The figures from the central State Bank of Pakistan showed net foreign direct investment (FDI) from July to September was just $87 million, compared with $263 million in the same period last year. Pakistan's financial year begins on July 1.
The overall FDI inflow during the quarter was $287 million while the outflow was $200 million, with only the oil and gas exploration sector recording a positive net figure.
Even the normally popular telecommunications sector registered a net outflow of $100.9 million.
Analysts said FDI inflows have been falling for the last four years.
"Poor economic management and persistent militancy has forced investors away from a market which has huge potential and prospects," said economist AB Shahid.
Earlier this month the International Monetary Fund (IMF) said Pakistan's economic situation was worsening and the country faced a return to double-digit inflation as the government prints money to finance its deficit.
The IMF also predicted growth of just 3-3.5 percent and warned the country's external accounts were deteriorating, with incoming investment slowing and the central bank's reserves dropping.
"But the biggest of the negatives is the deteriorating law and order situation that seems unmanageable," Shahid said.
Pakistan has repaid $1.3 billion of IMF loans in four instalments, including a $400 million chunk in August, and is due to pay a further $2.5 billion in the current fiscal year, which ends on June 30.
The central bank said Pakistan had foreign reserves of $14.4 billion dollars as of last week.
COMMENTS (40)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
The elites and politicians understand FDI to be their Foreign Direct Investments in Swiss banks and other overseas banks.
thanks to PTI , jamate islami and PPP all r responsible
@ meekal ahmed Though I do not want to compare India and Pakistan but as Asim has pointed out and you want to know in terms of ratio, here are some points for you: 1) In March 2012 only India got $ 8.1 bn in FDI which is almost 100 times than $87 mn recieved by Pakistan.
2) Thanks to new reforms,India is expected to get $70 bn in FDI for the year 2012 which is 80 times more than $800mn expected by Pakistan.
3) And last but not least, India's GDP is not 5 times of Pakistan's.By nominal GDP it is $2 trillion (2012 estimate) which is almost 10 times than Pakistan's $217 bn(2012 estimate).Even Mumbai city's GDP is $228 bn. For GDP by PPP-India has 10 times bigger GDP than PAKISTAN.So you see the size difference in GDP (almost 10 times) does not justify FDI difference( almost 80-100 times).Asim is absolutely correct.
@meekal a ahmed Just like you I am not aguing but I want to clear some facts given by Asim.Have a read: (1) In a single month of March India get $ 8.1 bn.That is almost 100 times of $87 mn in July-Sept quarter. (2) This year,thanks to reforms,India expects a total FDI of $70 bn which is 80 times more than $ 850 mn expected in Pakistan. (3) And finally ,India's GDP is not 5 times of Pakistan in any terms.By Nominal GDP India has $ 2 trillion (2012 estimate) compared with $217 bn of Pakistan (2012 estimate).It is almost 10 times. By PPP India's GDP is also 10 times larger than Pakistan.So even if we compare ratios of FDI ,Asim is absolutely right.
Pakistan has most of the ingredient required for a vibrant and thriving economy. What a waste of such a massive potential! As a finance professional I feel heart-broken to see the sorry state of affairs in my home country.
@Pakistani student in Canada: Pakistan has a perpetual Potential ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Somewhat like Priapism
When even a horrific incident like the Malala shooting is somehow turned into a conspiracy and the West is blamed for it, how can any sane man expect a crackdown on terrorism in Pakistan? I believe even the $87 million of investment is far too high given the state of affairs in Pakistan.
hah, well give investors 1 reason to invest in Pakistan. I am surprised even right now there is some investment.
"Analysts said FDI inflows have been falling for the last four years." +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ And how long has the PPP Govt been in power?
@asim:
I am not arguing the case for Pakistan but can you please express that as a ratio of GDP since India's GDP is five times bigger than Pakistan's?
It is no big deal but requires a bit of effort; look it up either at the IMF web-site or Wikipedia.
Absolute numbers mean absolutely nothing unless you "scale" the variable by some denominator -- usually GDP but you can use other variables such as, in this case, total investment.
Pakistan has the potential. A huge one at that. Since i am a student, i only need to look at the wealthy Pakistani diaspora in middle east and America (excluding Canada and UK because of taxes) who would invest the moment confidence returns. You have to see the number of businesses owned by Pakistanis in Dubai, Bahrain and Saudi to see that their combined wealth could put Pakistan well over the top. But this is too idealistic. I mean war with taliban is like never ending
I'm sure some Saudi Wahhabis can be persuaded to "invest" petro-dollars in some more madrassas.
@Pervaiz Lodhie: Not that current situation is any better, but Pakistan was declared 2nd most corrupt country during Mush Era. Can we not choose between these already tested corrupt Military and Political leaders?
Why would anyone invest in Pakistan ? When Pakistan is left alone with the Frankenstein it has created what do you think is going to happen ? An investor is far better off going to Vegas and putting it all on the tables, at least he will not be murdered.
Unless and until Pakistan goes after the thugs and cleans up its back-yard and front-yard, no one is going to invest in Pakistan. The side-effects of the clean up will have to be tolerated, then only Pakistan can dream of a good future. Until then, goodbye investments.
You got rid of Musharraf or military dictatorship that was attracting huge investments from 1999 to 2007 and now have the civilian Democracy that has successfully taken Pakistan to BANKRUPTCY. Has Pakistan now receive dor about to receive the "Most Corrupt" country in the world award?
Why am I not surprised? Everything in Pakistan is going South and downhill faster then speed of light. Soon, everyone in Pakistan will have to start bartering.
start blaming raw, nato, cia..aliens...what else ???
All is not lost. Silver lining is elections are around the corner and hope people of Pakistan elects a government who can bring about some real change. A good leader can change the things in really short span of time as Nitish kumar demonstrated in the most backward state of Bihar in India.
well i think this because of global economic depression....china too has been shaky in this matter..........
We should not take help from any non muslim nations as we dont give protection to minorities.
Even if you were making a real attempt at dealing with terrorists the investment would rise because they'd consider getting in early a positive thing. But, well, just look at the result of that Malala girl's shooting. There was a lot of "passionate" condemnations but the probability of some form of action seems to be fading fast. If that doesn't result in some kind of action, Pakistan ends up in the completely hopeless category in regard to future progress. If you don't go after them for that the only conclusion is that you're never going to or it's still years away. Why put up with that when you can invest somewhere else just as easily?
My country, Bangladesh, is the prime beneficiary of Pakistan's deteriorating situation. We have gotten huge foreign investments, most of them were originally meant for Pakistan, but diverted to my country due to Pakistan's precarious situation. Seems like GOD is compensating us against what Pakistan has done to us during 1971 war!
I just did quick calculation to increase GDP by $100 per capita just from FDI will require an inevstment of over $180,000,000,000 assuming 10% return on investment.
How does it matter; the great news is that Pakistan by next year is going to leave behind France in stockpile of Nuclear Weapons and is going to be number three in the world.Then it is going to be the proud leader of Muslim Ummah. Feel happy?
Let me ask the fellow Pakistanis:
Would you invest in a new project in North Waziristan or may be in South Waziristan ?
What about Bajaur ?
Did I hear you say "No Way"..
Exactly !
Thats how the outside world thinks of investing in Pakistan :)
I am sure Imran Khan can bring in $900 million within 19 days of being appointed as Prime Minister.
$ 100 million is pocket money for Mukesh Ambani's wife.
I work for an Investment Bank in the UK and have worked on deals throughout the world. Let me tell you this is a truly momentous fall in investment for a country the size of Pakistan. This investment is not even $0.50 per Pakistani. Think about it !!!! Also we have a huge diaspora and even after all this we have this level of FDI. I hope some Pakistanis understand what this means because it seems to me we are a country of fools ruled by fools !!!!
Imran Khan is now taking a rally against IMF and WB and has blamed drones for the drop in FDI in Pakistan.
oh this is such a terrible news for government who cares about Pakistan. We will now see the resignations of Investment boards, commerce minister and secretary and tough measure from Prime minister to improve Pakistan. Inshallah :)
Duh either you can collect the welfare cheque in the form of coalition support or create rule of law, peace, open borders, stop support for non state actors to attract variety of investors. Learn from Bihar and Gujarat how to be business friendly, infrastructure for business culture and predevelopment. If you build they will come. By the way there is more to Gujarat than Modi.
Who would invest in a country where Terrorists control the streets? And with all the barbaric incidents of terrorism taking place, and no action against them, if I were a buyer in another country, I would be boycotting all products from Pakistan, and would not be buying anything with a "Made in Pakistan" tag on it.
Pakistan is perceived as being a dangerous place...because it is...until the politicians get the courage to attack the radicals who are killing people all over your country you will be perceived as dangerous and unstable...Taliban violence cannot be tolerated...
Indeed, great 'achievement' by our PPP govt.. When the 'great' leaders of our own country do not invest here, what else you can expect from foreigners..
According to Ernst and Young, foreign direct investment in India in 2010 was $44.8 billion, and in 2011 experienced an increase of 13% to $50.8 billion.[10]. India has seen an eightfold increase in its FDI in March 2012
Pakistan is talking in millions and the other neighbour in billions.
Jiyaaaay Bhuttooooo!