Sustaining current momentum

While Pakistan government, opposition support better relations with India, India fails to show the requisite resolve.

Tariq Fatemi October 23, 2012

Relations between the two South Asian neighbours have been making steady progress ever since they resumed their dialogue process in July 2011. Since then, the two countries have taken important steps to reach understanding on issues that are mutually beneficial and, therefore, more amenable to resolution. Consequently, agreements have been reached on a more liberalised trade regime and on easing visa requirements for various categories of people. India has also agreed to allow Pakistani firms to invest in sectors other than defence, space and nuclear energy. More recently, India has agreed to further shorten its Pakistan-specific restrictive trade list by 30 per cent, removing an impediment to trade expansion. Hopefully, India’s early removal of the non-tariff barriers (NTBs) should create a level playing field for the business community in both countries.

The media has also reported that India has stopped work on the controversial Kishanganga Dam being built on the Neelum Jhelum River, in compliance with the International Court of Arbitration’s stay order. If indicative of a more conciliatory attitude, it would be warmly received here, especially as the water issue has become a major concern in Pakistan.

These are all positive steps that have encouraged more frequent exchanges between various groups, generally referred to as ‘peace lobbies’, thus reducing the hostility so very palpable only a few years ago. This change has also been well received by the major powers who have long expressed their unhappiness and frustration at the inability of the two South Asian neighbours to resolve their differences and usher in durable and sustainable peace. These developments have also been warmly welcomed by people in both countries, many of whom have never been enthusiastic about the policy of hostility pursued by their governments. In fact, if the political leaderships had been permitted by their respective ‘establishments’ the kind of freedom they should have had, the two countries may have arrived at a more cordial and constructive relationship decades ago, even if some of the ‘core issues’ had remained unresolved. But it is never too late to do the right thing.

It was now expected that these initiatives would promote mutual trust and confidence, enabling the political leaderships to take on the more contentious issues that have bedevilled relations for far too long. However, an element of uncertainty continues to hang over the bilateral ties and this relates to India’s hesitancy to move beyond small steps. The purpose is not to question Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s sincerity but to point out that while care and caution are advisable — given the tortured history of relations — a degree of imagination and resolve are essential as well.

Of course, one also has to recognise that apart from India’s lingering misgivings about Pakistan’s ‘intentions’, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh is handicapped by the peculiar arrangement wherein party president Mrs Sonia Gandhi retains the final say on all critical matters. His government’s image, too, has been tarnished because of the corruption scandals swirling around people in government and party. Moreover, the expectation that Rahul Gandhi will be able to resurrect the party’s popularity has not been met either. These have greatly emboldened the Bharatia Janata Party, encouraging it to oppose initiatives to improve relations with Pakistan — ironic, given that Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee prided himself on having co-authored both the Lahore and Islamabad Declarations. On the other hand, there is a rare consensus among stakeholders in Pakistan regarding relations with India. The government enjoys the main opposition party’s support in this effort. It is in this context that one has to express a degree of disappointment at the Indian government’s failure to demonstrate the requisite degree of resolve and determination in pushing for a more meaningful approach to the normalisation process. The stakes are huge and both sides have to remain equally committed to sustaining current momentum.

Published in The Express Tribune, October 24th, 2012.


G. Din | 9 years ago | Reply

@Lala Gee: " Look around, each and every neighboring country of India is unhappy with India " This incessant Pakistani refrain on "unpopularity" of India amongst its neighours is senseless. India does not need votes or approval of any one of its neighours. So, why would she bother if they are individually or collectively dissatisfied with her? Besides, how does just that fact benefit Pakistan or any of its neighours. Has it so far? Of course, we would like to have friendly relations with everyone. But if it is not on the cards, so be it. Go, take your business elsewhere!

shahid | 9 years ago | Reply

The main issue is to move forward. If you start scratching the past then we have to recall Indian role in separation of East pakistan and Indian refusal to give pajkistan its due share at the Time of partition. What most Indians refuse to acknowledge was that in Mumbai terrorism, Pakistan Government or even ISI had no role although individual help may be Possible. This tragic incident was planned by people who wanted India and Pakistan to go into war over this and thus extremists can consolidate thier hold. In my opinon although Partition of Subcontinent in 1947 was a tragedy but there is absolutely no need or desire to go back in Past. There is however genuine desire in people of both countries to live peacefully and as good neighbours and share the blessings of heritage we share in common such as URDU/ Hindi poetry music, movies , love of cricket etc. With changing world and times the desire of improving in relation ship between the two countrie is not in isolation but as part of a broader creation of global village which is having its impact in the region. India being much bigger contry and more stable presently is expected to take more leads. It is true that Presently Pakistan is going through a difficult time and India has an upper hand but Pakistan was doing much better than India from 47 to early eighties. Pakistan will soon rise back given its immense potential and resources. Pakistani public has learned a lot from its past and there is a genuine desire to have friendship with India but it should not be taken as weakness or begging.Both countries have survived independently even having adverserial relationship so far

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read