Asghar Khan case: Army endorses apex court ruling

The army also attempted to distance itself from the two former generals.

Kamran Yousaf October 20, 2012


The Army endorsed the landmark Supreme Court judgment, insisting that the military should not interfere in politics, said two senior security officials on Friday.

They also expressed their regret over former army chief Gen (retd) Mirza Aslam Beg and former ISI chief Lt-Gen (retd) Asad Durrani for overstepping their authority by interfering in the country’s politics.

However, the army also attempted to distance itself from the two former generals, saying the current military leadership was performing its functions strictly in line with the Constitution.

“During the last four and a half years, there were occasions when the army could have overthrown the civilian government, but it did not do so,” said an official, citing a “clearly defined policy” of the current military leadership that they will not seek any direct or indirect intervention. Another senior security official insisted that no political cell existed in the ISI, or any other military-related institution. “If anyone has evidence, they should come forward with it,” the official said, adding that the security establishment had no plans whatsoever to manipulate the next general elections. When contacted, the Inter-Services Public Relations refused to give reaction to the judgment.

Court-martial or civilian trial

Will Beg and Durrani be court-martialled, or tried in the civilian court, is on the minds and on the lips of everyone, following the Supreme Court verdict.

Experts are of the view that both options are open. The recent decision by the army to try three retired Lts Gen and one Maj Gen for their alleged involvement in the National Logistic Cell scam indicated that retired army officials can be tried under the Army Act.

“It depends on the government, but they [Beg and Durrani] can be tried under the Army Act,” said Lt Gen (retd) Talat Masood.

However, he said the army wanted to stay away from the saga and would like the government to decide their fate.

‘Change won’t come overnight’

Former Chief of Air Staff Air Marshal Asghar Khan, who took the Mehran Bank scandal to the Supreme Court in 1996, hoped the verdict would reduce the military’s role in politics.

“The Supreme Court has asked the defence services not to participate in politics and I hope it will be followed, and if it is followed correctly it will make a lot of differences to our politics,” he said.

Other observers suggested that the Supreme Court ruling will go a long way in ensuring civilian supremacy in the country. “But the change will not come overnight,” cautioned Ahmed Bilal Mehboob, who heads the Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development and Transparency.

Published in The Express Tribune, October 20th, 2012.


Most Read


Rommel | 8 years ago | Reply

Has anyone asked Asghar Khan , why did he seek Military Intervention against the first democratically elected Government of Mr Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto. It's an historic fact which needs to be touched upon. Mr Wali Khan publically said, pehley Ihtesab Pair Intikhab. Comments please....

Mirza | 8 years ago | Reply

@Abid P Khan: That defense was offered (we were just following orders) by Nazi officials and they were all hanged. If a superior asks a soldier to commit treason or kill an innocent neighbor no law forces the soldier to do the unlawful thing. Nice try to shield the traitors and law breaker criminals. What happened to the oath of protecting the country and constitution? Cheers, Mirza

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ