Asghar Khan case: In 1990, Benazir was labelled a security risk by army, says former MI official

Then head of MI Sindh chapter explains why military toppled Bhutto-led govt.

Azam Khan October 31, 2012


The Supreme Court’s short order in the Asghar Khan case may have placed blame on two army generals for violating the Constitution by rigging the 1990 elections against the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), but it left lingering questions about the details of the so-called “anti-state activities” of “some players” that prompted the interference to begin with.

One of the pushers of the “national interest” argument, the former head of the Military Intelligence (MI) Sindh chapter Brigadier (retd) Hamid Saeed shared details of such activities with The Express Tribune. In an earlier statement submitted by the former MI chief to the Supreme Court, which Saeed also shared with The Express Tribune, the former MI chief said former prime minister Benazir Bhutto was labelled a “security risk” for Pakistan, adding that Bhutto’s public criticism of the army had landed her in hot waters.

Saeed, who claimed that it was not an Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) operation and that the MI was supervising it when Lt-Gen (retd) Asad Durrani was its director general, claimed that the former prime minister had also blamed the army for supplying weapons to ‘Muhajirs’ in Karachi, citing the target killings of political workers by rival groups in the city. Bhutto also publicly slammed the army for enriching uranium to levels not acceptable to world powers, he said.

Furthermore, Saeed claimed that Bhutto in another incident censured the army for conducting an annual military exercise in Sindh without her consent, adding that the Inter-Services Public Relations (ISPR) was forced to issue a press release clarifying that under the law the army chief was not obliged to seek anyone’s permission for conducting training exercises in any part of the country.

Saeed also referred to a BBC interview of Benazir Bhutto in which she voiced her support to India in crushing the armed dissident Khalistan movement in Indian Punjab.

In his affidavit, Saeed alleged that the Bhutto-led government had also given sensitive posts in the government to Al-Zulfiqar activists, endangering national security. The retired brigadier alleged that these activists had been given training by India to carry out acts of terrorism and that a record of these terrorists was available with the intelligence agencies. In an interview with Waqt TV, Saeed also named Mir Murtaza Bhutto, brother of Benazir Bhutto, as a supporter for these activists.

The former MI official claimed that, after the Bhutto government was sent packing through a presidential order on September 12, 1990, the then DG MI Major General Muhammad Asad Durrani visited Karachi and directed him to open six accounts in different banks, send him the titles of the accounts and monitor the account balances on a weekly basis.

Saeed added that, in compliance with these directions, six accounts were opened in different banks, in which funds began pouring in from September 16, 1990. By October 22, 1990, Rs140 million had been deposited in these accounts, he said.

“I would like to state that, during my service with the Military Intelligence, I was of the opinion that the funds were coming from the General Headquarters (GHQ),” Saeed said, adding that he only learnt of Younus Habib’s involvement in the case after he was arrested for fraud at Habib Bank Limited.

Furthermore, he claimed that Durrani had called him to explore the possibility of bailing Habib out of jail, adding that the army chief wanted to secure his release because he had been helpful in doing work of “national importance.”

“I showed him my inability to do so because the case was sub judice,” Saeed said.

Published in The Express Tribune, October 31st, 2012.

Our Publications


Samina | 8 years ago | Reply The Asghar Khan is just the tip of the iceberg, we have seen time and again that the Military elite has done everything in there power to keep the people’s aspirations in check and define the entire national narrative of there choice and in the process they have done everything including hanging of an elected prime minister, propping up of new political actors, disfranchising the people of Pakistan of there right to chose, declaring people security risk, propping up and supporting militant outfits, suppressing the democratic movement, losing a portion of our country etc with full immunity. The unfortunate part of it all is they had support from the judiciary, so called civil society, journalist, politics and public at large (due to peoples indifference). The saddest part is we see them reinventing them each time as the Savers, even today the conspirators of the past and the present have now taken to airwaves as the champions of Pakistani cause.
Lt Col Imtiaz Alam(retd) | 8 years ago | Reply @Ammad Malik: . You are certainly not a very well informed person. Or plain Naive..At heart a Jiyala. Have the Grace to show some respect for the Organization you served. So, you are also a Joker in your own words.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ