Taliban activities may have originally begun in these areas but they have, long since, spread their vicious tentacles throughout the country with southern Punjab often being pointed to as a Taliban stronghold, even though there is much controversy about the accuracy of those supporting this school of thought. And now, long after having established themselves in Karachi, Interior Minister Rehman Malik has finally acknowledged Taliban presence there and claims that something will be done about them which, coming from this gentleman is, as always, best taken with a pinch of the proverbial salt.
The fact of the matter is that either pure Taliban or a growing number of people exhibiting dyed-in-the-wool ‘Taliban tendencies’, are now to be found in almost every nook and cranny of the country. If, those of other persuasions — and one sincerely hopes that this is the majority — would take off their blinkers, open their eyes and accept the truth before it raises itself up and violently hits them in the face, would be far better off lest they get blown to kingdom come.
Signs of what can, quite literally, be considered ‘Talibanisation’ have been evident for some years now and are not only spreading but are fast becoming firmly entrenched in the largely uneducated mindset that prevails. As sickening as it is to admit, this is actively encouraged by a government, which does absolutely zilch to promote equal education for all and under its rule, the Taliban have destroyed, literally, hundreds of schools over recent years and educational standards have suffered a massive downfall.
Much of the media, too, is guilty of ‘under-reacting’ to the spread of the Taliban, and ‘Talibanisation’ in general, as few journalists have taken the trouble to analyse the growing menace from a seriously sensible point of view. Instead, in some misguided cases, they have opted to promote rather than decry those responsible for carrying out atrocities under the Taliban banner. The media segment, which has stood up and spoken out against the Taliban, particularly in condemning the attack on 15-year-old Malala, is now under threat itself with those located in Peshawar — now a no-go city for many — bearing the brunt and having to relocate to high security areas which, as history has proven time and time again, are never as secure as they are considered to be.
With targeted assassinations of anti-Taliban peace workers becoming more commonplace by the day, a general population that blindly refuses to see the writing on the wall, a failed educational system and a media under threat, Pakistan will soon be renamed ‘Talibistan’ unless there is an immediate awakening and necessary change is put in place.
Published in The Express Tribune, November 10th, 2012.
COMMENTS (37)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
'how come Muslims are highly successful in most walks of life in non Muslim countries"
For a very simple reason. In non Muslim countries Muslims follow Islam because they can easily see the dreadful consequences of being unbelievers. And Allah has promised that when Muslims follow Islam, they will be victorious over everyone else.
@Iqbal: We don't want Pakistan to be a part of Indian. We want Pakistan to remain Pakistan. India has enough of other headaches to now go and buy a new problem. A big part of the Muslims in India wanted a separate nation. They got it. They must keep it and make something good of it.
@Pir Bulleh Shah: If non Muslims are your enemies, how come Muslims are highly successful in most walks of life in non Muslim countries? Is that because they are being discriminated? In today's world, we have to all get educated and be competitive. This is a world where there is no room for second bests. Everyone wants only the very best. Using religious texts or blaming others does not advance the cause of your personal or a nation’s success or well being.
@Iqbal: Iqbal, Hindus are not any special brained people. The average British business man or government office looks for a return on investment. Religion is largely an impediment to this exercise, especially in countries where organized religion as such is dying out. The key difference between so called Hindus and Pakistani Muslims (I must state that because I see very few Indians Muslims doing this) is that we do not wear religion on our shirt sleeves. We do not bring it to work and it makes for a huge difference to any employer. Hindus are not only successful in UK or the USA. Hindus are highly successful as business managers and owners in the Arabian Gulf which the last time I looked up is predominantly Muslim. The key thing to note is Hindus by and large do not identify themselves as Hindus. Our identity is India or people of Indian origin. Hindus are not any special people for Brits to like us any more than Pakistani Muslims. We just learned to play the game well and guarantee a ROI.
@gp65: I have reproduced the text of the covenant and also given the monastery's link
In 628 AD, a delegation from St. Catherine's Monastery came to the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) and requested his protection. He responded by granting them the following charter of rights. St. Catherine's Monastery is located at the foot of Mt. Sinai in modern-day Egypt and is the world's oldest monastery. It possesses a huge collection of Christian manuscripts, second only to the Vatican, and is a world heritage site. It also boasts the oldest collection of Christian icons. It is a treasure house of Christian history that has remained safe for 1,400 years under Muslim protection.
The Eternal Promise:
"This is a message from Muhammad ibn Abdullah, as a covenant to those who adopt Christianity, near and far, we are with them. Verily I, the servants, the helpers, and my followers defend them, because Christians are my citizens; and by God! I hold out against anything that displeases them. No compulsion is to be on them. Neither are their judges to be removed from their jobs nor their monks from their monasteries. No one is to destroy a house of their religion, to damage it, or to carry anything from it to the Muslims' houses. Should anyone take any of these, he would spoil God's covenant and disobey His Prophet. Verily, they are my allies and have my secure charter against all that they hate. No one is to force them to travel or to oblige them to fight. The Muslims are to fight for them. If a female Christian is married to a Muslim, it is not to take place without her approval. She is not to be prevented from visiting her church to pray. Their churches are to be respected. They are neither to be prevented from repairing them nor the sacredness of their covenants. No one of the nation (Muslims) is to disobey the covenant till the Last Day (end of the world)."
The promise is eternal and universal. Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) ordering Muslims to obey it until the Day of Judgment. The charter imposes no conditions on Christians for enjoying its privileges. It is enough that they are Christians. They are not required to alter their beliefs, they do not have to make any payments and they do not have any obligations. This is a charter of rights without any duties.
The document is not a modern human rights treaty but, even though it was penned in 628 AD, it clearly protects the right to property, freedom of religion, freedom of work, and security of the person.
If someone wants to validate, please visit http://www.sinaimonastery.com/en/index.php?lid=68
@Shahzad: Your link to the letter in the monastery does not work. Can you please provide a fresh link?
By the way have only seen you very recently posting on this forum but find your posts thoughtful and your links informative.Thank you.
@Iqbal: "The other firm belief in UK is that the destiny of Pakistan will be like East Germany. It will become part of India by 2025."
No way Sir. West Germans may have welcomed the reversal of partition - Indians would not. So my dear Pakistani friends , please rest assured - no-one in India wants an inch of your land. If we had wanted to reverse partition, we would have tried to annex what is now Bangladesh in 1971 (that would not have been moral or ethical so I am glad India made no such attempt).
"Speaking out in the name of ‘peace’ is increasingly rewarded, not with accolade, but with death in areas that the so-called Taliban claim as their own, with the reprehensible murders of two anti-Taliban leaders"
Your anguish that the state of Pakistan appears to be not winning in its battle against Taliban is totally understandable. But anti-Taliban leaders were not peaceniks as you think. They too were leaders of lashkars or private militias. The problem is that the government has abandoned its responsibility to maintain the law and order and ensure protection of ordinary citizens, Hence it is left upto these private lashkars to fight the Taliban.
Across the border too, such militias had sprung up in Chhattisgarh to fight the Maoists but the then Home Minister worked with CM on one hand to shut these down and Supreme court also gave a judgment that such private militias were illegal and the state needed to invest enough in its law and order processes and not rely on militias.
This is important because from state sanctioning armed private militias to the vigilantism that destroyed the school in Lahore is one long slippery slope.
Zara Nasir right u r
@Pir Bulleh Shah: Sir with respect Iqbal 's message to Muslims is to strive for excellence. But it is the covenant our Prophet gave to the monks of St Catherine which gives a message on the subject. I believe, the original of this was taken by Suleman I and is in the Ottoman library/ musuem, in Turkey.The monks in the Monastry at St Catherine's have a certified copy attested by Suleman I. See link below http://www.ijtihad.org/Prophet%20Muhammed's%20Promise.htm.
@saleem: A lot of the Talibans fighting in Afghanistan and FATA and swat may well be from Sindh , Baluchistan and Southern Punjab in fact from all over Punjab. So I sm afraid they are every bodies baby see link below :http://www.thefridaytimes.com/beta3/tft/article.php?issue=20121109&page=3
Here comes the Talibaan oooo be afraid be very afraid. More ppl have died in karachi, may be the author could find the courage to name the biggest terrorist organization in pakistan aka MQM, when its leader and top leadership get sheltered by west and given free hand to create killing fields in karachi ppl rightly question west's motive. What has 10 yrs of war given to pakistan? More misery, more radicalization and more polarization, solution as per writers and ET more war, insanity indeed.
Iqbal, tell us something new. Christians can't be our friends, were we not warned if only we listen? Muslims have to accept that non-Muslims will always discriminate against them and will always hate them. Conspiracies have been going on since Islam was born and Muslims have grown stronger beating all odds.
@Iqbal The other firm belief in UK is that the destiny of Pakistan will be like East Germany. It will become part of India by 2025.
I think the chances are that Pakistan will become part of Greater Afghanistan. That will be the true irony of the idea of Strategic Depth
@Just Another Injun Troll
As a distant obserer i think the process of Talibanisation started in 1947.
Agree with you on this, the funds that should have gone into education, went towards religion. As a result Pakistan now has jehadi extremists instead of educated workers
This spread of Talibization is directly linked to lack of education and poverty. Penning such articles in an english daily is a total waste of time since 99.9% of the people who study in english medium schools don't go taliban. Our english speaking elites should concentrate in educating the poor rather than writing about the obvious in ET. I wonder if this author has ever donated some of her time and effort in educating the poor?
The author is right in her assessment, with the exception that the Talibanised Pakistan will still retain its name as Afghanista will as well.
Rex Minor
Best way of judging any country is what foreigners in other countries think of them. I am in UK and I can confirm that the business community thinks Pakistan is a terrorist country and most of its citizens sympathise terrorism against non Muslims. Most of these Pakistanis condemn extremism in public but privately back them. As a result, they don’t hire senior staff of Pakistani descent and instead hire staff of Indian descent to maintain government strict regulations that certain percentage of staff must be of ethnic community. That is the one of the main reasons why in UK you will read headlines such as "Hindus are four times less likely to be unemployed than Pakistani and Bangladeshi Muslims" The other firm belief in UK is that the destiny of Pakistan will be like East Germany. It will become part of India by 2025.
I wish you people (Pakistanis) luck in your struggle with the Taliban; you really need it. As a distant obserer i think the process of Talibanisation started in 1947. It's only gotten more entrenched and widespread, that's all. A solution will only be possible when your country stops being so overtly religious. A tall order indeed, for a country carved out on religious lines. But there, that's my ha'porth to the discussion. Have a good day, dear neighbours.
Policy makers should look to the examples of Morrocco, Turkey, Malaysia and Indonesia, countries which have fostered and developed truly progressive and prosperous Islamic societies, as a means of countering extremist ideology.
@SFQ: They don't want peace , their objectives are to talibanise and then then threaten our neighbours China, India, Afghanistan and Iran. USA is far away, it is not their war.
To understand what the Taliban are and what their argument and objectives are, you need to read, Syed Shahzad Saleem , who paid the ultimate price for writing, produced an authoritative book on the subject " Inside the Taliban and Alqaeda ".
Wars are not only fought with guns they are eighty percent about ideas and points of view. The a Taliban ideology , which is a franchise of Alqaeda has to be understood and as a first step this book is essential reading. They quote the Quran , they quote the prophet pbuh, they even quote Iqbal to serve their purpose. They are a monolith, and before the Malala incident they had unfettered hold over our Urdu press. But like all fascist based organisations they relied to much on terror and I see a change in the trend, and very religious people have now started questioning their narrow views on religion and on the world and on how to deal with non Muslims.
It is for this reason when they briefly took Swat the Murtad (apostate) was the first casualty, they first want unfettered dominance of their turf, which is their narrow view of Islam. They will provoke USA to stay in Afghanistan because they need a Jihad. If USA goes then Pak Army will be declared the infidel, in fact it already has.
Thank you telling us something we already know.
@zeeshan sheikh: Since you do not agree with the author, please tell us WHO the "Zionist liberal fascists" are and also tell us just WHO has killed nearly 40,000 Pakistanis over the last decade????
i agree with every single sentence of the article.. and @zeeshan sheikh.. its not a US war on terror anymore. Taliban is threatening Pakistanis now. its our war now.
THE FURTHER A SOCIETY DRIFTS FROM TRUTH, THE FURTHER IT WILL HATE THOSE THAT SPEAK IT..GEORGE ORWELL.
another article threatening us from taliban, how fascinating. guess what, its not helping zionist liberal fascists . we will not join US war of terror.
@Raza Khan:
Imran Khan has nothing to do with the creation or support of TTP, blame the people and institutions who helped formed the monster...Mushraff, ISI, and the CIA. IK is just giving a peaceful solution. Your lack of historical knowledge and blind hate against IK is deplorable.....
In your dreams baby, if you are thinking that Pakistan would be renamed as Talibistan
Please stop propagating Malala's incident. Peace talks should be conducted with all the militants. They're the ones who have been protecting our borders for the past 60 years. There are misunderstandings which should be cleared out. Words like Talibanistan will just widen the differences. If US can go for negotiations, then why can't we?
The road to suicide, obscurantism, fascism and total destruction called Talibanization!
if this continues, sind and baluchistan will split from the islamic republic.
What took you so long to say all that?
I imagine this is what the fall of the Roman Empire was like. As the role of the military became more and more distant from the people, dominant in the political process, and demanding of tax money, wealth fled elsewhere, participation and enthusiasm for civil institutions declined, as did the quality of governance. Everyone looked out for him or herself, seeking a "strong man" for protection. So instead of the Romans romanizing the barbarians, the barbarians barbarized the Romans.
Its too late! We should request UN & other agencies to start calling us Talibistan with Talib khan Aka Imran Khan as its first PM.
Thank you author for your analysis, most of which we already are aware of. I was looking for your proposed solution to this Talibanization which I didn't find.