The government does not need permission from the Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) to levy an additional tax on incoming international calls, even though the commission has declared it anti-competitive, a deputy attorney general argued before the Lahore High Court on Monday.
Justice Ijazul Ahsan had suspended the imposition of the tax, which raised international incoming call rates by up to 400 per cent, at the last hearing on October 25. Lahore-based local loop operator Brain Telecommunications has challenged the tax, arguing that it is against competitive practices.
Deputy Attorney General Nasim Kashmiri appeared before the court on Monday on behalf of the federal government, Ministry of Information Technology (MoIT), Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) and Pakistan Telecommunications Limited (PTCL).
He said that setting call rates was the prerogative of the PTA and it had done so in accordance with the law. The government did not require the CCP’s permission as it was only concerned with matters which took place inside Pakistan, while in this case the tax only affected people outside Pakistan. He asked the court to dismiss the petition.
Counsel for the petitioner Barrister Umar said the imposition of the tax on incoming calls was a clear violation of competition rules. He said that the MoIT had issued a policy directive asking the PTA to execute an agreement with 14 long distance and international (LDI) operators to set up an international clearing house (ICH).
The PTA acted upon the ‘instructions’ and established an ICH for LDI operators with effect from October 01. The counsel said that the tax had raised the cost of calling Pakistan 3 to 4 times, hurting many overseas Pakistanis.
He pointed out that the Competition Commission had issued a dissenting note to the MoIT and PTA suggesting that it withdraw its decision to establish an ICH exchange. He said the decision also violated the Competition Act of 2010.
The court directed the counsels to present their final arguments at the next hearing on November 14. The suspension of the tax was also extended till that date.
Published in The Express Tribune, November 6th, 2012.
COMMENTS (5)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
plz withdraw the tax so that we save money for our lover one and let us play a roll in development of this country.
I want to know that what the court decided on 14, Nov. we are very worried.
Dear Sirs
Recent imposition of tax on international incoming calls outrageous and it demonstrates failure to collect tax inside the country. It is discrimination with overseas Pakistanis and a legalized robbery to collect Government's way of revenue.
It is also disobeyed of respectable courts orders that tax is suspended till the decision is made, whilst PTA still charging tax on calls.
Had this situation ever been occurred in UK relevant minister would have resigned or made a statement in Parliament.
I would rather call it failure of present parliament who failed to respect the rules of law and also for present Pakistan Coalition Government who has failed to look after its citizens interest.
Ppp will u plz let any space to benefits the people of Pakistan.. instead of taking a each corner Pakistan why your hunger is not control...I swear to call Pakistan from forigen country is verrrrrrrrry expensive