romance novel and sipping pina colada. There are many affluent people who also go to this reunion to renew their faith. As you must be aware that there are less than 0.6% of our population who has university education and education plays a major role in development and similarly we learn tolerance through this process. We should also be realistic to understand that keeping beard is not a crime and also we should know that majority of the people in our north are not as blessed as the writer financially and they are going through this learning curve. Lets tolerate them, educate them and embrace them for leaving their homes first time, in many cases so they can change due to our better behavior to them. Unfortunately the 'Urban Crust' does not represent our majority neither do the back seat travelers passing judgements.
To some commenter above... who say that that's the situation with our average countrymen... well that could be correct but we can not accept such behavior from a cleric or in must i say self-proclaimed-clerics. In my meager knowledge in Islam, there are more rights of humans than of God and everything in Islam is somehow has a social aspect to it...
As happens in our beloved country, laws go out the window the moment someone demonstrates piety.
Fully agree. But then that is how it is meant to be. Man made laws must bow to divine ones. For examle You Shalt Not Put the Foot in the Sink is a man made law, the needs of divine ablution overrule that.
Unlettered zealots, lacking the spirit of religion, pushed the Motorway back to the Dark Ages. If we don’t take heed, they will throw this entire country back in time.
Do not agree. It is about the divine v/s the man made. Education has nothing to do with this.
To illustrate my point, I will refer back to a PTV programme named Vision Pakistan, way back in 2002. The programme used to feature debates on important issues by the 'brightest' of the 'best Universities' including LUMS and NUST. I recall a debate on 'whether mother tongue or English should be the medium of higher education' went into sudden death when one of the 'bright'ones suggested that all Muslims need only one language, the language chosen by Allah to deliver His message.
See, piety trumps all else, even amongst the 'educated'.
Or, recall the Water Car. People, including 'scientists', supported this as a believer was rewriting 'manmade' laws of Thermodynamics.
So the writer was out for a 4 hours journey, and in the middle he stopped at washrooms to see their condition.
And has the writer seen this for the first time in Pakistan, no but he was able to link it with Tableeghi Ijtama this time, that is why he had to write a blog.
We need to identify what is the problem and why is it... the problem as they say, a driver, being taken as rep for all.. the cultural people, taken as religious,
I bet instead of a tableegi crowd if this was a crowd coming out of a concert, the author would not have had any problem and he would have sat in the traffic for 8 hours without any complaints! Note to the author; you live in Pakistan, not in the U.S.
It is not the matter of rich or poor. I have been in one of these motorcades once and have witnessed blatant disregard for respect from these pious men. Rules are rules. If riding on top of the bus and hanging your lota on the side is unsafe it is unsafe and if we need the law to enforce that well that speaks volume but our nation. Someone else commented that the average Pakistani is like the people the writer encountered. So then we need to start educating our people instead of critiquing what sort of world the rich want to live in. @Abdullah:
Four hour travel is turned into six hours and you are making fun of these people. Its biggest gathering of Muslims after Hajj and no special arrangements are made for participants, nor infrastructure is upgraded. You should have appreciated these people on their discipline and respect for other travelers. Try travelling after a political Jalsa next time.
@ Author - but this is the outcome of the policies that were so fervently pursued by your establishment (read - the Army). What did you expect? That jihad, strategic space, non-state actors...could be safely confined to the borders, the madarsas? You reap what you sow, Sir.
i agree with this person's point in general about why piety is not translated in to civic sense.. but i disagree with the way he rather abused some islamic rituals like ablution.. Somebody has to tell him that there are only 5-7 toilets in a motorway rest area...and when around 1-2 million people return from ijtima..nobody will be able to avail all civic amenities. however a muslim may not wish to abandon prayer coz he can not find a place for ablution... cars were parked on side of motorway coz all parking areas in reat area were already full... there may be thousand and thousands of car returning from ijtima.... and does he live in Las Vegas that he expects Ferraris and mercedezes with these people..Lotas because Raiwind has not been developed to accomodate 2 million people on a permanent basis..there are no water system to permanently resolve this... and neutrality is very important in criticism...which unfortunately i can not see in this article...
Love it that Ejaz Haider was forced out of his physical comfort zone. Now if only he could pull himself out of his intellectual comfort zone that involves talking up Pakistan and its military's non-existent prowess and facing reality.
@Mirza: You are right I grew up in frontier province and as a child I could not understand some of the people doing this shamefull practis on public places.It was even embarrasing for us childrens as passer by let alone females. These ignorant people never realised the vulgarity of their act in order to perform some obligations.This reminds me of a narrative: On the day of marriage a women went to stream to take a bath,as she put off her cloths she saw a cammel siting aside stream.The women knew riding a cammel was sunnah she thought she had all other sunnah performed except that riding a camel.She decided only to sit on cammel's back for a while. so she could claim performing that obligation too. As she sat on cammel,to her bad luck, cammel stood up and started running to the village people who were gatherd for marriage cermoney were taken aback seeing a naked women. riding a cammel.The women replied she only wanted to perform sunnah but that accident happened.The bridegroom started beating his bride.People asked this man why he beat his bride as she was only performing sunnah.The man replied he didn't beat her for performing sunnah but for ignoring farz (Must obligation) over sunnah,And in that case covering her body was more important and farz for her than performing sunnah which comes after farz.
@Rashid Hasan:
He is not an appeaser. He is an apologist.
You forgot to mention one important aspect of the expressway. Did they pay the toll tax? Kindly confirm.
Great article sir. In the western world, your topic will earn you the title Islamophobic (Looks like even in Pakistan, looking at the comments). But truth is truth.
Accusations of snobbery are wrong. This country must follow the ideals of not letting mob, violence, and disorder take over. The Quaid made that very clear in rejecting the regressive mobocracy of Ghandi. He chose the strict constitutional method because he wanted us to be strict constitutionalist and disciplined people. Ejaz represents the embodiment of Jinnah's lawful approach.
I think our co-called religious Mullas are not educating people,they are just running there business in the name of religion.These are stupid people who have no work so they go to ijtama in Raiwind for some picnic.
As Sashi Tharoor would say Ejaz traveled in the cattle class.
Ejaaz, where do you live? This is what an ordinary Indian or Pakistani looks like. You appear to be very unfamiliar with them?
@sabi: "It’s not clear whether holy cow has more liberties in India or mullah in Pakistan"
Hindus do not eat beef and some Indian states forbid cow slaughter but as a whole cow slaughter is not forbidden in India and non-Hindus (or even Hindus that choose to eat beef) certainly have no trouble finding beef in India. In fact India is a large beef exporter. http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-10-26/news/347503231beef-exports-beef-production-usda
So to answer your question, I would go with option b in your question.
You are assuming all of them were practicing religious people. Going to ijtima doesn't make one religious similar to going to mosque on friday prayer. Also did your authors and philosophers not tell u that education has something to do with civic sense as well? Or did you learn civic sense from people who taught you correct pronunciation of butwani?
Everybody who's wining about snobbery should take a slook at the main problem: rules & regulations. The motorway can only be used by vehicles who travel with more than 80kmph and any vehicle which is not safe for it's passengers is a risk to every other traffic member also. And since when has hygiene become snobbery?
Sir, I feel sorry that you went through this ordeal. If it hadn't taken you 6 hours instead of 4 hours, you would have reached your home in time. The ignorant faithfuls who spoiled your journey were the culprits. Those dumb people forgot that motorway is actually built for your royalty, how come they end up driving on it. I suggest you pass a legislation with the help of your liberal friends in parliament to ban these fanatics driving on the motorway. I would also suggest that your souls would be much happier in the US. Why not consider living there? You won't feel any homesickness; I guarantee. Your soul is stuck in wrong body and wrong country.
Unfortunately, the state, i.e. the authore's favorite 'establishment' has been playing footsie with the overly 'pious' so long that it is impossible to put the jinni back in the bottle!
@avrom yarushalmi: Those who claim to be more pious than others. What a shame. If you pass through Raiwind ijtima you will see the same scene there. Why the head of their party does not teach them manners. How to live and let others live.
This Op Ed is a glimpse of the future of Pakistan where the rightwing street power is ready to take over. The most organized, selfless and devoted among those are Tableeghi Jamaat without a doubt. When their behavior is like this then we can imagine the others. I would confine myself here to one example only. When we travel in a bus going from one city (long distance) to the other, at each stop we could see men walking around with their hands in their tunic for a long time. How can we explain it to the kids that what is going on? How can we explain to the foreigners or visiting overseas Pakistani kids? In no country of the world men are shamelessly allowed to walk with their hands in their pants openly. Why would only men need to take a leak in this fashion on the road in front of all?
Congrats Ejaz. Your country is worse off than Papua New Guinea. That’s exactly what made you shout back in December 2008 when DG ISI was requested to contact his counterparts in India. Next time do not insult a nation just because you have got nukes. Nukes do not guarantee civic sense.
Our Quaid could not have imagined that these illiterate, uncouth, dark-ages masses would take over his lovely country. He would have ensured that the roads were kept clean.
@faraz: yes you are right....the average pakistani is uneducated, uncouth, a little crazy in the head and many other things.
@Pir Bulleh Shah: what a stupid reply. again as a writer mentioned. no one dares say anything against the so called pious people, no matter what stupid things they do. I dont know why is it so difficult to accept that that pious people can be stupid, uneducated, jahil, lacking civic sense etc etc
@Rashid Iqbal: If 99% of pakistanis do something it automatically does NOT mean that its the right thing to do. imagine 99% of pakistanis start pooping on the roads, so then according to you its the right thing? what is wrong with you people
Sir I simply Salute you. This country needs writers like you.
I agree with the writer that everyone needs to obey the law, but the article touched sickining levels of elitism!
Because, you asked for it in objective resolution.you asked for it in 1973 constitution and you asked for it in Zia's ammendments.For the taste alone! and one for the highway.
It's not clear whether holy cow has more liberties in India or mullah in Pakistan
Seriosuly you got inconvinient by the dirty masses ohh poor you. LOL The elites of pakistan wah wah LOL
What does the motorway have to do with liberals???
Motorways are an anomaly in a country like Pakistan, so are street lamps and internet.
Sir, This is the great Pakistani Unwashed. They're 99% of our population. The country will look like what 99% of its population looks like. I think we really need to move away from the 1% urban upper class defining the terms of engagement for the rest of the country. This is what we are- why should we be embarrassed?
Why is he acting all so elitist and not letting common people use a common facility? Only rich Pakistanis with fancy cars are allowed to use a highway? Common pious Pakistanis should notice this snobbishness and destroy highways and fancy cars.
Agree with law & regulations, but habits which author found so repulsive are descriptive of an average Pakistani
Must you have to write in the end "unlettered zealots, lacking the spirit of the religion..." Lacking the spirit of the religion - no sir - they are not lacking the spirit of the religion. What they demonstrate is THE spirit of the religion. But we have to appease. Even an honest writer like you has to embellish your article with this small piece of appeasement. As long as we don't go to the root of the problem,we are not going to find any solution.
Certainly an informative article...but sorry to say I notice very elitist undertones. This is how most of Pakistan looks like, only if our sophisticated elite were to venture out more frequently from their gated communities in Islamabad.
Brilliant. Liberals have destroyed Pakistan by building these highways without any regard for controlling them.
.Cleanliness is half of the faith.
whose??
Take that......smack in the face of a liberal democratic forward looking progressive government whose motor way went as dysfunctional and Zooish as the government itself is. Rein in the maulvis and the ijtemah should teach the followers the faithfuls the benefits of the use of civic sense as well. A different and very well written piece. Thnx Haider
Mr. Ejaz understood it today what is the real problem in Pakistan. So ironic.
Ah, the beauty of Pakistani Musalmans. Utter disregard for anything and everything. Is it any wonder? No wonder foreign countries now think a million times before issuing a Visa to one of our countrymen.
A very apt and damning indictment at one of the many daily examples, of the insidious religiously rooted attempts to eventually overhaul the state.
Ahh Mr. Haider. You have done it again. sheer brilliance sir, sheer brilliance. The inability of the state to control religion and of our education system and society to promote the true "spirit" of religion under an educated and intelletual auspices, as opposed to the mundane and mere outwardliness of it all is a very sad reality that is truly eating away the writ of the state. If only you were actually affecting policy in this country.